nold_1702 wrote:

[General]

Combos Colours MUST be common in ALL DIFFS.Even though it's a taiko diff.

Makar8000 wrote:

nold_1702 wrote:

[General]

Combos Colours MUST be common in ALL DIFFS.Even though it's a taiko diff.

They don't have to be in any difficulty.

Philippines wrote:

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXxXXXXFULL REVOLUTION

SPOILER

1. 01:12:550 (2) - ^ This overlap was intentional
   
   
2. 01:13:777 (2) - ^ ^
   
   
   
3. 02:00:414 (2) - Insert break time after this note? break's too short.
   
   
4. There are no errors, believe me. Get this thing ranked. NOW! D:

nold_1702 wrote:

[Full Revolution]

00:49:368 - Add a note xp? that would be quite overmapping xD. Idk, it doesn't sound great either.

02:12:277 (12) - I think here a sound is missed ;P As intended.

02:55:914 (5) - Stack it 's end better at the begin of 02:55:232 (3) (Sorry my bad English is just coming xpp) This here was for better flow.

03:05:868 (3) - After this note,the "empty times"leave too long,map something?(From 03:06:005 to 03:10:096 ) That empty part is added there manually. I don't believe I have to map that in because it was all intentional.

03:28:368 (4) - I think you may add a note here :O Not really, the previous 3 circles were on the cymbals, and then it goes into the snares.

04:30:823 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - I duuno if they are unstacked objects (UNRANKABLE).I am not sure about this.
But you have better to change them like this

SPOILER

I'll check this over with a MAT.

aabc271 wrote:

[Cherry and Makar's Clockwork]

01:29:732 ~ 01:33:005 - This stream is very long and should be shortened. Consider that the high BPM ( 220 ) makes streams very tiring, esp the long ones. Players will probably miss at this stream, so it's better to shorten it by dividing it into a few shorter streams. ( eg Each stream is not longer than 9 notes ). I agree, it doesn't make much sense to have the hardest part of the map in the buildup to the Kiai/Chorus; however, I want to talk to cherry about this first before changing.

02:29:119 ~ 02:31:914 - Same as above, and this time the patterns are also very confusing, which increased the difficulty a lot. I strongly suggest you simplifying it ~ Same here as mentioned above.

04:30:823 ~ 04:34:778 - Although the patterns are repeating, players may probably miss this because of the increased speed and the confusing finishes. Consider reducing the speed to around x1.2 ? For now, I'm going ot keep this. I haven't had many opinions on this and would like to see what others think first.

Just saying that the Taiko BG is not cut perfectly. The name of the song and mappers in the BG are slightly cut ( as seen here ). Maybe it's better to remake the BG / SB ...? Fixed in the SB.

Suggested patterns

Suggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~

03:27:142 ( 1,1,1~2,1~3 ) - ooooooo ? kdkkddd feels odd imo ~ I like this pattern, and it was something that was suggested here. I'll keep for now but I want to ask cherry for opinions on this later =w=

03:48:414 ~ 03:49:232 - O o O, and then O o O ? This looks good for me ~ Fixed

04:05:869 ~ 04:06:687 - ^ Fixed

As I can see that the hitsounds are highly structured, I won't make too many suggestions on them ~

The map is OK overall ~

Nice job on hitsounds. They fit the drum quite well ~

Suggestions : Avoid using extra-long streams in high BPM songs as they are usually demanding for players ~

Rating : 8/10 ( +1 : Hitsounds. -0.5 : Uneven diff spread ( Long streams ) )

Star and good luck ~

Katty Pie wrote:

Hey :3

Full Revolution

00:32:596 - this slider to low you should lift it or put in other place
00:37:096 - add note overmapped
04:17:732 - add noteguitar here

Good luck ^^

Sync wrote:

[General]
-- The tags/difficulty name should probably be changed because xcherry and markar8000 have changed their names since then FUUUU

Mythol wrote:

wtf repeat spam at the end?
i prefer the troll ending from before than this :<

Xakyrie wrote:

I hope you know if you don't, Canadian bears will go down to Amurica and eat your house :3

Sync wrote:

rank rank rank

Makar wrote:

Sync wrote:

rank rank rank

this guy trying to make up for the awful thing he has done...

tsktsk
those bears are still coming

Charles445 wrote:

Makar got me to playtest this

I do have things to point out

1. The beginning is a readability mess. Stuff like 00:11:459 (3,4,5) - is a pain in the ass, and unexpected for the beginning of the map. Later on stuff like 00:21:823 (10,1) - gets even more annoying. are you sure this is not a little forgivable for the sake of fitting the music and creativity? (@ the first pattern mentioned). I can lower the spacing if thats what you want, it will certainly make it less unexpected. The good thing about these is that the previous slider is already long gone. You're just simply repeating a hand movement because the slider is now perfectly readable after the previous disappears. As for that second pattern. I agree, 1/1 stacks at slider ends are certainly harder to read that most other things. This will be gone.

2. Map gets frustrating to read again at 03:23:187 . The variable spacing here is frustrating. I think you mean the spacing change? That goes according to the sv change as well. I'm a little unsure of what you mean.

3. Your map is based around flow. DON'T KILL IT WITH 03:55:914 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - and DON'T PUT A STREAM RIGHT AFTER IT. BRO i don't know what I was doing yeah derp I'll redo that one.


That's my thoughts, map's alright except for those three things.

Charles445 wrote:

This story makes no sense

~Approved!~

EDIT: Lol wrong icon

Charles445 wrote:

This story makes no sense

~Ranked!~

EDIT: Lol wrong icon