Remember, taiko is not about how you follow the drums, it's also not about how to follow the music strictly, it's about delievering the emotion of the music accurately.MMzz wrote:
[Wmf's Taiko]
First things first change the SV to 1.4 There is NO reason a song that is 160+BPM needs 1.6 slider velocity, it is perfectly readable and playable at 1.4.
There IS. Because I'm using 1/6.
00:01:465 (2,3,4,5) - Try a different pattern for these 1/6 beats. dkdd feels really off to play, but the dkkd and dkdk you used work very well and feel more fitting to the song. Try kkkd and kddk aswell they work nicely and add some verity.
1) Fits the ,elodic change 2) The ending d is suitable as a keeping d through to the last note so that the last one is highlighted.
00:07:685 (40) - Remove this finish, there is no finish sound here.
This is a melodic accent so I'll leave it as it is. Finishes are not necessarily refer to the "finish sound" and in particular there is no "finish" snare in the taiko gameplay. It's about sth worth to highlight, in particular accents in the music. Accents are not necessariy delivered in the single way (finish sound), but through many ways, like a fortepiano note, a short term staccato behvaior, sudden breaks, pushing the climax, etc.
00:21:953 (129) - Try making this a normal don. It flows a lot nicer into the next notes then a kat, and breaks up that long kat pattern you have going. Also this shouldn't be a finisher, there is no finish sound.
k
00:25:063 (152) - Try making this a don aswell, it helps you keep that k d k d k d structure you have going.
such structure is not necessary. It fit shte melody here.
00:27:990 (173,174) - Try reversing these 2 notes, the d k serves as a better lead into ddk and feels more comfortable then k d.
as you wish
00:30:734 (193) - Again there is no finisher sound here.
00:34:026 (217) - Try making this a don, all these long kat patterns you have really do not fit well. They might match the melody but they don't help the drum beat at all.
Dealing with the melody is enough. You're right the whole k stuffs goes with the high pitch phrases.
01:08:051 (390,391,392,393,394) - alright this is a big issue, this does not fit AT ALL. The 1/6 might fit a little bit but the 1/3 right after it do not fit at all and are very hard to play and understand because there are no 1/3 beats here. these are destroying your flow and are going to kill players accuracy. You need to change these to something more fitting. Yes, every time you did this needs to be changed.
It's totally reasonable and fun based on the given melody. Comparing with ordinary 1/4 streams, the 1/6 will first be highlighted, and then the 1/3s acts as a buffer zone to bridge between the normal beating. A continuous soundinds is delivered by the music in the kiai time, and a 2/3 break is of course breaking the flow and more importantly the original message of the music. Such arrangement is providing a smooth connection from phrases to phrases. Remember, "being hard to play" is not a reason.
01:15:734 (444,445,446,447,448,449) - All these notes with finishes in this pattern need to be removed, again there is no finish sound why are you adding finisher? I could understand if it was to emphasize the music but these finishers are not doing that.
This is a obvious transition from the two repeating block of the kiai section, and the finishes perfectly paraphrase the gradually louder feeling and then push everything to the repeating block again.
I'll star for now and keep an eye out, but I think your insane and taiko need some more mods. Good luck.
SPOILER
osu file format v9
[General]
AudioFilename: DISTORTED NEW AGE.mp3
AudioLeadIn: 1500
PreviewTime: 67502
Countdown: 0
SampleSet: Normal
StackLeniency: 0.7
Mode: 1
LetterboxInBreaks: 0
[Editor]
DistanceSpacing: 1
BeatDivisor: 4
GridSize: 8
[Metadata]
Title:Babylonia
Artist:Troupe Record
Creator:Strawberry
Version:Wmf's Taiko
Source:Beatmania IIDX 17 Sirius
Tags:DISTORTED NEW AGE wmfchris Twice boss bossandy instrument
[Difficulty]
HPDrainRate:6
CircleSize:5
OverallDifficulty:6
ApproachRate:5
SliderMultiplier:1.6
SliderTickRate:2
[Events]
//Background and Video events
0,0,"Taiko BG[Babylonia].jpg"
//Break Periods
//Storyboard Layer 0 (Background)
//Storyboard Layer 1 (Fail)
//Storyboard Layer 2 (Pass)
//Storyboard Layer 3 (Foreground)
//Storyboard Sound Samples
//Background Colour Transformations
3,100,163,162,255
[TimingPoints]
1100,365.853658536585,3,1,0,60,1,0
68051,-100,3,1,0,60,0,1
88173,365.853658536585,3,1,0,60,1,1
88173,-100,3,1,0,60,0,1
107929,-100,3,1,0,60,0,0
108294,-100,3,1,0,20,0,0
110124,-100,3,1,0,60,0,0
[Colours]
Combo1 : 131,182,252
Combo2 : 207,128,251
Combo3 : 11,128,234
Combo4 : 254,184,245
[HitObjects]
480,88,1100,1,2
480,88,1465,1,0
480,88,1526,1,2
480,88,1587,1,0
480,88,1648,1,0
480,88,1831,1,0
480,88,2014,1,0
480,88,2197,1,2
480,88,2563,1,2
480,88,2746,1,2
480,88,2929,1,0
480,88,3295,1,2
480,88,3660,1,0
480,88,3721,1,2
480,88,3782,1,0
480,88,3843,1,0
480,88,4026,1,0
480,88,4209,1,0
480,88,4392,1,0
480,88,4575,1,2
480,88,4758,1,0
480,88,4941,1,2
480,88,5032,1,2
480,88,5124,1,0
480,88,5307,1,0
480,88,5490,1,2
480,88,5856,1,0
480,88,5917,1,2
480,88,5978,1,2
480,88,6039,1,0
480,88,6221,1,0
480,88,6404,1,0
480,88,6587,1,2
480,88,6770,1,0
480,88,6862,1,0
480,88,6953,1,0
480,88,7136,1,0
480,88,7319,1,0
480,88,7502,1,0
480,88,7685,1,6
480,88,7868,1,0
480,88,8051,1,0
480,88,8112,1,2
480,88,8173,1,0
480,88,8234,1,2
480,88,8417,1,2
480,88,8599,1,0
480,88,8782,1,0
480,88,8874,1,0
480,88,8965,1,0
480,88,9148,1,2
480,88,9331,1,2
480,88,9514,1,0
480,88,9697,1,0
480,88,9880,1,2
480,88,10246,1,6
480,88,10429,1,0
480,88,10612,1,0
480,88,10795,1,0
480,88,10978,1,2
480,88,11343,1,6
480,88,11526,1,2
480,88,11709,1,0
480,88,11892,1,0
480,88,12075,1,2
480,88,12441,1,0
480,88,12502,1,2
480,88,12563,1,2
480,88,12624,1,0
480,88,12807,1,0
480,88,12990,1,0
480,88,13173,1,0
480,88,13356,1,2
480,88,13447,1,2
480,88,13539,1,0
480,88,13721,1,0
480,88,13904,1,2
480,88,14087,1,0
480,88,14270,1,2
480,88,14636,1,6
480,88,14819,1,2
480,88,15002,1,0
480,88,15185,1,0
480,88,15368,1,2
480,88,15734,1,6
480,88,15917,1,2
480,88,16008,1,0
480,88,16099,1,2
480,88,16282,1,0
480,88,16465,1,2
480,88,16557,1,2
480,88,16648,1,2
480,88,16740,1,2
480,88,16831,1,0
480,88,17014,1,0
480,88,17197,1,2
480,88,17380,1,0
480,88,17563,1,0
480,88,17654,1,0
480,88,17746,1,2
480,88,17837,1,2
480,88,17929,1,0
480,88,18112,1,2
480,88,18295,1,2
480,88,18386,1,2
480,88,18478,1,0
480,88,18660,1,6
480,88,18843,1,0
480,88,19026,1,2
480,88,19209,1,2
480,88,19392,1,0
480,88,19575,1,0
480,88,19667,1,0
480,88,19758,1,2
480,88,19941,1,0
480,88,20124,1,2
480,88,20215,1,2
480,88,20307,1,0
480,88,20490,1,2
480,88,20581,1,0
480,88,20673,1,2
480,88,20764,1,2
480,88,20856,1,0
480,88,21039,1,0
480,88,21221,1,2
480,88,21404,1,0
480,88,21587,1,2
480,88,21770,1,2
480,88,21953,1,0
480,88,22136,1,0
480,88,22228,1,0
480,88,22319,1,2
480,88,22502,1,0
480,88,22593,1,0
480,88,22685,1,2
480,88,22776,1,2
480,88,22868,1,0
480,88,22959,1,0
480,88,23051,1,2
480,88,23234,1,2
480,88,23417,1,2
480,88,23599,1,0
480,88,23782,1,2
480,88,23965,1,0
480,88,24057,1,0
480,88,24148,1,2
480,88,24331,1,0
480,88,24514,1,2
480,88,24697,1,0
480,88,24789,1,0
480,88,24880,1,2
480,88,25063,1,2
480,88,25246,1,2
480,88,25429,1,0
480,88,25520,1,2
480,88,25612,1,2
480,88,25795,1,0
480,88,25978,1,2
480,88,26069,1,2
480,88,26160,1,0
480,88,26252,1,2
480,88,26343,1,0
480,88,26526,1,2
480,88,26709,1,0
480,88,26892,1,2
480,88,27075,1,0
480,88,27167,1,0
480,88,27258,1,2
480,88,27349,1,0
480,88,27441,1,2
480,88,27624,1,2
480,88,27807,1,2
480,88,27990,1,0
480,88,28173,1,2
480,88,28356,1,0
480,88,28447,1,0
480,88,28539,1,2
480,88,28721,1,0
480,88,28904,1,2
480,88,28996,1,2
480,88,29087,1,0
480,88,29270,1,0
480,88,29362,1,0
480,88,29453,1,2
480,88,29545,1,2
480,88,29636,1,0
480,88,29819,1,0
480,88,30002,1,2
480,88,30185,1,0
480,88,30276,1,0
480,88,30368,1,2
480,88,30551,1,2
480,88,30734,1,0
480,88,30917,1,0
480,88,31008,1,0
480,88,31099,1,2
480,88,31282,1,0
480,88,31374,1,0
480,88,31465,1,2
480,88,31557,1,0
480,88,31648,1,2
480,88,31740,1,2
480,88,31831,1,2
480,88,32014,1,2
480,88,32106,1,2
480,88,32197,1,2
480,88,32380,1,0
480,88,32563,1,2
480,88,32746,1,0
480,88,32929,1,2
480,88,33112,1,2
480,88,33203,1,0
480,88,33295,1,0
480,88,33478,1,0
480,88,33660,1,2
480,88,33843,1,2
480,88,34026,1,2
480,88,34209,1,2
480,88,34301,1,2
480,88,34392,1,2
480,88,34575,1,2
480,88,34667,1,2
480,88,34758,1,0
480,88,34941,1,2
480,88,35032,1,0
480,88,35124,1,0
480,88,35307,1,2
480,88,35490,1,0
480,88,35581,1,0
480,88,35673,1,2
480,88,35764,1,2
480,88,35856,1,0
480,88,35947,1,0
480,88,36039,1,2
480,88,36130,1,2
480,88,36221,1,0
480,88,36587,1,0
480,88,36770,1,0
480,88,36953,1,2
480,88,37136,1,2
480,88,37319,1,0
480,88,37685,1,2
480,88,37868,1,0
480,88,38051,1,2
480,88,38234,1,2
480,88,38417,1,2
480,88,38599,1,0
480,88,38782,1,2
480,88,38965,1,2
480,88,39148,1,2
480,88,39331,1,2
480,88,39514,1,6
480,88,39880,1,4
480,88,40612,1,2
480,88,40795,1,0
480,88,40978,1,2
480,88,41160,1,2
480,88,41343,1,2
480,88,41526,1,0
480,88,41709,1,2
480,88,42075,1,0
480,88,42807,1,2
480,88,42990,1,0
480,88,43173,1,2
480,88,43356,1,2
480,88,43539,1,2
480,88,43721,1,0
480,88,43904,1,0
480,88,44087,1,2
480,88,44270,1,2
480,88,45002,1,2
480,88,45185,1,0
480,88,45368,1,2
480,88,45551,1,2
480,88,45734,1,2
480,88,45917,1,0
480,88,46099,1,2
480,88,46465,1,0
480,88,46831,1,0
480,88,47197,1,2
480,88,47380,1,0
480,88,47563,1,0
480,88,47746,1,2
480,88,47929,1,2
480,88,48112,1,2
480,88,48295,1,2
480,88,48478,1,0
480,88,48569,1,0
480,88,48660,1,2
480,88,48843,1,0
480,88,49026,1,2
480,88,49209,1,2
480,88,49392,1,2
480,88,49575,1,0
480,88,49667,1,0
480,88,49758,1,2
480,88,49941,1,2
480,88,50124,1,2
480,88,50307,1,0
480,88,50490,1,2
480,88,50581,1,0
480,88,50673,1,2
480,88,50856,1,0
480,88,51039,1,0
480,88,51221,1,2
480,88,51404,1,0
480,88,51587,1,2
480,88,51770,1,0
480,88,51862,1,0
480,88,51953,1,2
480,88,52136,1,2
480,88,52319,1,2
480,88,52502,1,0
480,88,52685,1,0
480,88,52868,1,2
480,88,53051,1,2
480,88,53234,1,0
480,88,53325,1,0
480,88,53417,1,2
480,88,53508,1,0
480,88,53599,1,2
480,88,53782,1,2
480,88,53874,1,2
480,88,53965,1,0
480,88,54148,1,0
480,88,54331,1,2
480,88,54514,1,2
480,88,54697,1,0
480,88,54880,1,2
480,88,55063,1,0
480,88,55246,1,2
480,88,55429,1,0
480,88,55612,1,0
480,88,55795,1,2
480,88,55978,1,2
480,88,56160,1,0
480,88,56252,1,0
480,88,56343,1,2
480,88,56526,1,0
480,88,56709,1,2
480,88,56892,1,2
480,88,57075,1,0
480,88,57441,1,2
480,88,57624,1,0
480,88,57807,1,2
480,88,57990,1,2
480,88,58173,1,0
480,88,58356,1,0
480,88,58447,1,0
480,88,58539,1,2
480,88,58721,1,0
480,88,58904,1,0
480,88,58965,1,0
480,88,59026,1,0
480,88,59087,1,0
480,88,59270,1,6
480,88,59636,1,0
480,88,59697,1,2
480,88,59758,1,0
480,88,60002,1,4
480,88,60368,1,6
480,88,60734,1,6
480,88,61099,1,4
480,88,61465,1,6
480,88,61831,1,0
480,88,61892,1,2
480,88,61953,1,0
480,88,62197,1,4
480,88,62563,1,6
480,88,62929,1,4
480,88,63295,1,6
480,88,63660,1,6
480,88,64026,1,2
480,88,64087,1,2
480,88,64148,1,0
480,88,64392,1,4
480,88,64758,1,4
480,88,65124,1,6
480,88,65490,1,6
480,88,65856,1,4
480,88,66221,1,6
480,88,66587,1,6
480,88,66953,1,6
480,88,67136,1,6
480,88,67319,1,6
480,88,67502,1,0
480,88,67593,1,0
480,88,67685,1,0
480,88,67868,1,0
480,88,68051,1,0
480,88,68112,1,0
480,88,68173,1,0
480,88,68295,1,0
480,88,68417,1,0
480,88,68599,1,0
480,88,68782,1,2
480,88,68965,1,2
480,88,69148,1,2
480,88,69209,1,2
480,88,69270,1,2
480,88,69392,1,0
480,88,69514,1,2
480,88,69697,1,0
480,88,69880,1,2
480,88,70063,1,0
480,88,70246,1,0
480,88,70429,1,0
480,88,70520,1,0
480,88,70612,1,2
480,88,70795,1,0
480,88,70978,1,2
480,88,71160,1,2
480,88,71343,1,2
480,88,71435,1,0
480,88,71526,1,2
480,88,71709,1,2
480,88,71801,1,0
480,88,71892,1,2
480,88,72075,1,0
480,88,72167,1,0
480,88,72258,1,2
480,88,72349,1,0
480,88,72441,1,0
480,88,72624,1,2
480,88,72807,1,0
480,88,72990,1,0
480,88,73173,1,0
480,88,73234,1,2
480,88,73295,1,2
480,88,73417,1,2
480,88,73539,1,2
480,88,73721,1,0
480,88,73904,1,2
480,88,74087,1,0
480,88,74179,1,0
480,88,74270,1,2
480,88,74453,1,2
480,88,74636,1,4
480,88,74819,1,0
480,88,75002,1,2
480,88,75185,1,0
480,88,75368,1,2
480,88,75551,1,2
480,88,75734,1,6
480,88,75917,1,4
480,88,76099,1,6
480,88,76282,1,4
480,88,76465,1,6
480,88,76648,1,6
480,88,76831,1,0
480,88,76892,1,2
480,88,76953,1,0
480,88,77075,1,0
480,88,77197,1,0
480,88,77380,1,0
480,88,77563,1,2
480,88,77746,1,0
480,88,77929,1,2
480,88,77990,1,2
480,88,78051,1,2
480,88,78173,1,0
480,88,78295,1,2
480,88,78478,1,0
480,88,78660,1,2
480,88,78843,1,2
480,88,79026,1,0
480,88,79209,1,0
480,88,79301,1,0
480,88,79392,1,2
480,88,79575,1,0
480,88,79667,1,0
480,88,79758,1,2
480,88,79849,1,2
480,88,79941,1,2
480,88,80032,1,0
480,88,80124,1,2
480,88,80307,1,0
480,88,80490,1,2
480,88,80673,1,0
480,88,80856,1,2
480,88,81039,1,2
480,88,81099,1,0
480,88,81160,1,0
480,88,81221,1,2
480,88,81404,1,0
480,88,81587,1,2
480,88,81770,1,0
480,88,81953,1,0
480,88,82136,1,0
480,88,82228,1,0
480,88,82319,1,2
480,88,82502,1,2
480,88,82685,1,0
480,88,82868,1,2
480,88,83051,1,2
480,88,83112,1,2
480,88,83173,1,0
480,88,83234,1,2
480,88,83417,1,0
480,88,83508,1,2
480,88,83599,1,2
480,88,83691,1,0
480,88,83782,1,2
480,88,83965,1,0
480,88,84057,1,0
480,88,84148,1,2
480,88,84331,1,0
480,88,84514,1,0
480,88,84697,1,0
480,88,84880,1,2
480,88,85063,1,0
480,88,85246,1,0
480,88,85337,1,0
480,88,85429,1,0
480,88,85520,1,0
480,88,85612,1,2
480,88,85795,1,0
480,88,85978,1,2
480,88,86160,1,0
480,88,86343,1,2
480,88,86526,1,0
480,88,86709,1,6
480,88,86892,1,6
480,88,87075,1,6
480,88,88173,1,0
480,88,88233,1,2
480,88,88294,1,0
480,88,88416,1,0
480,88,88538,1,0
480,88,88721,1,0
480,88,88904,1,2
480,88,89087,1,0
480,88,89270,1,2
480,88,89331,1,2
480,88,89392,1,2
480,88,89514,1,0
480,88,89636,1,2
480,88,89819,1,2
480,88,90002,1,2
480,88,90185,1,0
480,88,90368,1,0
480,88,90551,1,0
480,88,90642,1,0
480,88,90733,1,2
480,88,90916,1,0
480,88,91099,1,2
480,88,91191,1,0
480,88,91282,1,0
480,88,91374,1,0
480,88,91465,1,2
480,88,91648,1,0
480,88,91740,1,0
480,88,91831,1,2
480,88,92014,1,0
480,88,92197,1,2
480,88,92380,1,2
480,88,92563,1,0
480,88,92746,1,2
480,88,92929,1,2
480,88,93112,1,0
480,88,93294,1,0
480,88,93355,1,2
480,88,93416,1,2
480,88,93538,1,2
480,88,93660,1,2
480,88,93843,1,0
480,88,93935,1,0
480,88,94026,1,2
480,88,94209,1,0
480,88,94392,1,2
480,88,94575,1,0
480,88,94758,1,0
480,88,94941,1,0
480,88,95032,1,0
480,88,95124,1,2
480,88,95307,1,2
480,88,95490,1,2
480,88,95581,1,0
480,88,95672,1,0
480,88,95764,1,0
480,88,95855,1,2
480,88,96038,1,0
480,88,96130,1,0
480,88,96221,1,2
480,88,96404,1,0
480,88,96587,1,2
480,88,96770,1,0
480,88,96953,1,0
480,88,97014,1,0
480,88,97075,1,0
480,88,97197,1,0
480,88,97319,1,0
480,88,97502,1,0
480,88,97685,1,2
480,88,97868,1,2
480,88,98051,1,2
480,88,98112,1,2
480,88,98172,1,2
480,88,98294,1,2
480,88,98416,1,2
480,88,98599,1,0
480,88,98782,1,2
480,88,98965,1,0
480,88,99148,1,0
480,88,99331,1,0
480,88,99422,1,0
480,88,99514,1,2
480,88,99697,1,0
480,88,99880,1,2
480,88,100063,1,2
480,88,100246,1,2
480,88,100429,1,0
480,88,100520,1,2
480,88,100612,1,0
480,88,100794,1,2
480,88,100977,1,0
480,88,101160,1,0
480,88,101221,1,0
480,88,101282,1,0
480,88,101343,1,2
480,88,101526,1,2
480,88,101709,1,2
480,88,101892,1,0
480,88,102075,1,0
480,88,102258,1,0
480,88,102441,1,6
480,88,102624,1,2
480,88,102807,1,0
480,88,102990,1,0
480,88,103172,1,2
480,88,103233,1,2
480,88,103294,1,2
480,88,103355,1,0
480,88,103538,1,0
480,88,103630,1,2
480,88,103721,1,0
480,88,103813,1,0
480,88,103904,1,2
480,88,104270,1,2
480,88,104636,1,2
480,88,105002,1,0
480,88,105185,1,0
480,88,105368,1,0
480,88,105551,1,2
480,88,105733,1,2
480,88,106099,1,0
480,88,106160,1,0
480,88,106221,1,2
480,88,106343,1,2
480,88,106465,1,0
480,88,106831,1,4
480,88,107197,1,4
480,88,107563,1,4
480,88,107929,1,0
480,88,108020,1,2
480,88,108112,1,0
256,192,108294,12,0,109941
480,88,110124,5,6
480,88,110307,1,0
480,88,110490,1,0
480,88,110551,1,2
480,88,110612,1,0
480,88,110672,1,0
480,88,110855,1,2
480,88,111038,1,0
480,88,111130,1,0
480,88,111221,1,2
480,88,111587,1,2
480,88,111953,1,0
480,88,112319,1,2
480,88,112502,1,2
480,88,112685,1,0
480,88,112746,1,2
480,88,112807,1,0
480,88,112868,1,0
480,88,113051,1,0
480,88,113233,1,0
480,88,113416,1,0
480,88,113599,1,2
480,88,113782,1,0
480,88,114148,1,0
480,88,114514,1,2
480,88,114697,1,0
480,88,114880,1,2
480,88,114941,1,2
480,88,115002,1,2
480,88,115063,1,0
480,88,115246,1,2
480,88,115429,1,0
480,88,115612,1,2
480,88,115977,1,2
480,88,116343,1,0
480,88,116709,1,2
480,88,116892,1,0
480,88,117075,1,2
480,88,117136,1,0
480,88,117197,1,0
480,88,117258,1,2
480,88,117441,1,2
480,88,117624,1,0
480,88,117807,1,6
480,88,117990,1,0
480,88,118081,1,0
480,88,118172,1,2
480,88,118355,1,0
480,88,118447,1,0
480,88,118538,1,2
480,88,118721,1,0
480,88,118904,1,6
480,88,119270,1,0
480,88,119636,1,2
480,88,120002,1,6
480,88,120368,1,0
480,88,120733,1,2
480,88,121099,1,2
480,88,121282,1,0
480,88,121465,1,2
480,88,121648,1,0
480,88,121831,1,2
480,88,122014,1,2
480,88,122197,1,6
480,88,122563,1,4