Thanks bossandy :3

Philippines, thanks =)

I'll mod this much later today, or maybe tomorrow....Or I might still be busy until Wednesday T_T

Kiddo-Kun wrote:

I'll mod this much later today, or maybe tomorrow....Or I might still be busy until Wednesday T_T

Thanks a lot

Hi.

Easy:

• 00:18:523 (5) - Add a new combo on this slider and remove it on the next one to match the change in the music.
• 00:22:676 - Add a break here like you did with the other diffs.
• 00:42:061 (1) - This slider looks sloppy to me. I cleaned it up for you:

124,68,42061,6,2,B|199:18|257:91|257:91|328:18|390:70,1,300,2|10

• 01:25:446 (3) - Add a new combo on this note, it matches the music better.
• 01:47:138 (5) - You should always try to avoid kick sliders on Easy diffs, they might screw easy players over. Do this instead. (Follow the new combos in that picture also)
• 01:51:292 (2) - New combo on this note to match the song.
• 02:20:369 (4) - You can make the flow here better by doing this.
• 02:41:599 (3) - Add new combo on this note and remove it from 02:42:523 to match the music.
• 02:45:292 (5) - Add a new combo on this note to match the music better.

Comments:

Aside from the combos, this is a really nice Easy diff. I really enjoy the sliders a lot and the rhythm is nice and constant.

Normal:

• 00:27:984 (3,4,5) - I think this pattern would fit the song better if it was something like this.
• 00:35:138 (3) - Remove the finish on the sliders end and instead add a clap. It match the song better that way.
• 01:18:753 (2) - I don't think this matches the song very well.Do something like this instead.
• 01:36:984 (4) - Add a new combo to this note to match the music .
• 02:23:599 (1) - This slow down will surely trip players up, mainly because it's 0.50x, but also because it seems a tad random to me. So, I suggest changing it to either a long - normal slider, or a 0.75x slow down.

Comments:

Overall, nothing is majorly wrong. It's just another normal, in my opinion.

Hard:

• 00:18:984 (1,2,3) - This stack has a weird flow to it. I would open it up like so.
• 00:51:753 (1) - It would feel better if you mapped through this spinner. This spinner seems unnecessary.
• 01:18:753 (2,3,4,5) - This stack seems pretty boring, in my opinion. I would change it to something a little more exciting.
• 01:19:907 (6,7,8,9) - I think you can make this feel better and match the music better if you did this.
• 01:36:522 (3) - Add a finish to this note to match the clash in the background.
• 02:21:753 (1) - This spinner seems random and unnecessary. I suggest mapping it.
• 02:28:907 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - I suggest spreading these notes out.
• 03:03:061 (2) - It would match the music better and give a greater ending if you delete this note.

Comments:

A tad boring, to be honest. I would add some jumps and/or some 1/4th notes here and there, also the stacking feels boring and a bit strange. But other than that, pretty solid difficulty.

Insane:

• 00:39:523 (1,2,3,4) - This anti-jump does not play very well and it does not work well with the song. Do this instead.
• 00:44:830 (1) - This spinner feels weird. Please map through it.
• 01:08:599 (4,1) - This plays oddly in my opinion. I think this would play much better
• 01:16:676 (4) - I think this would flow better if you bring it bellow the slider, like this

Comments:

I like this diff. You have some nice flow and sliders here which adds to the game play. This is my favorite difficulty in the mapset.

Overall:
Pretty solid mapset. Nicely balanced and it plays great. But I see space for improvement. Get more mods and I'll come back.

A star for a good map ♪

Kiddo-Kun, thanks for mod

Fixed everything except 00:44:830 (1). I'll probably map this part later.

[Easy]

02:24:523 (4) - Add finish in the begining?
02:31:907 - Normal hitsound start here? it more fit
02:31:907 (1) - Add finish

[Normal]

00:32:830 (5) - Remove finish? a bit noisy
00:59:599 (1) - Finish instead of clap?
01:29:599 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Use some slider?
02:13:907 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - ^
02:17:138 (8) - Add finish?

[Hard]

Fine

[Insane]

Fine

Nice map!
Good luck

athiota33 wrote:

Nice map!
Good luck

Thank you very much

hello. I think I forget to update so maybe my mod is not the latest update of the map T_T;; please deal with it orz~ from mini maya.

-easy-

00:36:523- (3) I think it'll looks better 1 grid right.
00:37:907- (1) You better map this part @_@;; imo.
00:42:061- (1) it feels really weird here o_o;; I think it becomes better when you add a note at 00:41:599
01:02:369- (3) I don't think this slider fits the flow well. consider to change it?
01:34:676- (1,2) I think this pattern flows better.
02:20:369- (4) place it at 256,48?
02:47:138- (2) I don't think this slider's reverse fits well @_@;;

-normal-

00:16:676- (4,5,6) I'm not sure about this, but imo, this kind of slider is dangerous D: better put a 1/1 slider with a note afterward rather than 3x 1/2 slider @_@;;
something like this :
00:57:292- (1,2,3) this one is fine for me because its the reff @_@;;
01:16:676- (5,6,7) I'd suggest you change this to reverse slider since it'll be easier for 'normal'
01:18:753- (2) one reverse is enough -_-;
01:36:984- (4) new combo here instead of at 01:38:830
02:36:523- (1) this actually starts 1/2 beat later isn't it..

actually I want to mod more here ;w;'' From the pattern, I would like to say that I like easy's pattern better.

-hard-

SV is definitely too high T_T;; I don't think you can call this 'hard' with that SV. skipping this diff T_T

-insane-

00:12:984- (1,2,3,4) imo, this pattern flows better xD
01:16:907- (4) I think it'll flow better if you ctrl+r here xD
02:19:446- (1,2,...7) pattern them to a 'C' letter would flow much better,
02:27:984- (4) I think slider would fit better o3o~
02:38:369- (5,6) add something like this?

03:03:292- (2) place it in the center?

THIS IS AWESOME xD
I like this diff.

most of them were ignored ;W;
but still, thank you _HydeSama_ and Maya-kira :3

Download: 4minute - WHY (IchiGUN) [Easy].osu

_HydeSama_ and Maya-kira, thanks a lot :3

Hi ~ IchiGUN ~

Mod time for my Queue ~

Red : Must be fixed
Pink : Should be fixed
Purple : Just suggestions





That's all ~ nice mapset ~

Good luck ~

Ooo...thanks for modding Kawayi Rika :333

карта очень нравится,так держать,покарать всех ;3
Удачки тебе ;3 гоу гоу гоу к новым =Р

[General]:

1. Artist: 4Minute, plz follow this post when change it.
2. spinner-background.jpg is a bit too bright (especially for the video), try to find a better one?
3. spinner-spin.png, spinner-osu.png, spinner-clear.png are default ones? remove them if that's true.

[Hard]:

1. 01:07:907 (5,6,7) - starting position is a bit weired cuz of the stacking, find a better place?
2. 02:59:830 (5,6,7) - this is totally ok (compared with ^

[Insane]:

1. 02:36:753 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5) - things can be much cooler if you follow exactly the how the rap goes. and this happened a lot after here.

[Normal]:

1. 00:31:676 (3,4,5) - nazi spacing, cancel grid snapping might help

歩くsounds like 歩ぶ orz
cool song~

I'm wondering if you can find a video with better quality, anyway send me a PM after your fixes.

Hi~
From my queue

[Easy]
00:42:061 (1) - Increased spacing accuracy,Put in x:124 y:84
00:47:599 (3) - I think straight view better.Put in x:128 y:160
00:49:907 (3) - How about change like this?more Symmetry
01:01:446 (1) - I think in the middle is good to me(Put in x:256 y:244)
01:01:907 (2,3) - ^(x:256 y:156)
01:10:215 (4) - Add Finish the end
01:14:369 (1) - Add Finish
02:47:138 (2) - spacing error.Put in x:68 y:276

[Normal]
00:58:907 (4,5,6,1) - I think lt`s hard to beginner.how about change like this?(Just suggestion)
02:58:907 (7,8,9,1) - ^some reason.Change some.

[Hard]
00:51:753 (8) - Add NC?
01:41:830 (11) - Remove circle
01:42:061 (1) - Move at 01:41:830 and increase 01:43:676
I think feel better like this
02:21:753 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - hard
How about reduce the spacing?

[Insane]
Good Insane! wow

That`s all
this is korean Musician song,light?
Go Go Rank~

Colin Hou and [Ranger] thanks :3

Colin Hou wrote:

I'm wondering if you can find a video with better quality, anyway send me a PM after your fixes.

I uploaded new quality video, but size is increased to + 4mb (previous 13mb, now 17mb)
It's okay?

sure

[Insane]
02:26:830 (6,7) - Couldn't really get why you increased the spacing here. Could have just kept it with the small spacing.
02:33:753 (3) - New combo

[Hard]
Smaller hit circles then [Insane]...? Interesting. Even though it feels some what odd, but I can't see why not lol
00:53:599 (3,1) - This needs a larger spacing in between. Just separate them a little bit for the impression.
02:17:599 (1~) - you used a larger spacing then [Insane] for this part. Seems out of unity. Even [Hard] seems harder then [Insane] for this part. May consider lowering the spacing.

That's all from me. Good luck!

bmin11 wrote:

That's all from me. Good luck!

Thanks

Изя ничё так и инсейн ничё так, но вот нормал и особенно хард. Из-за квадратности и не ровных слайдеров мне они не понравились.

Louis Cyphre wrote:

Изя ничё так и инсейн ничё так, но вот нормал и особенно хард. Из-за квадратности и не ровных слайдеров мне они не понравились.

Увы. Ничего менять уже не буду =)

bUbbled!

genre seems to be Japanese lol (pop of course

Colin Hou wrote:

bUbbled!

Thanks a lot
My first bubble (〃⌒▽ ⌒)

привет

может намапишь все же интро в нормале и харде? там совсем немного вроде - но будет намного лучше
и еще скин файлы требуют .png формата,переведи в него спиннер-бэкграунд + фулл-сабмит

и ещё размер видео удручает D:
я качал очень долго,еще больше пережать нельзя?

[Easy]
00:00:523 (1) - слайдер не идеально симметричен,но хотя бы на 1 грид влево бы подвинуть
00:34:676 (2) - тоже поработать бы над симметрией
01:11:138 - почему брейк отсюда начинается? должен с 01:10:907
01:20:369 (3) - подвинь средний вейпоинт на 1 грид вправо хотя бы,будет лучше
01:23:138 - вот тут нотки не хватает,советую добавить
02:54:061 (2) - опять же симметрия,2 грида вправо

[Normal]
01:32:830 (1) - ох,сделай-ка ты лучше другую форму,выглядит не очень,мягко говоря
01:58:676 - добавь сюда ноту,либо перетащи сюда брейк (просто кликни на его начале,и перетащи мышью)
02:24:984 (2) - лучше уж начни нк отсюда
02:30:522 (1) - я бы вообще начал спиннер с 02:29:830,так намного лучше,а закончил бы на 02:31:907 - под звук

[Hard]
00:30:061 (1,2,3) - тут всё,конечно,читаемо,так что можно оставить как есть,но на будующее - соблюдай спейсинг,тут он совсем неверный
01:18:753 (2,3,4,5) - нет,ну..правда не нужны эти джампы тут -_-
01:20:599 (8,9) - старайся не стаковать таким образом 1/2 слайдеры,т.к. при игре стакинг не появляется - это баг осу
поэтому,абсолютно не видно начала 2-го слайдера,так что измени их или сделай стак вручную:
01:51:292 (1) - стакни с (8) или дальше отодвинь,слишком близко сейчас
02:04:215 (1,2,3,4) - опять же стаки

[Insane]
00:13:446 (1) - убери нк
00:22:676 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - этна-стрим как-то совсем сюда не подходит,лучше уж просто реверс-слайдеры
02:00:870 (2,3) - я писал про это в харде,нужно сделать вручную стак
02:01:793 (2,3) - ^
02:49:907 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - если бы не вистл на (3) - был бы совсем ужас,можно оставить конечно,но очень странный спейсинг

вот,и желательно получить ребабл (или хотя бы чтобы колин ху написал что перепроверил и всё ок),а то слишком длинный мод вышел - а я всё же хочу ранкнуть,а не бабл возвращать

IceBeam, thanks again.
Всё исправил :3

[Easy]:

1. 01:22:215 (1,2,3) - sorry no jump in easy plz
2. 02:47:138 (2) - shape this better?

[Normal]:

1. 02:21:984 (1,2) - place them somewhere not touching each other?

[Insane]:

1. 02:26:138 (5,6,7,1) - nazi spacing

:]

Colin Hou, thanks again ^-^ Done

rebubbled

Colin Hou wrote:

rebubbled

\:D/

the band is korean but this single is japanese so genre will be pop (japanese)

ranked

поздравляю с 1-ой мапкой!

IceBeam, большое спасибо! ^^

Oshiete tte tte te te te <3
Поздравляю!

IchiGUN !! Congratulations

congratz for the first rank~ keep moving!

Reiji-RJ, спасяб ^^
kosiga, どうもありがとうございました :33333
Colin Hou, thanks =)

wow nice

Omedeto ichiGUN ~