hi, M4M
[Shy Heart]
I think overall finishes are a bit overused in this difficulty, try limiting their use to downbeats unless the music has a finish like sound at that part.
00:42:957(1)- remove this NC, doesn't really fit.
01:19:275 (1,2,3) - I think maybe this part would look better if it was more centered
01:42:975 (1) - remove the finish from the reverse
02:07:575 (1) - This would be better if it was symmetrical
02:09:975 (1) - ^
02:27:975 (1) - This spinner feels kind of random to me, I suggest mapping this part, or having it end at 02:29:175 - so that the spinner corresponds with her voice.
03:22:575 (1,2,1) - maybe replace this with a repeating 1/8 slider
03:23:175 (1) - if no to previous suggestion, remove NC here
03:23:775 (2) - NC
03:24:375 (
1) - remove NC
03:27:975 (2) - replace finish at head with whistle
04:10:575 (1,2,3) - move (2,3) to the left more to make it more lined up with the curve formed by 1, right now the angle is too sharp I think
04:24:375 (2) - I'd like this to be more symmetrical as well
04:33:975 (3) - Make this more symmetrical
04:41:175 (3) - remove the finish from the end, maybe replace with a whistle, but the finish does not fit there.
I think overall finishes are a bit overused in this difficulty, try limiting their use to downbeats unless the music has a finish like sound at that part.
[Brave Heart]
Again, too many finishes in this difficulty. The music doesn't tell you to put that many in, so limit them to downbeats.
00:30:375 (4) - the overlap with this and 00:31:575 (1) - is a bit ugly, I'd suggest either have them stack or move further apart so they don't overlap.
00:36:375 (1,2,3,4) - This plays a bit oddly and the random spacing difference between (1,2,3) then (3,4) is odd. Make (4) spaced 1.26 like the others and maybe have it follow a curve set by (1,2,3), maybe something like this
http://puu.sh/1VX2I00:41:775 (1,2,3,4) - I'd have 4 further away from (1,2,3). Right now the spacing looks too similar even though the time difference is not. Space (4) 1.2x. Also, make the spacing between (1,2,3) the same, right now it is not consistent.
01:02:625 (2) - Make this symmetrical so it makes a nice blanket around 01:02:475 (1) -
01:03:975 (4) - ^
01:05:175 (3) - stack end with 01:06:375 (5) -
01:13:575 (3,4) - replace with just a repeating 1/8 slider
01:34:275 - reduce the volume here, there is no instrumental and the sliderslide noise is too loud for what is happening.
01:46:275 (4) - NC
01:47:175 (1) - remove NC
01:48:375 (4) - NC
02:11:775 (4,1,2) - ugly overlap between (4) and (2)
02:13:275 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Please make this a perfect hexagon
02:34:575 (1) - Make this perfectly symmetrical, it will look a lot better.
02:46:875 (6,7,8) - Nazi, but make these perfectly spaced. I know its pretty close but I noticed it while playing. Maybe I'm weird.
02:47:775 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - This would look better if these were just equilateral triangle patterns. Maybe something like this
http://puu.sh/1VXkc03:00:375 - Decrease volume here
03:21:975 - I really don't like this break being here. A break during a kiai time just doesn't seem right. You don't have a break here in the Easy diff, so you might as well map this part.
03:58:425 (2,3) - This overlap isn't very good looking. Moving 03:58:875 (3) - to (240,68) both looks and plays better to me.
04:09:975 (1) - Increase the BSD to 1/8 and increase the length by one tick. Do the same for 04:11:175 (4) - . I know that this causes overlap with the other parts, so you have to remap them. I recommend this rhythm.
http://puu.sh/1VXua. It fits the vocal part better IMO
04:12:375 (1) - Same idea as before, increase BSD to 1/8 and increase length of this slider by 1 tick.
04:16:575 (6,7) - Don't do this. This is extremely confusing because the distance makes it look like this time difference is the same as 04:16:125 (3,4,5,6) - . The SV decrease here also does not fit at all. Move that timing point to 04:17:775 - and make 04:16:875 (7) - the proper length.
04:42:825 (1,2,3,4,5) - This part is just kind of messy to read and doesn't really fit either the music or the vocals. Try a rhythm like this if you want to keep those short slider parts.
http://puu.sh/1VXCJ04:52:575 - I don't think a SV decrease fits here. Remove that and remap to make slider lengths fit again.
04:59:475 - Decrease the volume here, too loud for this part.
That's all, good luck.