mapped by Ryu Sei
submitted
last updated
Hype Train9 / 5
Nomination Status0 / 2
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:03:623 (3623|6) - actually no effect sound, consider remove this or want to keep this concept, move to 00:03:709 instead.

same as 00:06:382 (6382|7) - , move to 00:06:468?
also 00:09:140 (9140|8) -

permalink

Keeping as an augmentation despite mapping to no sound

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

00:09:490 (9490|8,9662|9) - Subjective but wouldn't this be a bit uncomfortable for a layout where both of these are hit with the same finger on the keyboard? Could argue that players could work around it but I think at normal that's a bit too much to ask.

Would flip.

permalink

Sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

00:10:347 (10347|1,10519|10,10692|1) - is there a reason to move col2-11 not just kept concept trill at col3-10?

permalink

Do not neglect pinky fingers

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

00:17:071 (17071|2,17244|0) - this movement seems too hard consider it is Normal diff, suggest ctrl+h 00:17:244 (17244|0,17416|11,17588|0,17761|11,17933|1,17933|6) -

permalink

I was going to ignore the request but you linked the scratches, sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

00:17:766 (17766|0,17938|1) - On my layout that would be pinky -> ring finger, for sane people that'd be ring -> middle finger (I'd point it out even in a 7K map) and that's not the most comfortable thing to hit imo esp on 1/2. Would break it apart.

permalink

Still manageable since the finger position would be already moving

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

I'd like to bring this up, yes - this pattern can be played, but against everything else it seems rather awkward

permalink
Reopened by XRedyRatyX

I will simplify this to single LN

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

00:20:864 (20864|9,21037|2) - I think you missed placing kick note at 00:20:950, please make sure about this

permalink

Intended simplification to 1/2 instead of complex 3/4s

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

00:26:387 (26387|10,26731|10,27076|9) - Maybe emphasize the piano more with something like this?

permalink

No changes, too much hand movement is scary

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

00:27:588 (27588|3,27761|8,27933|3,28106|8) - this part is only not following basic kick+minor synth in previous part (00:24:830 - 00:27:244), there is no reason to follow piano sound although breaking your pattern rule in this phase. Re-consider about this.

permalink

No changes, since the layering fits

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

00:29:830 (29830|4) - should it be moved to col4 or somewhere considering your pattern rule in this phase?

permalink

No changes because 00:24:313 (24313|7) - still on same column too

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

00:31:904 (31904|1,32249|1,32593|2) - Could all be the same column for consistency with 00:29:145 (29145|4,29490|4,29835|4) -

permalink

Keeping with previous pattern

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

00:38:283 (38283|5) - This could be on the right hand too to preserve the pattern of some notes on one side + clap effects only for the other side.

permalink

Also no changes to emphasize hats

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

00:42:071 (42071|5,42071|6) - 00:43:450 (43450|6,43450|5) - can't figure what is your intention. I don't think you need to add double.

permalink

There is a sub bass and snare

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

00:55:519 (55519|1,55692|10,55864|2,56037|9,56209|3,56382|8) -

00:55:175 (55175|1,55347|10) - and 00:55:519 (55519|1,55692|10) - have different progression, suggest rearrange above pattern like this:

permalink

Leaving this open to other mapper's opinions

permalink

Agree with rurv, but dont feel strongly abt it

permalink

Yeah, it is. I rearranged to the similar pattern

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

01:13:450 (73450|1,74140|1) - suggest move to another col not make pinky based 01:13:450 (73450|1,74140|1,74485|1,75002|1,75347|1) - .

also need to move 01:14:830 (74830|10,75519|10) - for consistency.

permalink

The intended mapping style I am aiming for is arcade layout, so it can be played without pinky.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

01:47:766 (107766|0) - Could remove since it makes a 1/2 thing inside a 3/4 thing. Does match the music but for the players, especially since the scratches are on either side, this may be hard to detect esp at a lower scroll speed so I think removing would make for a better playing experience.

permalink

The simplification would make it weirder, so I leave it as-is

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei

01:49:140 (109140|5,109313|5,109485|5) - 01:49:830 (109830|6,110002|6,110175|6) - isn't it too hard to dealt thumb jack with scratch? Also it is clearly violating RC, please disperse this.

permalink

Intended single notes because #4836632/12811909

permalink
Marked as resolved by Ryu Sei
/