<a class="link link--white link--no-underline" href="https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/999770">Haniel no Uta

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

00:06:359

00:06:359 (3,1) - this dash is pretty unclear and can be confused with a walk. would recommend using around 3.6x ds

5 years ago

no salad-player would hit this as a walk. visually, this is fine as is

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

00:10:504

00:10:504 (1,2) - thats a pretty harsh antiflow after the dash. decrease the distance please

5 years agoLast edited by Phob 5 years ago.

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

00:15:522

00:15:522 (1) - remove NC here and put it right here 00:15:740 (2) -

5 years ago

yew

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

00:15:740

00:15:740 (2,3) - why is the dash here instead of at 00:15:522 (1,2) - ? doesn't make much sense to me

5 years ago

2,3 is a walk tho and 1,2 is a dash??

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/14641703/33e6 latest pending version

5 years ago

Reopened by Phob

ncs were different from phob's ver fsr, but this is a dash because the pitch goes noticeably higher there than (1)

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

00:15:958

00:15:958 (2) - Reduce a bit like x:226 to made a more clear dash

5 years ago

00:18:794 (3) - Same thing but slider's start can be in x:109

5 years ago

these distances are clear as is, reducing would rather create ambiguity

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

00:21:849

00:21:849 (5,6) - The movement is a bit confusing if this is a dash or a walk, please made it a bit vertical or reduce distance a bit

5 years ago

00:24:903 (3,4) - Same thing

5 years ago

just reduced distances

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

00:21:892

GIGACHAD

00:21:892 (5,6) - woah this is rather tough make ezier maybe

3 years ago

3 years ago

done

3 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

00:26:213

00:26:213 (1) - Can be reduced a bit the distance like 2,0x to made a clear dash with from 00:25:667 (5) - > 00:26:213 (1) -

5 years ago

this is already a clear dash

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

00:29:267

00:29:267 (6,1) - Increase a bit the distance to have a clear dash because it feels a bit walkable

5 years ago

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

00:31:449

00:31:449 (5) - NC?

5 years ago

5 years ago

5 years ago

not rly needed but k

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

00:48:031

00:48:031 (3,4,5,6) - The movement feels a bit static, so i suggest try with another shape like C

5 years ago

intended for the count, i think its interesting to have it as is so it doesnt feel as overdone

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

00:55:449

00:55:449 (3,1) - a very tight dash and an antiflow after that. oh no

5 years ago

and i oop

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

01:02:431

01:02:431 (2) - horizontal flip? the movement is pretty awkward

5 years ago

feels fine, it gives a more lenient feeling catching the next object imo

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

01:15:958

01:15:958 (2,3,4,5) - gradually increasing the distance doesnt really make sense to me, since all the drum finishes are equally strong

5 years ago

a curved pattern is what i intended here not the gradual spacing increase lol, but i think this works just fine

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

01:18:576

01:18:576 (5) - add NC here and remove here 01:19:449 (1) -

5 years ago

01:20:540 (5) - add here, remove here 01:21:194 (1) -

5 years ago

01:22:285 (3) - add here, remove here 01:22:940 (1) - ?

5 years ago

aslksadd

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

01:19:492

BIG H ZONDA KIT

01:19:492 (1) - could maybe make this a 1/1 slider like you did with 01:21:237 (3) - as sounds follow the same rhythm

3 years ago

01:19:710 and 01:19:819 have additional electronic sounds on them which is the reason I think so the current version is fine imo

3 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

01:20:976

GIGACHAD

01:20:976 (2,3) - A bit ambiguous/weak dash, considering it's high pitch you can buff this a little :3c

5 years ago

sure

5 years ago

resolved

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

01:41:485

01:41:485 (2,3,4,5,6) - it's really dense for a salad. i'd recommend replacing it with a 1/2 triplet

5 years ago

01:42:358 (2,3,4,5,6) - same

5 years ago

5 years ago

5 years ago

5 years ago

5 years ago

01:33:849 (3,4,5,6,7) -

5 years ago

01:34:285 (1,2,3,4,5) -

5 years ago

01:35:158 (1,2,3,4,5) -

5 years ago

these were all intended. keep in mind that this is a second salad, so these streams keep the spread balanced

5 years agoLast edited by Jemzuu 5 years ago.

hmm idk, people hated dense stuff like that in the past, will keep the point open for now

5 years ago

GIGACHAD

I like it, as Jemzuu has mentioned, streams are used for spread balance, it doesn't make the Salad dense whatsoever. It's readable and the way he mapped it fits the map.

5 years agoLast edited by GIGACHAD 5 years ago.

His Salad was mapped before Benny's Salad (and back then there was no plan to implement a second Salad), so Jemzuu couldn't have mapped these streams with the intention to be the harder Salad.

That is no argument against it though. I will close this for now, if other modders have an issue with that they can reopen the point.

5 years ago

Marked as resolved by Sanyi

01:43:449

01:43:449 (2) - make this a vertical slider, so the player doesn't have to make very quick movements and dash after that

5 years ago