mapped by Erowdi
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 22 November 2023!
nominated by arcpotato and op45667
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

“instrumental” 😹😹😹

permalink

mhm

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

y is "laundry" in tags if it's already title?

also add "pop" to tags since u have jpop and j-pop

could maybe add "instrumental" since technically around 30% of the song doesn't have vocals but u don't really have to

permalink

i would consider vocaloid an instruments so ye changed. additionally i added j for ''j pop''

also adjusted tags like removing laundry and shikiura from tags

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

idk how it was x2
but now laundry and shikiura both unncessarily included in tags

permalink
Reopened by BlackBN

also consider adding 歌愛ユキ Kaai Yuki as the vocaloid character which stated in yt video
and 清楚mol as the illustrator

permalink

removed unnecessary tags

added epic gamer tags u suggested along with kai for Kai Yuki (makes it easier to search for the vocaloid character)

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

really don't agree with instrumental as a tag though as someone looking for instrumental songs won't want a song that's a majority japanese? i could understand it if it was really chopped up vocals but it's super audible lol

permalink
Reopened by meiqth

The vocals are recognizable, yes, but i think the instruments stand out a lot more here than the actual vocals themself. Its oftenly also just repeated words. + the tag imo wont do as much removed or not

Altho not a mod that was applied 1999712#3761739 i do feel like its fine to use as an example to justify the tag here.

permalink

Also 33% of instruments is a large portion considering this song is only like 30sec.

permalink

every song has instruments to every song should be instrumental Imo

permalink

Instrumental implies the song (not a part) has no vocals, the prevalence of them means nothing as long as you know theyre there

  • usaha's point gets the gist
permalink

I do feel like a portion of the vocals are kinda chopped up as well, like the repeating vocals part.

permalink

Even if u dont agree, this is a rly minor tag thing eitherway. The tag kinda makes sense

permalink

dont want to waste my time with this

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

00:11:045 - 00:21:288 - 00:31:525 - wanna unfinisher these on all diffs instead cuz like it's nowhere near as strong as the two finishers surrounding it

permalink

ya

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi


don't really think having SV multiplier different on every diffs is acceptable as

  1. it violates rc

The base slider velocity should be 1.40 throughout all difficulties of a beatmap. This is to ensure optimal quantity of notes on the playfield, as well as the optimal distance of separation between different notes.

  1. bpm is not really that low needs you to slowdown the kantan, currently ~1.2 is making the notes too clustered and the scroll speed is not normalized which new players cannot be get used to.

however i would respect your intention to have higher scroll speed in top diff. therefore please consider following changes:
k/f/m/o 1.4
i 1.5

permalink

it doesnt violate a rule but a guideline, although i believe this is fine to have (with some small changes because imo 1,22 on kantan doesnt make much sense given the other values are on 0/5), whether you add a 0.9x greenline or change base sv to 1.3x doesnt make a difference at all :p

permalink

even at this low of base sv on the kantan / futsuu its still relatively fast, i dont get why u problem stamped this.

this is a guideline, an incredibly loose and justifiable guideline to break. this is readable, playable, this doesn't impact anything other than it feeling a little bit slower than expected. if u want playtesters, ig sure fine.

permalink

since youve completely dropped this set due to base sv reasons, im going to resolve :/ this should go as far as a suggestion stamp if anything

arc taking over, ty <3

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

00:03:028 - useless greenline accidently added?

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

depends on you but now
first offset is 1605 and preview time is 1608
you might wanna unify them

permalink

3ms isnt noticable so keep

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

yt vid description featured a dl link for this song as a wav, idk why you have a 128 one or ripped it off yt in that case but heres a 192 one i converted from the wav file: click
spek:

permalink
permalink

yoinked from a different set and debloated down to 128 cuz it was hella unrankable, will check

permalink

what the din dan diggidy doo this is a instrumental audio. wheres the vocaloid, keep for now cuz i wanna keep the vocaloiddidi

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

MY BAD

permalink

update: i found a 192 ogg one WITH VOCALS THIS TIME which i sent to erowdi in dms

permalink

finally applied it, goated tyvm

permalink

idk how it was x3
but now it is a 128 mp3

permalink
Reopened by BlackBN

#3963753/10592758 ass osu, should work now -w-----w-w-w-w-w

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

would -3ms to get closer to accurate offset

make sure to resnap kiais and notes

permalink

Very minimal + i think current is more accurate

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

there are some sounds that hit -6 so I'd rather not get qa'd later.

permalink
Reopened by op45667

Yup 👍 discussed irc ill recheck later

permalink

just went with it 1605

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

im not really sure how it was but

  • currently is 1608 not 1605
  • im keep hitting late

how about +4 or so?

permalink
Reopened by BlackBN

#3963753/10592758 Ig there was more stuff that osu just didnt apply ;-;

permalink

#3840296/10626175

did 1605, personal works better for me -- ty for pointing it out tho

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

considering the overall difficulty and note count i think the hp settings are too harsh, espeically with such bpm.
i respect you to keep the high hp settings, but could you consider to nerf them a bit? like making MOI to 987?

permalink

personally i wouldnt consider it too harsh IMO

https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/1960489#taiko/4062833 bad example, but even at 148 note count u could pass with shit acc d ranks even at hp10 1960489#3696286

so keeping for now -w-

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

This beatmap set was updated by the mapper after a nomination. Please ensure to re-check the beatmaps for new issues. If you are the mapper, please comment in this thread on what you changed.

permalink

osu forgot to save some of the stuff i applied so had to reapply them ;-;

TLDR; osu fucking sucks

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

bg source to desc

permalink

Not quite necessary. #3815404 Did here with metadata cuz thumbnail is the bg

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

its from yt thumbnail dont think it needs to be sourced

permalink

based off the ranked sets the artist name should be capitalized as "Shikiura." unless you can back it up that the current one is accurate cuz i can't find any source regarding it except for some wiki post lol

permalink

while researching idk why people were using the period in the artist's name because that period isn't used in their artist handles? rly weird

permalink

older videos had the dot in the name https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vSYBPIbeoek&ab_channel=%E5%BC%8F%E6%B5%A6%E8%BA%81%E5%90%BE check description.

which translates to Shikiura.

eitherway ye fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Erowdi

i think its fine to keep the dot for ranked consistency reasons

permalink

alright didnt know, keep the dot in that case ye

permalink
/