kriers wrote:

Wishy22 wrote:

Yeah, ignore retarded votes, some stuff is clear and the top 4/5 can't really be topic of debate, the best 4/5 players are obvious and all you may do is change the other of the 2~5 ones.

No votes are retarded so long as they're serious. No matter how silly they sound from your own subjective point of view.

kriers wrote:

Salvage wrote:

It's not a bout that kriers, we're not trying to show we apply democracy here and that we're not some badass guys who want to manipulate the users votes, that doesn't even matter here .. we are voting to make an interesting top 20 video of osu players, top 1-5 it's clearly that way and it can't change, not because we're some anti democratic fascists or anything like that, but because the idea is the video to look as it should look, and i think u can't deny the 1-5 places are those.

Because there doesn't seem to be a good way to measure skill except for opinions, voting is inevitable.
With voting, you get all the negatives effects of it as well and some places might get swapped.

It's impossible to make the list look entirely right for everyone.

I can't deny the 1-5 places, but if someone does, I can't deny their opinion either

CXu wrote:

So if I voted Rucker as #1 in 2011, WW as #2, Silvia as #3 and Cookiezi as #4, you would just "lolfuckyou" and disregard my voting just because "hey it's obvious Cookiezi is #1 huehue"?

That's silly.

lesslunatic wrote:

CXu wrote:

So if I voted Rucker as #1 in 2011, WW as #2, Silvia as #3 and Cookiezi as #4, you would just "lolfuckyou" and disregard my voting just because "hey it's obvious Cookiezi is #1 huehue"?

That's silly.

Stop with this, I am getting sick of you. I\we didn't decide to ignore any vote, I was just saying as someone (rightly wrote), do you think will be right see a player that did not play in the last year into the top 20? C'mon we all know that ShaggoN is a pro, okay, but he did not play the last year; well I am not going to ignore any vote, the discussion ends here, let people vote, learn to read and stop discussing.

kriers wrote:

you should stop disrespecting votes from here on.

lesslunatic wrote:

kriers wrote:

you should stop disrespecting votes from here on.

did I ? D:

kriers wrote:

Any vote for Shaggon should count.

lesslunatic wrote:

I didn't decide to ignore any vote

XylemBeer wrote:

1. Cookiezi - No explenations needed
2. Mesita - Flashlight God <3 (wtf, Flashlight + Hidden on Emotional Skyscraper ~ World's End, beating Cookiezi)
3. Silvia - Mouse user, pro on Hidden
4. Reisen Udongein - He's damn good at Hidden+Hardrock.
5. Renard - \:D/
6. val0108 - I see him getting 1st-3rd on tag4 maps. He's just pro.
7. KRZY - Pretty good. I love his jumps and DT on insane maps.
8. Rucker - HD + HR, but slightly inactive. I rarely see him play now.
9. White Wolf - I don't really know something about this guy, but he's number 1, so...yeah.
10. CXu

XylemBeer wrote:

9. White Wolf - I don't really know something about this guy, but he's number 1, so...yeah.

Blue Dragon wrote:

XylemBeer wrote:

9. White Wolf - I don't really know something about this guy, but he's number 1, so...yeah.

Why are we letting these kind of people vote?

tolliken wrote:

Because it's democracy! \:D/

Oh, wait, looks like i got an idea. Maybe we should'nt let to vote peoples who registered in 2011. ( or at least second half of 2011)
So, newfags, like me, wont be able to vote. And it is rightly, because this peoples can't see the whole picture of the last year.

Salvage wrote:

God .. there is no way to make you people realize it is not about democracy but making a good video about this?



I'm really leaning towards top player voting ONLY on private messages and lesslunatic making the votecount himself, cause this is just retarded, as wishy said before this should be called Most Popular playters of 2011 if we're gonna do it this way cause it doesn't even make sense ..

Salvage wrote:

kriers you're talking like if it matters when people get offended if they're votes doesn't count, IT DOESN'T .. the idea is to make a fair video of the really top 20 players of osu, if i come here and say Renard, and every guy who doesn't know the game votes Renard he get's 1# and that's it? you really expect the video to be done that way just cause awwwwwwwwww we don't want to offend them let's make them happy putting a fake top 20 players video instead.

lesslunatic wrote:

After several requests I decided to work on top 20 players (osu! standard) of the year' again.
I hoped that someone could make it this year as I am pretty lazy, but didn't happened :\



(Read this before to vote) :

~ First of all I am asking you guys to be objective, don't vote your friends or just your favorite players, but vote who for you were actually 10 best players in osu! in the year 2011, put a comment about players you choosed if you wish, will be really apreciated.

~ as I wrote people will be able to pick only 10 players, after that the poll will be closed I'll count total votes and I'll make the list (in order of votes gained)

~ Be sure to write rightly the name of the player or the vote for this player will be not accepted.

~ The last year everyone was able to vote, this year no. only players who joined osu before 30 September 2011 will be able to vote, I mean, if you registered only some days ago, how should you able to know about 2011' players; i'll ignore people voting that were register after this date.

~ The poll will be closed after 15-20 pages of voting, so I am asking you guys to be inherent to the discussion avoid random spam posts. this is not a topic for discuss about who are actually the best players, so post here only for make your choice



Example :

Hello I am an user who wants to vote :

• Player 1
• Player 2
• Player 3
• Player 4
• Player 5
• Player 6
• Player 7
• Player 8
• Player 9
• Player 10

SPOILER

Also informing that Top20 osu! players of 2010 is online again.

~ ♥

jesse1412 wrote:

#1 - Cookiezi
#2 - Silvia
#3 - Rucker
#4 - Whitewolf
#5 - Shaggon
#6 - Tom94
#7 - Sprosive
#8 - torein 13rd
#9 - TTTL
#10 - Failboat