mapped by Wonki
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 9 October 2022!
nominated by Kim_GodSSI and Touru0711
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:00:354 (354|4,389|0,424|1,459|2,494|3,529|4,564|5) - 여기 1/5 인것 같은데? 나오는 멜로디 갯수 따져보면

permalink

잘 들어보면

permalink

3개로 되어있음

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

yea I have to say 1/5 is also closer snap for me, for I count the number of time that pitch change

permalink
Reopened by Touru0711

something like : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18163684/c1d1
the blue selected 5 notes are 1/5, and the starting 2 notes are around 1/4
how do you think?

permalink

ok fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:05:843 - according to PR I think u can make some folds to express Piano strength better https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18113146/70ea

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:06:892 (6892|2) - how about col1 I think col1 col 2 is mirrored with col6 and col7 it will make beautiful

permalink

col3 is good i guess

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:06:892 (6892|2) - actually it should be 3 note becuz comparing with 00:09:095 - 00:09:305 - it is more a kick than others

permalink

i think it is ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:16:962 - tbh I prefer 4 notes becuz cymbal and it is the beginning as one part I think it could be stronger

permalink

but it's gonna be hard.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:19:270 (19270|0,19270|4,19270|1,19270|3,19322|5,19375|4,19427|3,19480|5,19480|6,19480|1,19480|2) - this part, personally i will suggest avoid 00:19:270 (19270|4,19375|4) - this jack like what you do at 00:24:305 (24305|2,24305|0,24305|4,24357|5,24410|3,24462|2) - , since the BPM is 286 and the pitch also not support this jack.

but this is kinda subjective so depends on you.

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:19:899 (19899|4) - how about move it to col 7 I think it is more beautiful for pattern

permalink

it's intended pattern

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:20:633 (20633|3) - ghost note

permalink

00:21:053 - 00:21:263 - u should add them one note to keep consistency with 00:20:214 - 00:20:424 - 00:20:633 -

permalink
permalink

good

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:21:892 - is this piano sound intentionally ignored? since it's a bit weird for me to miss here

permalink

good

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:22:102 - actually triple is overmaped it is less strong than 00:22:207 - 00:22:312 - double is enough tbh

permalink

good

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:24:305 - 00:24:515 : it should be piano sounds? I can hear it

permalink

okay

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:26:612 - miss snare

permalink

nice

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:28:815 - how about double it it is synth sounds and stonger than hi hat and so on

permalink

00:28:710 (28710|1,28815|1) - i want to keep this

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:37:312 (37312|5,37312|6,37364|4,37417|1,37417|0,37417|2) - the snap here is weird
what I heard is like : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18160096/0aeb
the blue selected notes are 1/3 and the triple chord is on 1/2 line.
If you have any other intention (simplification or sth), feel free to tell me.

permalink
permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

Subjective issue :
00:37:731 (37731|6,37731|0,37731|5,37731|2,37836|6,37941|0,37941|5,37941|4,37941|2,38046|2,38151|4,38151|0,38151|1,38151|3,38256|3) -
I will suggest rearrange here like what you do at
00:32:696 (32696|2,32696|5,32696|6,32696|0,32801|3,32906|1,32906|4,33011|3,33116|0,33116|5,33221|3) -
Because they are similar rhythm structure and pitch.
Maybe sth like : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18160103/ea67
you can rearrange by yourself if you think my suggestion is bad.

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:40:878 - hmmm I think here triple is enough for only kick (no cymbal), and also better for consistency like 00:41:193 -

permalink

and also 00:41:508 - 00:41:612 - 00:41:717 - 4 3 3 should be fixed like 00:38:990 - 00:39:095 - 00:39:200 - 3 3 4.
so 00:41:508 - triple
|00:41:717 - quad.

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:50:996, 00:51:066 - 1/3 스냅 여기 피아노 사운드 넣어야 00:50:716 (50716|2,50769|1,50821|4,50873|3) - 이부분의 피아노 사운드와 일관성이 맞아짐

permalink

ㅇㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:52:394 - 이랑 02:30:531 -
둘중 어떤걸로 할지 하나로 통일 하셈 근데 소리 없어서 지우는게 타당할듯

permalink

ㅇㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

00:52:394 (52394|6) - 02:30:531 (150531|3) - they're still there?

permalink
Reopened by Touru0711

it means integration into one pattern. so i add 00:52:394 (52394|6) - here

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

oh ok maybe just google translation say sth wrong

permalink

use papago naver 💀

permalink

01:00:262 - hmm single is too less for this kick? I think at least double here

permalink

good

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

01:01:415 - 노트 3개가 맞지 않음 ? 똑같은 소리 나는곳도 01:01:625 - 01:01:730 - 3놋 인데

permalink

02:40:811 - 여기도 마찬가지

permalink

02:50:881 -
그냥 확인차 물어보는거임 4놋도 ㄱㅊ

permalink

ㅇㅇ 일관성만 맞으면 상관없을듯

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

01:02:464 - to 01:02:884 - the snap here is 1/3 not 1/4, but 01:02:884 - to 01:03:094 - is 1/4 right, and also miss a note at 01:03:041 -

permalink

good

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

01:23:234 (83234|2,83339|2,83443|1,83548|1,83653|0,83758|2) - 여기랑 01:23:234 (83234|4,83234|5) - 여기 위치만 바꿔주는게 어떰? 왜냐하면 메인 신즈 음정은 낮고 드럼 사운드는 높은 음정부터 내려가니까 그게 PR에 더 적합할 것 같음

permalink

ㅇㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

01:25:541 - think this should be only triple like 01:25:332 - since they both only have the main melody without any drum, better to be consistent.
suggest remove 01:25:541 (85541|4) -

permalink

01:26:276 - and I will suggest nerf this to double like 01:31:311 - and 01:31:940 - ...etc

permalink

there are based on main sounds. so i choose main sounds to 4 notes. it's seems fine

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

01:27:587 - miss a very strong snare here, if add a note here I guess should nerf 01:27:534 - a bit
and also 01:28:793 (88793|5,88793|4,88846|2) - and 01:32:569 (92569|3,92569|6,92622|2,92622|5) -
it's better to make this 3 places consistent since they're the same.

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

01:29:003 - 여기 드럼 하이햇소리 넣어야 전체적인 일관성에 맞음

permalink

ㅇㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

01:31:066 (91066|4,91136|2) - 이거 스냅 1/4 01:31:101 - 01:31:153 - 임

permalink

ㅇㅇ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

01:37:709 (97709|3,97709|6,97709|2,97814|4,97814|5,97814|1,97919|3,97919|2,98024|4,98024|0,98024|5,98129|2,98129|1,98234|4,98234|3) -
the note usage here is kinda weird, compare with other part in this section. If you want to emphasize 01:37:709 - and 01:38:024 - , should nerf 01:37:814 - to double since you already ignored the snare at 01:38:129 -

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

01:38:915 (98915|6) - 이거 정당성이 그다지 없어 보임 메인 멜로디도 음정이 변하는 것도 아니라서 지우는게 타당할듯

permalink

ㅇㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

01:48:731 (108731|5,108839|0) - 하이햇 소리 굳이 넣어야 함? 다른 소리에 거의 뭍혀서 들리지도 않고 패턴 진행상 1/2 스냅 유지 하는게 더 좋아 보이는데

permalink

넣어야함ㅋㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

01:50:416 - 하이햇 소리 노트 빠짐

permalink

위에 노트를 꽉꽉 넣고싶어서 뺐음

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

02:14:923 - 02:15:133 - 못해도 노트 2개는 넣어야 다른 부분과 일관성에 맞을듯
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/944465282418769980/1025980887600468059/unknown.png
요런식으로 ㄱㄴ

permalink

ㅖㅏ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

02:24:144 - 여기 스냅 02:24:130 - 02:24:144 - 02:24:158 - 1/16 으로 이렇게 해야 피아노랑 스냅이 일치 함
02:24:130 - 여기 안쓴다 한다고 하더라도 02:24:172 (144172|2) - 이건 02:24:158 - 여기로 옮겨야 할듯

permalink

ㅇㅇ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

02:27:594 - maybe triple is enough here? like 02:27:175 - , better for consistency

permalink

ya

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

02:36:930 (156930|4) - I will suggest move this jack to left hand and rearrange the pattern after since the right hand already very intense and already jack 02:36:720 (156720|5,156825|5) - here

permalink

like what you do at 02:46:895 -

permalink

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

02:40:287 - 메인신즈+ 드럼사운드가 들어갔기 때문에 못해도 3놋 이상 해야함

permalink

ㅇㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

02:41:860 - to 02:42:490 -

actual snap here is : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18160179/0395
the blue selected note is actual a bit different with 01:02:604 - (1/6 late).
and 02:42:280 - to 02:42:490 - is also 1/4 again.
so how to rearrange here, depends on you.

permalink

02:42:962 - 드럼소리 노트 빠짐

permalink

ㅇㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

02:50:252 - and 02:50:462 - are there 2 single intentionally? since I can still heard snare here, so only single is too weak I think

permalink

add one note to each

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

02:58:084 (178084|5,178084|4,178154|2,178154|1) - are this 2 double for drum? if so they are 1/4 not 1/3

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

03:03:049 - 이전 규칙 보면 3놋이 맞지 않음 ?
소리도 3놋에 적절 하다고 생각됨

permalink

ㅇㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

03:08:869 - 여기부터 피아노 소리 나는거 노트 안넣는것 보단 LN 하나 넣어서 03:09:357 - 여기까지 채워주는게 더 좋을꺼임

permalink

ㅇㅇ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

03:12:092 (192092|4,192168|5) - 1/5 스냅으로 가야함
03:12:245 (192245|1,192245|2) - 1/7 스냅으로 가야함
03:12:361 (192361|3,192361|4) - 1/9 스냅으로 가야함

permalink

ㅇㅇ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

good

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

03:17:091 -
suggest rearrange like : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18160211/9d26
because I notice you follow pitch strictly in this section so I provide the advice for you.
you can rearrange your own version but at least do not make 03:17:685 - and 03:17:982 - in this same column since they are different pitch.
Also 03:17:982 - and 03:18:576 - are the same pitch so that's why I put like that.

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

03:28:953 (208953|4,208953|3,209186|4,209186|5) - 그냥 오른쪽 한칸 옮기는게 어떰
쉴드 패턴이라 좀 불편함

permalink

패턴상 옮기기는 좀 그럼

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

03:39:882 (219882|1,219932|2,219987|1,220043|2) - 이 한손트릴이 갑자기나와서 조금더 퍼지게놓았으면 좋을듯

permalink

ㅇㅇ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

03:42:301 (222301|4,222415|4,222529|4,222643|4,222757|4,222871|4) - are you sure about this 6 notes jack in 263 BPM? strongly suggest 03:42:529 (222529|4,222529|5,222643|4,222643|5) - to col67 lol

permalink
permalink

ya it's fine. i promise

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

03:54:672 ~ 03:56:980 - 소리에 비해 난이도 spike가 좀 심함 전채적인 패턴이랑 비교 해봐도 조금 언밸런스 하다고도 할 수 있겠음
너프 해야 한다는 의견이 강하게 들음 ㅇㅇ

permalink

208비펨이라 괜찮은거같음

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki

03:56:980 - to 03:59:288 -
This whole section is 1/5 not 1/6, should be fixed.

permalink

good

permalink
Marked as resolved by Wonki
/