The Sea (C418 Remix)

I'm not super sure if I'm understanding this correctly. I assume you're talking about 00:09:000-ish where the melody drifts off quite a bit?
Because I think generally going lower with the spacing from the start to the end of of the section you timestamped seems a bit counterintuitive, especially towards the very end where it leads into the next section

closing since I personally believe it's fine (?)

me when I throw

made me recheck the first two minutes again cause updating right when looking at map, i would like to revoke the praise :C

01:48:821 (13,1) - if you adjust anything here aswell.

agree on 01:27:146 (3,4)
On the 1/8 stacks I wouldn't like "space" them but I can unstack them

? I don't think so

yeah, I still don't see it

03:57:446 (5,1) -

thanks for catching that

I like this. I think I initially wanted to do this but struggled with the exact patterning

yeah, probably a good idea 👍

makes sense yep

02:05:396 (3,4) -

yep
also kinda had to reverse the 02:01:496 (2) slider cuz otherwise I didn't see a good way to significantly nerf the first one, should be fine I think

did something

02:28:796 (1) - from here on onwards, the same applies. In the section inbetween i can understand since the extra "fluteish" layer is coming in but from here on onwards you should consistently give the extra emphasis for the blue tick, see 02:30:896 (5) - and 02:33:296 (5) - missing it, the other ones are fine due to the extra incoming layers youre focusing on

02:16:346 (4) - on this I'd tend to disagree, following that squeaky sound on the reverse (similar to 02:01:496 (2)) and overall pushing emphasis on those longer sliders in this small section.

The one's mentioned in the reply are fair though,y ep

was a little tricky to fit in but I did something!

true, I already felt like it was kinda odd to play

yea I think I forgot

03:03:296 (1) - 03:08:096 (1) -, not a mistake in itself, since you do it consistently for the specific sound, but compared to the rest of the small section

nah, it's intentional, every second half of these patterns focus on the barrel sound instead since clicky sound is fading out

actually pretty cool

03:20:996 (3) -

mayb doublecheck snapping for these in general lol

honestly yea 3/8 sounds much more sensible and overall more fitting, even for the ones that slighty drift offbeat that's probably the better simplification.

Now about the silly 1/7 on 03:41:996 (1,3) - the sliderends which use the 1/7 snap honestly sounds fine as is to me but I'm a little unsure about where the 3 slider begins. Sounds noticably off to me, but pushing it back makes it worse playability-wise

hi, i was asked to post opinion here so yea these are 1/3

you can hear in the song, the grouping divides the measure into 3 equal parts indicating 1/3 rhythm

I'll check this again tomorrow :) tysm for chipping in!

i think they're not equal at all

yea after listening to it again and trying out a few different things, MAYBE it was intended as 1/3 rhythm, but those sounds shift so much that 3/8 genuinely just sounds better to me 🤷

i agree with sebas here, to me it both sounds like 1/3 in the song and feels better when mapped as 1/3

not much of a way i can argue this other than literally going into an audio editor, slowly dragging the playhead, and marking the spots where i can first hear each note so i can visually test that they're evenly spaced (so that's what i did)

1/3 it is I suppose ✨
Thanks everyone for your thoughts!

makes more sense ye

sure I guess, since you were so nice to send it to me on discord as well lmfao

that melody drowns out there so much that I'd much rather follow that sound that sounds like you put tension on a rubber band and then pull on it lol

cool idea, I like it :)

oh yeah sure!