mapped by Mohab500
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 30 November 2018!
nominated by Ryuusei Aika and Nowaie
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:00:000 if there are ugly sliders or combinations, contact me.

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Teky

00:10:777 (1) - make this slider more similar to this 00:07:282 (1) - (Copy and paste them)

permalink

Make 00:38:738 (4) - similar to 00:56:214 (5) - ^

permalink

01:01:457 (3) - make this more symmetrical

permalink

make 00:28:253 (1) - similar to 01:19:806 (1) - also I'd recommend increasing the angle because this is probably hard to read

permalink

00:30:000 (2) - I'd avoid using slider like this in Easy (as in using more simple designs would be preferable) since significant part of the slider is overlapping itself so that the sliderborder in the middle (thus the path of the slider) is little obscured and may cause unnecessary problems for players of this level EDIT: note that there are actually multiple sliders with sort of this but some more some less

permalink

i agree with this, especially for easy

permalink

I agree as well.

permalink

Even though this part is a slow section, I think 00:34:660 deserves to be mapped.

permalink

00:38:738 (4) - strong sound on its tail I'd recommend mapping its end as a circle

permalink

00:42:233 (1) - Not sure how the Spinnerrecoverytime works out for this one. The Ranking Criteria states;

"Spinner recovery time should be at least 4 beats. This is to ensure adequate time to click a hit object following a spinner."

Now, technically you follow that rule with enough time until the next note, but considering that this diff is mapped in a half-bpm style Im not sure how the ruling for that is. Halving the bpm doubles the measures you'd need for the Spinnerrecoverytime, which would place the next possible object onto 00:45:728 - , which eliminates 00:44:855 (1) - .

Idk maybe Im wrong, might want to make sure with a QAT or something.

permalink

A member of the QAT was consulted, waiting for mraihai's response

permalink

repaired some parts of my gd (apologies, storyboard team) http://puu.sh/AHMOh/5e9b845f2d.osu

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Teky

00:48:350 (2) - unclear slider paths arent recommended at all, would not do anything like this

permalink

agreed

permalink

I agree.

permalink

00:49:224 (3) - pretty strong place under sliderend, maybe make it circle instead? (and NC it)

permalink

00:51:845 (1) - avoid having objects touch interface elements (in this case, progress bar)

permalink

00:56:214 (5) - this'd be good to have clicked and all that, much like the previous. Though at the same time as this is missing the vocals it'd also be nice touch to keep this but change the other I guess

permalink

01:11:359 (3) - this sliderend too, having vocals this time as well (maybe like shortening the slider 1/2 and adding the circle or smth)

permalink

01:18:058 (4) - reverse point missing hitsounds? Since the whole point of this slider (rhythm) are those snares back there you should add the hitsounds for this as well

permalink

01:19:806 (1) - unclear slider path

permalink

01:22:500 - spinner all the way until 01:25:340 - ................

permalink

added (but started from 01:22:719 - )

permalink

/

permalink
Marked as resolved by Teky

01:25:340 (4) - Remove this green line if it stays unsused.

permalink

now that line is used.

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Teky
/