Byakugan249 wrote:

[Kenezz's Easy]
00:20:813 (1) - this slider looks like it's just put there. i suggest adding another point in the middle of the slider for a better flow to the next note. naah not is neccesary
00:37:834 (1) - replace the whistle for a finish? i think it fits with the vocals IMO. The finish in the map are only in the parts when the track mark this, like the begin of the chorus, and here sound a bit loud with finish.
00:41:239 (1,2) - i think you're going to make beginners nervous because (1) is touching the hp bar and (2) is touching the score. move it down a bit so that it doesn't happen. hmm imo if a circle/slider touch the hp not is a problem (inclusively in easy diffs) furthermore here is only a bit...
00:54:005 (1) - maybe end this at the blue line and add a repeat to follow vocals accurately? I prefer make the diff more easy without notes 1/2~1/2.
01:01:664 (1) - remove the NC because the vocals are still going. Vicho alreay fix this...
01:04:217 (5) - same as 00:41:239. i suggest that you change the direction of the slider so that it doesn't touch the hp bar. Same as 00:41:239.
01:09:323 (3) - same as 00:41:239 for (2). ^
01:12:727 (2) - i think beginners might let go after the second repeat, so get rid of the repeats and add another 1/1 slider to make it easier for beginners and to give a nice flow to the next note. hmmm I will bear this in mind.
01:35:706 (2) - *nazi* move this at the middle of the slider to form a blanket. Nope, this slider is symmetric with the before and I want symmetry.
i suggest that you avoid putting the notes on the score and the hp bar on easy diffs because beginners might either mess up or become nervous which leads them to messing up. Really not is a problem haha :3

lovhin456 wrote:

Gu's Normal:
- 00:01:664 >> Since the beats are kind of separated it would be good to put new combos on 00:01:664 and 00:03:366
- 00:26:239 >> New combo ?
- 01:08:047 >> New combo ?
- 01:20:387 >> New combo then remove new combo on 01:21:876 and add new combo on 01:22:089
- 01:43:366 >> New combo then remove new combo on the next slider

SapphireGhost wrote:

Modding Vicho's version...

[General]
- Timing needs to be consistent with Rika's version, I think this one is more likely to be correct because it's a whole number, but I don't know.

[Insane]
- Changing 1/8 stacks to kicksliders discussed over IRC.
00:54:749 (1) - It makes more sense for this spinner to start on a white tick, that's where the next vocal is.

[Hard]
01:34:217 (1) - This note needs a new combo.

[Gu's Normal]
01:31:983 (1) - It makes more sense for this spinner to start on a white tick, that's where the next vocal is.

[Kenezz's Easy]
01:04:217 (5) - This goes too far into the HP bar, try to avoid this somehow.

I hope this can end well for both mappers.

Verdisphena wrote:

Tan rapido conseguiste una bubble o.o

Philippines wrote:

2 Unranks by Odaril. Pretty cool eh.

Philippines wrote:

That was a compliment for you actually cause you are aware of these errors. >.>
Try to understand it first before you start off with a "hey i'm a BAT so learn to respect."
I ain't gonna give a shit if that's what you think I was trying to say.

1. Add "climbb" to the tags of all difficulties for the mapper, and "zombie" because not everyone might think of the question mark.
2. I find tick rate 2 to fit much better the song, and it will get rid of unsymmetry on symmetric sliders.
3. Both offsets need +10ms. Remember to resnap all notes and kiai sections.

• Fine. All those symmetric sliders ruined by tick rate 1 =(

1. 00:01:664 (1,1,3) - I find these to sound pretty bad. Also for a Normal, these might be pretty confusing, as they're really short, and make the rhythm quite complex. Replace them with circles ?
2. 00:25:068 (4,1,2) - This should be a 3/4 rhythm. And it'd be better to make it a repeat slider instead of adding a repeat to (4), which breaks the comboing (the new combo should be on the white tick where it ends) and makes the rhythm hard to play.
3. 00:41:239 (1,2) - and 00:48:047 (1,2) - Silencing beats like this is unrankable. The song DOES have sounds there, so there's no point in silencing them.
4. 01:00:823 (1,2,3,4) - Keep the spacing consistent in this pattern. The raise of spacing makes the timing very unclear.
5. 01:34:855 (2) - I really hate that kind of slider in Easy or Normal difficulties. They're confusing to play for new players and feel completely out of place in the rhythms used in the diff.

• This is too hard for a Hard... Ah well.

1. 00:16:770 (4,5,6,7) - Why such complicated rhythm here ? The song clearly goes for a simpler 1/2 rhythm... This doesn't really belong to a Hard diff. =|
2. 00:22:090 (1,2) - Why a jump here ? I don't get it. Is that a mistake ?
3. 00:24:430 (2,3,4,5) - Same as above.
4. 01:01:025 (1,2) - This comes too soon after the spinner. Shorten the spinner ? Add a note where it ended if necessary.
5. 01:03:153 (3,4) - Pretty confusing, knowing that all of these patterns before were 1/4s, when this one's 1/2. And because it's hidden under a previous hitburst, it's pretty hard to read.
6. 01:16:344 (1,2,3) - This feels like it's lacking something. Make (2) a 1/2 slider to keep the same rhythm as before ?
7. 01:26:344 (2,3,4,5) - This might be pretty confusing too. Make (2,3,4) a repeat slider instead ? It will be more playable, but you'll be able to keep your current rhythm.
8. 01:28:047 (1) - This is hidden under the hitburst from 01:26:664 (5) - . Also I don't think this stream is a good idea for a Hard. Replace it with a spinner ?
9. 01:31:451 (1) - Shorten this spinner by 1/1. It will fit the song better, and 01:34:217 (1) - will be much easier to catch.

1. 00:06:132 (5,6) - Why a jump here ? I assume it's a mistake ?

• is fine now o/

Natteke wrote:

Lmao there are maps that have been pending for months and bubbled for weeks yet this chit keeps happening.

fuark this community

SPOILER

1. 00:27:100 (6) - Delete it and add a circle in 00:27:312
2. Add circles in 00:31:142 and 00:31:568 or delete 00:31:355
3. 01:26:567 (4) - Delete it and add a circle in 01:26:567 and a slider from 01:26:674 to 01:26:993