beatmap discussions

05:03:198 (33,34,35,36,37,38,39) - the spacing on this particular pattern seems slightly harsher and a bit more inconsistent compared to previous and following iterations of the pattern (examples: 02:43:019 (31,32,33,34,35,36,37) ; 05:14:884 (33,34,35,36,37,38,39) ) despite few variations of the song (be it vocals-wise or instrument-wise) during the chorus. Changing the position of 37 to somewhere like 406;202 or 407;203 could be better in this case.

permalink

00:18:668 (1,2) - rhythm suggests a circle at 00:18:668 then a circle at 00:18:816 (to line up with the percussion in this section)

permalink

02:21:843 (10) - isn't this circle misplaced? I don't hear a clear sound, just the fadeout of the previous drum sound at 02:21:736 (that isn't mapped)

permalink

HERE WE GOOOOO

permalink

02:22:329 (2) - pretty sure the note is supposed to begin on a grey tick there instead of a pink one (so it would begin on 02:22:311 instead).

permalink

04:02:268 (9) - I get that you don't want to put a nc in the middle of a stream, but to be consistent with 04:00:912 (1) (where a similar feat happens), it would be better to represent the beginning of the conflicting voices with a nc there rather than on 04:02:607 (1).

permalink

03:05:658 (1) - I understand why you placed this here (to coincide with the wooshing noise at that point), but why the break afterwards? The noise feels like rippling out, so it would make more sense to place a slider. Same applies to 03:08:370 (1).

permalink

00:49:135 (1,2,3) - A few suggestions
On 1, I would make the slider slightly more angled to face the head of 2.
On 2, I would reverse the slider and make it more angled to face the head of 3.
On 3, I would angle slightly the head.

It would look something like this:
https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/12095498

but probably smoother

permalink

01:03:030 (8) - maybe reverse the direction of the slider? it makes for a smoother transition between 7, 8 and 1

permalink

Oui.

permalink

00:13:666 (3) - Your slider finishes too late, it should finish on 00:13:777

permalink

00:08:999 (4) - Your slider finishes too early, it should finish on 00:09:222

permalink

00:07:666 (4) - Your slider finishes too early, it should finish on 00:07:888

permalink

00:07:999 (3) - Your reverse doesn't seem to be mapped to anything (mostly because it's placed on a red tick while this part only requires purple ticks). Maybe replace it with 2 1-beat sliders or 1 slider with 2 reverses instead?

permalink

00:08:666 (3) - Your reverse slider still acts like a 1/4 reverse slider instead of the 1/3 reverse slider that would be needed to represent the sounds there. It should finish on 00:08:888

permalink
/