forum

Wotamin - Cat Food

posted
Total Posts
43
show more
Mismagius
~General~
  1. Folder seems to be okay.


[Normal]


  • Maybe OD+1? Felt a little better with it...
  1. 00:32:707 (1) - add finish?
  2. 00:53:397 (2) - remove finish? o.o this isn't consistent with 00:47:880 (2). Either remove the finish there or add one at 00:47:880 >:
  3. 00:54:776 (1,2,3,4) - Not sure if this is fine for the easiest diff of the mapset... D: I'd remove (2) and (4), but meh. Your choice.
  4. 00:59:604 (4) - Add a whistle at the start / finish at the end?
  5. 01:07:363 (4,5) - Same as 00:54:776 >:
  6. 01:13:397 (4) - Add whistle at end?
  7. 01:18:397 (5,6) - Check 00:54:776 D:
  8. 01:49:949 (1) - add finish like 00:32:707?
  9. 02:12:018 (1,2,3,4) - Same as 00:54:776 >:
  10. 02:27:880 (4) - whistle? fits with the vocals D:
  11. 03:19:604 (3) - Remove clap from the end? IMHO it doesn't fit right now.
  12. 03:22:018 (2,3) - As I stated earlier, 1/2s on the easiest diff >:
  • Overall Rating: 9.0/10 ~ Pretty fun difficulty, didn't spot anything really bad. Just didn't like the copypaste abuse at some parts but meh, the map itself is very good~
[S o r d a'sHard]


  • Is this really a Hard? o-o AR -1, please.
  1. 00:07:535 (6) - Remove whistle? Sounds a bit better without it.
  2. 00:08:742 (4) - Whistle at the end? Fits with the song D:
  3. 00:12:363 (5) - Remove finish and add clap? It prevents finish abuse and sounds pretty nice.
  4. 00:29:259 (8) - whistle at the start?
  5. 00:34:431 (2) - Add whistle? Fits with vocals.
  6. 00:34:776 (4) - Add finish? Feels a bit empty right now.
  7. 00:36:673 (5) - Whistle at the start?
  8. 00:39:431 (6) - ^
  9. 00:41:328 (2,3,4) - Pretty confusing spacing. Maybe space (4) away?
  10. 00:51:328 (8) - whistle at start?
  11. 00:53:397 (3) - Finish at end? You can hear it in the song.
  12. 01:12:879 (4) - New combo, maybe? It makes the pattern a bit less confusing.
  13. 01:19:949 (1) - May I ask why the new combo? It's inconsistent with the rest of the diff >:
  14. 01:59:949 (4) - Whistle at the start? It feels so empty >.<
  15. 02:13:225 (3) - Finish at the start? You can hear it in the song! >:
  16. 02:21:673 (4) - Whistle? Feels so empty D:
  17. 02:29:087 (2) - ^ at the start?
  18. 02:58:914 (1) - Add finish? Fits with the song D:
  19. 03:04:431 (x) - Add a note here with clap?
  20. 03:07:190 (x) - ^ with finish?
  21. 03:28:914 (4) - clap at the start?
  • Overall Rating: 8.4/10 ~ The lack of hitsounds makes this diff feel a bit empty... And also, some inconsistencies about the New Combos, but not really much. Just PLEASE fix the AR, it's way too high for a Hard diff right now. >:
[Insane]


  • Isn't HP Drain a bit too high? ;-; Not a real problem anyway.
  1. 00:27:535 (3,5) - Hitburst is covering (5) D: You can barely see it, like showed here.
  2. 00:28:397 (1,2) - Maybe space (2) from (1) like you did for (2,3,4)?
  3. 00:29:259 (4) - Add whistle here? Sounds good with the vocals.
  4. 00:31:673 (2) - Add clap? You'll understand why :3
  5. 00:47:880 (8) - New combo? There is a big white tick there >:
  6. 01:46:500 (4) - Add whistle? Same reason as 00:29:259 (4).
  7. 02:05:121 (8) - New combo? Same as 00:47:880 (8).
  8. 02:13:225 (1) - Remove whistle from end? (2)'s whistle already sounds good enough alone.
  9. 02:30:638 (4) - Whistle at the end? IMHO sounds better.
  10. 02:32:190 (2,4) - As stated before, hitburst covers (4) D:
  • Overall Rating: 9.5/10 ~ Extremely nice map, just some things about hitbursts, but nothing really bad. Enjoyed it a lot, nice job!~
Sorry for taking so much to mod. D:
Topic Starter
rEdo

Blue Dragon wrote:

[Normal]


  • Maybe OD+1? Felt a little better with it... that's a compensation for 1/2s you're gonna complain about, with that I'm making them easier
  1. 00:32:707 (1) - add finish? sure
  2. 00:53:397 (2) - remove finish? o.o this isn't consistent with 00:47:880 (2). Either remove the finish there or add one at 00:47:880 >: I know it's inconsistent, but there's a little increase in her tone of voice, so it fits~
  3. 00:54:776 (1,2,3,4) - Not sure if this is fine for the easiest diff of the mapset... D: I'd remove (2) and (4), but meh. Your choice. the beginners need some challenge, too! ; )
  4. 00:59:604 (4) - Add a whistle at the start / finish at the end? nope
  5. 01:07:363 (4,5) - Same as 00:54:776 >: =w=
  6. 01:13:397 (4) - Add whistle at end? yep
  7. 01:18:397 (5,6) - Check 00:54:776 D: =w= x2
  8. 01:49:949 (1) - add finish like 00:32:707? k
  9. 02:12:018 (1,2,3,4) - Same as 00:54:776 >: =w= x3
  10. 02:27:880 (4) - whistle? fits with the vocals D: it's alright like how it is right now
  11. 03:19:604 (3) - Remove clap from the end? IMHO it doesn't fit right now. it's fine
  12. 03:22:018 (2,3) - As I stated earlier, 1/2s on the easiest diff >: =w= x4
  • Overall Rating: 9.0/10 ~ Pretty fun difficulty, didn't spot anything really bad. Just didn't like the copypaste abuse at some parts but meh, the map itself is very good~ please don't use copypaste while mapping an over three-minutes Normal, you'll see ;>
[S o r d a's Hard]

  • PUR PU PUR PU PUR! leaving that to Sorda's opinion
[Insane]


  • Isn't HP Drain a bit too high? ;-; Not a real problem anyway. that's a rather easy Insane after all, so at least this should give it some extra difficulty ; )
  1. 00:27:535 (3,5) - Hitburst is covering (5) D: You can barely see it, like showed here. that's alright and made on purpose. actually, you can clearly see the approach circle even before the hitburst. also, a little funfact: you didn't pointed out the same issue on 00:37:535 (4) ; )
  2. 00:28:397 (1,2) - Maybe space (2) from (1) like you did for (2,3,4)? nuu
  3. 00:29:259 (4) - Add whistle here? Sounds good with the vocals. it's breaking the pattern I'm going with, nope
  4. 00:31:673 (2) - Add clap? You'll understand why :3 I get it, but still, I prefer my whistle ; )
  5. 00:47:880 (8) - New combo? There is a big white tick there >: you're right, added
  6. 01:46:500 (4) - Add whistle? Same reason as 00:29:259 (4). ~
  7. 02:05:121 (8) - New combo? Same as 00:47:880 (8). sure
  8. 02:13:225 (1) - Remove whistle from end? (2)'s whistle already sounds good enough alone. that's right, did the same with 00:55:983 (1)
  9. 02:30:638 (4) - Whistle at the end? IMHO sounds better. not at all : )
  10. 02:32:190 (2,4) - As stated before, hitburst covers (4) D: ~
  • Overall Rating: 9.5/10 ~ Extremely nice map, just some things about hitbursts, but nothing really bad. Enjoyed it a lot, nice job!~ huhu, thanks : )
Sorry for taking so much to mod. D: no probs, thanks a bunch! ^^
a note to Sorda: I increased the hitsounds' volume a bit, so please update your difficulty and take a look at them, thanks~
S o r d a

Blue Dragon wrote:

[S o r d a'sHard]


  • Is this really a Hard? o-o AR -1, please.
  1. 00:07:535 (6) - Remove whistle? Sounds a bit better without it.
  2. 00:08:742 (4) - Whistle at the end? Fits with the song D:
  3. 00:12:363 (5) - Remove finish and add clap? It prevents finish abuse and sounds pretty nice.
  4. 00:29:259 (8) - whistle at the start?
  5. 00:34:431 (2) - Add whistle? Fits with vocals.
  6. 00:34:776 (4) - Add finish? Feels a bit empty right now.
  7. 00:36:673 (5) - Whistle at the start?
  8. 00:39:431 (6) - ^
  9. 00:41:328 (2,3,4) - Pretty confusing spacing. Maybe space (4) away?
  10. 00:51:328 (8) - whistle at start?
  11. 00:53:397 (3) - Finish at end? You can hear it in the song.
  12. 01:12:879 (4) - New combo, maybe? It makes the pattern a bit less confusing.
  13. 01:19:949 (1) - May I ask why the new combo? It's inconsistent with the rest of the diff >:Hmm,this note bit away I think need newcombo no change now~
  14. 01:59:949 (4) - Whistle at the start? It feels so empty >.<
  15. 02:13:225 (3) - Finish at the start? You can hear it in the song! >:
  16. 02:21:673 (4) - Whistle? Feels so empty D:
  17. 02:29:087 (2) - ^ at the start?
  18. 02:58:914 (1) - Add finish? Fits with the song D:
  19. 03:04:431 (x) - Add a note here with clap?
  20. 03:07:190 (x) - ^ with finish?
  21. 03:28:914 (4) - clap at the start?
  • Overall Rating: 8.4/10 ~ The lack of hitsounds makes this diff feel a bit empty... And also, some inconsistencies about the New Combos, but not really much. Just PLEASE fix the AR, it's way too high for a Hard diff right now. >:
other fixed thanks for mod Blue Dragon

@rEdo okey,I see~

Download: Wotamin - Cat Food (rEdo) [S o r d a's Hard].osu
fartownik
S o r d a
yey bubble!
lolcubes
Yo!

[General]
  1. Some diffs (Insane and Normal) have countdownoffset when countdown isn't used at all. Not a big deal, but could be removed to make your settings look cleaner.
[Insane]
  1. 00:44:259 (2) - Swap the clap so it's on start instead of end? Sounds better and follows the music better. (if you do this, add a clap to the start of 00:44:776 (3) too, cause that would "complete the set")
  2. 01:59:259 (3) - Missed a clap?
  3. 02:01:500 (2,3) - Same thing as 00:44:259 in the mod.
[kanpakyin's Taiko Oni]
  1. 01:22:276 (408,409) - I found these very strange. Maybe remove 408 and put a finish on 409 or just leave it alone? That sounds better to me. Up to you though.
[Normal]
  1. 01:11:328 (1,2,3) - Maybe you can make this look better? (triangle lololnazi) You could move 01:10:638 (4,1,2) a bit further towards the top to create some space to do so.
  2. 02:27:018 (3,4,5,1) - Similar case to the above.
  3. 03:17:535 (3) - I think you should place that clap at the end instead of the start, just like you did in a section before. Sounds much better.
Check these out and call me back and I'll rank.
Topic Starter
rEdo

lolcubes wrote:

Yo! Yo!

[General]
  1. Some diffs (Insane and Normal) have countdownoffset when countdown isn't used at all. Not a big deal, but could be removed to make your settings look cleaner. I'm not sure what did you mean, but I guess it's fixed now. :D
[Insane]
  1. 00:44:259 (2) - Swap the clap so it's on start instead of end? Sounds better and follows the music better. (if you do this, add a clap to the start of 00:44:776 (3) too, cause that would "complete the set") not really, I completely prefer it like it is right now. those claps are giving some nice undertone to the whole beatmap, even while not really fitting the song.
  2. 01:59:259 (3) - Missed a clap? yeah
[kanpakyin's Taiko Oni]
  1. 01:22:276 (408,409) - I found these very strange. Maybe remove 408 and put a finish on 409 or just leave it alone? That sounds better to me. Up to you though. kinda edited, hope kpy won't kill me for it :D
[Normal]
  1. 01:11:328 (1,2,3) - Maybe you can make this look better? (triangle lololnazi) You could move 01:10:638 (4,1,2) a bit further towards the top to create some space to do so. sure, hope it plays alright now :3
  2. 02:27:018 (3,4,5,1) - Similar case to the above. yeah, it was a lot easier to fix though
  3. 03:17:535 (3) - I think you should place that clap at the end instead of the start, just like you did in a section before. Sounds much better. mhm
Check these out and call me back and I'll rank. LOLCUBEESSSSSSSSSS~
so, thanks for modding. o.o
kanpakyin
I'll kill you T_T

Anyway,fix my diff name and some notes arrangement.


Download: Wotamin - Cat Food (rEdo) [Kanpakyin's Taiko Oni].osu
lolcubes
Alright then.

Ranked!
Congratulations.
Topic Starter
rEdo
thanks a lot, guys (:
Sander-Don
Grats!
ryuu
congrats,rEdo *3*
mapset and song veryveryvery cute >wwwwwwww<
ertyukjh010
Good map :)
Fuuko
Congrats. Although I'm sad because you didn't use the awesome original background for this, it's still a good map!
S o r d a
finally gratz!!!
Cyril Scarlet
Cat Food :P ~
phonic
Gratz~ :)
hoLysoup
congrats :D
eikkaleyd
lol Oh my AVA!
Coffeezi
nice song and map~
=w=
kikoredog
grats on ranked + thx for making this map!
Please sign in to reply.

New reply