SteRRuM wrote:

Hi~!
[Normal]

1. Smaller hitcircles pls :3, Fixed.
2. 01:00:37 (5) - This one isn't symmetrical to (4) or it's on purpose o.o, Fixed.
3. 01:23:37 (4) - Maybe move 1 Grid to left?, Fixed.
4. 02:20:71 (1) - Auto makes 2000 on it, is it OK on Normal? :<, Not Fixed :3
5. 02:23:37 (6) - Align with (5)s end, Fixed.
6. 02:23:71 (1) - Align with (6), Fixed
7. 02:25:04 (4) - Align with (3)s end.

Fixed.
[Hard]

1. 01:08:87 (9) - Align with (8)s end, Fixed.
2. 01:48:71 (3) - Align with (1) OR (2).

Fixed.
[Oru's Insane]

1. 00:13:87 (2,3) - Stack manually with (1)s end, Fixed.
2. 00:18:71 (1,2,3,4) - Stack manually :3, Fixed.
3. 00:37:37 (3) - If you want Insane effect on this maybe exchange it with 3 beats?, Not Fixed.
4. 01:23:71 (1) - Stack manually with (1)s end, Fixed.
5. 01:30:87 (1,1,1) - Align with (5), Fixed.
6. 02:17:21 (4,5) - Stack manually, Fixed.
7. 03:22:71 (1,2,3,4) - Stack manually, Fixed.
8. 03:41:37 (3) - Same as before, maybe exchange for 3 beats?.

Not Fixed.

Symbolic wrote:

[Oru's Insane]

00:14:54 (1) - Remove new combo. No.
00:15:04 (1) - ^ ^
00:18:21 (1) - ^ ^
00:18:37 (1) - ^ ^
00:25:71 (1) - ^ ^
00:25:87 (1) - ^ ^
00:28:54 (1) - ^ ^
00:28:71 (1) - ^ ^
00:29:21 (1) - ^ ^
00:29:37 (1) - ^ ^
01:19:87 (1) - Remove new combo. ^
01:20:21 (1) - ^ ^
01:20:54 (1) - ^ ^
01:23:878 (x) - Add a note here. ^
01:31:04 (1) - Remove new combo. ^
01:31:21 (1) - ^ ^
01:33:87 (1) - ^ ^
01:34:04 (1) - ^ ^
01:34:54 (1) - ^ ^
01:34:71 (1) - ^ ^
01:37:545 (x) - Add a note here. ^
01:37:71 (1) - Remove new combo. ^
01:38:212 (x) - Add a note here. ^
01:38:37 (1) - Remove new combo. ^
01:38:878 (x) - Add a note here. ^
01:39:212 (x) - ^ ^
01:44:21 (1) - Remove new combo. ^
01:44:37 (1) - ^ ^
01:44:54 (1) - ^ ^
01:44:71 (1) - ^ ^
01:47:04 (1) - ^ ^
01:47:37 (1) - ^ ^
02:02:37 (1) - Remove new combo. ^
02:02:54 (1) - ^ ^
02:18:21 (1) - ^ ^
02:18:37 (1) - ^ ^
02:45:54 (1) - Remove new combo. ^
02:45:87 (1) - ^ ^
02:46:21 (1) - ^ ^
03:05:21 (1) - ^ ^
03:05:71 (1) - ^ ^
03:18:54 (1) - ^ ^
03:18:87 (1) - ^ ^
03:19:21 (1) - ^ ^
03:22:545 (x) - Add a note here. ^
03:29:71 (1) - Remove new combo. ^
03:29:87 (1) - ^ ^
03:32:54 (1) - ^ ^
03:32:71 (1) - ^ ^
03:33:21 (1) - ^ ^
03:33:37 (1) - ^ ^
03:37:54 (1) - ^ ^
03:37:71 (1) - ^ ^
03:37:87 (1) - ^ ^
03:38:04 (1) - ^ ^
03:46:878 (x) - Add a note here. ^
03:47:04 (1) - Remove new combo. ^
03:47:545 (x) - Add a note here. ^
03:47:71 (1) - Remove new combo. ^
03:48:212 (x) - Add a note here. ^
03:48:545 (x) - ^ ^
03:53:54 (1) - Remove new combo. ^
03:53:71 (1) - ^ ^
03:53:87 (1) - ^ ^
03:54:04 (1) - ^ ^
03:56:37 (1) - ^ ^
03:56:71 (1) - ^ ^

Symbolic wrote:

[Normal]

Don't use too much 1/4's in Normal. Not Fixed.

[Hard]

00:10:04 (1) - Please make this slider faster, the -2x speed sux imo. Not fixed.
00:42:71 (1,2,3,4) - Spacing is inconsistent with the rest of the song and it doesn't fit as a jump. Not Fixed
00:58:71 (1,2,3,4) - ^ ^
01:02:21 (7,8,9,10) - ^ ^
01:33:37 (3,4,5,6) - ^ ^
01:56:87 (1,2,3,4) - ^ ^
02:50:71 (1,2,1,2,1) - Speed-up doesn't fit. ^
03:04:71 (2) - Line this up with (1) FIXED.
03:10:71 (3,4,5,6) - Spacing is inconsistent with the rest of the song and it doesn't fit as a jump. Not Fixed.
03:54:71 (1,2,1,2,3,1,2,3) - ^ ^

Eddycted wrote:

First of all, great song.

[Oru's Insane]

Kiai right at the start doesn't make a whole lot of sense. I'd use it only for the climax of the song, at 03:13:37(), which you did as well. The kiai on the last note is rather silly as well. In short; too much kiai. Well, I think that this decision must be taken by HarryOrunitia

[Normal]

See Oru's Insane on kiai. Some kiai fixed.

00:52:21 (6) - Line this up with (5). Fixed.

[Hard]

See Oru's Insane on kiai. Unfortunately I like the kiai mode in this beatmap and I think I will remain it unchanged. s'ry :3

00:15:87 (2,3,4) - This stack doesn't feel intuitive. I have to recheck this. Anyway, not fixed.
03:24:21 (1) and 03:25:71 (1) - These two spinners don't feel like they're based on anything. Fixed.
03:55:37 (1,2,3) - I think this should be a combo of two, like the previous. same at 00:15:87 (2,3,4)

Other than that, great work. I enjoyed your map.

Star.

Eddycted wrote:

First of all, great song.

[Oru's Insane]

I like how you did the hit sounds, very nice. Thanks a lot!! :3

Kiai right at the start doesn't make a whole lot of sense. I'd use it only for the climax of the song, at 03:13:37(), which you did as well. The kiai on the last note is rather silly as well. In short; too much kiai.
I tried to follow Armin's difficulties with kiai. But for me it's totally fine to leave only the kiai at 03:13:37 and the one on the last note, so I guess it's up to him to decide what to do!

Saturos-fangirl wrote:

[Normal]
00:52:22 (6) - move out from under 5 so i can tell this is a slider and not a hitcircle "Fixed"
02:07:88 (1) - end on a tick Fixed

Card N'FoRcE wrote:

- Normal:
02:28:71 (5) - sovrapposizioni del genere sconsigliate per normal Lo prendo in considerazione, se qualcun'altro lo segnala cambio
02:29:37 (1) - consiglio di farlo finire a 2:32:045 Not fixed

- Hard:
00:42:37 (6) - new combo? not fixed o.o
2:52:38 - KIAI? O.o (non è meglio direttamente a 3:14:712?) Questa parte col kiaimi sembrava più azzeccata. Proverò a togliere le altre
03:46:37 (6) - come 0:42:37 Not fixed o.o

- Oru's:
Troppi clap D: Chiedo a Oru, sempre se si connette
Molto bella

Star'd ^^

Larto wrote:

Overall:
Please watch out that the sections inducing Kiai time on YOUR difficulties, Armin, are placed DIRECTLY on the notes. Because if the timing sections are placed earlier or later, the Kiai fountain does not sync the song, which looks horrible ;( Fixed ;(


Oru's Insane:
[nazi mod] Waiting for Oru's fixes :3
ROFL. Oh well. This mod post is NOT done yet. I'm just posting the mod for this diff already. And if you wanna know, NO, I didn't only check the new combos, I also checked the map itself, and it seemed alright. Just the New Combos... ;_;

Hard is good Oh yes u.u

Normal:
00:20:37 (1) - Remove New Combo Yea, Fixed!
02:20:71 (1) - Spinner is a bit too short for a Normal Yeaaa! Fixed!!!

That's everything.

Thank you Larto

Card N'FoRcE wrote:

- Oru's:
Troppi clap D:

Larto wrote:

Oru's Insane:
00:14:54 (1,1,1,1,1) - Remove New Combos
00:18:21 (1,1) - ^
00:25:71 (1,1) - ^
00:28:54 (1,1) - ^
00:29:21 (1,1) - ^
00:35:04 (1,1) - ^
00:40:54 (1) - ^
01:01:71 (1) - ^
01:19:87 (1,1,1,1,1) - ^
01:23:37 (1,1) - ^
01:31:04 (1,1) - ^
01:33:87 (1,1) - ^
01:34:37 (1,1,1) - Move this combo away from under the combo before please? Oh, and remove the new combos on the second and third note ;p
01:37:71 (1) - Remove New Combo
01:38:37 (1) - ^
01:42:04 (1) - ^
01:42:37 (2) - ADD New Combo. Lol something new.
01:44:21 (1,1,1,1) - Remove New Combos.
02:00:87 (3) - Add New Combo
02:01:71 (1) - Remove New Combo
02:02:37 (1,1) - Remove New Combos
02:10:04 (1) - Don't Start Kiai time on the beginning of this slider, do it at its end. Up to Armin.
02:18:21 (1,1) - Remove New Combos
02:20:54 (1) - Remove New Combo AND maybe move it away from under the other slider.
02:24:54 (1,1) - Remove New Combos
02:28:54 (1,1) - Remove New Combos
02:45:54 (1,1,1,1,1) - Remove New Combos
02:49:54 (1) - Remove New Combo
03:05:04 (1,1,1,1) - Remove new Combos
03:18:54 (1,1,1,1,1) - Remove New Combos
03:22:04 (1,1) - Remove New Combos
03:29:71 (1,1) - Remove New Combos
03:32:54 (1,1) - Remove New Combos
03:33:21 (1,1) - Remove New Combos
03:37:54 (1,1,1,1) - Remove New Combos
03:39:04 (1,1) - Remove New Combos
03:40:71 (1) - Remove New Combo
03:41:37 (3) - ADD New Combo
03:44:54 (1) - Remove New Combo
03:47:04 (1) - Remove New Combo
03:47:71 (1) - Remove New Combo
03:51:37 (1) - Remove New Combo
03:51:71 (9) - ADD New Combo
03:53:54 (1,1,1,1) - Remove New Combos

ROFL. Oh well. This mod post is NOT done yet. I'm just posting the mod for this diff already. And if you wanna know, NO, I didn't only check the new combos, I also checked the map itself, and it seemed alright. Just the New Combos... ;_;

Starrodkirby86 wrote:

[Oru's Insane]:
01:23:04 (1,1) - I personally don't like these no-whistle at start sliders and such.
01:42:04 (1) - Remove new combo?
01:42:37 (2) - New combo?
02:49:37 (1) - What's this new combo doing here? :O
03:39:71 (x) - Add beat here?
03:51:37 (1,2) - That new combo thing I mentioned up there ^

Armin wrote:

Oru, per il momento ho uppato un'altra difficoltà con i fixes di Larto che riguardavano i colori delle combo e questi due:
01:34:37 (1,1,1) - Move this combo away from under the combo before please? Oh, and remove the new combos on the second and third note ;p
02:10:04 (1) - Don't Start Kiai time on the beginning of this slider, do it at its end.

Di Starrodkirby86 non ho fixato nulla di tuo, mi sono limitato a fixare solo i miei D:
La seconda difficoltà l'ho creata quindi NON per rimpiazzarla con la tua ma per evitarti noie se i colori delle combo vanno male. Ma puoi sempre fixare tu e alla fine mandarmi in allegato la mappa.

HarryOrunitia wrote:

Ok, come ho già detto preferisco lasciare le combo come sono, ma se i bat fanno ancora storie (-___-) fixale. Stesso discorso per gli hitsounds.
Per il kiai scegli tu, mentre per ciò che riguarda lo spacing o il timing preferirei dare un'occhiata personalmente, a meno che non siano cose stupide di allineamento o roba simile. Comunque la mappa è la tua quindi in caso non dovessi farmi sentire per troppo tempo (da ora in poi comunque controllerò regolarmente) fixa pure quello che vuoi e falla rankare D:

Ah, inoltre grazie per il kudosu ma in post come questo o quello di prima non dovresti darmelo dato che non ho moddato nulla :3

MarioBros777 wrote:

I see a lot of flaws in this map... The massive Kiai time (near the end) in Hard is just not needed... Please fix it before I give you the star. Sorry about this made I hate most custom made skins so I won't go bragging about that here. >_> I am worried also about the amount of spinners that you put in one difficulty. Please recheck them and see if they are not necessary and that you can replace them differently.

[Normal]
00:42:71 (1) - Align this with the end of slider 6 (using Grid lvl 3) and move all other placements if necessary...
00:54:04 (3) - Align with 1
2:07:87 (Spinner) - I'm worried about how the two spinners are done one after another. It doesn't seem right for Normal but... It's your call.

[Hard]
00:44:87 (1) - Align with 8 and move all hitcircles in front if necessary.
00:54:37 (4,5,6,7,8) - Together, align them with 3 and it will align with new combo 1.
01:13:21 (Spinner) - With this, you can even put no volume or very little on the hit at the end.
03:49:37 (Spinner) - 3 spinner in a row? Oh come on... You can't be serious. >_>

Seriously... You need to fix some of these. I'll give you a star later.

blissfulyoshi wrote:

blue text = nazi post

Normal:
00:15:54 (1) - start a quarter note later but end where it currently is Fixed
01:05:87 (7) - align with 6? Fixed
01:18:04 (1,2,3,4) - make a straight line Fixed
01:29:71 (3,4) - make parallel to 1,2 Fixed
02:01:71 (2) - align with 1? Fixed
get rid of all the extra inherited timing sections at the end Fixed

Hard:
01:00:04 (5) - make a horizontal reflection of 1 Fixed
02:45:04 (6) - align with 5? Fixed
03:16:54 (1) - start a quarter note later but end where it currently is Not Fixed
03:19:87 (1) - " " Not Fixed
03:29:21 (4,5) - I don't like how the spacing between these 2 is inconsistent compared to 1,2. Please a dd a new combo or change it ""Fixed""
03:53:21 (1) - start a quarter note later but end where it currently is Fixed

Insane:
00:09:71 (1) - the beginning of this spinner does not snap to anything, I would recommend to start this a whole note later and change it to a slider because a spinner that long only gets 1k bonus Fixed (only the size of the spinner).
00:36:71 (4) - new combo for to make it easier to read? Fixed
00:52:21 (3) - make a horizontal reflection of 1 Fixed
00:52:54 (4) - make a vertical reflection of 2 Fixed
01:15:04 (1) - same as 00:09:71 (1) Not Fixed
01:26:04 (4) - align with 2 Fixed
01:47:04 (1) - make a horizontal reflection of the note before it Fixed
02:27:37 (4) - make a horizontal reflection of 2 Fixed
02:46:87 (4) - new combo for to make it easier to read? Not Fixed
03:11:71 (3) - make a horizontal reflection of 2? Fixed
03:56:37 (1) - make a horizontal reflection of the note before it Fixed

The problem I think most ppl have with your combos is sometimes it feels random when you do it. You should limit those combo changes to when you map to the drums.

Nice map. Star.

Alace wrote:

pretty good mapset
i enjoyed playing all diffs

<Insane>
IMO too many claps here
maybe one clap/2 divisors is better
those random claps sound noisy
Normal and Hard`s hitsounds are pretty good

Saturos-fangirl wrote:

[Normal]
its ok


[Hard]
00:39:37 (5) - move the whistle to 6 Fixed
too much whistle, it doesnt really fit the song. try using clap instead Too much whistle? Really? If I replace them with the claps I risk to change also other beats! anyway I won't change the hitsounds because I like them :3
02:20:21 (1,2) - hitsound Not fixed.
02:52:71 (1) - remove kiai Fixed
03:18:37 (3,4,5) - wtf is this it sounds terrible Fixed
yeah the whistles are pretty bad, fix them plz


[Insane]
02:52:71 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,1,2,3) - hitsounds please
03:38:37 (2) - finish
03:51:37 (8) - ^
Waiting for Oru's Fixes :3

whymeman(Overall) wrote:

Tags: No (Please add the Tags for all of the beatmaps.) Fixed.

whymeman(Normal) wrote:

00:38:71 (1,2,3) - Just needs a touch up with the line up. Nothing major though. Not fixed
01:13:21 (1) - This spinner sounds like it ends slightly late. Try adjusting it to 01:14:49 (with 1/3 timing). Fixed, thank you.
01:36:93 (B) - Delete and replace break. Fixed.
02:23:37 (4) - Looks a bit odd over the slider end. Just something to take notice of. Not fixed.

whymeman(Hard) wrote:

01:13:21 (1) - This spinner sounds like it ends slightly late. Try adjusting it to 01:14:49 (with 1/3 timing). Fixed.
01:36:93 (B) - Delete and replace break. Fixed.
03:00:71 (5,6) - Looks a bit too close to the bottom of the window. Just something to take notice of. Not fixed.
03:55:21 (X) - Is there a note missing here or is that intentional? (It kinda made 03:55:37 (1,2,3) a bit confusing without a note there, but just something to also take notice of). Not fixed, but If a BAT report this "error", I'll fix it.

HarryOrunitia wrote:

I don't understand how the doubled BPM can be an issue, same for the single combos. I've had like 10 posts about my combos, but I don't see how that ruins the map or goes against the guidelines for ranking. I'll check the other nazi mods later.

Takuma wrote:

I'm sorry this mod post was so delayed, really. >W<

General:
Holy shit that spinner is adorable. However, I think you're using way too many spinners. Is that a problem? I don't see many spinners in Normal and in Oru's Insane difficulty. In the Hard there are 21 spinners, but they are all justified.
Isn't that Kharl's Sakura kiai? You should probably ask him first, forgive me if you did already. Yeah, I sent a PM ot Kharl. I'm waiting an answer from him. <3

Insane:
Please lay off the new combos - you're using them a little too much in some parts, mainly the chorus. I won't list them all because there are many, but in specific parts like 00:14:37 (1,1,1,1,1,1) - and 00:18:04 (1,1,1) - I suggest you remove. I think that Oru wont fix this, and I agree with him <3

Have a shiny star.~

whymeman wrote:

00:18:71 (1,2,3) - The link is slightly uneven. I don't see the problem
02:20:21 (1,1) - ^ (Also the left slider doesn't look neatly placed with (6) as it was still fading out.) Fixed
02:24:04 (3) - Start a new combo here. Done
02:46:54 (1,2,3,4) - Feels a bit questionable to me since the stack of beats is not constant, but then again, its an insane map... Yeah...
03:22:71 (1,2,3) - Its hard to see it, but the link is slightly uneven. Again, I don't see the problem
03:23:87 (4) - Not even under the slider end. Fixed

Notes: The map is okay, but way too many unneeded single note combos. Only place single note combos when its necessary. Other than that, just some minor shape fixes to be done. The HP Drain felt a bit staggering to me but the map is cleanly made though.

Lizbeth wrote:

[oru's Insane]
01:20:04 (1) - maybe remove this, fit a lot with the vocal You're actually kind of right, but it looks ugly if I remove it.
add a note at 01:38:87 and 01:39:21 Again, I don't feel like messing with this part D:
03:18:71 (1) - remove this, like above ^

star

Takuma wrote:

Insane:
Please lay off the new combos - you're using them a little too much in some parts, mainly the chorus. I won't list them all because there are many, but in specific parts like 00:14:37 (1,1,1,1,1,1) - and 00:18:04 (1,1,1) - I suggest you remove. Read after the quote
02:48:71 (1,2,3) - The combo is a tad off. Highlight (1,2) and move them 1 level 3 grid to the left. Done

Takuma wrote:

Why did you put Takuma in the tags? ?_?

Lokamp wrote:

Ecco qui le mie dritte!

[General] imposta il volume dei suoni dei beat al massimo: la musica di base li copre!Not fixed

Normal

[00:15:370] (spinner) secondo me, questo è un pò forzato... prova a sostituirlo con un beat ed uno slider... Not fixed <_<
[00:20:710] (spinner) da come la vedo io, anche questo potrebbe essere cambiato, magari con uno slider e 3 beat... ^
[00:36:710] (2) finish qui Fixed!
[01:26:040] (spinner) un'altro slider e 3 beat al posto dello spinner Not Fixed
[02:05:870] (5) cambia questo slider in un beat Fixed!

Hard
[00:34:370] (6) whistle qui! Not Fixed, ma se qualcun'altro lo segnala, fixo
[02:20:710] (spinner) ...non ci starebbe meglio uno slider? No. :*
[03:03:370] (spinner) come sopra... ^
[03:16:540] (spinner) cambialo con qualcos'altro (comincio ad essere un pò a corto di idee ) ^

Oru's insane
[General] a mio avviso, i vari beat e slider sono collocati perfettamente, ma il ritmo diventa + confuso nei "momenti" dove predominano i clap... prova a miscelarli con qualche finish! Si, ma lascio decidere a Oru

Per il resto, hai scelto proprio una bella skin... continua cosi!

Starrodkirby86 wrote:

Normal seems a bit too difficult, especially with all those short spinners against beginners.

May I suggest lowering Overall Difficulty and possibly HP Drain by 1-2 ticks?

That's it. Everything else seems to be in order...

EDIT: Also, do you think there might be a wee bit too much Kiai in [Hard]? Oru's Insane is fine in Kiai (Roughly), but I'm quite curious about the whole slowdown and before the last chorus. (Is it needed, in other words)

There's a new guideline about not overusing Kiai Time. In short, the rule generally is 'One toggle per playable length of beatmap'. You can check it in the Ranking Criteria.