Songs Compilation

yup

[***]
By making it a circle and a slider, i wanted to emphasize the instrumental sound on 00:25:770 - compared to 00:28:164 - which doesn't have that sound. It's the same on 00:15:398 (5,1) - and i also mapped it as circle and slider. If someone else reads this, I'd appreciate another opinion on this, but I'ma keep it like it is for now.

its a bit over map but who really cares make sure to resolve

he wants to keep it open for another opinion

.

nerfed it

Yeah you're right, I didn't really know what to do there. I modified your suggestion a bit, and i feel like it makes it more interesting than before.

makes sense, yeah

Made it consistent, so that circle always stacks with sliderhead. Still difficult to read, but yeah... won't change for now

It's a triple now

whoops, didn't mean to do that

imo a circle works better as a way to end a song anw cuz it gives more closure(?)

[***]
The way the songs end at 01:11:568 - and 04:25:649 - feel different than the other one imo. It's hard to describe, but I just feel like a slider with muted end represents the song better there. On the other hand, I don't really know any other maps that do this, so maybe it's just me thinking that way. Keepin it as it is for now, might change later when I get another opinion.

its fine it doesnt affect gameplay and can be quirky and cool

think I'm happy with the way it currently is

nc, + ctrl . to make it more outstanding

fixed

changed to 1/8 slider

Reduced spacing

I agree on the NC part, so I changed that. Since I had to change the part before this one, I also had to change up the 1/3 section. I scaled it down a bit, hope that works.

update your map this isn't NC at all

relax u only gave him 30mins😭

i lowkey didnt read how long ago he replied lol

Tying into this; I would differentiate the 1/3 a little more. Giving it a change in direction & moderate spacing difference comparative to the 1/4 would be nice

ex move 01:31:461 (1) - to x84 y238 & 01:31:672 (1) - to x46 y73

@Deag the way you suggested feels very similar to the previous combos (01:30:303 (1,2,3,1,2,1) - ) so it's even less differentiated I think. I also agree that the solution I currently have also isn't the best, so I'll keep it open for now, until I / someone else comes up with a better solution.

.

I agree with the first one. Since you don't follow the slider the whole way up, it's actually not a lot of movement - increased spacing. As for the second one, I believe the spacing is alright, since you actually have to stay on the slider until the end, before aiming down to the next one.

I don't think you updated the map, cause its still the same as before

.

you do this a lot; and it's consistent. so you can probably disregard this it's not an issue. ME personally I would try to tie each of these patterns together a little more aesthetically. but the generic slider rotation & spacings you give has it's own good aesthetic. Definitely nothing wrong with how anything is mapped

I get what you mean. I played around a lot with this one, and I couldn't really find a way to keep this type of rotation, while keeping it closer together. I changed it, so that each sliderpair is a combo. This way it looks a bit better imo.

01:48:935 (1,2) - Same

There's a little drum at 01:38:987 - and 01:49:093 - which 01:36:461 - doesn't have for example. Also gives a bit of variety to the player imo.

i personally think that 01:52:093 (5,2) - these two stacking are fine since the 2 is perfectly visible as you hit it, but 01:52:882 (2,4) - should probably still be moved for readability

Yeah, I changed it the way fireblaze suggested.

04:51:617 (5) - same

05:06:017 (1) -

yeah, changed it

you should use this picture instead for reference (JAYLEN APPROVED)

I think the way you two made it, is too difficult, by a lot, considering how fast that section is. I adjusted the pattern a slight bit, to make it look more interesting, but appart from that I believe making it any harder will not benefit the map.

bro you HAVE to change this, its still way too easy what fireblaze3028 has is not that hard considering its 5.8* almost 6*. I think whoever your target audience is is not gonna complain about his suggestion.

02:17:718 (1,2,3,4) - these notes do not flow into one another, its just going in a straight line and doesn't emphasize the kick+snare well

considering how hard your buildup to the last kiai and the last kiai itself is, this isn't really anything too difficult so that shouldn't be a concern

also if youre gonna keep this at least change 02:17:541 (3,1,2) -, this stacking is actually pure evil just move 02:17:541 (3) - somewhere else, same thing with 02:40:130 (3,1,2) -

i agree with the original suggestion but dont entirely agree with #4754955/12608790 as it's already quite a tapping map and this just furthers that playstyle

both ideas do work tho , up to mapper as a bit subjective at the end of the day

I think it's different now, I don't know when i last updated, but it's way more difficult now

Yes, I agree. I switched up the second overlap, I believe that makes it better.

part afterwards is probably a lot more difficult to read now, but it looks better, so yeah ^^

Not worth adjusting the pattern around it, since I'd have to change up a lot, to still keep my visual spacing.

good to know, I'm kinda bad at rating the difficulty of streams, but I think I like them the way they are, so I won't change anything

The spacing is slightly increased on the NC. Also a lot of songs that are stream maps have a kick on the white ticks, and don't change up anything, unless there is some other important sound, that deserves a change in flow etc - therefore i won't change it for now.

• the "spacing" isn't increased enough for anyone yet alone the player to notice or feel a change in the NC.

• Quit comparing your maps to other maps, try to at least hear what I'm saying and apply it, and if you still don't like it that's fine keep what you have

• The 'other important sound" you are hearing is the kick on 03:23:104, its too noticeable for you not to change it.

just adding my two cents on this, i believe a new combo is enough emphasis to acknowledge these kicks on the white ticks and i feel like if mapper was to change direction constantly for extra emphasis it would start to look very cluttered and also feel awkward to play.

i feel your screenshot makes for quite a bumpy stream with the direction change which i personally do not think the song warrants for, and i think this song should be quite flowy lol

maybe mapper could arch down for the second 4 but i dont agree with the bump for the nc (which is alr done at 03:22:729 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - )

this isn't your map, let him respond to his own mods lol

the whole entire point of a map DISCUSSION is to DISCUSS i am allowed to DISCUSS on a DISCUSSION page , what do you mean?

furthermore the mapper literally asked me for my opinion. don't be so rude and assumptious next time, thanks and happy new year

happy new year.

still not fixed
03:14:104 (1,2,3,4) -
03:18:604 (1,2,3,4) -
03:23:104 (1,2,3,4) -

he clearly doesnt want to fix it because its not that big of an issue hakuna matata. so happy new year

ill let his map be mid its ok <3

the classic modding ego where the modder thinks hes always right and that his mapping style should be imprinted on every single map cause his mapping style is perfect. Learn some manners and grow up, i suggest taking a break from the game if you’re this upset by someone disagreeing with your SUGGESTION. Congrats on your first ranked map.

happy new year

and that's your opinion have a good day.

you should also quit the game to have 628 kudosu and have nothing to show for it 🤡

i think this discussion is over. waste of time and nothing is being progressed. mapper doesnt want to change so thats that.

I prefer the way it plays / looks without making it burst sliders.

maybe I accidently changed it already, or you wanted to point out sth else, but 03:42:229 (1,3) - is not perfect overlapped.

this 03:42:604 (3) - is directly on top of the 03:42:229 (1) - try doing something like this

https://imgur.com/a/cTfiyMA

I don't like the way it looks, but I agree it's easier to read so yeah...

I think it feels better the way it is currently mapped.

yup, reduced spacing.

No real reason to map the first sound (04:09:413 (1) - eg.) any different. Given the first one has a drum on it, the spacing between the object before, and this one is way bigger, than the spacing between all the alarm sounds. But apart from that i don't see why the first alarm sound should be treated differently.

It should be treated differently because there is a SNARE on the first note and that doesn't happen with 04:09:590 (2,3,4) -, you have to pay attention to detail and not just let it be boring.

If there's other people who share Jaylen's opinion feel free to re-open. But I believe it's better to not over complicate it.

its called paying attention to detail not over complicating

It's not perfect overlaps.
Since it's the same sound several times, and always the same pattern, I'm sure that the player will get the idea, after the second or third repetition and adapt to it.

bro 💀

• You need to have good sight-read capability as well. If I'm struggling to read a 5.8*, call it skill issue if you want but that is way too hard to read for certain players

skill issue, time to get some glasses 💀

NOT YOUR MAP 🗣🗣🗣

"discussion" page btw

I can see how it could be problematic, for me only using this one pattern for this whole song. As for the pattern itself though, I don't see the problem.

yes, works nice ^^

yes, also looks a lot better