Well thank you, for finally answering me. Took you long enough.
oh wait. Markie broke many rules.

He did not have a cause. He was RIGHT outside my settlement, he even came to my settlement to kill my friend. I think he did kill me twice. I remember getting attacked one second time.
I didn't carry anything valuable.
buttersea tried to kill me multiple times IN my settlement
I was a new player. It was my first day playing here and he killed me anyway.
I have a neutral town. There's no point for you and your "wife" to attack me.
I think he deserves a spank.