wmfchris wrote:

well I failed to identify the difficulty on the diff name but it's fine
Also, if it's remixed from SMRPG song, tag the song used to remix Alright, fixed.

[Un-tan]
00:18:876 (5) - feel like removing clap sounds better Looks cool, added.
00:27:611 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - the recent one is ok but does not look very good... just a suggestion http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/301604 (ooops the blue slider disappear) Looks way better now, fixed.
00:32:512 (1,2) - just can't understand the point to place like this, the man sound starts 1/2 after so I prefer 1/4 slider + (2) reduced 1 tick I wasn't sure, but after I heard it some times it is better than before. fixed.
00:34:216 (1,2,3) - spacing which can be fixed within grids Fixed.
00:36:773 (1) - add one more tick I think it will be too hard when at 00:37:519 is no break.

[Clap-tan]
OD-1 Fixed.

[Fish]
fine

good luck :3

wmfchris wrote:

well I failed to identify the difficulty on the diff name but it's fine
Also, if it's remixed from SMRPG song, tag the song used to remix

[Kyshiro-tan]
00:02:682 (4) - If possible, reflect (3,4) horizontally because it may touch the ranking frame :/ Moved 1-4 a bit to the right, fixed.
00:11:844 (9) - make it down 1 grid so that (6,7,8) looks "curved" around (9) Done
00:12:483 (5) - imo the whistle on the slidertrack goes odd with the music, even whistle at the end sounds better Removed
00:16:958 (4) - clapAdded
00:19:302 (2) - maybe it's better to take away the clap to make contrast against (3,4,5) since it's quite quiet in (1,2). Added a clap on 00:19:728 (3) - and removed the one on (4), this makes it sound better

DJPop wrote:

Rechecked


~Fish-tan~
00:47:853 (1) - add clap at the end IMO it sounds bad

~Clap-tan~
00:25:268 (2) - add clap Added.
00:25:694 (3) - add whistle at start It feels too loud there with Whistle.
00:44:870 (2,4) - add claps Added.
00:47:001 (5) - add clap at the end Doesn't fit IMO
00:47:853 (1,2,3) - ^ Added.

~Un-tan~
00:04:387 (6) - add clap at middle Added.
00:07:796 (6) - ^ Added.
00:09:074 (2) - add clap Added.
00:14:614 (5) - O_O" ... and what are those bookmarks? \:D/ *trollface*
00:34:216 (1) - change finish to clap Added.
00:43:591 (7) - remove all hitsounds I left Finish there for Taiko Mode.

since Kyshiro got Internet Problems, I talked to him and changed the things for him:

~Kyshiro-tan~
00:22:391 - HP drains too fast, I suggest add a spinner here
00:23:989 (1) got removed and Spinner started from 00:22:391. fixed.
00:26:440 (7,8) - do the same as 00:33:258 (6,7) Fixed.
00:53:819 (3) - remove whistle at the end Fixed.

1. Timing is off. The map slowly gets later and later as the song progresses. You should re-time the map or find someone to help you with it.
2. Tags are inconsistent. Fish-tan has different tags.
3. Consider adding 'super' and 'mario' to the tags.

1. 00:37:626 (1,2) - These sliders are a little ugly... you should try to make them more symmetrical.

1. The spacing in this difficulty is cramped causing objects to be quite difficult to read. I suggest increasing the spacing to something like 1.0x so the objects aren't overlapped so much.
2. 00:51:262 (1) - Spinner missing new combo.

Charles445 wrote:

I think this is worth popping over

General

1. Timing is off. The map slowly gets later and later as the song progresses. You should re-time the map or find someone to help you with it. I'll look about it.
2. Tags are inconsistent. Fish-tan has different tags. Fixed.
3. Consider adding 'super' and 'mario' to the tags. Fixed.

Fish-tan

1. 00:37:626 (1,2) - These sliders are a little ugly... you should try to make them more symmetrical. Fixed.

Un-tan

1. The spacing in this difficulty is cramped causing objects to be quite difficult to read. I suggest increasing the spacing to something like 1.0x so the objects aren't overlapped so much. Fixed.
2. 00:51:262 (1) - Spinner missing new combo. Fixed.

Popping over timing and tags.

1. 00:03:001 (5) - d
2. 00:07:793 (4,5,1,2,1) - ddkdk
3. 00:23:342 (1,2,1) - kdk
4. 00:33:352 - add k?

Gabe wrote:

This mod is only for the Taiko. >w<
It may be short, but uh. ._.'
NYAAAAAAAAAAAaaaa.

1. 00:07:793 - ka
2. 00:34:630 - ka

I don't find both reaaally cool enough, but thanks anyway for the mod.

BrokenArrow wrote:

~Taiko mod by request~

1. 00:03:001 (5) - d The tone of the seven bleeps dnes not change, so no.
2. 00:07:793 (4,5,1,2,1) - ddkdk Chose this one.
3. 00:23:342 (1,2,1) - kdk I want to keep the 1/1 d pattern for long enough (and make the map easy enough, so I'll consider also lowering OD lol.)
4. 00:33:352 - add k? Ok.

That's all I could find.. weird song Did I say that I could map every song ?

Sync wrote:

[General]
-- Even though the difficulties don't all start at the same time, make audioLeadIn the same length on each difficulty. I wasn't sure because I thought it would be ok to remove Lead-In Time from all except of Kyshiro-tan/Gettaiko-tan, fixed to 2000. Again. orz

[Un-tan]
00:45:919 (5) - What exactly is this following? (nothing!) Remove it and map to the beat instead. I came up with something like this: add a hit circle at where the slider originally started and add a 1/2-beat slider starting at 00:46:132 (6). That should work fine. ughuu~, sounds way better, fixed.

[Clap-tan]
00:18:443 (4) - I see no reason to stop mapping after this slider. Keep it going or else the transition to the next pattern is awkward. Added at 00:19:295 a Circle.

[Fish-tan]
00:23:977 (1) - Unsnapped slider Forgot to fix after changing BPM, fixed.
00:23:977 (1) - Unsnapped slider ^
00:25:682 (2) - Unsnapped circle ^
00:26:534 (3) - Unsnapped circle ^
00:27:386 (1) - Unsnapped slider ^
00:27:386 (1) - Unsnapped slider ^
00:49:540 (2) - Unstack this slider. A new player is bound to hit it too early. I think it's not a big problem. May happens that a player hit it too early, but it is different from person to person.

Jacob wrote:

here to stalk Sync's mod

• Un-tan and Kyshiro-tan use slider tick 2, so why don't you use it in the easiest difficulties too ? Tick 2 sounds great and it is needed for consistency.

1. 00:29:092 (1) - Even if the reverse arrow isn't totally hidden, it surprised me, so please make this arrow more visible ! (and stack it correctly with (5) too please).
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:32:713 (2) - ^
3. 00:43:576 (7) - Don't silence it please, that's awkward to play.. use at leat 30% (without hitsounds the player doesn't have any feed back to know if he hit the note properly or not).

1. 00:43:682 (1) - This spinner is short, too short, not even 800ms. I know the max score with auto is 2000 and that's rankable, but this is stille too short for my taste, those kind of ninja spinners arevery surprising and most player will do a 100. Thus consider removing this psinner and making something else.

Kurai wrote:

Rechecking time ~ !

[General]

• Un-tan and Kyshiro-tan use slider tick 2, so why don't you use it in the easiest difficulties too ? Tick 2 sounds great and it is needed for consistency. Fixed, sounds quite ok.

[Un-tan]

1. 00:29:092 (1) - Even if the reverse arrow isn't totally hidden, it surprised me, so please make this arrow more visible ! (and stack it correctly with (5) too please). Alright, fixed.
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:32:713 (2) - ^ Should be fine now, fixed.
3. 00:43:576 (7) - Don't silence it please, that's awkward to play.. use at leat 30% (without hitsounds the player doesn't have any feed back to know if he hit the note properly or not). I added at the slider Whistle because it fits with the Ring Sound from the song. And fixed to 30% Volume.

Sync wrote:

[General]

[Kyshiro-tan]
00:08:432 (5) - Add a hit circle here to follow that one brassy (not sure what it is ;_;) instrument There already is a circle here? o-o
00:17:165 (6) - It's really confusing when the rest of the stream uses the normal sampleset and this one note uses soft... I'd change it Fixed
00:26:430 (7) - This slider should start 1-tick later. It sounds and plays awkward as hell. When you move it forward, replace it's start point with a hit circle and make sure it still lands on the red-tick. What the hell, I did not place it like this, fixed o-o
00:33:246 (6) - ^ Fixed
00:41:659 (1) - This combo spam is pretty unnecessary... I'd remove it (take this as a light suggestion, though). You're right, fixed
00:42:511 (1) - ^Fixed
00:43:682 (1) - This slider reaches 2k bonus when auto plays it, but that's besides the point -- it comes out nowhere. It's more of a trap than it is fun and additive. Remove it. Also, it lands on a beat where the user should hit.Fixed

Kurai wrote:

Rechecking time ~ !
[Kyshiro-tan]

1. 00:43:682 (1) - This spinner is short, too short, not even 800ms. I know the max score with auto is 2000 and that's rankable, but this is stille too short for my taste, those kind of ninja spinners arevery surprising and most player will do a 100. Thus consider removing this psinner and making something else.Fixeddddd

Garven wrote:

Sorry, have to unrank this.

[Un-tan]
00:14:609 (5) - We don't allow these anymore, sorry.

I'll do a full mod later, but that's the main concern right now.