NotShinta wrote:

General:
- Seriously, I suggest you use a more related background rather than just Vinyl Scratch. Doesn't have to be Sapphire's. It's still less disturbing than ztrot's avatar plot though.new BG
- The metronome doesn't seem to fit the intro section, and seems like it should start at 4525. Yo' choice though of course.i was told to move it back by a few people so i did that lol

ztrony:
00:41:005 (6) - I thought this felt a bit lacking without a slider whistle, and the clap at the end rather unnecessary. Do what you want with it, though.
00:48:445 (2) - In my opinion, a 'whistle' works nicely here. Since they match up perfectly.
00:48:925 (1) - Likewise, ^.
00:58:285 (1) - A thought about a finish here, but do you think it would be overdoing it slightly?
01:18:685 (5) - Clap on the repeat?
01:23:725 (6,7,8) - Maybe you could replace these with a pattern similar to this. The 1/1ness works as well, this is just an alternative.
Oh my god this is a hitsound mod I never thought I wouldand you didn't lol

Hard:
00:35:005 - This feels a bit like an empty space, as there should be another triple here, considering you mapped the one at 00:34:525 (4,5,6). did
00:38:125 (7,8) - Variable stacks on slider ends feel a bit uncreative,changed
00:50:605 (1) - I recommend a finish on the start of this, to fit with the chorus starting very well.
01:17:725 (1) - Finish on this?nope
01:29:005 - You could add a hitcircle to be consistent with zedtrot's difficulty.added

I'll mod this notshittily and star it when the other difficulties get done, bro. Sorry if I came across a bit nitpickyish with the hitsounds so far. And Sapphaha's difficulty is nice. Good effort so farsapphy's is sadly not getting added because he refuses to use the hitsounds

Zelos wrote:

Hard:
00:13:885 (4,6) - adjust the ending of slider 4 or note 6 ever so lightly so that they stack each other perfectly.fized
00:23:245 (1,2,3,4,5) - stack these endings better please.stacking woot
00:56:125 (5,6,7) - stack these better please also.yarp
Very nice thar meg.why thank you <3

ztrony:
Nothing wrong here.ofcourse

Charles445 wrote:

General
Resize your background so it is 1024x768. This will save you file space and look much better.already changed
Try a video offset of 100

Hard
Tickrate 2
00:08:125 (2,3,4) - I know you want jumps like ztrot but I don't think they fit in this Hard.
00:15:805 (2,3) - ^^
00:17:965 (7,8) - Make these sliders the same
00:35:725 (1,2,3,4,5) - Don't have jumps like this
00:39:085 (1,2,3) - ^^
00:46:765 (3) - This clap sounds out of place
01:14:125 (3) - Move this down for some better flow like this http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/128631
01:23:965 (3,4) - Don't have jumps like thisyeah did all those lol

ztrony
Stick a spinner in there somewhere, I bet a lot of people will try to get the max feasible score on this.
00:12:205 (6) - New combo, then...
00:13:405 (1) - Remove new combo. Much better!
00:19:885 (6) - New combo here too
00:22:285 (1,2) - Turn this into a slider. Right now it relies too much on approach circles to be read.
00:25:165 (3,4) - The player might screw up here if they think the 4 is going to be on the red tick. This looks like a real pain to make readable though so I guess it's okay. It's just something to watch out for.
00:28:045 (6,1) - I think this one works fine because while the previous slider signals the next note to be on the blue tick, the new combo effectively nullifies that notion.
00:29:965 (1,2) - Turn this into a slider. Right now it relies too much on approach circles to be read.
Yeah that's it actually, the rest of the map is cool beansonly did the combo mods

Zelos wrote:

Here is my diff.
BTW you should totally name MM's Taiko, MMzz's Taiko Poni! *Run*
Also add MMzz to tags.

1. 00:17:965 (7,8) - Align these together. (Move one inch left, then one inch up)
2. 00:57:805 (x) - Add note here?
3. 01:13:165 (x) - ^

Agnes wrote:

Hi, Muffy.

[General]
Song is nice, timing seems alright. The whole bit. Most I'll have is opinions to throw.

[ZelPony]

No errors.

[Muffpony]
Just a couple of suggestions:

1. 00:17:965 (7,8) - Align these together. (Move one inch left, then one inch up)
2. 00:57:805 (x) - Add note here?
3. 01:13:165 (x) - ^did those

[ztrony]

No errors.

[MM's Taiko Poni!]
I'll check back on this later...

Roley wrote:

The quality of the video is a bit tedious, imo :l

So, because I love this song so much and I want to get this ranked, not only am I gonna shoot a kudosu star (no problems found within the maps by the way so no mod is needed for me as of this moment), but I also went and uploaded a significantly improved quality of the video.

The thing is the video previously included only looks good if you view it in a small screen size/display. However, when osu! blows the up the video display size, everything becomes really pixelated. So hopefully the .avi version I have uploaded will look quite nicer than the previous version.

Download to the new video is available here http://www.mediafire.com/?fytu6xay34zr1pp

For the purpose of convenience, the video file-name is the same as the previous version of the video, so no alterations of the .osu video load script is required

Oh yeah, also, I know we already have one taiko map for this song, but would it be okay if I make a contributed taiko map for this song as well? It shouldn't take long for me to map it considering how the song itself ain't that long.

Thanks! also brohoof trololololol.

Roley wrote:

The quality of the video is a bit tedious, imo :l

So, because I love this song so much and I want to get this ranked, not only am I gonna shoot a kudosu star (no problems found within the maps by the way so no mod is needed for me as of this moment), but I also went and uploaded a significantly improved quality of the video.

The thing is the video previously included only looks good if you view it in a small screen size/display. However, when osu! blows the up the video display size, everything becomes really pixelated. So hopefully the .avi version I have uploaded will look quite nicer than the previous version.

Download to the new video is available here http://www.mediafire.com/?fytu6xay34zr1pp

For the purpose of convenience, the video file-name is the same as the previous version of the video, so no alterations of the .osu video load script is required

Oh yeah, also, I know we already have one taiko map for this song, but would it be okay if I make a contributed taiko map for this song as well? It shouldn't take long for me to map it considering how the song itself ain't that long.

Thanks! also brohoof trololololol.

Zelos wrote:

Roley wrote:

The quality of the video is a bit tedious, imo :l

So, because I love this song so much and I want to get this ranked, not only am I gonna shoot a kudosu star (no problems found within the maps by the way so no mod is needed for me as of this moment), but I also went and uploaded a significantly improved quality of the video.

The thing is the video previously included only looks good if you view it in a small screen size/display. However, when osu! blows the up the video display size, everything becomes really pixelated. So hopefully the .avi version I have uploaded will look quite nicer than the previous version.

Download to the new video is available here http://www.mediafire.com/?fytu6xay34zr1pp

For the purpose of convenience, the video file-name is the same as the previous version of the video, so no alterations of the .osu video load script is required

Oh yeah, also, I know we already have one taiko map for this song, but would it be okay if I make a contributed taiko map for this song as well? It shouldn't take long for me to map it considering how the song itself ain't that long.

Thanks! also brohoof trololololol.

I would maul iMuffin if he said no. you make some damn good taikos.

Lizzehb wrote:

[Zelpony]

00:52:045 (2) - Kinda unexpected since the whole begining of the son it 1/1. Change to a sliderlike at 00:52:765 (4).
00:55:885 (2,3) - ^
01:00:445 (3) - This one might be ok since you don't have to move your mouse.
01:07:405 (2,3) - ^
01:11:245 (2,3) - ^
01:15:805 (3,4) - ^

I'll talk to Zelos about his diff

[Muffpony]

00:16:045 (3,4,5,6) - To complicated for a normal. (I suggest only over lapping notes with sliders once, not twice on the same slider.)who says it's a normal?
00:20:845 (x) - Add a note?doesn't need it
00:20:845 (x,4,5) - Also if you add a note, I suggest making it a repeating slider.
00:34:525 (4,5,6,7,8,9) - Notes on 1/4 like this are frowned upon in normals.again not a normal and if you look back I was told to add the second set
00:36:205 (3) - OMG NAZI I KNOW. LINE YOUR SHIT UP. kthx. :3the 5 was off not 3 but fixed
01:02:365 (1) - Spinner feels strange where it ends here, but there's nothing else you can do. RAGE.
01:13:165 (6) - Would look nicer if you lined this up with (3).it's lined up with a different note
01:28:765 (4) - Add note.naaahhh

I don't mod insanes, so I'm not touching [ztrony].

Lizzehb wrote:

[Zelpony]
00:52:045 (2) - Kinda unexpected since the whole begining of the son it 1/1. Change to a sliderlike at 00:52:765 (4). its not really unexpected.
00:55:885 (2,3) - ^ its also not that hard to hit 1/2 notes at 125 BPM
01:00:445 (3) - This one might be ok since you don't have to move your mouse.
01:07:405 (2,3) - ^
01:11:245 (2,3) - ^
01:15:805 (3,4) - ^

SapphireGhost wrote:

mod

SapphireGhost wrote:

lolmodpost

SapphireGhost wrote:

post

iMuffin wrote:

SapphireGhost wrote:

post

Okay I'm gonna take this and put it in the stop being so butt hurt I didn't use your difficulty and background pile and remind you for the last time that I am NOT using that background. I also would like to point out that i only have one difficulty of my own because people came to me and asked to make a difficulty, except for MMzz, I asked him for a taiko. Now I will add the tags because that is the only thing I cared to decipher among all the useless and cluttering screenshots, but the rest of it can poot off.

SapphireGhost wrote:

rantrantrantbutthurt

dkun wrote:

SapphireGhost wrote:

rantrantrantbutthurt

I'm sorry, who the hell mods with retarded pictures from storyboards?
Why should he take your mod post seriously when you don't even take your own shit seriously?

Mods should be straight forward, not content you should decipher with something. It's his set, he can decide what he wants with it. Now you want to be serious when you've been called out with your BS?

jajajajajajjaja funny

dkun wrote:

SapphireGhost wrote:

rantrantrantbutthurt

SapphireGhost wrote:

I've edited the clutter out of the post and would appreciate if you could check the suggestions you didn't care to decipher before. Thanks.

Jarby wrote:

dkun, there's no point stirring shit here anymore. Are you seriously trying to reprimand him for attempting to resolve a conflict when his joke upset someone? Think about who's being the most childish one here.

dkun wrote:

Jarby wrote:

dkun, there's no point stirring shit here anymore. Are you seriously trying to reprimand him for attempting to resolve a conflict when his joke upset someone? Think about who's being the most childish one here.

No point stirring shit? I'm sorry, if he didn't start in the first place, this wouldn't of happened.

That's not resolving a conflict. That joke shouldn't of been there in the first place. I'm not the one being childish, I'm the one being serious.
And, you for kudo'ing the post in the first place? Childish, right.

Jarby wrote:

dkun wrote:

No point stirring shit? I'm sorry, if he didn't start in the first place, this wouldn't of happened.

That's not resolving a conflict. That joke shouldn't of been there in the first place. I'm not the one being childish, I'm the one being serious.
And, you for kudo'ing the post in the first place? Childish, right.

Okay, so the joke was a mistake. He removed it. He's condensed his mod post and is doing his best to improve the map now without offending the mapper. His post had constructive content in it and deserved kudosu from the start, I simply gave it kudosu when he linked it because I found it hilarious. Dunno why it was denied later. Anyway, there's nothing more we should have to say as third parties. Drop it.

NotShinta wrote:

The following mod post is to be read in the most monotonous tone possible, but with less emotion.
Someone should get that guy who does those eye drop commercials.

ZelMy Little Pony: Friendship is Magic adult male fan:
00:15:565 (6) - Indeed, I wouldn't recommend stacking on a slider end on a lower-level difficulty, much less the lowest of the mapset. It can be very difficult to read the timing of this. AndincrediblydifficulttospotonHidden but still. fixed by making a pretty triangle
00:33:805 (1) - A hitobject 1/1 after a spinner is not recommended on an easier difficulty; this is because some spinning methods may require more time to recover, so 1/1 to react might not be enough for Easy players. all feexed
00:42:445 (6) - I talked about hitcircles hiding under slider ends earlier. did another pretty little triangle shape with this mod.
00:48:685 (5) - Kicksliders like this might ALSO be difficult, as the player cannot easily see where they end, and as some said, they may find it difficult attempting to go back and forth rather than staying in one spot as they are designed to do. oh come on they arent THAT hard.
00:50:605 (1) - A finish on the start of this would be lovely. okie
01:02:365 (1,2,3) - Yeah, kicksliders again. In fact, you'd probably get a better mod just looking at Sappha's. Who's lovely despite everything. Oops, I did it again. spamming spinners would make it harder for easy players. so im keeping this here.
01:05:965 (1) - Of course, finish again. okie
01:13:165 (5) - You might want to move this up a grid for straight lines. Or not. Dear God, I'm a horrible person. cant you see the isosceles triangle?

NotShinta wrote:

The following mod post is to be read in the most monotonous tone possible, but with less emotion.

General:
- What Sapphire means is that your current background, has large letterboxing, which doesn't look good. On top of that is that it isn't even of the ratio 4:3, which means white letterboxes on top of the black ones on the preview. Plus, its mock sinisterness clashes with the mood of the song. There are plenty more you can choose from, like this one, this one, or this one. Okay, that last one was not funny. But I know what is. 4TVb chose one that wasn't one of those but i think works just fine
- To refer to Sapphire again, what he means with the Sia reaction images is that your spread could be greatly improved with an Easy and/or preferably a difficolty between Zelos' and Muffin's. Mogsworth talked about making a Normal, but he's rarely present, and I had a difficulty mapped but it's a patterny Insane. I'd like to see one of the difficulties from you, actually, as Muffpony shows some promise despite all the hiddeny and stacky notes.if it becomes a huge issue then i will
- You still haven't added the suggested tags, I think you must have not gotten around to it or forgotten to update the beatmap. If so, sorry for any redundancies that might pop up here. And Sappha has a good point about the colon. THERE I DON'T NEED TO REFERENCE HIM ANYMOREAdded them to all the difficulties

zbaloney:
- Sorry if I repeat myself here at all, since I have modded this before.
- This is one of those difficulties that I hated at first but seem alright later on. Eyup.
00:14:125 (5) - I think this would look better a grid or two up and right. Or something else. Basically, I'm saying you could make this a more perfect rhombus. And in my opinion, would look much better and consistent! .ive fixed that
00:17:965 (2) - I think whistles on this start and end would work nicely.
00:23:005 - A hitcircle here would be nice, gets rid of the awkward pause there and I think fits slightly better. Plus it's more consistent. Although I've probably pointed this exact thing out before.can't remember if z wanted me to do these other ones or not though.

Muffhorse:
- For future reference, be careful using such stacky patterns as they can be difficult to read and not very good to look at. This map, however, works well enough.will keep that in mind
- Otherwise, quite nice. I think I pointed out everything I wanted to last time.

Krisom wrote:

I'm guessing Roley didn't do anything then?

ztrot wrote:

OMG RANK THIS! I mean really please I'd buy you a cookie or whatever you wanna do is fine~

Roley wrote:

it was done for the hell of it.

Larto wrote:

...it's STILL not a good idea.

Larto wrote:

I'm not hating, I'm just saying it defeats the purpose of difficulty names; they shouldn't ONLY be creative space for the mapper, they should also indicate who mapped a difficulty and, especially, what kind of difficulty your map is supposed to be. The star rating alone is not always reliable, and thus, difficulty names like these just leave the difficulty to free interpretation and won't become clear until the player plays all difficulties. You can still make it something like "Zelbrony's Normal" or something silly like that.

ztrot wrote:

it is better than some diff names we get anyays

Zelos wrote:

Not trying to spark any more drama but Ive seen sets with just "Larto" and even one as wierd as "Larto's Vegetables"

1. Disable "letterbox during breaks" as you have a video ? This will prevent the black bars that usually appear in breaks from appearing - and hiding the video.
2. Write in the map description what diff each of these is supposed to be. :/ I can guess Normal-Hard-Insane, but still.
3. You could easily get custom combo colours for that map, just following the ponies' hair for example. Try doing this =p

1. Since you went for a pretty simple (simple as in easy to play, I don't mean it in a bad way) rhythm, I recommend (really) to use simple combos to match the rhythm - that is, a new combo every big white tick. It will make sense with the way you mapped things, and emphasize the rhythm. A new combo every second big white tick could work as well, but it would make the combos quite long.
2. There are sliders that I think don't fit in the map, because they completely stop any movement and flow, and link together things that shouldn't be linked (the poum-clap should be a duo rhythm). Also, if you go for the 4/1 comboing, they break it in a very bad way. These:
   00:06:440 (4) -
   00:21:320 (4) -
   00:35:240 (1) -
   00:48:680 (6) -
3. Still talking about repeat sliders, I really think kick sliders don't fit in a Normal diff (especially not the easiest diff of the mapset). They're confusing because the number of repeats cannot be expected nor read (because the cursor hides the repeat arrows). New players don't get the reflex of holding sliders until the very end, so they will combo break on them. On top of that, yours start on red ticks, which confused even me. You're using tick rate 2 but never explot it in your diff. You can just make long slider, using the tick rates for the vibrato (kind of vibrato) in the vocals ! These:
   01:02:360 (1,3) -
   01:17:720 (1,3) -

1. I'd suggest to raise OD by one tick, but that's just a personal preference =p
2. Talking about the map itself, the blankets could be improved. I know I'm picky about it and stuff, but I see errors in blankets very easily (not everyone does or even cares), and these are easy to fix and make maps look instantly better, so please spend the few minutes for each slider. :/
   00:06:440 (4) - The body is further away than the ends.
   00:09:320 (6) - The body is closer than the ends.
   00:13:160 (2,4) - Make them parallel =p
   00:29:240 (5) - Uneven blanket ? If it's not a blanket, my bad. But if it's not, making it one would look better !
   00:41:960 (5) - Same.
   00:47:240 (5) - The slider goes too close near the end.
3. Some of the stacks feel weird to me. For instance:
   00:16:040 (3,4,5) - This one stops the movement twice in the same combo, which played weird to me.
   00:25:160 (5) - This one breaks the pattern. (4) is move to the upper left due to stacking, and it breaks the symmetry of the pattern. Not to mention the stack stops the movement induced by the sliders.
   01:09:800 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - All the stacks break the symmetry of the pattern. :/

1. I didn't like this as much as I usually love your maps, to be honest. I foud this one to have worse flow. It might be because of the complicated spacing and directional changes, or just the way you used jumps - I don't know. Also, at times, the rhythm becomes really difficult to read. Here:
   00:22:280 (1,2) -
   00:29:960 (1,2) -

1. All diffs but this ones start at the same point. I strongly recommend to make this one start there, too.
2. Make the kiai end at the same spot as the other diffs ?

• This is the most awesome custom difficulty name I have ever seen in my modding career. I love it. Really love it.

Odaril wrote:

Roley-Pony's Taiko

1. All diffs but this ones start at the same point. I strongly recommend to make this one start there, too. done
2. Make the kiai end at the same spot as the other diffs ? I personally don't see the point of Kiai being in that end portion, so I removed it in my contribution map. But, if it really is that bothersome that the kiai time spots don't fully match the other difficulties, then alright -- said change is applied as well.

Odaril wrote:

Muffpony

1. I'd suggest to raise OD by one tick, but that's just a personal preference =p
2. Talking about the map itself, the blankets could be improved. I know I'm picky about it and stuff, but I see errors in blankets very easily (not everyone does or even cares), and these are easy to fix and make maps look instantly better, so please spend the few minutes for each slider. :/
   00:06:440 (4) - The body is further away than the ends.
   00:09:320 (6) - The body is closer than the ends.
   00:13:160 (2,4) - Make them parallel =p
   00:29:240 (5) - Uneven blanket ? If it's not a blanket, my bad. But if it's not, making it one would look better !
   00:41:960 (5) - Same.
   00:47:240 (5) - The slider goes too close near the end.
3. Some of the stacks feel weird to me. For instance:
   00:16:040 (3,4,5) - This one stops the movement twice in the same combo, which played weird to me.
   00:25:160 (5) - This one breaks the pattern. (4) is move to the upper left due to stacking, and it breaks the symmetry of the pattern. Not to mention the stack stops the movement induced by the sliders.
   01:09:800 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - All the stacks break the symmetry of the pattern. :/

Krisom wrote:

Everything looks clean, buuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuut you'll have to +12 to the offset (692), confirmed with Alace senpai.

I'll rebubble after that (unless you wanna get a rebubble from someone else, then I'd rank)

Charles445 wrote:

I'm pretty sure you can rank on offset change.

Krisom wrote:

Charles445 wrote:

I'm pretty sure you can rank on offset change.

Everywhere I asked was a loud and sounding no.
Did iMuffin fix the offset yet? He has not notified me..

Mecha Shadow wrote:

Just as I said. We're doomed.

Ekaru wrote:

Mecha Shadow wrote:

Just as I said. We're doomed.

Actually, we were doomed whenever somebody decided to start mapping Touhou music.

Mecha Shadow wrote:

Well, the fandom around Touhou is really clear. But the FAGGOTRY (yes) around MLP:FiM has no point.

Shiirn wrote:

protip: none of the above is, get over yourselves.

Mecha Shadow wrote:

Ekaru wrote:

Actually, we were doomed whenever somebody decided to start mapping Touhou music.

Well, the fandom around Touhou is really clear. But the FAGGOTRY (yes) around MLP:FiM has no point.