Snowy Dream wrote:

Mod request from Snowy Dream's Queue
-------------------------------------------------
[bestz's Easy]
00:07:344 (1) - umm..why newcombo? ok, delete

[Hard]
00:26:015 (1) - not stack completely? (or just separate from each other) use 0.1 for this slider
00:41:682 (1) - delete finish ok
00:42:015 (2) - finish no
00:44:349 (1) - delete finish ok
00:44:682 - finish no
00:47:015 - delete finish ok
00:47:349 (1) - finish no
..... .....

[Taiko Muzukashii]
00:17:991 (1) - newcombo ok

--------------------------------------------------
Great Mapset :3
Good Luck with Rank

Snowy Dream wrote:

[Nich's Normal]
00:06:677 (1) - whistle No
00:08:011 (3) - ^ ^
00:42:015 (1) - finish at the beginning I felt that sound is strange.
00:44:682 (1) - ^ ^
00:47:348 (1) - ^ ^
00:52:682 (1) - ^ ^
00:55:348 (1) - ^ ^

Netsukawa wrote:

aabc271 wrote:

As requested by Netsukawa, I'm coming for a Taiko mod ~
Let's go ~

Blue~ Critical issues. You must fix this
Purple~ It's better to fix this
Pink~ Suggestions only. Change only if you want to

[Taiko Muzukashii]

Although SV 1.3 is fine, you may consider using SV 1.4, even if it's an easier muzukashii. The default SV for taiko is always 1.4, regardless of the difficulty ~

Suggested patterns

Suggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~

• For 00:17:989 ~ 00:28:682, as only red notes are used and I understand this is a style, it's your choice whether to change the following or not ~
  
  00:20:504 ( 10 ) - Blue note ? ok
  
  00:23:186 ( x ) - Add a blue note ? ok
  
  00:25:848 ( x ) - ^ ok
  
  00:28:015 ( 36 ~ 39 ) - Add a note at 00:28:182, and use o o o o O ? ik

00:33:348 ( 57 ) - Red note ?

00:34:015 ( 60 ~ 67 ) - o o o o o o o o ? ( 1/1 )

00:39:182 ( 80 ~ 81 ) - o O ? just o O

00:48:432 ( 123 ) - Delete this note ? A sudden, single 1/4 doesn't look good imo ~ ok

The map is OK overall ~

Good to see that the diff is quite friendly to newer players :3

Rating : 8/10 ( +0.5 : Good diff balance )

Star and good luck ~ Where is your star =w= !

Saten wrote:

[General]
Add a soft-slidertick to the Normal custom hitsounds
Is the timing really correct? the kiai part felt somewhat off (maybe it's just me)

[bestz]
00:11:344 (1) - I think you can make this slider more pretty/curvy - FIXED
00:49:682 (4) - why not a custom 2 whistle here instead? Like the rest of the previous patterns. - Huh ? ... I forgot it , now I change it.

That's all =w=/

Saten wrote:

[Nich]
AR+1? (Sure you don't have that high SV, but the BPM says something different here. I think it's better for the flow) Ok, fixed
00:24:682 (3,2) - might be an issue with the hit-burst overlapping the repeat, but in the end you'll be able to see it in time I guess..
00:58:015 (1) - soft finish instead? Ok, fixed

1. 00:18:493 (2) - reverse arrow may be hidden here http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/357682 , you can move up a little
2. 00:24:682 (5,6,7) - maybe move left a little - -" http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/357684
3. 00:25:848 - better stack a note here to make constant flow
4. 00:44:182 (8) - this note plays awkward imo... remove it?
5. 00:44:349 (1,2) - The stressed beat (bokura) here is mapped as repeat slider end, while those at 00:39:349 (3) and 00:42:015 (2) are slider starts /.\ I think it's better to make them constant as it's a Hard diff , so better for small jumps slider head.
6. 00:50:182 (2,3) - ^ and why is the spacing...
7. also it would be better if you add finish on these parts o.o
8. 01:17:015 (2,3) - ...why??
9. 01:21:015 (5) - ^

1. 00:45:182 (3,4) - ...怎么这么坑爹 00:40:348 (4,1) 00:43:015 (4,1) 说好的1/2呢
2. 00:46:015 (1) - ...而且居然是1/4 根本不科学!!
3. 01:03:015 (6) - 这个如果跟vocal从这里开始的话比较舒服 speed 1.0x http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/357693
4. 01:04:848 (2) - 这个跳得不好 还不如叠着
5. 01:06:848 (4) - jump?
6. 01:23:848 (2) - blanket算了我还有没有人性._.
7. 233

1. 00:22:013 (3) - personally I think it's rankable, but this is just a Normal diff, beginner players may be confused what it is ;_;
2. 00:26:348 (2) - ;_; this is completely hidden repeat, no please
3. 00:42:015 (1) - finish on head..?
4. 00:44:682 (1) - ^
5. 01:06:515 (3) - add clap at reverse..?

1. can't find anything sorry ;_;

-Bakari- wrote:

[Nich's Normal]
00:12:344 (3,4) - http://puu.sh/EZ5a I think it isn't a problem on the rhythm.
00:14:993 (2) - this one looks really strange :/ i suggest you to use circles instead For me think that it isn't strange.
00:26:348 (2) - reverse arrow covered by hitburst. unrankable fixed
00:51:348 (3,1) - almost overlap fixed
01:25:849 (3) - use 1/2 slider instead no

[CSGA]Ar3sgice wrote:

Nich's Normal

1. 00:22:013 (3) - personally I think it's rankable, but this is just a Normal diff, beginner players may be confused what it is ;_; fixed
2. 00:26:348 (2) - ;_; this is completely hidden repeat, no please fixed
3. 00:42:015 (1) - finish on head..? no
4. 00:44:682 (1) - ^ ^
5. 01:06:515 (3) - add clap at reverse..? no

• the timing of hit sounds of 00:17:989 sounds something strange, but I can't find better timing so I don't say about this...
  but how about remove whistle and it maybe sound better

• unify the timing section with other diffs.(also you must fix Kiai Time and preview point)
  00:11:344 (1) - too far from the center. I think the note after the spinner should be put to more center.
  00:15:156 (2) - remove these notes because this circle is on the red tick. this is Easy, so you should make rhythm more easier imo.
  how about this rhythm?
  SPOILER

  
  00:16:406 (4) - NC. spinner new combo bug
  00:20:672 (3) - NC. this combo seems too long.
  00:26:015 (4) - ^
  00:31:348 (3) - ^
  00:36:015 (3) - ^
  00:40:349 (2) - there is no sounds to emphasize in music here and newbie players will be confused by these rhythm. so you shouldn't put circle here.
  to put the note like as 00:50:015 (1) is better.
  00:43:015 (2) - ^
  00:43:015 (2) - ^
  00:48:348 (3) - remove this "circle". no one can clear here
  01:00:515 - this break time seems unnecessary. remove, and put some notes.

• AR -1? I feel too fast with 5
  00:08:677 (1,1) - I want more interval between these notes. to be shorten the spinner...but it may not match with the music
  remove 00:11:344 (1) and lengthen the spinner to 00:08:677 (1), or if you don't like it, how about put 00:11:344 (1) more closer to the center?
  00:58:097 - this inheriting section doesn't snapped
  01:00:664 (1,1) - same as above, it seems too short. how about this rhythm?(like as later section)
  SPOILER

  
  01:25:497 (2,3) - how about replace with one slider? because these notes are both on red tick.
  01:26:331 (6) - move to 01:26:497 and it will follow the music well imo.

• 00:03:844 (3) - covered with previous slider, the start point can't be almost found.
  00:25:330 (7,1) - very nazi. how about remove stacking? because only these notes are stacked in this section.
  01:00:331 (9,1) - in my image of the song, these notes should be separated. because the melody changed.
  01:08:664 (2) - add finish to the head? I feel something lonely to hitsound.
  01:16:664 (1) - ^

• 00:03:344 (1,2) - I think it's better to closer them. it looks hard to read rhythm visually.
  00:16:822 (1,1) - remove stacking? because these sliders have different SV. I think they should be separated.
  00:48:831 (2,3) - remove stacking? because of hitburst, it seems a little hard to read the rhythm of (3)
  00:57:831 (4,5,1) - stack them to easy to read rhythm. the distance of these notes are same as ..for example 00:49:331 (3,4,5).
  so visually it may be confusing.
  01:02:831 (6) - don't be silent the end of slider
  01:08:664 (1) - same as Hard
  01:16:664 (1) - ^
  01:27:164 (7) - replace with a circle? covered with hitburst, someone can regard this slider as a circle. also, this slider is very short.

SPOILER

h-728 wrote:

Thank you for request

[bestz's Easy]

• 
  01:00:515 - this break time seems unnecessary. remove, and put some notes.- Ignore

Leorda wrote:

Oh hi there


[bestz's Easy]
* Overall of combo.... the combos seems messed up. Try add a new combo when the object is snap at 1st and 3rd long white tick -FIXED
* The last red timing section should snap at 00:23:331 for consistency of each diff -FIXED
* Set the preview time to 62914, fix this using a notepad -FIXED

Nice song~

Seph wrote:

hichman's CTB

I really like how you do your ctb diffs, its very clean, and I don't see anything wrong with it except:

I really suggest you make it CS 4, having it in CS 5 makes it too hard imo, from a regular player's point of view (mind you im not bad in ctb D:) i find some of the jumps pretty hard to catch. First try with its original CS led me to 10 misses, tested with CS 5 it became pretty enjoyable for me. And why is your OD set to 10 lol

jericho2442 wrote:

no you update it now so when a bat checks it its in the state bubble means, bubble means that it is waiting for a bat to rank, if it has a needed mod pending, it gets popped and fixed, then after you find a mat to rebubble again

1. GUILTY CROWN and Guilty Crown , which source is correct?

1. Unrankable stuff
   ( You must fix all of these , if I write something is not unrankable , please tell me in the reply )
   
   1. None
   　
2. Beatmap design/Suggestion
   ( Most of them are my suggetion , you can disagree if you want )
   
   1. 01:27:330 (1) - End at 01:29:330 - , to follow the vocal well
   　
3. Hitsounds
   ( Almost of them are my ideas , you can ignore them )
   
   1. 00:38:997 (129) - k sounds better?
   2. 01:26:497 (168) - k to follow the vocal?

1. Unrankable stuff
   ( You must fix all of these , if I write something is not unrankable , please tell me in the reply )
   
   1. OD should be centerd! It mean OD+1 to 5
   　
2. Beatmap design/Suggestion
   ( Most of them are my suggetion , you can disagree if you want )
   
   1. 00:14:993 (14,15) - I think it is a best if you delete note 14 , because BPM change on note 15 , and I feel strange while playing , different speed on by one makes me uncomfortable , delete note 14 can solve this problem
   2. 00:23:186 (20) - Same reason as above
   3. 00:32:330 - It's my feeling , I think you can add a circle here
   4. 00:35:664 (72,73,74) - Move these notes back 1/2 tick to red tick , and then add a note 00:36:497 - . I think follow vocal here is better than music >_<
      
      Moe Photo (What!

      
   5. 01:07:331 (220) - Move forward 1 tick to 01:07:497 - sounds better :3
   6. 01:12:664 (244) - Same as above
   7. 01:18:664 (269) - Back 1 tick to 01:18:497 - sounds great :3
   8. 01:27:330 (1) - Same as Climbb's Taiko Oni :3
   　
3. Hitsounds
   ( Almost of them are my ideas , you can ignore them )
   
   1. 00:28:497 (41) - d here is better to me
   2. 01:17:664 (265,266) - kd sounds good?

spboxer3 wrote:

Recommendations:

1. Custom combo colours
   Custom combo colours do not really matter to taiko as they will be overwritten in actual gameplay. The case is the same with combo numbering, but you may wish to use the numbering to mark out red/blue notes visually within edit mode (assuming no custom colours have been set), this would make modding for other people easier and could make mapping easier:
   

　　--------------------------------------------------------
Nice song! , I hope this can rank as soon as it can xDD
Good Luck :3

Garven wrote:

[CtB]
00:11:344 (1,2,3,4,5) - I'm not understanding this spacing progression. Feels unnecessary
00:14:010 (5,6,7,8) - Nor this one. The song feels like it's sustaining intensity - not regressing.
00:19:331 (1,2,3,4) - Really? During such a calm part?
00:22:348 (6,7,8) - ^
00:25:330 (6,7,8) - ^
Why are there any hyper fruits during such a calm part anyway? Doesn't make any musical sense.
00:39:831 (2,3) - This jump is badly placed. If you're doing it for the guitar part, you're missing every other instance of it. If you're doing it for the vocals, it's badly misplaced. I really don't know what you're trying to map to at all.
00:41:997 (1,2) - This is pretty much the same thing. What are you mapping to to justify this hyperfruit use?
00:46:664 (7,8,9) - Hey, the first hyperfruit that I can see what you mapped to. Unfortunately with how oddly the rest of the map was, it diminishes this particular use.
01:00:497 (8) - This should continue the jump pattern and you should return to center with 01:00:664 (1) -
01:07:331 (1,2,3) - This would fit a lot better with the "motto he" at 01:06:497 - , would you agree?
01:12:331 (5,6) - Whoa, what?
01:15:664 (9,1) - ^ Such strange places for hyperfruits

CtB needs -a lot- of work. Badly placed hyperfruits all over the map. Get more mods on it please.

Garven wrote:

Hey look, still have that Timing file I made, haha.

[Easy]
00:11:344 (1) - This is pretty soon after a spinner for this level of difficulty. - Okay FIXED
00:18:661 (1) - ^ - Sorry I can't

Garven wrote:

Hey look, still have that Timing file I made, haha. lol

[Muzukasii]
01:00:497 (192) - Set this to d since it transitions better keeping to the snare/bass until 01:00:664 - when everything backs off OK

[Hard]
00:03:011 (1) - I'm not feeling the first hit of this slider considering the music... follow *piano* lol
00:49:997 (2,3) - Way too close Just my style D: so It can play lol
00:52:997 (4,5) - ^ ^
01:16:997 (2,3) - ^ ^
01:20:497 (4,5) - ^ ^
01:21:580 (7) - Why? just follow the music *guitar*
01:24:580 (2) - ^ ok, Delete D:

CtB needs -a lot- of work. Badly placed hyperfruits all over the map. Get more mods on it please.
Oh yes, about this, hichman want me to delete his diff so now I deleted it.

Thank you for mod Garven !

Sync wrote:

[Nich's Normal]
00:08:677 (1) - Ending a spinner on a downbeat is not the way to go. It doesn't stress the transition in music -- on this particular downbeat, it's huge. The player needs to feel the music and the only way to do that is by adding a hit circle or a slider there. You can do two things to solve this problem: either move the slider back to the next white tick or remove it entirely. The former doesn't give the player much time to finish the spinner, but this normal is pretty hard to begin with so it'd fit the map just fine. If you're going to do that, add a 1-beat slider at 00:11:344 (1). Previously, I used to do similar to things you say. But the reason I didn't change because I want to leave time between the spinner and note to new players can not play hard to the right of them. To make the new players can play it, which may not difficult exceed their ability.
00:13:344 (4) - Remove the repeat and add a hit-circle at 00:14:010 (5) instead. Also, add a new combo there. It adds more emphasis to the build-up. The slider end is in a red line, which was during change the rhythm. Okay, I fixed it
00:16:155 (1) - Same as 00:08:677 (1). The same reason as 00:08:677 (1).
01:00:664 (1) - ^ ^

Garven wrote:

Oo, that saves me another check that I was expecting, haha. Congratulations!

mancusojuanmattos wrote:

/me lates as always
Congratulations, Net! :3