-[NYAN]- wrote:

好图不解释

Normal

DS全程0.9修改下 ok

00:42:803 (1) - 用finish好点？ ok

00:57:634 - 01:08:421 - 这一段可以用音量渐强 ok

或者降低这三个地方的音量

01:01:679 (1) -
01:02:353 (2) -
01:04:376 (1) -

Hyper

00:06:914 - 这个地方空着么
00:07:251 - ^ (00:12:307 (5,6,1) - 主要是想着和这里呼应) keep 理由有二：一个是声音比较低，加了对形状有些破坏 一个是333cb



Another

CS-1

00:18:038 (6) - nc kept 因为我是跟的白线NC
00:18:206 (1) - 去掉nc
01:05:050 (3) - 加finish
01:05:724 (1) - 加finish
01:06:398 (1) - 加finish
01:07:747 (8) - 加finish kept 我这段的Finish跟的都是音乐里本来就有的大镲(咦)所以这些finish显得弱 不如不加

1. 01:05:724 (1) - Start this spinner with 35% volume, then increase the volume to 40% in 01:07:073?
2. 01:09:769 (2) - Whistle on slider's start
3. 01:13:140 (1,2) - Remove new combo on (1), add new combo on (2)
4. 01:23:926 (1) - Whistle on slider's start again, yep
5. 01:26:623 (5) - New combo

1. 00:33:880 (64,65,66,67) - Not really sure with the k k k k here, d k d k is better imo...

1. 00:27:971 (5,6) - Move both to ~x:241 y:148 so it won't overlap with (4) in play mode (stacking's nature)
2. 01:05:724 (1,1) - Same here, use 35% vol. on first spinner and 40% on the second?
3. 01:09:095 (1) - Whistle on slider's end also, to fit the piano?
4. 01:10:106 (4) - Remove whistle from slider's end here, add whistle on (3)'s start...
5. 01:22:241 (3) - Remove whistle from slider's end here, and add whistle on next slider's repeat?

1. 00:06:914 (1,2) - Use N sampleset (with ~5-10% volume) for these two?
2. 00:13:487 (2,4,2) - I prefer having whistle only on each slider's start, but this one is up to you...
3. 00:56:960 (3) - Remove whistle on slider's end, add whistle on your next (1)'s start?
4. 01:14:994 (4,1) - (4) and (1)'s start is missing whistle here o.o
5. 01:25:865 (3) - Whistle should be on (2)'s end here
6. 01:26:960 (3) - Again, you also need a whistle on this slider's end...

Niva wrote:

Hi Flower, I just went home and still very tired, here's a quick recheck:

[General]

-> Taiko diffs and osu! standard diffs starts on the same point, so I don't think you need a different lead-in time for them (however, my feeling says it's better to add 500ms lead-in to osu! standard diffs, rather than using 0ms lead-in on taiko diffs :3)
Ouch I really forgot it. Fixed
-> I see you changed mp3 (?) - second offset should be 23936 (it's highly recommended to resnap the inherit sections afterwards, especially the kiais~) No I did not change the mp3. But well, I think there is problem for my second uninherited section in osu diffs. Fixed.

[Normal]

1. 01:05:724 (1) - Start this spinner with 35% volume, then increase the volume to 40% in 01:07:073? OK.
2. 01:09:769 (2) - Whistle on slider's start OK
3. 01:13:140 (1,2) - Remove new combo on (1), add new combo on (2) That is not the idea, I think. I tried to follow NC pattern of 01:09:105 (1,2,1,2)
4. 01:23:926 (1) - Whistle on slider's start again, yep OK
5. 01:26:623 (5) - New combo OK

[Taiko Muzukashii]

1. 00:33:880 (64,65,66,67) - Not really sure with the k k k k here, d k d k is better imo... Yep

[Hyper]

1. 00:27:971 (5,6) - Move both to ~x:241 y:148 so it won't overlap with (4) in play mode (stacking's nature) yep
2. 01:05:724 (1,1) - Same here, use 35% vol. on first spinner and 40% on the second? OK
3. 01:09:095 (1) - Whistle on slider's end also, to fit the piano?
4. 01:10:106 (4) - Remove whistle from slider's end here, add whistle on (3)'s start...
5. 01:22:241 (3) - Remove whistle from slider's end here, and add whistle on next slider's repeat? Well I think that sound a bit weird. I try to follow "2,4 white line--clap, red line--sometimes whistle, syncopation--only whistle on the treble", which sounds better for me.

[Another]

1. 00:06:914 (1,2) - Use N sampleset (with ~5-10% volume) for these two? That is good idea but Normal sound is ambiguous. I think I will use Drum clap instead.
2. 00:13:487 (2,4,2) - I prefer having whistle only on each slider's start, but this one is up to you... yep
3. 00:56:960 (3) - Remove whistle on slider's end, add whistle on your next (1)'s start? OK
4. 01:14:994 (4,1) - (4) and (1)'s start is missing whistle here o.o I intend to leave them without whistle. They are not treble, whistle will make them sound strange.
5. 01:25:865 (3) - Whistle should be on (2)'s end here I intend to do so, too. Placing whistle on 01:25:790 is too rigid.
6. 01:26:960 (3) - Again, you also need a whistle on this slider's end... yep

Taiko Oni looks fine, I did this mod in a rush because I don't have much time atm... (I hope it covers all of the whistle problems I'm quite worried about, as I said in my PM to you)

I see a lot of improvements, yep, you can call me back for a bubble but I REALLY can't promise a fast recheck (just read my userpage orz, really busy with that atm, can only online ~1hrs per day ._.) OK > <

Sagisawa-Yukari wrote:

Normal
normal的话改成CS3吧 好
00:28:993 (1) - 这个建议从00:28:824 - 这里开始 为了跟clap而设的 干脆留着
00:46:858 - 这里加个note 为了避开里拍所以没下，下了还爆星
00:52:251 - 这里也是 ^
01:22:588 (5) - NC OK


Hyper
00:40:116 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - 这段听上去和BGM很不符啊。。考虑重新做下？ 和Taiko Muzu是一个梗 排的太紧不是很舒服
00:44:330 - 这里可以放个转盘，感觉太空了，如果放的话到00:45:341 - 结束 没有完全采用，我把这段最后一个note改成了slider并且在00:45:172 结束，和Another一样
01:15:425 (4) - 这里怎么会突然有2连的。。remove 第一个是切分音，第二个是clap，很多歌都用这个梗的
01:18:122 (3) - 同上，remove ^


Another
00:12:307 (1) - remove NC OK
00:52:083 (1) - remove NC 和00:46:689 (1) 同样的配置，如果去掉的话不甚协调
00:52:588 (2) - 如果你按照上面那么做了那这里加NC ^
01:07:757 (8,9,10,11,12,13,14) - 这个串和前面间距1.98就不要了，按照DS摆吧 这样就有遮挡了……QQ讨论后决定不用

感觉所有难度最前面不要消音，有点合适的鼓点什么的会更有感觉吧，不错的map，加油喽~

1. 00:12:813 (11) - D
2. 00:22:251 (18) - K
3. 00:25:959 (30) - k
4. 00:29:835 (44) - k
5. 00:31:858 (53) - re
6. 00:56:296 (154) - D
7. 01:20:566 (57) - k
8. 01:21:493 (60) - k
9. 01:21:914 (62) - d
10. 01:23:262 (67) - k
11. 01:24:611 (72) - K
12. 01:25:959 (77) - K
13. 01:27:307 (82) - K

1. 00:18:206 (23) - D
2. 00:18:880 (25) - k
3. 00:19:218 (26) - k
4. 00:20:229 (30) - k
5. 00:20:566 (31) - k
6. 00:21:914 (37) - k
7. 00:22:083 (38) - k
8. 00:28:150 (37) - k
9. 00:34:723 (92) - D
10. 01:23:262 (462) - k
11. 01:27:307 (498) - K
12. 01:27:392 (499) - re

Cuvelia wrote:

Hi ~ , Taiko modding ~ .

These are all suggestion. If you don't like them , you could ignore

| d = don | k = kat | D = BIG DON | K = BIG KAT | re = remove |


[Taiko Muzukashii]

1. 00:12:813 (11) - D Good idea but the 1.3 SV does not allow the tight D. Kept
2. 00:22:251 (18) - K ok
3. 00:25:959 (30) - k ok
4. 00:29:835 (44) - k ok
5. 00:31:858 (53) - re ok
6. 00:56:296 (154) - D ok
7. 01:20:566 (57) - k ok
8. 01:21:493 (60) - k ok
9. 01:21:914 (62) - d ok
10. 01:23:262 (67) - k nope, cause there is no treble
11. 01:24:611 (72) - K
12. 01:25:959 (77) - K
13. 01:27:307 (82) - K The tree one has the same reason as the first mod

[Taiko Oni]

1. 00:18:206 (23) - D ok
2. 00:18:880 (25) - k ok
3. 00:19:218 (26) - k ok
4. 00:20:229 (30) - k ok
5. 00:20:566 (31) - k ok
6. 00:21:914 (37) - k ok
7. 00:22:083 (38) - k ok
8. 00:28:150 (37) - k ok
9. 00:34:723 (92) - D ok
10. 01:23:262 (462) - k ok
11. 01:27:307 (498) - K ok
12. 01:27:392 (499) - re ok

good luck !!

Niva wrote:

...what happened on 00:22:335 (18) on Taiko Muzukashii diff o.o...

Anything else looks fine~

Niva wrote:

EDIT : Okay, definitely the map has improved a lot, and personally I think it's the time (:
Sorry for my recheck lateness orz >_<

Bubbled ~

Andrea wrote:

~Taiko Muzukashii~

00:27:981 (40) - Unsnapped slider end. fixed
00:44:161 (113) - ^ fixed

~Another~

01:13:150 (1) - This slider could be stacked better. fixed