mapped by yf_bmp
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 30 January 2024!
nominated by Garden and 3y3s
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:00:625 (1) - 跑第一根红线前面去了

permalink

1

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

00:00:998 00:02:443 强烈建议折返改滑条+单点,音效太强了,这折返很难受

permalink

我没太理解你的意思,是指这样吗

permalink
permalink

不是,你折返尾是一个大白线,歌曲还有很重的鼓,所以你要 https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/17894233/8357
你再看眼insane和主难,是不是带数字的

permalink

明白了,感谢

permalink

改动完看了一下感觉有点怪,暂时不修改

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

换成了滑条+单点

permalink

00:06:058 (6) - a single note is a bit weak following the instrument here since it's not as distinct as 00:05:335 - etc. , a slider would do it better imo -> https://i.imgur.com/eDVJt5v.png

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

00:08:216 (4) - 再放的离23远点

permalink

好嘞

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

00:08:949 (3,4,6) - hard在这种情况我的建议是松开ds,不然视觉上46太近了,空间关系不明所以

permalink
permalink

好的

permalink

已修正

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

00:16:359 (4,5) - 包起来

permalink

好的

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

00:16:901 (5,6,7) - 请注意间距,让他们等距

permalink
permalink

是视觉保持一致吗,,我先改一下

permalink

间距已修改好了

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

00:18:347 (1,2,3) - 00:21:238 (1,2,3) - etc. could probably stack 2, 3 to differentiate vocal (00:18:528 (2,3) - ) from filler instrument mapping (00:18:347 (1) - ), would also reduce consecutive 1/2 movement in this relatively calmer section

permalink

应该是修了的

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

00:18:528 - add a note

permalink

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

00:24:130 (1,1) - 为了配合低难度保持一致是没问题,但是低难度空出两个转盘的时间是为了体现人声,你这里反而把最明显的最需要点击的那个节奏放到了转盘开头。我建议00:24:130 - 00:27:022 - 都加一个圆圈。把转盘缩短往后面放。

permalink

好的

permalink

已修正

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

拉远啊,太近了

permalink
Reopened by yf_bmp

好的

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

00:29:913 (1,2) - similar to #3636366 , would suggest doing same thing as 00:41:479 (1,2,3) -

permalink

i think it was fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

00:36:419 (4,1) - more fitting as two circles or one 1/1 slider instead since there are no vocal on the slider ends, unlike 00:36:058 (3) - 00:33:528 (3,4) - etc.

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

00:48:708 (4,5,6,1,2,3) - 排列上我觉得这里5和2的不叠处理有点不合曲,比较建议和6 3各叠起来

permalink

5与6叠加感觉很棒,但是我感觉00:50:696 (2,3) - 大概效果差一点?

permalink

部分修补

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

00:50:154 (1) - wrong snapping, slider tail should end on the white tick (00:50:516 - ) instead

permalink

oh

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

应该是修了的

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

修改好了

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

00:52:323 (4,5) - 前面类似部分都是跟的人声,这里突然变成跟鼓点很违和。我建议删掉00:52:504 (5) - ,把00:52:323 (4) - 改成1/1滑条

permalink

已解决

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

00:52:323 (4) - 的1/1滑条呢 怎么成单点了 这里从前后空间关系和歌来说都该是个滑条

permalink
Reopened by S_Saika

好的

permalink

已经修改好了

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:02:263 (4,3) - 使用类似的摆法,01:01:720 (1,2) - 使用类似的摆法会好看一点 现在太乱

permalink

这里的摆法是指滑条的形状还是位置
是这样子吗
https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18006023/5f46
https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18006026/ca2f

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

抱歉点错按钮了

permalink
Reopened by -Spring Night-

looks ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

01:04:251 (1,2,3,4) -这不是suggestion,我觉得这超出hard的容许范围了

permalink
permalink

明白了,这里确实很不妥,在改正中

permalink

已修正

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:04:612 (2,4) - 我说实话这个原地放,甚至不如固定间距跟着走。毕竟音效和人声都是渐强,起码拉开一点好,没必要做的这么gimmick

permalink

已修改

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:05:696 (1,2,3) - 开着ds把1往下拉一点会好看很多 现在1和3的间距不明所以 另外01:04:973 (3,3) - 都可以试着包一下01:05:877 (2) - ,会好看一些

permalink

00:41:479 (1,3) - 同 13相互之间拉开一点

permalink

我重新修改了一下排列

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

01:07:504 (1,2,3) - 细节,让这三个等距

permalink

2,3重新调整了

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:09:672 (8) - consider using lower sv for this slider because instrument is less active there, for better comparison with 01:08:949 (7) -

permalink

1

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

01:14:000 - 这个kick还是加上比较好,用nc来区分vocal就行

permalink

ok, 补充上了

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:14:732 (1,2,3) - i'd do a 1/4 reverse slider here for simplicity since all other active 1/4 rhythms in kiai are following vocals and this triple suddenly coming out of the blue can be a bit odd

permalink

Makes sense, I'll fix it.

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:21:238 (1,2) - 间距有点大,不合曲

permalink

我试了试换一种滑条

permalink

e

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

01:21:238 (1,2) - would use just one 1/1 slider like 01:09:672 (8) - for better density comparison with rest of the kiai where consecutive 1/2 sliders were only used at spots with very active instrument and vocal

permalink
permalink

1

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

01:22:142 (4,5,6) - broken stack

permalink

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:22:323 (6,7) - 01:25:214 (4,5) - would really recommend ctrl-g rhythm on these to better grasp the vocal rhythm, similar to first part of the kiai (00:58:829 (2,3,4,5) - etc. ), currently there are a lot of filler instrument notes (01:22:684 (7) - 01:24:853 (1) - etc.) that make it hard to tell what's the rhythm focus in the section

permalink

already fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

01:23:046 (2,1) - 这两个快贴在一起了,请让他们保持一定的视觉间距

permalink

好的

permalink
permalink

修改完成

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:24:853 (6,13) - 忘记NC了吧

permalink

抱歉,马上改正

permalink

已修正

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:27:744 (1,2) - 我是觉得,既然你有用 01:30:636 (1,2) - 这种圆圈叠滑条尾的方法,不如这种 3/4 直接错开比较合适

permalink

01:28:738 - 可以加绿线消音

permalink

已添加

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:29:190 (3,4,5,6) - this should be using some actual harder rhythm and maybe spaced patterns instead of 01:30:636 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - where the song intensity goes down, would buff the former and nerf the latter for better song expressions, example -> https://i.imgur.com/FrUflDC.png

permalink

yes, I agree with you.

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:30:636 (1,2,3,4,5) - 比较建议01:31:178 (2,3) - 01:31:901 (4,5) - 叠起来,而不是叠在滑条尾,一个是移动很难为打hard的人,另一个是,音的强度和点击性我觉得是1 23 45

permalink

此处主跟人声,没有修改

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:31:359 (3) - 这个替换成1/2节奏会比较符合原曲子的感觉

permalink
Reopened by yf_bmp

这里我尝试改了一下但是不确定行不行

permalink

修改完成

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:32:805 (1,2) - 建议重新做成一个1/1滑条,跟人声就好

permalink

现在1,2是跟随两个人声

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

如果你拆成两个的话,需要注意一下这里音乐没有那么强烈的,但是你的间距却和后面01:34:612 (2,3) - 差不多,并且节奏也是两个1/2滑条,也就是说会出现失衡的情况的,因此建议是1换成两个圈 2是按照上面1/1的改,再考虑下?

permalink
Reopened by yf_bmp

修改完成

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:33:799 - 01:36:690 - could do a triple for vocal

permalink

I think the vocal here is not prominent enough.

permalink

01:07:775 (2) - Like the vocals here, it is strong enough, would be better for Hard version. that's what I think.

permalink

no fix here

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

01:34:431 (1,2) - ctrl-g rhythm? i feel 01:34:973 - is more fitting grouping with 01:35:154 (3,4,5) - instead

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:35:154 (3,4,5) -不如摆三角

permalink

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:35:335 (4,5,6) - 太近了

permalink

https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/17952104/2a6c
我建议干脆摆成类似这个样子 因为你前后的1/2要么是叠起来的要么是1.7间距 现在这样没法读

permalink

好的

permalink

已修改

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:36:419 加个 circle 叠在 01:36:600 (1) - 头上

permalink

这个其实之前有,后来删了

permalink

改了一下

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:37:855 (3,4) - 人声这里在渐强了考虑也改4个圈吧,这样和前面01:34:963 - 难度起码对应

permalink

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:41:479 (3) - 加个NC好看一点

permalink

已添加

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:44:732 (3) - 缩短成1/2滑条,跟人声好一点,毕竟你整个难度都是跟人声为主,这里乐器又不是主要声音

permalink

好的,已修正

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:46:540 (1,2) - 整个ctrl+shift+R 180°,现在这个flow难读

permalink

已修正

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:46:540 (1) - 摆个 2 times reverse 也不大方,直接切换成 2 个 1/2 滑条就行了

permalink
Reopened by Muziyami
permalink

后面也一样,就和 01:55:214 (1,2,3) - 处理方法差不多就行

permalink

好的

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:50:516 - add a note

permalink

好的

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-

01:53:769 (4) - might need a nc here for consistency

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by yf_bmp

01:55:937 (3) - 建议改成单点,其他难度都这么做的

permalink

已修正

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Spring Night-
/