Lissette wrote:

hi~

Insane
Add spinner to vary scores? Not sure if someone can 100% this tho >.> N....Orz
http://puu.sh/aZkm xD

D:

Another
00:07:497 - add note? Feels like you missed one here (I always miss here)
Whistle are too loud, but that's my personal taste

maybe farto dont want to change it o.o;...

Hard
Add spinner to vary scores? N....

Normal
00:04:069 (2,3,4,5) - replace them with sliders, 1/4 doubles are hard for normal diffs (same to other like this) Y
00:49:712 (1) - remove new combo, so is the same as 00:44:569 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Y
01:20:997 (8) - new combo to make the combo shorter Y
Add a breaktime for normals Q_Q?

Easy
01:48:426 (4) - new combo, or maybe here 01:49:712 (5) - to shorten the combo Y
Add a breaktime here too Q_Q?

S.Nagi's Taiko
Finish kiai on top of the note Y

AngelHoney wrote:

XD thx again lis~ all done

(btw , why my baka AImod didt find it Orz...)

1. 01:06:855 (9) - I would suggest a new combo here because the music changes a little. It makes the pattern more pretty too. (you did this in hard btw)
2. 01:09:855 (2) - I would also like to see a new combo here because it starts the next section, it's a different instrument than this combo was following before and in general it looks better.
3. 01:51:426 - Unclosed kiai time is unrankable. Use a timing section after this one to cancel the kiai.

1. 00:51:426 (1) - Finish?
2. 01:12:855 (2) - This slider is really confusing, it doesn't follow the music at all. You should definitely change this. I suggest a change like this. This follows the music perfectly and also flows better if you position it similarly how I did. Used distance spacing of 2.0.
   The slider after it doesn't really follow the music that much better either, but I don't find it confusing so I am ok with it, but I do suggest to change it to something like this because this follows the music much much better.
3. 01:38:997 (5,6) - You should definitely increase this spacing.
4. 01:53:140 (1) - Maybe use 5% volume at the end of the spinner? Since the music disappears, I think it sounds better that way (or it doesn't sound at all, if you know what I mean).

1. Any reason it uses 1.2 SV? For this bpm, you should be using 1.4 SV.
2. Your speed changes (1 -> 0.75 -> 1.5) are too drastic. I feel that the difference from 0.75 to 1.5 is too big and too sudden.
3. 00:51:426 (1,1,1,1,1,1) - I am not so sure this is a good idea. You can even put big dons here (or kat's whichever you prefer). Several consecutive spinners aren't good imo.

1. 01:09:855 (5) - New combo perhaps? Same reason like I wrote in Insane.
2. 01:13:712 (8) - New combo please. (the combos in insane are even shorter, but I am okay with longer combos, but here you should definitely use one)
3. 01:14:355 (9,10) - Increase this spacing, it could be confusing a little (this is a hard diff).
4. 01:51:426 - Unclosed kiai is unrankable.

1. Since this normal is a bit on the harder side, I feel that reducing drain by 1 more tick (HP drain 3) is a good idea because it makes the map easier to pass for newer players.
2. 00:22:283 (5) - New combo. Every diff has a new combo here except this one.
3. 00:30:855 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - These silenced slider ends don't fit and are really confusing for a normal diff. You could just make them more quiet instead of silenced, so atleast 20% volume please. With 20% they actually sound pretty nice.
4. 00:36:426 (2) - I think you are missing a clap here on the slider start.
5. 01:51:426 - Unclosed kiai is unrankable.

1. 00:08:569 (1,1) - If you really have to have a slider after the spinner this soon, it needs to be much closer to the middle of the screen. You will have to reposition your slider somehow to make this possible, or just think of something else instead of the spinner.
2. 00:35:569 (4) - This note is almost offscreen. You should try to move it a bit. Best solution would be to move 00:32:569 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - all this slightly up and left to preserve spacing.
3. 01:34:712 (4) - You should place a new combo here because this combo is really really really long for an easy diff.
4. 01:48:426 (4) - I think you are missing claps on this slider.
5. 01:51:426 - Unclosed kiai is unrankable.

spboxer3 wrote:

from AHO's Taiko mod request

[S.Nagi's Taiko]

• 
  Settings
  let AR use 5
  
  mapping
  00:13:605 (70) - suggest use k ~because really too many don and this way. and k It's really fit for this part~
  01:23:997 - please set x0.75 speed and add other green line at 01:24:212 - and use x1.0 speed
  
  other
  don't use short spinner e.g.00:53:140 (1,1,1,1) -
  

  OnosakiHito wrote:

1. Spinner
   These should be used sparingly as they represent the bonus notes from Taiko no Tatsujin. Not completing a spinner does not effect whether you full combo or S a map. Do not put more than 2 spinners in a row.
   Normal use: Leave at least a 1/2 beat between a note and a spinner, or 1/2 a beat between a slider and a spinner.
   Information: Short spinners are not recommended because it's loud and distracts players.
   Exception use: You may put a spinner at the end of a note stream, 1/4, 1/6 or 1/8.

from:New Taiko Rules Discussion Thread(making first rules)

lolcubes wrote:

[S.Nagi's Taiko]

1. Any reason it uses 1.2 SV? For this bpm, you should be using 1.4 SV.
2. Your speed changes (1 -> 0.75 -> 1.5) are too drastic. I feel that the difference from 0.75 to 1.5 is too big and too sudden.
3. 00:51:426 (1,1,1,1,1,1) - I am not so sure this is a good idea. You can even put big dons here (or kat's whichever you prefer). Several consecutive spinners aren't good imo.

• 
  Title:

1. There are ranked maps from SHK that seem to be "parts" of something, and they are numbered with Roman numers:
   
   1. http://osu.ppy.sh/s/8911
   2. http://osu.ppy.sh/s/3971
   So, I think that for consistency with those mapsets, you should number this in Romans too: IV instead of 4.
   
   Kiais:
2. I guess that people might have told you this before but why are the kiais in Easy/Normal/Hard/Insane so different fom the Taiko and Another? I guess the long kiai in Another/Taiko would fit the other difficulties too! But that's entirely up to you, maybe you did it to make them somehow different on purpose

1. AR 2 feels better here. I think it would make this easier to play. What do you think?
2. 01:44:569 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - This combo feels way too long, not by the number it reaches but because it doesn't change in 5 entire 1/1s. You should add a new combo somewhere in the middle.

narakucrimson wrote:

Hello!

[General]

• 
  Title:

1. There are ranked maps from SHK that seem to be "parts" of something, and they are numbered with Roman numers:
   
   1. http://osu.ppy.sh/s/8911
   2. http://osu.ppy.sh/s/3971
   So, I think that for consistency with those mapsets, you should number this in Romans too: IV instead of 4.
   
   
   Orz...
   
   Kiais:
2. I guess that people might have told you this before but why are the kiais in Easy/Normal/Hard/Insane so different fom the Taiko and Another? I guess the long kiai in Another/Taiko would fit the other difficulties too! But that's entirely up to you, maybe you did it to make them somehow different on purpose
   
   b-but another/taiko are guest diff , and looks like they dont want to change it :3..

[Easy]

1. AR 2 feels better here. I think it would make this easier to play. What do you think? k~
2. 01:44:569 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - This combo feels way too long, not by the number it reaches but because it doesn't change in 5 entire 1/1s. You should add a new combo somewhere in the middle.um , k~ added

Well that's all! Call me back!