1. trun off Letterbox in Breaks
2. fix Frobe's Source, it's jubeat copius now
3. in Frombe's diff, add timing of #5 kiai ends on 01:53:644
4. delete 'collab' from tags
5. consider making easier diff

1. 00:01:022 (1) - fix this annoying slider, move 4th tick to (232,24), and 5th tick to (264,64), more looks good, isn't it?
2. 00:12:050 - feels empty, add a circle here
3. 00:12:374 - ^
4. 00:12:698 (1) - same as 00:01:022 (1) -
5. 00:17:887 (4) - move 1st tick 1grid left(you should keep press shift when you move it) and 4th tick to (372,24), so that they don't touch 00:16:590 (3) - at all
6. 00:28:914 (4) - remove the annoying whistle from body, and don't curve it, stretch it
7. 00:36:050 (2) - remove clap and add whistle, what you did like 00:37:347 -
8. 00:37:347 - remove clap, only whistle will emphasize the sweet melody
9. 00:41:239 - ^
10. 00:42:212 - ^
11. 00:42:536 (3) - 1grid up to be symmetry with 00:41:239 (2) -
12. 00:44:158 - same as 00:37:347 -
13. 00:44:806 - ^
14. 00:49:022 (1) - remove the annoying whistle from body, should be on head and tail only
15. 00:50:320 (1,2) - remove the clap in each tails
16. 00:51:617 (1,2) - add whistle on each arrows
17. 00:55:509 (3) - add whistle
18. 00:55:995 (4) - add shistle (head,body,tail)
19. 00:55:995 (4,1,2) - chance to make a nice stack here, move 00:55:995 (4) - to (300,300) and 00:56:806 (1) - to (200,68) to be symmetry, also you should move the 4th tick left so that it doesn't touch 00:55:995 (4) - , then move 00:58:104 (2) - to (320,68)
20. 01:05:887 (1) - this spinner should start from 01:07:185 - , add 2 more sliders or circles between 01:05:887 - and 01:06:860 -
21. 01:13:671 (3) - ctrl+r to flow, and 1.0x distance
22. 01:14:320 (4,1) - 1.0x distance plz
23. 01:25:347 (1) - down this touching hp bar slider
24. 01:31:185 (2) - 1 grid up to be symmetry with 01:30:860 (1,3) -
25. 01:33:131 (1,2) - ^
26. 01:46:590 (2) - 6 grid up will be more playable
27. 01:49:185 (2) - ^

1. 00:35:077 (2) - delete clap will be fit with music
2. 00:36:374 (2) - ^
3. 00:37:671 - ^
4. 00:40:266 (2) - ^
5. 00:41:563 (2) - ^
6. 01:08:320 - i think this 5% is useless
7. 01:08:482 (1) - 5% volume instead of finish, there's no melody
8. 01:14:644 (1) - fix this invisible arrow
9. 01:34:752 (2) - 2 grid right the 3rd tick

1. consider adding name tag SB
2. 00:17:887 (1,2,3,4,1) - ctrl+r to follow 00:16:590 (1,2,3,4) - (don't drag)
3. 01:19:590 (1) - if you really want to NC here, you should NC 01:19:509 (6) - , not here
4. 01:25:022 (4) - NC like other notes
5. 01:29:887 (1) - because you did NC at 01:19:590 (2) - , NC it plz

BeatofIke wrote:

Request from modding queue, but I can't find any suggustions. Sorry!

STAR~

thx

1. Remove .osb, it's empty

1. Volume 50% on the first red tick
   Too fast slider velocity, but who cares
2. Work on a beauty of the sliders, and use 5 points on a big sliders
3. 00:11:401 (3) - eh 1 grid right
4. 00:11:725 - note there
5. 00:12:050 - green section there with the soft sound, and 00:12:050 (1) - whistle there
6. 00:12:698 - volume 35%
7. 00:24:374 - wow, my ears, 65% volume there
8. 00:24:374 (1,2,1,2) - make them the same
   like this:
   SPOILER

   
9. 00:42:536 (3) -
   SPOILER

   
10. 00:56:806 (1) - bend an object near the slider
11. 01:09:779 - 65% volume
12. 01:26:644 (2) - stack with 01:24:698 (3) (i think you've understand)
13. 01:30:536 - add note there, coz kiai must end on the note yeah and sounds better with it
14. 01:35:725 - ^

1. 00:01:023 - finish there
2. 00:08:806 - ^
3. 00:08:806 - i hear whistles there
4. 00:24:374 (1) - remove clap there
5. 00:28:266 (1) - ooone grid down
6. 00:34:671 - remove clap there D:
7. 00:55:509 (1,2) - do it like this:
   SPOILER

   
   and copy it, flip horizontally and add there 00:56:806
8. 00:58:104 (1,2) - will be better if: 00:58:752 (2) - this slider on a previous red tick and add note there - 00:59:077
9. 01:14:644 (1) - not visible reverses, change the angleof rotation

1. AR = 8, coz the other indicators are easier
2. 00:01:023 (1) - finish
3. 00:08:806 (1) - ^
4. 00:08:806 - remove that green sections, they're wrong or you can add it there - 00:09:293 (silence this note 00:09:293 (4) - )
5. 00:41:077 - note there
6. 00:42:374 - ^
7. 00:55:833 (2,3) - spacing
8. 00:59:401 - add there the same normal sounds like in the previous part, on the each beat
9. 01:52:590 (1,2) - make them parallel

SPOILER

300,52,58104,2,0,B|375:19|467:141|415:205,1,240,0|0

SPOILER

[/spolierbox]
but for the next pattern
[spoilerbox]

SPOILER

1. Timing points
   
   
   1. 00:11:725 - You can not hear whistle at all with this volume. I recommend 70% here and remove the claps from this section. I will suggestion how to do hitsound here later.
   2. 00:12:697 - What is this timing point use for?
   3. 00:19:185 - Lower the volume of this spinner when you change 00:11:725 as 50% is too loud for this spinner.
   4. 00:46:428 - This part sound a bit quieter than the previous. I think you should add 50-55% volume timing point here. If you use 50%, be sure to remove duplicate timing point.
   5. 00:59:401 - Spinner is too loud, consider adding a timing point with lower volume.
   6. 01:01:995 - Don't forget to add 60% volume here if you follow the above suggestions.
   7. 01:36:374 - Feel this spinner is a bit too loud.
   8. 01:51:293 - ^, -10% from these two spinners seem good.

1. New combos
   
   
   1. 00:55:509 (3) - New combo here because you did 2 combos for the previous section 00:49:022 (1,2,1,2)

1. Hitsound
   
   
   1. 00:11:077 (3) - Clap or finish I think fits well with the drums in music.
   2. 00:12:698 (2) - Follow the piano, add whistle to begin, clap doesn't sound good so remove from end.
   3. 00:14:320 (2) - Whistle on the whole slider and remove clap.
   4. 00:15:293 (1) - Whistle at begin and end for piano
   5. 00:16:266 (2,3) - Whistle on (2) and begin of (3), remove clap from end of (3)
   6. 00:17:887 (4) - Whistle on begin, remove clap from end. Especially if you follow what I said in the timing point here, clap sound really bad.
   7. 00:32:806 (2,3) - Just whistle on the end sound better to me, clap sound off to me.
   8. 00:43:833 (1,2) - Clap at end sound nice to me.
   9. 00:49:995 (2) - Why no whistle + clap like the end of these two sliders? 00:46:428 (1,2) -
   10. 00:51:617 (1,2) - Similar here, inconsistent with 00:46:428 (1,2) -
   11. 00:55:185 (2) - Same as 00:49:995.
   12. 00:58:104 (2) - Removing this timing point and keeping at 50% seem better. You are emphasizing the drum like this, but the drum in music doesn't get louder here.
   13. 01:20:644 (1) - Why clap at end, the clap sound is playing on the 2nd and 4th white tick. If you want to put clap at end, put it at the end of the repeating slider in previous section, on the red tick is really weird. Like 01:22:752 (1), this make sense as the end is on the 4th white tick, but not here.
   14. 01:36:050 (1) - Since there was a pause here, I don't think you should continue the clap pattern and just put only finish. So that you see that the clap "restarts" and not just continues.
   15. 01:40:914 (1,2,1,2) - I think putting all whistle here fits well with how the instrument is here. Instrument remind me a lot of whistle spam
   16. 01:46:104 (1) - I think whistle here is better.
   17. 01:48:698 (1) - ^

1. Placement & Rhythm
   
   
   1. 00:01:022 (1) - Feel weird to me as there is a missing clap because you did a long slider. How about adding clap at end to compensate for this?
   2. 00:03:617 (1) - ^
   3. 00:06:212 (1,2,3) - Same concept, put on the end to be consistent with the above two sliders. Remove clap from (2) and put on begin of (3) instead. Remove from end as the music gets quiet there.
   4. 00:17:887 (4) - I prefer if you copy (3) instead http://puu.sh/ym1K
   5. 00:49:995 (2) - To be honest, I prefer if you do repeating slider here too. The slider end on a red tick, but this circle is on the white tick. Hard to hit properly, especially for beginner.
   6. 00:55:185 (2) - For the easiest diff, I don't think you need this note. A bit hard to explain, but since you did a long slider, felt weird to play a 1/1 hit circle patterns. Plus if you do this, you emphasize 00:55:509 (2) much more, and in the music, this note is quite emphasized.
   7. 00:56:806 (1) - Something like this looks nicer to me http://puu.sh/ym4p
   8. 01:46:104 (1,2) - To emphasize just the whistle (if you follow my whistle suggestion in hitsound), I suggest slider here, gives a really nice effect with the whistle hitsound.
   9. 01:48:698 (1,2) - ^

1. Timing points
   
   
   1. 01:08:320 - Shouldn't silence the end of this slider when there is still sound in music. Move to begin of the spinner instead.
   2. 01:39:617 (3) - Why not do the same thing with the timing point as 01:38:320 (1) ?
   3. 01:43:509 - Perhaps add timing point with 70% volume here to represent the increase in loudness in the music here.

1. New combos
   
   
   1. 01:05:239 (1) - All your combos are 4 white ticks long here, only these two combos are 2 white ticks. Feel weird to me. I suggest removing this new combo.
   2. 01:14:644 (1) - This seem inconsistent with 00:34:428 (4) - Choose what you want to do and keep it consistent.
   3. 01:17:239 (1) - ^
   4. 01:25:022 (4) - ^
   5. 01:27:617 (5) - ^
   6. 01:31:185 (1) - Hm, why new combo here? The song "restarts" at end of 01:30:536 (1) so I think they should still be in same combo.
   7. 01:35:725 (1) - ^
   8. 01:48:698 (1) - New combo here? So 01:46:104 (1,2,3,4) and 01:48:698 (1,2,3,4) have the same number of combos. You can combo-hax it if you don't like the color.

1. Hitsound
   
   
   1. 00:09:455 (3,4) - Whistle on the begin of these sliders make sense to me, but maybe too loud with the volume you use here.
   2. 00:32:158 (1) - Clap on repeat and end, 00:32:968 (4) - clap at begin and end. Sound a bit better for me, the clap are use to follow the bass drum (sound that is similar to the normal-finish).
   3. 00:34:752 (1,2,3,4) - I think it's better to do whistle rather than the clap with what you're doing here. Won't mention again, this apply to all similar rhythm.
   4. 00:45:941 (4) - The sound at the end of this slider is a drum tick, cymbal sound really off to it. I suggest whistle instead.
   5. 01:08:482 (1) - Weird finish as there is a almost no sound or very quiet sound at the end of this spinner and 00:21:779 (1) -
   6. 01:17:887 (3) - Clap sound good here for me.
   7. 01:23:239 (3) - Feel like a hitsound is missing at begin, whistle on it?
   8. 01:28:266 (2) - Listen to end of this slider, really feel like it need a hitsound, consider whistle.
   9. 01:38:320 (1) - Remove from whistle at end, unlike (3), there is no sound at end of this slider.
   10. 01:46:104 (1,2,3) - Whistle would work better than clap imo. If you really want to keep clap, remove from end of (3).
   11. 01:48:698 (5,6,7) - ^

1. Placement & Rhythm
   
   Recommend -1 od for nicer difficulty jump from basic.
   
   
   1. 00:45:131 (1) - Would play better if the hitsound volume was a bit higher (+10%?)
   2. 00:59:401 (1) - ^, this is to get gameplay feedback on when you hit a note, when a slider ball reach the end of a slider, when you hit a repeat, etc. This is why I put this mod here and not in timing point/hitsound.

1. Timing points
   
   
   1. 00:16:590 - As mention in Normal, I think you should follow piano here and not do clap liek this. So you should increase volume of this so you can hear the whistle more and remove claps. Also, the timing points after this are useless 00:17:536 - 00:18:536, all the timing point in between doesn't change anything.
   2. 00:46:428 - Same as what I mention in Basic.
   3. 01:01:995 - Normal hitsound should restart here with higher volume than 00:46:428.
   4. 01:08:320 - You should move this timing point to the begin of the spinner as there is still sound playing at the end of the slider.
   5. 01:43:509 - I would do slightly higher volume here.
   6. 01:51:941. 01:52:941 and 01:53:239 - The volume change is quite small, plus I don't see that much change in the volume of the music here so I think these timing points are unnecessary.

1. New combos
   
   
   1. 00:31:509 (8) - Maybe new combo here?
   2. 01:06:536 (3) - Think you should new combo here.
   3. 01:37:022 (6) - Combo feel a little too long, maybe new combo here, notice you follow stanza for most new combo (big white tick).
   4. 01:42:860 (3) - New combo here to make all combo 2 notes long

1. Hitsound
   
   
   1. 00:08:968 (2,6) - Whistle on these two notes for hihat.
   2. 00:19:833 (3) - Remove this whistle
   3. 00:16:590 - 00:21:617 - Remove clap from this section, the only instrument playing is piano, clap is more to follow when there are drums. Also, instead of doing for example 70% volume on the entire section. How about adding 70% volume only when the piano is playing really loudly like 00:16:590,
   4. 00:17:563, 00:17:887, etc. Give a nice effect and you can keep the current whistle pattern.
   5. 00:20:482 (1,2,3,4) - Whistle at begin of these slider, remove finish from (4). I can't hear any cymbal to justify finish here.
   6. 00:25:671 (1) - Whistle fits more with the instrument, clapping to the blue tick is generally weird.
   7. 00:26:968 (1,2) - Whistle for the repeat of these two sliders as well.
   8. 00:29:239 (6) - Because of instrument that play here and 00:29:563, I think you should put clap here.
   9. 00:34:590 (8,9) - The song sort of distort here, so clap seemed weird. I think you should remove. Since the hitosund isn't distort like the song, so weird to hear a clean sound with a distort sound.
   10. 00:45:455 (2) - Whistle at end sound good with what you did with the whistle on last slider.
   11. 00:45:941 (4) - The finish at end is way too loud, I prefer whistle instead.
   12. 00:54:698 (4) - You should put whistle at the begin of this slider.
   13. 00:59:239 (5) - Should start soft-hitsound at the end of this slider and put whistle to be consistent with this combo.
   14. 00:59:401 (1,2,3,4) - Do this for hitsound, (1) & (3), begin and end, whistle (no other hitsound). (2) & (4), clap at begin, whistle at end. Sound better with music.
   15. 01:00:698 (1,5) - Clap at end of (1) and on (5) to continue the clap pattern.
   16. 01:10:671 (4) - Clap on blue tick sound really weird, just whistle is better.
   17. 01:11:968 (6) - ^, the drum is playing on the white tick, not blue so this is why it sound weird. Like here 01:13:266 (2,3), you did the hitsound correctly here.
   18. 01:22:266 (2,4) - I think whistle with reduced volume would sound good.
   19. 01:27:941 (1,2) - Same thing, but at end of these slider
   20. 01:38:320 (1) - Think you should have a finish at begin
   21. 01:39:617 (1) - ^
   22. 01:46:104 (1,2) - Whistle at both slider begin
   23. 01:48:698 (1,2) - Same thing, but whistle on repeat for (2). Recommend to leave finish and clap from begin of (1).

1. Placement & Rhythm
   
   
   1. 00:24:617 (2) - Imo, should do stream instead, really weird not to hit anything for the sound at 00:24:698 to me.
   2. 00:31:509 (8,9) - I think you can easily overlap here.
   3. 00:31:671 (9) - Also, I think it better to do hit circle rather than this slider. Feel weird to me having to hit a slider than play a stream right afterward.
   4. 00:34:590 (8,9,1) - Can you move the whole stream further right? Would play better to me if this were a jump.
   5. 00:37:185 (4,5) - Feel like there should be a jump, can you stack this note on (1)?
   6. 01:11:077 (1,3,5) - Can you adjust this part so that there is jump on these notes? Felt weird to me this part because you didn't do any jump here. Something like this http://puu.sh/yoed
   7. 01:42:212 (1,2,3,4) - Should be bigger jump, not very noticeable atm.
   8. 01:43:833 (1,1,1) - Weird not to do jump on these notes since you did jump for it at 01:41:239 (1,1,1).
      Hopefully, I didn't miss anything.

haha5957 wrote:

다큰 빵's request in #korean

[Extreme]

01:07:499 (2) - grid left fix
01:15:121 (2,3,4) - 여기에 점프가 있잖아요, 01:09:769 (1,2) - 여기도 점프가 있고.. 그런데 01:16:256 (1,2) - 여기에는 점프가 없어요.
무튼 잡설 버리고 결론부터 말하자면 01:16:256 (1,2) - 여기서도 점프를 하고싶은 느낌이에요 죄송합니다 전체적인 난이도나 분위기가 그런쪽으로 이끌어 가더라고요

예를들어 01:20:148 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - 이부분을 보시면 이 부분은 점프가 알맞은 부분에 규칙적으로 잘 들어가있는데, 위에 언급된 부분같은 경우는 좀 불규칙하고 랜덤한 점프였다는 느낌이 강해요. ^

01:32:472 (1,2,3,4) - 이전 점프에 비해 조금더 멀리 뛰고싶은 느낌인데 같은부분에 같혀있어서 으앙해요. 좀더 넓은 공간을 흐르듯 스치는 점프를 만들면? ^
01:42:202 (1,2,3,4) - 바로 전부분과 음악의 변화도 없고 계속 단타를 치고싶은 부분이에요. 01:43:499 (1) - 이 부분부터는 음악의 느낌이 다르니 패턴도 달라도 괜찮지만요. 저부분 모두 단타를 넣으면 아마 가비맵처럼 이상해질겁니다.
01:53:229 (1,2,3) - 예를 들면 삼각형모양의 점프를 치고싶어지는 부분이에요 이것도 맵의 전체적인 난이도 문제로...

전반적으로 괜찮네요 헤헤
good fang ^-^ thx ^-^

[Basic]

00:30:526 (2) - 이런 서클들을 이전 서클과 겹치게 잘 패턴들을 조종해서 미세한 부분들에 신경써주는것을 제외하면 괜찮은것같아요 이전은 무리더라도 다음노트와는 곂치게 하엿습니다. 지적감사합니다

[Beginner]

죄송해요 귀찮아요(우울) :3


화이팅 다큰빵님 'ㅁ'/ 'ㅁ'/ !!!

Leorda wrote:

Hi there Hi


[General]
* I heard that one taiko diff are unrankable.... Maybe add one more taiko diff? one Taiko diff is not unrankable :3that's rule apply to after 7/29 submit maps


[Beginners]
00:12:040 (1) - This slider isn't that great, make a same slider as 00:13:985 (3)? fix, that's more pretty
00:58:418 (1) - Remove new combo fix.


[Extreme]
00:21:850 (1) - End at 00:23:715? of course
00:41:067 (4,5,1) - Not stack correctly with head slider (look at test mode for proof). I suggest you to move further away from it well.... I think that's okay, sorry..
01:30:526 (1) - 0,5x slider after streams are make the break flow. Try something else? sorry , I think that's good
01:35:715 (1) - ^ ^


That's all I got, hope it's help! thx

Leorda wrote:

[Frobe's Advanced]
00:34:418 (4) - Remove 1 repeating slider, so players are able to click the next note with perfect timed
00:44:796 (4) - ^
01:14:634 (4) - ^
01:17:229 (4) - ^
01:25:012 (4) - ^
01:27:607 (5) - ^

kajiyatta wrote:

hi from #modreq
General
me likes this song 33 almost suggestions
Beginner
AR4 seems a bit faster , OD3 seems good I think
Placement
00:11:391(3) 1 grid down?
01:29:229(2) like this? it's more hitable for newbie I think.

SPOILER

Rythem
01:52:904 add a note?
Hit Sonud
00:16:580(1) add whistle at head? I hear back sounds.

Basic
Placement
00:18:850(4) x:256 y:212 ?
01:30:850(1) it's a bit closer, so try to replace? e.g.)

SPOILER

01:46:094(1) DS error?
Rythem
00:21:769(4) delete this note and start spinner this better I think. it fits with music.

SPOILER

Frobe's Advanced
me likes this diff =3
Rythem
00:11:067(3) remove 1 repeat and add anote?

SPOILER

SPOILER

Hit Sonud
00:44:472(3,4) add whistle at the head?

Extreme
wow, really pro map for your 1st map@@ awesome!
Placement
00:26:310(2) try this?

SPOILER

00:27:607(2)^

SPOILER

Hit Sonud
01:28:256(6) add whistle at the end?

that's all. so Excellent map, go Rank and star!

kajiyatta wrote:

Frobe's Advanced
me likes this diff =3
Rythem
00:11:067(3) remove 1 repeat and add anote?

SPOILER

SPOILER

Hit Sonud
00:44:472(3,4) add whistle at the head?

Sonnyc wrote:

모딩 드려요~ ㅇㅅㅇ 별 너무 많으신듯 어여 장판 잡으세요

Beginner:

00:38:634 (4) - 슬라이더 속의 휘슬은 없애주세요 Fix
01:09:769 (1) - 그냥 생각이지만 상하 대칭이 아닌게 아쉽네요.. Nope
01:20:148 (1) - 시작에 피니시 추가 끝에 박수는 왜 안넣으셨나요? 의도라면 두시고 실수면 뒤의 비슷한 사항도 고쳐주세요~ of course
01:39:607 (2) - 끝에 피니시? fix
01:42:202 (2) - 클랩 삭제 ^
01:43:499 (1) - 시작과 끝에 클랩 삭제 ^
01:52:904 (2,3) - 시작에 클랩? nope

Basic:

-- 비기너와 달리 박수가 없군요 ㅇㅅㅇ

00:04:904 (3) - 리버스. 디스탄스 따위.. of course and adjust next notes
00:07:499 (3) - ^ ^
00:16:580 (5) - 좀 더 왼쪽으로 움직이길 추천합니다 fix
00:56:472 (3) - 휘슬 삭제 nope i heard HL sound at that
01:07:823 (2) - 시작에 피니시 oops, Fix :3
01:08:472 (3) - 피니시 삭제 nope
01:36:040 (1) - (4)에 겹치는게 좋을 거 같습니다. 이후의 스페이싱은 알아서.. Fix

Frobe's Advanced:

00:11:067 (3) - 1/8 슬라이더로 바꾸는건 어떨까요 nope
00:32:148 (1) - 끝의 클랩 삭제 Fix
00:32:958 (4) - 중간의 휘슬 삭제 nope
00:42:526 (1) - 피니시 삭제 Fix
01:08:472 (1) - ^ nope
01:53:229 (1) - ^ nope

Extreme:

00:21:850 (1) - 님의 난이도와 동일하게 00:23:634에서 끝내세요 Fix xD
00:30:040 (3,4,5,6,7) - 연타가 적당하지 않은듯 합니다 (5,7) 삭제 Fix
01:23:715 (5) - 1칸 위로 Fix
01:45:121 (2,4) - ctrl+R nah

어려운 맵 모딩은 가능하지만 정작 매핑이 안되는 :OO cheer up
GOOD LUCK

NoHitter wrote:

[Beginner]
- 00:13:985 (3) - I suggest you reverse this (Ctrl+G) for better flow. sure. Fix
- 00:47:715 (2,3,4) - Make these into a repeat slider first, so that beginners can catch the rhythm first. You can use notes after that. of course I use repeat slider instead circle
- 00:59:391 (1,2,1,2,3,4,1,2,1,2) - IMO these combos should be placed 1/1 back, so that the notes will hit the downbeats. The rhythm is more distinct there. You can extend 01:07:823 (2) into a 1/1 slider. I fix and adjust them
- 01:21:769 (2,3) - [nazi] Move these right by one grid, so the slider blankets them better. You may want to adjust 01:22:742 (1) too. sure

[Basic]
- 00:21:121 (3) - I suggest you reverse this (Ctrl+G) for better flow. sure
- 00:37:337 (1) - IMO this looks better if you flip the slider vertically like this. Fix
- 00:42:526 (3,4,1,2,3) - May I suggest a pattern like this? It flows better. sure
- 00:46:418 (1,2,3,4) - I suggest you start with the repeat sliders like the ones in 00:49:012 (1) first to familiarize players with the rhythm. OK fix
- 00:59:391 (1) - Placing it like this looks better IMO. Being centered between the two sliders. sure fix
- 01:40:904 (1,2) - [nazi] The overlap doesn't look good. fix and adjust
- 01:53:229 (1) - Don't see a reason why you need to new combo this. Remove new combo. OK

[Frobe's Advanced]
- 00:10:094 (1,2,3) - I suggest you change the pattern to this. It looks neater. Fix
- 00:17:877 () - Map this break! There's really no reason not to. I consider that
- 00:26:148 (2) - [nazi] The overlap doesn't look good IMO. Fix
- 00:36:526 (3) - I suggest you reverse this (Ctrl+G) for better flow. OK fix
- 01:13:012 (3,4,5,1,2,3) - The pattern here doesn't really play well since it looks really clumped up. OK I fix it. keep to Frobe's pattern
- 01:17:229 (4) - Would look better like this IMO. OK fix
- 01:25:012 (4) - Same as above. Like this. Fix too
- 01:48:364 (5,6,7,8) - Why not use a slider instead for consistency? You've been using sliders up until now. nope. ond day Frobe said me "I like that's pattern and othes too"

[Taiko]
- Note: Regarding the kiai, flashes may be used but they fit the song as they emphasize the x1.50 speed parts.
- 00:10:742 (3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5) - kkddkkkkk fits the music better here. Fix
- 00:15:283 (3) - k here. You've been using k to emphasize the music similar to these parts. [Like in 00:12:688 (3) and 00:14:634 (3)] Sure
- 00:19:175 (1) - Same as above.
- 00:44:472 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - ddkkddkkk for more variation? You've already used ddddkkkkk. no. I think that's good
- 00:54:850 () - d. I can hear a distinct beat here. add a note
- 01:08:148 (7,8,1,2,3) - kdkdd or kdkdk? Fits the music better IMO. sure. I'm going to use kdkdk
- 01:17:067 () - d. I don't see why you left this part blank. There's a beat there. OK add a note

[Extreme]
- 00:05:229 (9) - Move one grid left then reverse? Flows better IMO. I think better now
- 00:09:445 (4) - I don't really recommend anti-jumps, but it fits the song here.
- 01:24:688 (3) - I suggest you place this where (1) was. It flows nicely! No change by that. but I replace that note due to your advice
- 01:44:796 (1,2,3,4) - Why not space these equally like this? Fix that

Lou-kun wrote:

-Easy-

Slider Vocalist need to go slower.
Plus you can add you'r own skin to make it popular. one day I consider that. but I know that's not need for my map

-Normal-

Needs at least one spinner for the multiplayer and online rankings. OK. but I have spinner at all diffs

Q:Why?

A:Because, in Mutliplayer some people spin better than others, That will cause them to win. And in online rankings, If you didn't add the spinner many people will be in the same rank.

Ps:-

The one that I didn't talk about is totally perfect. Keep on mind my comments.

Dark Fang wrote:

Lou-kun wrote:

-Easy-

Slider Vocalist need to go slower.
Plus you can add you'r own skin to make it popular. one day I consider that. but I know that's not need for my map

-Normal-

Needs at least one spinner for the multiplayer and online rankings. OK. but I have spinner at all diffs

Q:Why?

A:Because, in Mutliplayer some people spin better than others, That will cause them to win. And in online rankings, If you didn't add the spinner many people will be in the same rank.

Ps:-

The one that I didn't talk about is totally perfect. Keep on mind my comments.

Thanks for modding

intoon wrote:

SPOILER

20:33 intoon: 제가 여기다 일단 적어드릴테니 님 모딩 끝나고 읽어보세여
20:33 intoon: 참고로 익스트림만..
20:34 intoon: 00:02:148 (6,7,8,9,10) - 다른모양 추천드림
20:35 intoon: 00:06:202 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ 00:06:850 (5,6) - 점프가 필요없는부분같아서 그래요
20:36 intoon: 00:24:364 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - 여기 지루해요
20:36 intoon: 00:38:634 (1,2,3,4) - 애매하네요 2하고 3을 일정한 거리를 쓰던지 아예 점프로 만들던지 둘중하나
20:38 intoon: 00:43:823 (1,2,3,4) - 다른모양 추천하고싶어요 (개인적으로)
20:38 intoon: 00:45:445 (2,3,4,5,6) - 스냅은 상관없이 거리가 일정하지않아요....
20:39 intoon: 00:48:688 (4) - 노트 1개 change가 나을거같아요 00:49:499 (2,3) - 여기처럼..
20:40 intoon: 01:01:985 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - 다른모양 추천드림 매우 많이........
20:40 intoon: 모양이라기보단 배치....
20:40 intoon: 01:07:175 (1,2,3) - 단타 6개가 훨~씬 나아요
20:42 intoon: 01:30:526 (1) - 여기 왠만하면 하얀색이던 검은색이던 여기만 특별한 컬러쓰세요, (여담이지만 린이
20:42 intoon: 이런거 좋아해요) 가비 따라하는거같긴한데 어쩔수 없어요
20:42 intoon: 01:30:526 (1) - ^
20:42 intoon: 01:38:310 (1,2,3) - 다른모양..
20:42 intoon: 01:38:958 (4,5,6) - ^
20:43 intoon: 01:43:823 (1,1) - remove nc
20:44 intoon: 01:53:229 (1,2,3) - 왠만하면 점프로 바꾸세요, 뭐 개인적 취향이시라면 할말은 없는데 점프만드는쪽의
20:44 intoon: 훨씬 나아보이네요..
20:44 intoon: =End=

simple irc modding
boooooooooooooooom

NatsumeRin wrote:

[Beginner]
00:16:580 (1) - remove sliderwhistle? Fix
01:07:175 (1) - http://puu.sh/1dYNm too get it tight maybe? the music is quite strong and i think some kind of emphesis is needed. Sure. I fix that
01:51:283 (1) - no. the hitsounds is too quiet and i don't see the need to do so. I think too
In general, i think the sliders in this diff could be made in a more pretty way. Even it's an Easy i think you could put more effort on it. ;w;

[Basic]
00:01:013 (1,2,3) - glad to see you could use such organized beats. It could be made better if you place the notes according some kind of rules. now it seems a bit loose (i mean, make 1/2/3 looks more like "in a group") OK fix that
00:54:202 (1) - honestly, a bit ugly, you surely could think some better ways for a slider... Fix that
00:58:094 (3) - ^ ^
01:35:067 (5) - remove the reverse, and it shows a "stop" effect at the beats, i think this fit the music better. OK

[Frobe's Advanced]
00:07:499 (5,6) - why not 4 circles as before. Fix
00:11:067 (3) - remove a reverse and add a note at 00:11:391 ? I think that's for Finish
00:24:364 (1) - this part...i kinda doubt about it because music is not that 1/2 all the time, the 3/4s should be something you could consider, or use some 3/4+1/4 would also make it better imo. I can't dare to touch that o_o
01:01:985 (1) - for this part you should really look at the extreme diff for the note choices... notes are very obviously "3 in a group" (even in the jubeat game itself), but i don't have such feeling when playing this one. I fix that
The problem in this diff is... it looks not a map for this song. Or say this is something i don't like. D:

[Extreme]
00:11:715 (1) - maybe 0.75x would be already enough. too short sliders looks not that good imo. OK I use 0.75x sv
00:12:850 - add a note? I think that's not good
00:24:364 (1) - 6*3/4 sliders in a row just makes this exciting part in a boring way. try to use various of way in this part, based on the main beats. That's good idea. but I follow main beat now.
01:00:040 (3,4) - move right a bit so the spacing looks more comfortable. Fix
01:07:175 (1) - the idea here expressed kinda enough, but i thnk you could do more at the "skill" part. (for example: use 1.2x, make the direction change a bit, larger the spacing http://puu.sh/1dZa4) sure i try make large spacing
01:20:148 (1,2,1,2) - still, i like the idea you showed, but don't you feel after you stress those "parts", as a whole they are a bit separated? though it may be a too much task for new mappers but still want to mention it here. I consider that, but not now.

-Kirito wrote:

안녕하세용.
#korea에서 부탁하셨습니당.
(조언을 별로 하지 못 해서 ㅈㅅ합니당.. )

[Beginner]
01:48:364 - Combo Add? Fix

[Basic]
00:25:661 (4) - NC? nope
00:28:256 (4) - NC? ^
00:42:526 (3) - NC? Fix
01:09:769 (1,1,1,1) - 흰색선에 맞춰보는게 어떠신지? 컨셉..
01:10:742 (2,2,2,2) - Combo Add? nope
01:39:607 (3) - NC? ^

[Frobe's Advanced]
01:31:175 (2) - NC? OK
01:36:364 (2) - NC? ^
01:39:607 (3) - NC? ^
01:47:067 (1) - NC? no

[Extreme]
00:05:877 - Combo Add? 아니되오!
00:08:472 - ^? ^
완벽한 난이도...

닭빵님 이 맵 좋아욧! 빨리 랭크되시길!! 헉 감사해요!

HelloSCV wrote:

IRC

SPOILER

19:34 Dark Fang: 브레이크타임 매꿧는데 혹시 그부분만 모딩 가능하신가요?
19:34 HelloSCV: 넹
19:35 *Dark Fang is editing [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/150494 Tatsh - HEAVENLY MOON [Frobe's Advanced]]
19:35 Dark Fang: 00:11:715 -
19:35 Dark Fang: ~ 00:21:445 -
19:38 HelloSCV: 박자 말인데
19:38 HelloSCV: 00:17:229 (7) -
19:38 HelloSCV: 노트추가
19:38 HelloSCV: 00:18:202 (3,4) -
19:38 HelloSCV: 삭제
19:39 Dark Fang: 스레에도 irc 모딩 올려주시면 감사합니다
19:39 HelloSCV: 넹
19:39 HelloSCV: 00:18:850 (4) - 00:18:526 (3) -
19:39 HelloSCV: 추가?
19:39 HelloSCV: 아 물론 슬라이더로 하셔도 좋구요
19:39 HelloSCV: 00:19:175 (1) - 1/1 슬라이더로?
19:40 HelloSCV: 굳이 잡자면 이정도

모딩모딩

NoHitter wrote:

Rechecked and bubbled!
Good luck.

Garven wrote:

[Advanced]
00:21:769 (1) - End this at 00:23:634 -
00:45:121 - Maybe increase the volume a little bit? Kind of hard to hear
01:18:526 (5,1) - This is just cruel. Either add a beat between or making the spacing larger please.

Garven wrote:

Ahoy

[General]
Tick rate 2 fits this song best I'll keep tick rate

[Easy]
00:24:364 (1) - This is really soon after a spinner for an Easy - especially one with such a low star rating. It might be best to map through it. fix
00:56:796 (1) - This slider could look better. The curve is a little sharp and uneven. I trim that note
01:07:175 (3,4) - This has high potential to be quite confusing for newer players. It's fairly fast and quite short with more than one repeat with a note one beat afterward. I recommend you rethink this. hmm.. fix. longer than now
01:51:283 - I think a crescendo (gradual increase in volume) would work great here instead of keeping it all at a low volume. OK fix

[Basic]
00:08:796 (1,4) - I recommend you either stick with 3-hit sliders or 5-hit sliders. This is like that short slider from the Easy - Even though this is a Normal you still want to keep things at least consistent with the harder techniques used for this tier of difficulty. hmm... well.. I fix 00:08:796 (1) - this note. but keeping (4)
00:18:850 (4) - Maybe delete considering how tranquil the melody line is here I delete that note
00:30:850 (3) - This flows better ctrl + h'd. If you do this, you'll have to ctrl + h pretty much everything up until 00:44:472 (3) - fix
00:59:391 (1,2,3,4) - Maybe instead of having straight 1/1 rhythms here during this calm bridge, have a more stagnant rhythm such as this? Fix. but I use other rhythm

01:38:310 (1) - Same suggestion at this part. Maybe a simpler and smoother rhythm to transition better. ^

[Taiko]
01:30:850 (1) - That's... kinda weird. Probably best to keep it all at the same SV. hm..ok fix
01:36:040 (2) - ^ ^

[Extreme]
HP drain is too high. It's too hard to recover health from a mistake. change HP drain
00:09:445 (4) - Way too close to 3. Increase that spacing please. ok
01:35:715 (1) - You'll need tick rate 2 for these sliders anyway. I'll keep tick rate

Garven wrote:

For the Insane, you must have tick rate 2 if you want those .5x sliders.

Garven wrote:

[Easy]
00:24:364 (1) - This is still soon after the spinner. Maybe adding a circle at 00:21:769 - and 00:23:067 - will work better I use circle instead spinner. I won't add circle at 00:23:067 - (if that have problem. I'll fix)

[Basic]
01:51:283 - You should apply that same crescendo you did in Beginner here (and the Taiko and Extreme) fix at Basic, Extreme.cuz lower sound is unplayable at taiko.

Wreath wrote:

랭크 화이팅!! >ㅅ</

☆～

Melophobia wrote:

[Extream]
01:08:472 (5) - This note cannot be muted, move green line to 01:08:553 - Fix
01:08:553 (1) - Since spinner end doesnt follow anything, it would be better to remove finish. also use soft sampleset instead. OK I use soft sampleset.
01:30:526 (1) - Better to use 0.75x instead. this is pretty confusing imo not only because change of slider speed is sudden but because 0.5x looks the same as 1.0x sliders. anyway it's fitting very well with the song so it's up to you. hm.. keeping now
01:35:715 (1) - ^ ^

[Adcanced]
00:51:445 - Since there's an extra bass drum in this section, add a note here? add note :3
01:08:472 (1) - Since spinner end doesnt follow anything, it would be better to remove finish. also use soft sampleset instead. same as above
01:48:364 (5,6,7,8) - Change them into a kick slider? there's no long stream like this elsewhere so it's much harder than the rest of difficulty~ Fix ~

[Basic]
00:21:769 (1) - This spinner is too loud compared with other diffs. try to mute it OK

[Beginner]
00:13:985 (3) - This combo is kinda long, so how about adding newcombo here? OK add newcombo
00:37:337 (1,2,3) - Considering that This difficulty is based on 1/1 of whitetick, This is too hard for beginners imo, change them into a slider or at least change (2,3) to a slider. hm.. keeping now.
00:41:229 (2,3) - for the same reason as above, CTRL+G for better rhythm and adjust placement. there wont be much difference but it will be much easier for beginners to get 300 well.. Fix that

Nice first map. Fix whatever you want and call me back for a recheck

Melophobia wrote:

Rechecked via IRC, and we added a spinner in the Beginner diff and fixed some minor stuff. And now everything looks fine to me! great first map :3

log

21:46 Melophobia: Hello :3
21:46 Dark Fang: Hello
21:46 Melophobia: i would like to ask you a quiestion before rechecking
21:47 Melophobia: there's no spinner in Beginner diff, but i think it would be best if you could find a way to add one
21:47 Melophobia: what do you think?
21:47 Dark Fang: hm...
21:48 Dark Fang: OK I will add spinner in Beginner diff
21:48 Melophobia: Thanks :3
21:48 Melophobia: i will rebubble after rechecking
21:48 Melophobia: i think Garven will do the rest
21:48 Dark Fang: i think too
21:57 Melophobia: sorry, i would like to recheck via irc now
21:57 Melophobia: do you have some time to do?
21:57 Dark Fang: OK
21:58 Melophobia: in Extreme
21:58 Melophobia: 00:21:769 (4) - Finish is too loud, whistle is better imo
22:00 Melophobia: in Basic
22:00 Melophobia: 00:01:013 (1) - Finish
22:00 Melophobia: 00:06:202 (1) - ^
22:01 Melophobia: everything else looks fine now, i will recheck again after fixes
22:02 Dark Fang: OK all fix
22:02 Melophobia: update please :3
22:02 Dark Fang: upload ~.
22:03 Dark Fang: wut.. I got an error
22:03 Dark Fang: stopping at 22.2%
22:03 Melophobia: maybe restart osu!?
22:03 Dark Fang: OK
22:03 Melophobia: i have gotten it once
22:03 Melophobia: yeah
22:04 Dark Fang: Finish ~
22:04 Melophobia: ok!
22:04 Dark Fang: btw I really thank you ~ :3
22:04 Melophobia: my pleasure :3
22:05 Melophobia: ah
22:05 Melophobia: 00:21:769 (1) -
22:05 Melophobia: need to be muted
22:05 Melophobia: in Beginner
22:05 Dark Fang: oh
22:06 Dark Fang: update ~ thank you for checking sound xD
22:06 Melophobia: hm
22:07 Melophobia: i think the following notes appear too suddenly
22:07 Melophobia: considering the level of this difficulty
22:07 Melophobia: i mean 00:24:364 (1) -
22:08 Dark Fang: Can I replace near by spinner?
22:08 Melophobia: nah just uneasy about recovery time
22:08 Melophobia: maybe
22:08 Melophobia: end the spinner at 00:23:067 - instead?
22:09 Dark Fang: hmm.. that's great
22:09 Melophobia: update it once again please
22:10 Dark Fang: update
22:11 Melophobia: ok

Rebubbled!
Enjoy my first bubble

W h i t e wrote:

congratz~ :3

haha5957 wrote:

앗 다큰빵님 다컸잖아 ㅊㅋㅊㅋ