1. Storyboarding:
   1. Disabled "Letterbox during breaks" because the map has video.
   2. Disabled "epilapsy warning" because no storyboard detected in this beatmap.
2. Folder: remove "normal-sliderslide" and "normal-sliderslide2"? if this aiming for silenced the slider body, that's unrankable silenced the slider body for normal-hitsound imo.

1. 00:51:799 (5) - add new combo in here. for easy diff, not good idea if add long combo set. usually, the combo set for easy is between 1 - 5 or 6.
2. others are fine in here.

1. 00:01:133 (1) - add whistle in the slider's beginning? a bit shocked because different rhytm with before note (1). beside that, the new vocal is coming.
2. 00:04:113 (1) - ^
3. 00:21:250 (1) - can you make this slider into just one repeat? not friendly for newbie if too many repeat in here (they will break the combo). well, add the note in the next long white tick after you do this. oh, don't forget to remove new combo in here, then add new combo in the next note.
4. 00:24:230 (1) - ^
5. 00:27:210 (1) - ^
6. 00:39:877 (1,3) - ngg.. in my eyes these slider is a bit untidy shape. maybe, you can see this picture for my suggestion. well, I fix the spacing for (2) too. here:
   

   424,176,39877,6,0,B|368:196|328:136|328:136|292:84|232:96,1,220,8|0
   128,120,40995,1,2
   128,224,41368,2,0,B|140:284|216:284|216:284|280:284|308:356,1,220,8|0

7. 00:47:328 (3) - same as above, my suggestion: see this picture
8. 00:53:289 (5) - same as I mentioned in easy difficulty (00:51:799)
9. 00:58:505 (3) - add clap for consistent hitsounding in here? I think you just forgot to add clap in here.
10. 00:59:995 (6) - just a little thing, 1 grid up for linear with (5)?
11. 01:05:211 (4) - add clap for following the drum sound, sir?

1. 00:26:465 (9) - add new combo?. too long combo set for hard u.u
2. 01:05:211 (1,2,3,4,5) - not fit with the fast drum sound, I suggest you add 1/4 repeater slider like this ?
3. why the spacing in some notes is different? you use 1.0x, 1.2x, 0.8x, etc. that make me confused to read ;_; use consistent spacing more better. I just want to notice this.

1. Difficulty Setting: Decrease the HP drain -1. do you want to kill people in here orz = =
2. 00:01:133 - 00:06:442 - the rhythm is weird imo (in other word, this is not following song properly). then, the pattern is a bit mess.
3. 00:02:157 (3) - why the whistle in here? the sound is reallyl weird for me (because in the off-beat imo) you should add in (2) instead in here imo, since you already add in 00:01:226 (2).
4. 00:12:122 (4) - add new combo in here. for noticed player that's jump pattern.
5. 00:18:083 (5) - same as above
6. 00:57:015 (5) - ^
7. 01:05:211 (1,2,3,4,1) - same as I mentioned in Hard diff.
8. 01:07:964 (2) - add finish in the slider's beginning for following the cymbal sounder?
9. 01:09:931 (2) - ^
10. 01:11:898 (2) - ^
11. 01:13:620 (1,2,3,4) - I guess, this pattern is a bit boring because just stacked. well, make them like this
12. 01:14:849 (1) - this spinner should be starting from 01:14:665 like others difficulty. don't forget to move green timing point too (ngg, change the N:C2 -> S for really silenced the end of spinner)

Yasora wrote:

yo bro

General

1. Storyboarding:
   1. Disabled "Letterbox during breaks" because the map has video.
   2. Disabled "epilapsy warning" because no storyboard detected in this beatmap.
2. Folder: remove "normal-sliderslide" and "normal-sliderslide2"? if this aiming for silenced the slider body, that's unrankable silenced the slider body for normal-hitsound imo. no, actually melophobia is the one that suggest that i should use this mute slider slide from the last mod, since it was too noisy when i'm not use it, so i think it will be fine this way

Easy

1. 00:51:799 (5) - add new combo in here. for easy diff, not good idea if add long combo set. usually, the combo set for easy is between 1 - 5 or 6.
2. others are fine in here.

fix'd all

Normal

1. 00:01:133 (1) - add whistle in the slider's beginning? a bit shocked because different rhytm with before note (1). beside that, the new vocal is coming.
2. 00:04:113 (1) - ^
3. 00:21:250 (1) - can you make this slider into just one repeat? not friendly for newbie if too many repeat in here (they will break the combo). well, add the note in the next long white tick after you do this. oh, don't forget to remove new combo in here, then add new combo in the next note.
4. 00:24:230 (1) - ^
5. 00:27:210 (1) - ^
6. 00:39:877 (1,3) - ngg.. in my eyes these slider is a bit untidy shape. maybe, you can see this picture for my suggestion. well, I fix the spacing for (2) too. here:
   

   424,176,39877,6,0,B|368:196|328:136|328:136|292:84|232:96,1,220,8|0
   128,120,40995,1,2
   128,224,41368,2,0,B|140:284|216:284|216:284|280:284|308:356,1,220,8|0

7. 00:47:328 (3) - same as above, my suggestion: see this picture no
8. 00:53:289 (5) - same as I mentioned in easy difficulty (00:51:799)
9. 00:58:505 (3) - add clap for consistent hitsounding in here? I think you just forgot to add clap in here.
10. 00:59:995 (6) - just a little thing, 1 grid up for linear with (5)?
11. 01:05:211 (4) - add clap for following the drum sound, sir? no, young lady

fix'd all

Hard

1. 00:26:465 (9) - add new combo?. too long combo set for hard u.u i think it's fine this way
2. 01:05:211 (1,2,3,4,5) - not fit with the fast drum sound, I suggest you add 1/4 repeater slider like this ?
3. why the spacing in some notes is different? you use 1.0x, 1.2x, 0.8x, etc. that make me confused to read ;_; use consistent spacing more better. I just want to notice this.

fix'd all


Insane

1. Difficulty Setting: Decrease the HP drain -1. do you want to kill people in here orz = = NO
2. 00:01:133 - 00:06:442 - the rhythm is weird imo (in other word, this is not following song properly). then, the pattern is a bit mess. fix'd the pattern
3. 00:02:157 (3) - why the whistle in here? the sound is reallyl weird for me (because in the off-beat imo) you should add in (2) instead in here imo, since you already add in 00:01:226 (2). fix the whistle arrangement on the 1/3 beats pattern
4. 00:12:122 (4) - add new combo in here. for noticed player that's jump pattern.
5. 00:18:083 (5) - same as above
6. 00:57:015 (5) - ^
7. 01:05:211 (1,2,3,4,1) - same as I mentioned in Hard diff. i wanna make a jump on this part, i'm make this into stream, it will be kinda really hard for play normally (because the drum beat are only 8, and stream with even number are harder than odd number) plus it was not blend well with the jump on 01:05:956 (1,2,3) -
8. 01:07:964 (2) - add finish in the slider's beginning for following the cymbal sounder?
9. 01:09:931 (2) - ^
10. 01:11:898 (2) - ^
11. 01:13:620 (1,2,3,4) - I guess, this pattern is a bit boring because just stacked. well, make them like this
12. 01:14:849 (1) - this spinner should be starting from 01:14:665 like others difficulty. don't forget to move green timing point too (ngg, change the N:C2 -> S for really silenced the end of spinner)
    
    fix'd all

That's all
Good luck :3 omg L!! *q*

Philippines wrote:

• Easy

1. 01:14:665 (1) - Why is this spinner here? :O Move here: 01:14:480?

• Normal

1. 00:24:975 (1) - One grid left.
   
   
2. 01:14:665 (1) - Why is this spinner here? :O Move here: 01:14:480?

fix all

• Hard

1. 00:02:250 (4) - Fix this spacing please.
   
   
2. 00:09:887 (8) - I don't know if the spacing is intentional, but I don't see any reason for a jump on this part.
   
   
3. 00:11:377 (4) - Spacing.
   
   
4. 00:13:798 (3) - ^.
   
   
5. Can't go on. Too many inconsistent spacing. :O Sorry. You could call me back when you think it's fine now.
   
   
6. 01:14:665 (1) - Why is this spinner here? :O Move here: 01:14:480?

all the spacing was intentional, but i'm still work to make it consistent now

• Insane

1. 00:35:593 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - A perfect hexagon for this pattern would be better.
   
   
2. 01:14:665 (1) - Why is this spinner here? :O Move here: 01:14:480?

fix all

• General

1. Wow for that 244 BPM thing. :O i'm more glad if someone can tell me the perfect timing for this mapset orz

1. Make sounds by 10% quieter
2. Lead in = 2500
3. 00:30:938 - kiai fountain there
4. 00:01:691 - 30% volume
5. 00:04:113 - ^

1. HP and AR -1
2. 00:02:437 (2) - will be better if you will remove reverse and prolong slider to that white tick
3. 00:05:417 (2) - ^
4. 00:39:877 (3,5) - 1 grid right

1. 01:14:480 (1) - finish it on a big white tick

1. OD = 6, HP = 7
2. 00:12:774 - note there
3. 00:21:156 - ^
4. 00:24:137 - ^
5. 00:39:505 (4) - spacing
6. 00:55:152 (2) - srack with (1)

Vass_Bass wrote:

Hi

General

1. Make sounds by 10% quieter
2. Lead in = 2500
3. 00:30:938 - kiai fountain there
4. 00:01:691 - 30% volume [/color]
5. 00:04:113 - ^ same

Easy

1. HP and AR -1
2. 00:02:437 (2) - will be better if you will remove reverse and prolong slider to that white tick
3. 00:05:417 (2) - ^
4. 00:39:877 (3,5) - 1 grid right

change all distance with 0,5 DS \o/


Normal

1. 01:14:480 (1) - finish it on a big white tick

Hard

1. OD = 6, HP = 7
2. 00:12:774 - note there
3. 00:21:156 - ^
4. 00:24:137 - ^
5. 00:39:505 (4) - spacing
6. 00:55:152 (2) - srack with (1)

done all

Good luck

ikari_kyon wrote:

timing check requested by Leorda

1st timeline
BPM: ok
offset: 565 (-9 on current)
time signature: please use common 4/4

2nd timeline
BPM: ok
offset: 7110 (+17 on current)
time signature: ok

3rd timeline
BPM: ok
offset: 66480 (-9 on current)
time signature: 3/4 is ok, I thinkg

well I think that popner cant check multiple bpm songs, so Ill try to check the timing request starting with the next ones

yuugeki1234 wrote:

random from modreq~
death note
i have comicbooks and anime blue-ray discs lol
this music hard diffcult timing point ...
well mapping.

Easy

00:30:953(1) whats this kiai time? remove it. but you add this on all diffcult. intentionally? if that, sorry. is this pass to ranked? to make a splash effect when play :3

Normal

00:30:953(1) remove kiai time or not same reason as above

01:14:102(2) remove circle? i think this is better for music. fix'd that part

Hard

01:05:973(7) add clap?

01:06:159(8) ^

01:06:346(9) ^
if u change above three, change volume 50% inherrited point at 01:05:973.

i'm intended to make a silent part before 244bpm moment

01:13:979(5) remove circle? removed


Insane

00:18:100(1,2,3,4) like this? jump point. http://puu.sh/w4uc ok

01:05:414(2) add nc? no

01:05:787(4) add nc? no

01:05:973(1,2,3) if u change my hard's modding, line up this. i'm trying to make a jump here, so i think lined up this three is not really a good idea for now, dunno for later :3

good luck ranked!

-Bakari- wrote:

hi there!

[General]
clear

[Insane]
00:19:776 (1) - u really want new combo here? i want to make the new combo each 2 tick here
00:21:267 (1) - ^ since it was the jump pattern, i think it was better if i add the new combo, some modder back there are also said so

[Hard]
00:14:561 (5) - if it should be symmetrical fix it! (ctrl + h to check)
00:16:796 (3) - a bit closer to (2)
00:25:737 (5) - new combo? no
00:38:590 (1) - http://puu.sh/w8Gv
00:41:385 (9,3) - overlap
00:56:287 (1) - move NC to (2) no, i think it was better this way
00:57:777 (1) - ^ ^
01:14:348 (5) - lol i want NC here

[Normal]
00:31:698 (3) - if it possible, somehow move in the center of screen http://puu.sh/w8HL
00:37:659 (2) - ^
00:45:855 (1) - try to cover (4) better i think just make them spaced are better

[Easy]
00:48:836 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - change some of them into sliders! it'll be hard for beginners!

fix'd eveything that i did't give a comment

~~~~~~~~~~~

gl~

Leorda wrote:

Hi there

[Easy]
00:07:110 (3) - New combo for new timing
00:51:816 (5) - New combo for preventing of long combo


[Normal]
00:24:992 (1) - Don't stack under slider, it's confusing for beginners about which object should click first
00:27:973 (1) - ^


[Hard]
01:05:228 (5) - New combo for your new pattern


Good luck~

crabovan wrote:

Hello, I'm from #modreqs

General

00:12:698 - end of Kiai time
00:13:070 - second start of Kiai time
00:31:046 - delete this point no, since i'm set the NC1 there because it have the custom hitclap that i need to use for that part, the NC2 for the gong-hitfinish
00:42:875 - end of Kiai time no, since the kiai time are already ended even before that timing points , also i just removed the small kiai part on all diff just now

fixd everything without comment

Insane

00:06:526 (10,3,4,5) - this isn't good
00:42:875 (1,3) - this isn't good stack (3) qith (1) startpoit
This part - my opinion (don't surely to change it) i think it was better to make them full notes, rather than that, i'm think adding a note here 00:44:365 would be better, so i just add it there just now
00:47:345 (1) - maybe better delete this note?
00:53:306 (1) - ^
00:56:287 (1) - ^
00:59:267 (1) - ^
01:02:248 (1) - ^

Hard

01:00:757 (1) - move on 2 tiles left

Normal

All fine.

Easy

All fine.

fix'd all

fabriciorby wrote:

[general]
i think the timing at the last red timing section is a bit wrong +/- here 01:09:799 (1)
ask some bat to check this for you, i recomend sakura hana
well, actually for the timing i'm already ask for the expert on modhelp before, and ikari kyon give me the almost-perfect timing position that posibble, i think i'll look for another person again later
[easy]
change the slider tick to 1
00:28:718 (2,3) - this spacing is not the same as 00:29:463 (3,4)

fixd all

[normal]
change the slider tick to 1
fixd all

[hard]
00:19:404 (2) - in these sliders it would be better to use 1,0x distance snap imo i think the current one is ok, since i wanna make a rail pattern (each slider edge are atached with each other, i saw this pattern are quite matched for theis kind of difficulty ) on this part, so make the spacing with 1,0 will be destroying it because it makes the spacing between two sliders became parted, thus making ruining the rail pattern that im intended too
00:22:384 (2) - ^ same as above

that's it (:

BeatofIke wrote:

Maximum the Hormone so overrated. -_-

1. 00:30:953 - 00:42:875 - You might want to add another kiai time here.

1. 0.5x DS? Oh. My. God. This diff becomes almost unplayable for me when I attempted to go for this. Consider using 0.7-0.8x DS. You might need to rearrange things here and there, but you won't regret it. It's just one week from the time you submitted this anyway, so don't think it's too late (although there's 16 mods already...). Everything else is fine, though.

1. 00:06:526 (3) - 0.83x DS? Eh? Maybe go around 0.9x?

1. *plays the last kiai time* FATHER IN HEAVEN; THIS IS NOT SCARLET ROSE OR THE BIG BLACK. *calms* Maybe you should make another inherited timing point that overlaps with the last red timing point and go for 0.75x BPM, since 1.8 SV @ 244 BPM is too extreme even for an Insane diff (although the approved version of the full version of this song has 2.7 SV...). I won't force you to do this, but you should consider it.

Hinsvar wrote:

\:D/

*Note: Gold ones are a must-do. Everything in red are things that look awkward or wrong to me (subjective suggestions; you can follow my lead here or not); everything else are rants and minor suggestions to make things look cooler and a bit better.

>General

1. 00:30:953 - 00:42:875 - You might want to add another kiai time here. if im add the kiai time on there too, then the 2/5 of the song will be consisted with the kiai part, while it was bad since kiai is can be added only when the most epic part are comes, so i cant add it there too

>Easy

1. 0.5x DS? Oh. My. God. This diff becomes almost unplayable for me when I attempted to go for this. Consider using 0.7-0.8x DS. You might need to rearrange things here and there, but you won't regret it. It's just one week from the time you submitted this anyway, so don't think it's too late (although there's 16 mods already...). Everything else is fine, though.

so i just read this on the wiki some days ago http://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Easy

Most of the time, just having them next to each other without overlapping is good enough

so i just make all the notes to be next with each other like this, and i think this way are way easier since the player/newbies do not need to move the hand too far away :3


>Normal

1. 00:06:526 (3) - 0.83x DS? Eh? Maybe go around 0.9x?

fix'd

>Insane

1. *plays the last kiai time* FATHER IN HEAVEN; THIS IS NOT SCARLET ROSE OR THE BIG BLACK. *calms* Maybe you should make another inherited timing point that overlaps with the last red timing point and go for 0.75x BPM, since 1.8 SV @ 244 BPM is too extreme even for an Insane diff (although the approved version of the full version of this song has 2.7 SV...). I won't force you to do this, but you should consider it. nah, im already tried this hudred times and ask various player like Darksonic, Chewin, Doomsday etc, and i think this way is perfect to me, no need to make it easier since this is an insane diff, and it will be boring if i just make that part easier imo, i'm sure most of the experienced player feel that way too Kyou-kun even said to me that the last part are too easy =w=

Aside from some problems I consider serious and an extremely minor one, I think this mapset as a whole (including the Hard diff, which is pretty nice for me) is great. Also, the song is the epitome of AWESOMENESS.

Good luck on the way

*Note: Don't give me kudosu if you didn't change anything.

Envi wrote:

give kds anyway, thanks!

No_Gu wrote:

request from my queue
title should be What's up, people?! (TV Size) http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/324261 thanks for reminding this T_Tb, and also i think the "P" should be in capital too since the title on the official single are capital o3o

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zawa...Zaw ... ......Zawa

SPOILER

maybe this need some discussion later, i think o3o

01:14:594 (1) - end at 01:18:652 fix'd
there is something wrong with the hitcircle.png.you can see a little red shadow on top right no, actually i'm make it like that from the beginning, since it was not looks weird when i'm try it so, i just put it on the songfolder like that. Maybe i'll change it if many ppl are disagree with it orz

[easy]
00:07:110 -00:18:286 I don't like hitsound here.try 24clap or 24whistle fix'd
01:06:480 (1,2,3,4,1,2,1,2,1,2) - I mainly suggest using SV change here ,change SV similar to the other parts.beacuse It's hard for beginners to read BPM change change the SV into 0,75 there, hope this one are easier =='

[normal]
01:06:480 (1,2,1) - it's not good to change spacing in normal diff imo it's ok, i just remapped that last part orz

[hard]
ehhh this diff is full of 1/2 notes.It's more like an insane diff... o.o i think this is not really that hard for the well experienced for play, since i'm not making any complicated pattern like back jump or anything here, and also because the song is like this, i dunno how to make this more easier than this orz, maybe i'll remap some part of this later

also i'm actually using the same style for this diff as my ranked map :3

[insane]
01:00:757 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) - maybe add some streams gradually.I can hear the drums clearly

the problem is, the only pattern that can fit with the drum voice are streams or sliderstreams, which imo is not a good way to put the streams in that whole part because 01:00:757-01:04:856 are quite long (yeah, i know too that rubick's cube 7x7x7 stream part can do it fine, but i think it will not work well for this diff ) so i just put the slider stream on the most audible part of the drum voice here 01:05:228 (1,2,3,4) - instead, hope you can understand what i mean =='
01:13:611 (1,2,3,4) - add NC for each.hard to read imo.

easy is a little disorderly.other diffs are fine for me.orz crazy song yea so crazy, but i love it so much orz

1. 00:02:428 (2,2) - Tambah whistle di akhir kedua slider ini? Kalau didengar baik-baik, bunyi gitarnya persis dengan (1), dan di (1) ada whistle~
2. 00:06:526 (x) - Gitarnya berhenti tepat di downbeat, jadi akan jauh lebih pas kalau ada circle di sini. Mungkin coba atur seperti ini? (bagian linear pada slider ini flownya bagus dengan circle setelahnya xD)
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:10:090 (3) - New combo - selain itu, mungkin ini bisa ditaruh di x:215 y:75? Soalnya titik itu pertengahan (1,2) :3
4. 00:19:031 (1,2,3,1) - (optional) Mungkin empat ini bisa diatur zig-zag supaya nggak terlalu linear? (2) tinggal digeser ke atas sedikit kok xD
5. 00:26:482 (3,1,2) - Di sini, akan jauh lebih rapih kalau tiga ini bisa dibuat simetris... Intinya (1) itu didesain ulang aja midpointnya (lebih bagus kalau tanpa grid snap), lalu (2) itu ditaruh di koordinat x yang sama dengan (2)~
6. 00:33:933 (3) - New combo
7. 00:34:679 (4) - Kenapa circle ini terlalu dekat ke (5) dibanding (3)? Memang nggak susah dibaca sih, tapi tetap...
8. 00:39:894 (3) - Lagi, New combo disini (uhm, intinya combo streak yang sekarang itu terlalu panjang buat Easy diff >_<)
9. 00:48:836 (1,2,3) - (optional) Kenapa di sini arrangement-nya linear? imo flow-nya akan jadi lebih bagus kalau tiga ini dibuat arc seperti ini: (jangan lupa (1,2) setelahnya di re-arrange juga ya kak xD)
   
   SPOILER

   
10. 00:57:777 (3) - Lagi, slider ini terlalu dekat ke (4) dibanding (2), tapi nggak susah di-catch kok xD
11. 01:03:738 (3) - Uhm, apa memang slider ini sengaja dibuat ke-overlap akhir dari (2) kak? imo sih ini agak nanggung, mending dibuat lebih overlap lagi (midpoint x:404 y:90 endpoint x:426 y:53) supaya nggak nanggung (:

1. 00:01:124 (1) - (optional) Untuk variasi, mungkin coba dibuat begini? :3
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:01:124 (1,2,3,1) - Seperti yang gw bilang di atas, di sini agak maksa... Meskipun begitu, masih bisa ketolong kalau whistle hanya ditaruh di saat gitar mencapai nada tinggi (dalam kasus ini: akhir (1), (3), dan akhir 00:02:428 (1))
3. 00:04:104 (1,2,3,1) - Samakan ritmenya dengan yang di atas (kalau memang dirubah) xD
4. 00:09:345 (6) - Uhm... Apa slider ini sengaja dibuat nggak simetris begini kak (waypointnya terlalu ke atas)? imo sih mending disimetrisin aja, nggak terlalu susah kok~
5. 00:15:678 (2) - Geser ke x:159 y:212 supaya jarak antar (2,2,2) jadi konsisten?
6. 00:17:541 (1,1) - Jujur, overlap antar kedua note ini kelihatan aneh... imo sih solusi terbaik adalah dengan menggeser 00:19:031 (1,2) lebih ke atas, dan kalau perlu curve di (2) didesain ulang supaya spacingnya tetap konsisten :3
7. 00:21:267 (4) - Hmm, vokalnya nggak berhenti di sini... Jadi imo sih mending ditambahin whistle juga di awal dan repeat slider ini. Berlaku untuk semua bagian yang seperti ini~
8. 00:22:012 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - (optional) imo sih enam circle ini agak random penempatannya... Mungkin fan pattern begini bisa buat jadi lebih rapih? (:
   
   SPOILER

   
9. 00:30:953 (1,2) - Hmm, apakah disengaja untuk menaruh (2) sedikit lebih rendah dibanding (1)? imo sih mending (1)-nya langsung tarik ke bawah aja kak supaya jadi arc sekalian xD
10. 00:33:933 (1,3) - (optional) Mungkin akan jadi lebih rapih kalau (1) dibuat melingkari (2) dan (3) dibuat melingkari (4), namun ini murni optional~
11. 00:39:894 (1,3) - Tambahkan clap di slider end agar clap-nya tetap konsisten 2/1
12. 00:47:345 (3) - (optional) Jujur sih kak, bentuk slider ini agak kurang beraturan imo... Mungkin coba dibuat seperti ini? xD
    
    SPOILER

    
13. 00:59:267 (5,6) - (2,3) sebelumnya dibuat simetris, kenapa dua ini nggak dibuat simetris o.o (well, sebenernya sih tinggal mencocokkan koordinat x dua ini dengan koordinat x (2,3), tapi bukan masalah besar kok~)
14. 01:03:738 (1,2) - (optional) Tambahkan "slight curve" pada dua ini ((1) ke bawah, (2) ke kiri)) supaya flow dari (2,3) jadi lebih enak dilihat?
15. 01:08:201 (4) - Err... di bagian ini new combo-ingnya mulai kacau >_< - New combo itu harusnya di sini (seperti di diff Easy, intinya setiap kali ada vokalnya) dan yang paling penting finish juga harusnya ada setiap awal slider ini (bukan di akhir (3))... Berlaku untuk semua bagian yang seperti ini~
16. 01:08:693 (5) - Coba untuk geser ini sedikit ke bawah (tanpa distance snap) supaya nggak ke-overlap (3) yang sebelumnya?

1. 00:00:565 (1,2,3) - (optional) Karena 00:03:545 (1,2,3) yang berikutnya itu jump, gw sih melihatnya kalau di sini ada jump juga bakal jadi lebih menarik~
2. 00:07:110 (1) - imo sih akan lebih dapat feel lagunya kalau ini di-stack dengan (8) yang sebelumnya :3
3. 00:11:394 (4,5,6,7) - Arc ini kurang nge-flow imo karena (5,6) itu berada dalam satu garis lurus... Mungkin bisa dibuat zig-zag di sini? xD
4. 00:16:051 (1,3) - (optional) Seperti yang gw singgung di Normal, menurut gw sih kalau begini lebih baik (1) di-curve mengelilingi (2) dan (3) mengelilingi (4), tapi ini murni optional kok~
5. 00:21:267 (1,2) - Sama seperti Normal, vokalnya belum berhenti di sini, jadi whistle seharusnya juga belum berhenti di sini... (cek juga bagian berikutnya yang seperti ini xD)
6. 00:22:012 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Hmm, kelihatan sih kak ini placingnya agak random, untuk pattern begini sih kalau dirotate dengan sumbu yang konsisten pasti hasilnya akan lebih rapih (dalam gambar ini, setiap slider diputar 50°)
   
   SPOILER

   
7. 00:28:718 (3,5) - (optional) Hmm, ini cuma ide sih kak, mungkin (3) bisa dibuat menghadap lebih ke atas dan (5) dibuat menghadap lebih ke kiri supaya (1,3,5) kesannya agak2 simetris gitu :3
8. 00:38:590 (1,2,3,4) - Err... Di sini juga agak kelihatan random imo, akan lebih bagus kalau dibuat arc seperti ini: (di gambar, (4) dibuat mengelilingi (1) sesudahnya)
   
   SPOILER

   
9. 00:40:639 (4) - Kalau diperhatikan, slider ini lebih dekat ke (3) dibanding (5), tapi masih gampang di-catch kok~
10. 00:41:943 (2) - Coba tambahkan slight curve ke kanan bawah, untuk menunjang flow dari (3,4,5) sesudahnya?
11. 00:48:836 (1,2) - Err, pakai 1/1 slider + circle di sini? Soalnya 00:42:875 (1), 00:45:855 (1), dan 00:51:816 (1) itu semuanya 1/1 slider xD
12. 00:53:865 (2,3,4) - Uh, jujur gw kurang dapet maksud dari jump ini... Terutama kenapa dari (1,2) itu nggak jump >_< - imo sih gw lihatnya mending ini dijadiin accelerated spacing aja kak, tinggal tarik (4) menjauh aja soalnya~
13. 01:00:757 (1,2,3,4) - (optional) Supaya lebih intens, CTRL+R empat-empatnya? :3
14. 01:02:248 (1,3) - Uh... Kenapa tiba-tiba linear >_< - Coba tambahin curve supaya tetap bezier di sini? Soalnya tiba-tiba linear dari bezier di sini agak aneh imo >_<
15. 01:06:346 (5) - Udah di-tes, ini harusnya 1/8 lebih awal - nah, karena ritme 1/8 itu bisa menjebak, gw saranin untuk buat (4) jadi 3/8 slider xD
16. 01:09:799 (1) - Finish seharusnya bukan di repeatnya... Gw yakin ini, tapi gw kurang yakin harus geser finish-nya ke mana >_< - coba geser ke repeat, mungkin :3
17. 01:13:488 (1,2,3,4) - Uh, sebenernya nggak ada yang salah sih, tapi cuma mau bilang di sini mungkin bakal agak ngagetin (soalnya tiba-tiba quadruple begini orz, pasti di sini pemain udah keasyikan sama 1/1-nya xD)

1. 00:06:246 (8,9,10) - Geser tiga ini lebih ke kanan bawah? Aneh aja ngelihatnya kak dari (7) ke (8,9) sudutnya tiba2 tajam o.o
2. 00:09:159 (5) - (optional) Coba buat slider ini mengelilingi akhir dari (4)?
3. 00:11:953 (3,1,2,3,4) - Meskipun udah AR9, tapi tetap imo jump di sini agak ngagetin... Mungkin pakai accelerated spacing di sini?
4. 00:15:865 (1,2) - Tukar posisinya (repeating slider dulu baru 1/2 slider) - patokannya sih downbeat aja kak, sebelum-sebelumnya kan 1/2 sebelum downbeat itu repeating slider (:
5. 00:18:472 (3) - (optional) Tarik (3) lebih jauh ke kiri, supaya ada kesan "fan"-nya di sini?
6. 00:22:012 (1) - Stack dengan 00:20:521 (1)? Di play mode, comboburst dari 00:20:521 (1) itu masih kelihatan kak...
7. 00:33:002 (5,6,7) - Kenapa (6) tiba-tiba jadi terlalu dekat dengan (7) o.o
8. 00:35:051 (6) - Whistle harusnya ada di awal slider - plus imo repeat banyak begini kurang pas sama lagunya, mungkin coba dua circle + satu repeating 1/4 slider di sini? xD
9. 00:35:610 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - (optional) Coba pattern ini? Bakal lebih mengena sama lagunya imo karena ada stack di (5,6) :
   
   SPOILER

   
10. 00:42:689 (5) - Uh, ini jelas banget kelihatan kak, ini terlalu dekat ke (4) dibanding (1)...
11. 00:47:345 (1,2,3) - Kalaupun mau ada stack di sini, sangat disarankan untuk men-stack (2,3) dibanding (1,2) - lebih pas dengan vokalnya kalau di-stack di (2,3) :3
12. 00:52:561 (3,4,5,1,2,3) - (optional) Kalau diperhatiin baik-baik, ini bisa jadi star/pentagon pattern lho xD
    
    SPOILER

    
13. 00:55:355 (4) - Lagi, terlalu dekat ke (5) dibanding (3), tapi ini mudah untuk di-catch (:
14. 01:03:738 (1,2,3,4) - (optional) Sama seperti yang gw saranin di Hard, CTRL+R empat-empatnya agar jadi lebih intens?
15. 01:06:346 (3) - Sama pula seperti di Hard, ini harusnya 1/8 lebih awal (teknisnya gimana ya kurang lebih udah gw sebut di atas~)
16. 01:13:611 (1,1,1,1) - Uh, combo color yang sekarang jujur agak susah dibaca kalau ditumpuk begini kak >_< (makannya di awal gw saranin combo color hax :3)

Niva wrote:

o/

[General]

-> Nada pertama itu baru mulai setelah 500ms, apa lead-in time 2500ms nggak kebanyakan? Memang sih, nggak unrankable, tapi 1500 udah lebih dari cukup imo (bahkan 1000 juga sebenarnya cukup) ok 1500ms
-> Nah, untuk lagu yang speed up begini, gw saranin pakai combo color hax kak, intinya di bagian 161BPM-nya pakai combo color yang agak calm, nah nanti pas di bagian 244BPM langsung pakai merah dan semacamnya xD ok, ntar dicari dulu warna yang cocok buat ini, sebenarnya di map ku sebelumnya juga make color hax sih
-> Hmm, imo sih orang lebih banyak nyari pakai tags "op2" dibanding "opening2", tapi bukan masalah besar kok :3 g usah diganti, sepertinya tidak masalah :3
-> Karena lagunya pendek, kalau ada file audio yang 192kbps ya dipergunakan aja kak, nggak terlalu ngegedein filesize kok :3 lagi dicari juga, agak susah nyari lagu lama yang HQ


[Normal]

-> Rhythm buat openingnya (sebelum kiai pertama) kok agak maksa yah... Kalau di Hard itu masih intuitif soalnya 1/2 semua, tapi ini Normal bener2 kerasa kepaksa imo... Kalau mau bener2 ngikut lagu sih mestinya 00:01:124 (1) - circle, 00:01:310 (2) - 3/4 repeating slider, 00:02:055 (3) - circle, 00:02:241 (1) - 3/4 repeating slider, dst... >_< pattern dibuat ulang :3

1. 00:09:345 (6) - Uhm... Apa slider ini sengaja dibuat nggak simetris begini kak (waypointnya terlalu ke atas)? imo sih mending disimetrisin aja, nggak terlalu susah kok~ nggak deh, menurutku posisi ini udah bagus kok, terutama pas dimainin
2. 00:33:933 (1,3) - (optional) Mungkin akan jadi lebih rapih kalau (1) dibuat melingkari (2) dan (3) dibuat melingkari (4), namun ini murni optional~ kasaknya posisi ini sudah enak kok menurutku

[Hard]

1. 00:16:051 (1,3) - (optional) Seperti yang gw singgung di Normal, menurut gw sih kalau begini lebih baik (1) di-curve mengelilingi (2) dan (3) mengelilingi (4), tapi ini murni optional kok~ aku lebih senang posisi ini ,rasanya kalo dibuat mengelilingi satu sama lain pas dimainin kayak berasa jump2 gimana gitu ><
2. 00:21:267 (1,2) - Sama seperti Normal, vokalnya belum berhenti di sini, jadi whistle seharusnya juga belum berhenti di sini... (cek juga bagian berikutnya yang seperti ini xD) disini aku mau lebih menekankan suara instrumen dibanding vokal :3
3. 01:13:488 (1,2,3,4) - Uh, sebenernya nggak ada yang salah sih, tapi cuma mau bilang di sini mungkin bakal agak ngagetin (soalnya tiba-tiba quadruple begini orz, pasti di sini pemain udah keasyikan sama 1/1-nya xD) sengaja, pemain manapun pasti sebagian besar ud menduga quadruple disitu bakal ada kalo ud pernah ngedengerin lagunya xD

[Insane]

-> Uh, jujur kak ini susah di mod... Stylenya itu kak, memang sih ngikutin dist.snap tapi placement-nya kelihatan random banget... Rankable sih, tapi aneh aja dilihatnya >_< - untuk map yang banyak double+triple+quadruple begini sih gw saranin belajar ke map-nya Muya yang ini kak buat stream design-nya~ hanya saja menurutku ini style yang paling pas buat dipake pada lagu semacam ini, rasanya maksa sekali kalo make pattern simetris, lagipula approved version juga ud mengadaptasi pattern simetris, jadinya berasa monoton gimana gitu kalo aku pake style yang sama, kalo gaya random begini kan pemain jadi merasa lebih tertantang karena g bisa langsung menguasai pattern style diff ini. FL one try, screw that orz
beberapa pro player juga ud kuminta coba dan mereka senang dengan style seperti ini buat insane diff lagu ini

1. 00:09:159 (5) - (optional) Coba buat slider ini mengelilingi akhir dari (4)? keliatannya agak kurang pas o.o
2. 00:35:051 (6) - Whistle harusnya ada di awal slider - plus imo repeat banyak begini kurang pas sama lagunya, mungkin coba dua circle + satu repeating 1/4 slider di sini? xD aku lebih prefer ke repeat 3x kayak gini, karena suara drum 5 kali dibelakang plus persiapan sebelum jump pattern setelah repeat slider ini
3. 01:13:611 (1,1,1,1) - Uh, combo color yang sekarang jujur agak susah dibaca kalau ditumpuk begini kak >_< (makannya di awal gw saranin combo color hax :3) lagi nyari warna yang tepat :3

Jujur kak, imo untuk Easy/Normal/Hard itu udah jauh lebih berkembang dibanding omokage warp, tapi Insanenya itu... orz >_< (nggak bisa dijelasin orz :3) orz

(cuma point of view gw aja kok kak, jangan marah ya kak :3) - Good luck kak Envi~

BeatofIke wrote:

Request from my modding queue. Sorry for the long wait:

General
-> Nothing found.

Easy
-> Nothing found.

Normal
-> Nothing found.

Hard
-> Nothing found.

Insane
-> Nothing found.

Niva pretty much pwned your map with his mods. I can't find any more suggestions. Sorry.

ikari_kyon wrote:

he have no suggest, he post like this

xD

Netsukawa wrote:

irc modded

Envi Rock \m/

SPOILER

09:27 <Netsukawa> : Tadaima
09:27 <Netsukawa> : Let's irc Mod
09:27 <Envi> : okaeri
09:27 <Envi> : roger
09:28 <Netsukawa> : EPIC HS lol
09:28 <Netsukawa> : Easy
09:28 <Netsukawa> : 00:04:383 (1) -
09:28 <Netsukawa> : Remove NC
09:28 <Envi> : done
09:29 <Netsukawa> : I suggest you
09:29 <Netsukawa> : to move pv point
09:29 <Netsukawa> : 00:04:383 (1) -
09:30 <Envi> : yeah
09:30 <Netsukawa> : It's more EIPIC when select the song
09:30 <Netsukawa> : so serprise
09:30 <Netsukawa> : ww
09:30 <Netsukawa> : Easy diff nothing weird
09:31 <Envi> : roger
09:31 <Netsukawa> : Normal
09:31 <Netsukawa> : 00:01:030 (1) -
09:31 <Netsukawa> : Remove NC
09:31 <Netsukawa> : 00:04:010 (1) - ^
09:31 <Envi> : done
09:31 <Netsukawa> : 00:06:246 (1) - This too
09:32 <Netsukawa> : orz
09:33 <Envi> : ?
09:33 <Netsukawa> : Hard diff
09:33 <Envi> : k
09:34 <Netsukawa> : My avartar fascinating
09:34 <Netsukawa> : wwwwwwwww
09:34 <Envi> : yeah
09:35 <Envi> : dunno from what H manga u got it
09:35 <Netsukawa> : 00:40:918 (6,7,8) - change to 1/4 slider
09:35 <Envi> : lol like i wana know anyways
09:35 <Netsukawa> : =w=
09:35 <Envi> : k
09:35 <Netsukawa> : I will give you If you wnat
09:35 *Netsukawa runs
09:36 <Netsukawa> : 01:06:200 (1) -
09:36 <Netsukawa> : This too suddenly
09:36 <Netsukawa> : ;w;
09:36 <Netsukawa> : plz make it with no jump
09:36 <Envi> : what should i do? D:
09:36 <Netsukawa> : easier to play
09:37 <Netsukawa> : 01:13:208 (1,1,1,1) - Change to slider ?
09:37 <Envi> : delete 01:05:816 then?
09:37 <Envi> : k
09:37 <Netsukawa> : NoNo I just suggest you to make it with no jump
09:37 <Envi> : w8, move the pattern
09:38 <Netsukawa> : Yea
09:38 <Envi> : k done
09:38 <Envi> : btw for this 01:13:208 (1,1,1,1) -
09:38 <Envi> : i think 4 notes are better
09:38 <Envi> : although a bit harder =w=
09:38 <Netsukawa> : But hard to read
09:39 <Netsukawa> : If that insane , It's ok
09:39 <Netsukawa> : I guess
09:39 <Netsukawa> : lol
09:39 <Envi> : ok
09:40 <Netsukawa> : Insane look fine to me
09:40 <Netsukawa> : Then
09:40 <Envi> : lol

That's all ~

spboxer3 wrote:

※ Notice

red is unrankable issue.
blue is recommended to fix.
Black is just suggestion.

:idea: general

• 
  Settings
  (For the setting/general issue.)
  

1. When you have skin~you need add sliderbroder
2. Inconsistency in preview time you must unify it.
3. Offset: 285.277684021032 ._.? 285

Easy

• 
  
  Overlaps
  (Some overlaps of notes/sliders in this diff don't look good. Here is a list of beats that overlap each other could space them farther apart. Yep. It's just suggest and nazi. you can ignore this par)
  

1. 01:01:968 (2,1) -

mapping
(These are about your pattern.Mostly for the suggest, Just some unrankable issue I will use red color to highlight it.)

1. 00:04:383 (2,3) - [arc issue] It's looks awkward slider arc because it's not coincidence arc to 00:04:383 (2) -

Normal

• 
  
  mapping
  (These are about your pattern.Mostly for the suggest, Just some unrankable issue I will use red color to highlight it.)
  

1. 00:04:010 (3,4) - [suggestion] let the slider ball set at turning point on slider tick (00:04:393 - & 00:05:501 - )

Hard

• 
  Settings
  (For the setting. like Song Setup/timing or break time~)
  

1. unused green line (It's not effect to player. but I suggest you should to remove it):
   01:06:322

Hitsound
(For my listened. Just some suggest for the hitsound.)

1. 00:39:428 - forget whistle?

mapping
(These are about your pattern.Mostly for the suggest, Just some unrankable issue I will use red color to highlight it.)

1. 00:51:536 (1,2,3) - uneven spacing.

Insane

• 
  
  mapping
  (These are about your pattern.Mostly for the suggest, Just some unrankable issue I will use red color to highlight it.)
  

1. looks fine.

fix'd everything

good luck~

haha5957 wrote:

From the group 3's Challenge Queue!!

[General]
Since the map itself has some quality, I won't mod every single rhythm parts or placements for maximum respect to the mapper, but I decided to do some general suggestions for some parts on every diffiulcty o.o/

[Easy]

01:06:200 (1,2,3,4) - I think this pattern is too much for easy since this counts as preety much 1/8 yellow tick according to past timing section
so I think at least make 1-2 slider to make sure the player can "adjust" to the new BPM and the timing section o.o/ i think so too, but slider all the way are kind boring too, so i just adjust 2 notes to be a slider there =w=



[Normal]

(placements)
00:19:496 (2) - like http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/327555 this? to make sure this forms preety shape with previous (4). currently, I think it makes me feel kinda um... o.o/ fix'd there some bit



[Hard]
- like i said in insane, about round-and-round pattern, applys here a little bit but is better then insane in my personnal opinion 'o'/
- AR 7? because of the low spacing 'o'; i don't think people would like that map has small spacing but high AR (yes 8 is not that high but as hard and this spacing I guess so o.o/) no, i'm feel something is not right/fit if i'm put this with lower AR orz

(timing point)
same as insane, is that being used O.O?
I think you mapped this map on easy->normal->hard->insane order, and I see x0.8 usage on normal but it's not used on Hard and insane, thus, this needs to be removed
[/color](btw i modded this map on insane->Hard->normal->easy order, so yeah)

(placements)
01:09:519 (1) - I think parts after this, can be done little more creative 'o'/ I think it's little bit waste of good kiai part just following the previous pattern~ still looking for a better pattern for this in 1 week already, still not found some inspiration yet


[Insane]
- I think you can use little higher distance snap because the map is. hardcore, but the map's flow is bit too slow for me.
with 161bpm and AR9, this map flows too slow IMO, or at least I would like to suggest to make this AR8 'o'/
- The map doesn't really have much authentic issues and I know that means this is rankable, but if you fast-forward the map (just press the right arrow key to do to) this map goes.. round-and-round-and-round.
Idk how should i explain due to my poor English (;o;) but let's this this image ( http://puu.sh/xdaF , yes my drawing skill sucks lol) , your map preety much feels like containing only black and blue arrows, and I think you need some patterns at red arrow section, like by putting screen-crossing(vertical way) jump, or some stream goes vertical way, etc.
Since this is matter or style, you can just ignore it but I think the map would be much greater with it o.o/ i'm made it like this from the beginning, i think if i adding a pattern with the red arrows section type while most of the sliderstyle that i'm putting here are curved, it will not match much for each other, also since i'm not really like straight slider, it's kinda unattractive imo

So i just make it on the blue black arrow section^^

and for AR9, it's simply because the song itself give the strong and fee and makes people wanna do hardcore, so i think put AR9 for this kind of song are better (yeah, i'm never consider putting lower or higher AR because the mapset is hard, but because the song type are match forthat

please take this as a consideration


(Timing Point)
[color = red]01:06:332 (t) - is this section needed or has any purpose? if so, my bad but if not, this is unrankable, so you need to remove this[/color] my own error o.o/
00:54:517 (1) - from this point, wouldn't it be much cooler if we have slight speed-up section, since the map is going preety higher-and-higher? i dunno for this, i'm used to do the same thing before but still not got the best portrait that i want to see in this diff, maybe i'll try something later


(placements)
00:30:673 (1) - I think this can be placed somewhere else because of the overlap on previous 2 'o'/ (the hitburst and confuse thingy) fixd



Good luck on the map ~^^

Katty Pie wrote:

hi from our mod Q ^.^

INSANE

AR 8 >.<

HARD

AR 7 >.<

but i saw they're was less amusing with the lesser approach rate, because just hearing the song will makes you(the player) see/do the crazy things (you will realized that while play), so i'm not changing this '-'

NORMAL

00:29:183(4) - make so http://puu.sh/xi61 look better


EASY

00:36:261(3,1) - correct spacing it very confused for beginners

fix'd everything except AR^^


ha ha it's all ^.^ good luck with rank ~~

Genkishi wrote:

Sorry i can't mod this because i really don't like your song

miss_master wrote:

lol Bikk0?