lkx_shore wrote:

mod from my queue

General
nice song,maybe you can cut beginning,because it so long - i will do when i'm not so lazy

Dream
why not use more whistle? - whistles are work in progress, only claps and finishes added
01:17:126 (6) - 3hit is better,i fell - fixed
01:19:626 - add note - added
01:39:126 (1) - head add finish - added
02:48:126 (1) - new combo and finish - new combo yes, no finish

Normal
this look like Easy,:? - it's called Sleep anyway, so it doesn't matter yet
OD2→4
AR3→4
HP2→4 - all fixed
02:09:126 (1) - head finish
02:15:126 (1) - ↑
02:20:876 (4) - Tail finish - no hitsounds changed here

Pink Agate wrote:

HI,modding time


Sleep

00:00:000 - ~00:48:126 (1) - beatmap read time is too long,you can add some note - still need to think if I remove this part or map it
01:10:126 - add a circle an stack in 01:10:376 (2) - (just suggest) - nooooo
01:21:126 (1) - too close to 01:20:376 (4) - ，Maybe you can open AiMod to check。- not sure, will leave it like this now, maybe change it later
01:35:126 (3) - too close to 01:34:376 (2) - fixed
01:34:376 (2) - Are you Are you sure this isn't it difficult for easy diff? - not sure, not changing yet
02:11:626 (3) - ^ - ^
02:22:626 (2) - Be in front of the this slider02:20:876 (4) - the cover - fixed
02:24:126 (1,2) - too close to 02:23:376 (4) - fixed
02:39:126 (1) - too close to 02:38:626 (5) - ^
02:43:626 (3) - too close to 02:42:876 (2) - ^


Dream
Is it hard diff?I think you can reduce the difficulty,
just like HP and OD use 4 ,DS use 0.8x - made some changes


OK,nice hitsound，good luck!

wantuole wrote:

[Genera]
difficulty name is very interesting
do more careful in easy difficulty next time
[Sleep]
is all dis snap,but seem a little junmp,maybe close to dis snop is butter - what?
AR-1? - just fixed after previous mod, but thanks~
01:18:126 (1) - move left a little,same like 01:17:626 (4,5) - fixed little bit, but not into straight line
01:21:626 (2) - middle is no sound,not clap - but there is clap alraedy
[Dream]
good job
01:47:376 (9,10) - ctrl+r - no
02:13:126 (5,7) - ^ - uh, fine
[Jaymare]
only for looking,feel so bad for play ，don't know why get this jump in a slow song, use it in exrta song is butter
00:48:126 - cut green line, change red line vol 35% is ok


that all ,good luck

Lally wrote:

M4M ~

[Sleep]
01:11:126 (3) ~ remove some points http://puu.sh/18lE9 - less points, but will be uglier imo ;w;
01:16:376 (3) ~ ^ http://puu.sh/18lF5 - no
01:27:876 (3) ~ ^ http://puu.sh/18lGL - no
01:43:376 (3) ~ ^ http://puu.sh/18lMf - okay
02:12:126 (1) ~ ^ same - it doesn't even fit there, why why what

[Dream]
01:20:126 (9) ~ nc - noooo
01:21:126 (1) ~ remove NC and add it here : 01:21:626 - no
01:41:626 (9) ~ nc / remove it here: 01:42:126 (1) - no
01:44:876 (12) ~ nc/ remove it here: 01:45:126 (1) - no
01:46:376 ~ nc - done
01:57:126 ~ just a little bit shorter the slider http://puu.sh/18Nvj - done
02:23:376 ~ remove some points http://puu.sh/18NwI and new combo / remove it here : 02:24:126 - done
02:26:376 ~ nc - done

• 00:48:126 (1,2,3) - I'd prefer if all this was symmetric on the Y-axis
  00:51:126 (1,2) - you can better these blankets around 3 out
  00:57:126 (1,2) - I suggest swapping the new combo since there is a new soundpattern starting at 2 while 1 still follows the previous
  00:58:376 (4) - also add a new combo here because the sound pattern of 2-3 repeats here and it's an in-itself closed one as there is a break inbetween, makes more sense to me
  00:59:126 (6) - the 1/2 there is overdone, just have it be 1/1 or silence the reverse arrow
  01:00:126 (1) - I'd put the slider so it has the reverse arrow on the blue tick, that'd suit the light sound in the song more (blue tick: 01:00:501), then add another slider at 01:01:251 that ends at 01:01:626
  01:03:126 (1) - again this would look better if it was symmetrically placed on the Y-axis
  01:06:126 (1) - same
  01:11:126 (3) - a 1/1 slider with a reverse arrow would do better here, also the overlap with 1 is meeh
  01:16:376 (3) - this should end at 01:16:876 to follow the song better
  01:17:126 - you can add a 1/4 slider here, should be k even for lowest diff
  01:21:626 (2) - I don't see the reason behind this shape, the edgyness that comes from the red points does not suit the song too well either, it just seems to skip part of the song because you had no idea what to do there
  01:24:626 (1) - ^
  01:27:876 (3) - feels better if this ends 1/2 earlier; you can put a circle to where it currently ends
  01:31:876 - add a circle here?
  01:33:126 (1) - stack on previous 2's end
  01:38:126 (3,4,1,2) - that square could be done better; for that, copy 3-4, rotate by 90°, put 0.0x snap and set it onto 4, so you get 1's correct position; do the same for 2
  01:43:376 (3) - this should end 1/1 earlier
  01:46:876 (3) - make this blanket 4 better, gridsnap off
  01:50:126 (3) - this came kinda sudden as you never had more than one reverse arrow before
  01:57:126 (1) - that slider is meeh... change it, it's not smooth enough for the song
  02:00:126 (1) - should end 1/2 later
  02:11:626 (3) - stack that properly on 1's end
  02:15:126 (1) - move the sliderpoints (not counting end and start) more to the right to make the curve look more interesting
  
  
  here

  
  
  02:18:126 (1) - similar, CTRL-J
  02:19:876 (2,3,4) - these sliders starting on red ticks feel awkward to hit and hold, please change this so they either start on whites or use circles
  02:21:376 (1) - put the sliderpoint more to the right (coordinates are 295|40) to generate a better curve
  
  02:42:876 (2) - you can improve this blanket
  02:45:126 (1) - the current shape is kind of creative, though I suggest another one; see below
  
  
  dere

  

• 00:48:126 (1,2) - you can improve these blankets
  00:50:126 (4) - i don't like how the slider pokes out of the playfield and iirc, objects that touch the HP-bar too much are unrankable
  00:51:626 (2,3) - these curves are somewhat weirdo, better just use one sliderpoint each
  
  
  as in here

  
  
  00:54:126 (1,2,3,4,5) - this pattern comes kinda sudden and the spacing appears to be very wide; I'd suggest 1.3x instead
  00:56:126 (6) - a) new combo, b) move it so it's not as close to previous 1, that feels ugly to me
  00:57:126 (1,2,3) - first you get a straight movement from 1 to 2, then you go edgyly up-left; that transition is not so good; I suggest mirroring 2-3 and placing them so 2's start is on where 4 starts - that gives a better connection and feel
  
  
  here, so you got something to look at

  
  
  00:59:126 (4) - that curve is somewhat unbalanced, move the sliderpoints to 376|215 (2nd), 450|164 (3rd), 443|90 (end) to fix
  01:06:126 (1,2,3,4,5) - well this is kiiiiiiiiinda wide, better use 1.4x or 1.6x imo
  01:11:126 (4) - as in easy/normal diff, use 1/1 reverse slider here
  01:20:126 (9) - that shape is very clunchily compressed which makes it look ugly, just use a little curve
  
  
  as this one

  
  
  01:22:376 (6) - appears a bit too compressed, move 2nd sliderpoint to 362|189 and 3rd to 333|225
  01:23:126 (8) - creative shape; either use a custom slidertick for the tick on this or do a 1/1 reverseslider to suit the rhythm better - i'd prefer the slidertick option
  01:25:376 (3) - at the current state the red point is somewhat useless, make it poke more out
  01:26:126 (4) - to balance this more out, move 2nd sliderpoint to 516|229, 3rd to 512|178, 4th to 480|136 and end to 373|184
  01:29:126 (6,7) - not sure about how much these are overblended by 3's and 4's hitbursts, better move them somewhere else
  01:29:376 (7) - that could blanket next 1 better
  01:32:626 (9) - suggesting to put this to 470|276 to follow the flow better
  01:32:876 (10) - this to 417|366
  01:33:126 (1) - move 2nd sliderpoint to 248|330 for better blanket of 2's start
  01:33:876 (2) - move sliderend to 243|93 to have a better blanket around 1's end
  01:34:626 (3) - improve blanket around 4's start
  01:35:626 (5) - I do not like how this comes so close to 4's end, more distance please; also, make it blanket next 1
  01:38:126 (4) - that should end exactly where 2 ended, right now it's a bit more to the right from what I see
  01:39:126 (1) - trapezoid sliderpointplacement makes this feel bad; more curve please
  01:47:126 (2,3,4,5,1) - these jumps came sudden and also are hard to decipher with the current AR
  01:50:126 (5,6,7,8,1) - such patterns are meeh to play in general; remove some of the sliders or redesign it
  01:51:126 (1,2,3) - this straight dropping movement doesn't feel too flowy to me
  01:52:376 (7) - red point is somewhat badly placed/negated by the white ones around it, make it stand out more or remove it and redesign the slider
  01:53:626 (8) - too close to 7's slidertrack imo
  01:54:126 (1,2,3) - that straight line is not pretty desu
  01:59:376 (6,7) - kinda giantic spacing
  02:00:376 (1) - ninjaspin for such a diff, please do not do this - better use a long slider
  02:01:626 (1,2) - 30% volume for these
  02:02:126 (3,4) - 40% for these
  02:02:626 (5) - slider is very clunchy and thus feels bad
  02:03:126 (1) - start your 55% volume again on this one - also, this slider is clunchy again, don't make it feels so crumply-overlapping
  02:03:876 (2,3) - ginourmeous spacing, do this in your highest diff if you want but not in the middle one
  02:05:126 (4,5,6) - I do not like this after 3 :<
  02:06:876 (3,4,5) - straight line movement is still meeh
  02:08:126 (6,7) - this is a new soundpattern, thus, NC
  02:09:126 (1,2) - swap NC, 1 belongs to the soundpattern of 6,7
  02:11:126 (6) - clunchy
  02:15:126 (1) - rotate this by 35° (selection center), then arrange following objects to it
  02:16:126 (2) - improve this blanket
  02:18:126 (1) - that may partly be overlapped by 4's hitbursts and it's not too pretty in general
  02:23:376 (1) - I do totemo not like this :<
  02:25:626 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - maybe add variety in volume here?
  
  02:28:876 (4,5,6) - i find this transition bad - 4 points downwards but you go upwards with your objects, that does not fit each other
  02:30:126 (1,2) - these could blanket each other's ends a bit better
  02:34:626 (3) - the overlap with 1,2 is ugly and the spacing feels too close, might be misshit as a 1/3 or 1/4
  02:35:126 (4,5,6,7,1) - HUGE spacing o_o (please change, this is not what belongs in a hard diff)
  02:37:126 (3,4,5) - ^
  02:38:126 (6) - new combo; this will be misshit as 1/2 because of the little spacing
  02:38:126 (6,7,8,9) - makes no sense that these are regularely spaced when you have huge jumps at 02:35:126 - that is the same soundpattern
  02:45:126 (1,2,3,4) - these curves are kinda clunchy and compressed, balance them more - also, big big jumps again :v
  02:47:126 (5) - NC because of new soundpattern
  02:48:126 (1) - remove NC, still same soundpattern

hoozimajiget wrote:

Gogogo!! Hinkstep is thouroughly amazing, their release is one of my all time favourite albums.

GL with ranking

1. try using normal-hitnormal sound as your costom clap sound

1. 00:52:626 (2) - please keep your distance
2. 00:59:126 (3) - i don't recommend to mute the arrow, use at least 30% please
3. 01:21:126 (1) - don'y overlap like this plz, it's annoying to read
4. 01:32:876 (5) - i don't recommend to stack like this in easiest diff, can you find any other ways?
5. 01:48:626 (2) - raise it a bit to avoid overlapping with 01:48:126 (1) -
6. 01:50:626 - missing clap
7. 02:20:376 - ^
8. 02:31:626 - ^

1. 01:06:126 (1,2,3,4,5) - this jump is too sharp, maybe use 1.6x
2. 01:24:876 (2) - avoid overlapping with 01:23:126 (8) -
3. 01:29:126 (6) - it's really annoying to read for me, can you find other ways
4. 01:32:126 (6) - it feels too lack of sound, 40% would be better imo
5. 01:46:376 (1) - make a neat slider plz
6. 02:25:751 (2) - a bit hard to hit it well, stack it on 02:25:626 (1) - plz
7. 02:37:126 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - too sharp again, reduce its distance plz

All repeat arrows on sliders must be visible. Make sure that hitbursts (100s/300s/etc) from previous notes are not covering the repeat arrows or even the paths/ends of sliders (use the default skin to check if using hitbursts from another skin). This way, all sliders will be easily visible and playable.

1. too less hitsounds.. although song quiet and smooth, there must enough hitsounds here/_\
2. overlaps should be fixed. for example, 02:35:126 (4) - in diff <dream> : it almost covered by 02:33:876 (2) - . you should put it out owo☆

1. 01:18:126 (1) - try add whistle
2. 01:21:126 (1) - ^
3. 01:27:126 (1) - ^
4. 01:30:126 (1) - ^
5. 01:33:126 (1) - start^
6. 01:36:126 (1) - ^
7. 01:48:376 - +note
8. 01:58:876 (5) - move clap to slider end
9. 02:01:876 - +note
10. 02:06:126 (1) - +whistle
11. 02:09:126 (3) - ^
12. 02:12:126 (3) - ^
13. 02:15:126 (3) - start^
14. 02:18:126 (3) - ^
15. 02:21:126 (1) - ^
16. 02:24:626 (5) - ^
17. 02:25:126 (7) - clap at start
18. 02:35:126 (4) - NC for spacing change

1. 01:18:126 (1) - whistle
2. 01:21:126 (1) - ^
3. 01:27:126 (1) - ^
4. 01:30:126 (1) - ^
5. 01:33:126 (1) - start^
6. 01:36:126 (1) - ^
7. 02:39:126 (1) - 1 grid right(grid level 4). put it on y-axis.

• 
  "re" is means "remove"
  Black is just suggestion ~OAO , if you don't like , you can skip it
  Blue is recommended to fix
  red is unrankable issue

[Sleep]

1. 00:57:126 (4,1) - swap NC ?~

[Dream]

1. 01:35:126 (4) - re clap in the start
2. 01:50:876 (10) - add clap?
3. 01:59:876 (7) - re finish in the end, strange for me
4. 02:20:626 (10) - re clap?
5. 02:48:126 (5) - NC?

l1106188 wrote:

Hi~
Sorry, I am late, I am busy in this month ;w;
M4M from L18's & Crystal's Modding Queue.

• 
  "re" is means "remove"
  Black is just suggestion ~OAO , if you don't like , you can skip it
  Blue is recommended to fix
  red is unrankable issue

[Sleep]

1. 00:57:126 (4,1) - swap NC ?~ - done

[Dream]

1. 01:35:126 (4) - re clap in the start - done
2. 01:50:876 (10) - add clap? - done
3. 01:59:876 (7) - re finish in the end, strange for me - no
4. 02:20:626 (10) - re clap? - no
5. 02:48:126 (5) - NC? - done

good song & good luck~
sorry for late ;w;
and sorry to my poor English