mapped by Donpa-chan
submitted
last updated
Hype Train17 / 5
Nomination Status0 / 5
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:00:901 - 00:04:297 - 00:05:147 - , etc.

are these intended to be empty? because if it isn't, I suggest that you map these empty spaces in this section too to give emphasis on the flute techniques

permalink

01:19:509 - same here

permalink

Added 1/4 note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:05:430 - missing 1/4 rice? (I following angki diff)

permalink

Added a note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:05:925 - for me can do 1/4 like previous pattern bc it heard it like the same
just do this!

permalink

Added a note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

Fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:21:490 (21490|0) - small suggestion, for the ascneding pitch u can move this to col 3
then move 00:21:631 (21631|2) - to col 1

permalink

Moved

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:23:047 - miss note?

permalink

I think it is continuation from 00:22:905 - So I will leave it be.

Maybe change it if another modder say so

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:25:311 (25311|3) - i think sound here is same as 00:25:736 (25736|3,25736|2) - so maybe you should double it?

permalink

Added a note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:26:820 - here has a rapid sound before 00:26:868 (26868|1) - so i think you can add a note at 00:26:820 (26820|2) -

permalink

Um, I think it will make it different than the others, which I think will make it weird and not consistent. So I will leave it be. Maybe change it if another modder say so

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:27:151 - 00:27:292 - 00:28:566 -, and more timestamps

are these intended to be tap notes? if not, I suggest that you make them as LNs because they follow the sound the other LNs represent

permalink

Um, actually it's for drum like sound. And I think the violin is in 1/2. So I think it will be annoying If I put 1/4 note in 1/2 LN. Also I don't want to make this diff LN Heavy, making that 1/4 LN will make it more LN Heavy I think. So I will leave it be

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:27:363 (27363|0) - Ghost note

permalink

Deleted

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:27:434 - 00:39:603 - Check the 1/2 red line in this part. The music has the small Ethnic instrument sound (maybe it's Marimba) at these timepoint, but you only add at someplace like 00:28:424 (28424|1) - 00:29:273 (29273|2) - 00:34:792 (34792|0) - etc.

And other place like 00:27:575 - 00:29:556 - 00:30:971 - didn't do this.

It's not necessary to add everything 1/2, but it's best to recheck and unify it

permalink

Rechecked and added

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:27:717 (27717|2,27858|3,28000|2,28141|3,28283|2) - not a big fan of this trill as it doesnt represent anything, maybe just rearrange to smthn like this?

permalink

Fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:29:273 (29273|2,29415|2) - 00:30:122 (30122|3,30264|3) - 00:30:971 (30971|3,31113|3) - 00:33:518 (33518|3,33660|3) - 00:35:641 (35641|3,35783|3) - jacks appear on same hand 5 times in a row maybe move 00:30:264 (30264|3) to the other hand with some restructuring

permalink

Moved

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:30:759 (30759|3) - ghost note? i didn't here any sound here and as for 00:30:547 (30547|0,30618|1,30688|2) - has strong sound and it is very obvious so i suggest to delete this note make it more clearly or you can make 00:30:547 (30547|0,30618|1,30688|2) - to all double to make a jumptrill

permalink
permalink

Removed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:32:103 (32103|3,32103|2) - This sound is not very loud to double it.
I suggest you check for similar problems.

permalink

Fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:34:085 - missed 1/2 ln here

permalink
permalink

Changed to 1/2 LN

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:34:509 (34509|3) - the violin sounds cut off on the 00:34:651, so how about change that 1/1 ln to the 1/2 ln

permalink

Shorten

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:37:339 01:25:169 01:28:566 - should be doubles cuz of the taiko drums

permalink

Added a note. Thank you very much

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:39:603 - i suggest triple here to make a comparison with 00:41:302 -

permalink

Added a note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:39:603 - to 00:46:396 - the flutes here do some kind of "playing in between keys". is it intended that you mapped them as one LN only? if not, I suggest that you map the "riff-y" parts of the flute too

permalink

For calm part, I think mapping it as one LN is better, because it will make better feel than mapping glitching flute

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:40:594 00:40:665 I think it is better to mark these notes, the sound is too noticeable not to take them into account.

permalink

Added notes

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

There are details that need to be expressed, the section is very quiet so they are very noticeable.

00:43:000 (43000|3,43283|1) -

00:44:698 (44698|3) -

permalink

Changed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:45:122 - i think i heard sound here can shorten the long LN and add 1/2 LN one

permalink

Um, I think it's still a glitch sound which is I do not mapped in this calm section. So I will leave it be. Maybe change it if another modder say so

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:49:226 (49226|2,49509|2) - feel like the ln release is too tight here? (compare it with the previous lns) just shorten the ln to the 1/2 snap

permalink

Shorten

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:49:509 - can sacrifice the LN length for 1/4 for the double of kick, i think is not good in here to be single cuz it kinda noticable

permalink

Changed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:49:934 - could use a double, sounds the same like 00:50:075 -

permalink

Added a note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:50:004 (50004|3) - why use 1/4 here , for the consistency i think you should delete it

permalink

Deleted

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:52:339 (52339|0,52339|3,52339|2) - i don't think here need triple actually , i suggest just delete 00:52:339 (52339|2) -

permalink

Deleted

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:53:401 - 00:58:919 - , and many other timestamps in kiai

are these also intended to be empty? some parts of the kiai with the same "riff-y" flute sounds, you mapped them including the blue ticks (ex. 00:55:169 (55169|0,55240|1,55311|2) -) so why not fill the other spaces too?

permalink
permalink
permalink

Added a note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

Rearranged

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

00:58:283 suggest just reducing this to a triple as this is just a normal kick

permalink

Delete a note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

Um, I think the sound is really fit to make 1 direction, modify it I think it will feel weird

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:00:264 - for consistency here shoule be tripled

permalink

Added a note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

Added a note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan
permalink

Moved

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:03:872 - i think its a miss note cuz you didnt ignore any mainsounds before
1
if want to show the difference between this sound and kick , i think can do something like this ↑

permalink

Changed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:04:226 - there is a continuing drum, i recommend using some anchor to highlight the feeling

permalink

I think that's is enough. Because the long anchor will not enjoyable and annoying to play

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:05:075 (65075|0,65075|2,65075|1,65075|3,65500|3,65500|1,65500|2,65500|0,65924|3,65924|1,65924|2,65924|0) -
these 3 quads have 3 different pitches, add lns in diiferent columns to distinguish them.
for example:

permalink

Added LN

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:05:075 - make here like https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/19223925/e60d to fit the low-high-low pitch

permalink

Fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:08:613 (68613|3) - move to col 3 to avoid the 3 note anchor

permalink

Moved

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:09:320 (69320|0,69320|1,69462|3,69462|2,69603|0,69603|1,69745|2,69745|3,69886|1,69886|0,69886|3) - you can make it to jack instead of jumptrill like https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/19223928/120f becuase the 1/2 jumptrill is a little bit boring and can't make flow

permalink

Will do this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/19224430/d936 instead. Because I think it will be more enjoyable to hit

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:11:797 - I still think move 01:11:868 (71868|3) - to here is better: Compared to the difference between 2 and 3, the difference between 1 and 2 is more noticeable

permalink

I will change it if another modder say so. Because the sound is same like 01:08:471 - 01:10:169 - Which is using Quad. So if I change it to double, I think it will less feel

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:12:717 (72717|3,72717|2,72717|1,72717|0,73566|2,73566|0,73566|1,73566|3) -

Seems no bell sound like you use 4 in recent place, I haven't hear the bell. I don't know if I heard it wrong, can check again

permalink

Already check it. It have heavy sound like 01:08:471 - 01:10:169 - 01:11:868 - . So making Quad is acceptable

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:13:849 should be triple? like 01:13:283, 01:14:415

permalink
permalink

Fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:16:962 (76962|2,76962|3,76962|0,76962|1) - you can represent the melody by making this quad ln, just like 00:46:396 this section

permalink

Change it to LN

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

Changed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:20:358 - i think this part missing some LN ,
like
01:22:905 - personal dont think it sounds like a long sound , its more like 01:22:622 - 01:22:764 - 01:22:905 -
01:29:698 - LN ? have the similar feeling like 01:29:132 (89132|2,89273|0) - for me
01:30:971 (90971|1) - should be a LN ?

permalink

For 01:20:358 - I don't hear any flute in there, also I want to use 1 Column LN only in this section because the pattern itself is Jack, So adding LN in more than 1 column is making it too hard I think. And this is not LN/Hybrid Concept so I will leave it be

For 01:30:971 - I don't hear any sound that fit to make it LN

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

Because it have drum sound different from 01:20:500 (80500|2,80783|2,81066|2)

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:39:037 - too empty
add some ln to snap the violin.

permalink

Added LN

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:43:707 (103707|2) - delete this
if you want to snap the sound, you should snap all this sounds in this period of songs.

permalink

Added a note with corresponding sound

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:47:528 - i think you can use some 1/2 ln to embellishment here

permalink

Um, I think 1/2 double will too dense for this calm part. So I will leave it be. Maybe change it if another modder say so

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

01:53:471 you can add notes for the bubbly sounds here on every 1/2s so it doesnt feel too empty?

permalink

Add it to 1/1 instead. Because there are noticeable sound that make 1/2 I think

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

02:04:368 (124368|2,124509|3,124509|2,124651|3) - probably should avoid being too heavy on the right hand, move 02:04:651 (124651|3) - to col 1 probably

permalink

Moved

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

02:05:358 - triple for cymbal?

permalink

Added a note

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

02:11:302 (131302|0,131302|1,131302|2,131302|3) - ignore this if it's intended but just a suggestion, what if this quad was to be reduced into a triple to make way for the flute "riff" sound?

https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/19232109/8276

permalink

Um, This is like end of dense pattern which is another calm section. So ending it with Quad and simple pattern is better feel I think

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

Fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

02:20:641 (140641|2,140641|1,140782|2,140782|3) - all kick like these ,you can make double at same column like https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/19223937/486a

permalink

Fixed, Thank you very much

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

02:20:782 02:21:348 maybe double for kicks?

permalink

Change to double

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

02:24:887 (144887|3,145028|2,145170|1,145311|0,145453|1,145453|3) - I think the structure can be change abit, because for me flowing of the notes is still stuck for me
so i think it can 02:25:170 (145170|1,145311|0) - swap these columns and moves 02:25:453 (145453|1) - to column 1 for better flows also constant with the sound pitch

permalink

Changed. Thank you very much

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan

02:28:283 (148283|1,149981|2) - I perceive more of a cut than an extra intensity, so I can suggest:

permalink

Changed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Donpa-chan
/