mapped by Chrisse
submitted
last updated
This beatmap wasn't updated since 8 April 2023 so it was graveyarded...
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:00:158 - your intro provides very inconsistent emphasis for the trills, sometimes you have two note trills (e.g. 00:00:513), sometimes two plus one (e.g. 00:07:613), sometimes three on each, etc. I'd suggest coming up with a consistent trill pattern because this causes very imbalanced strain over the course of this section.

permalink

fixed, idk what was going on here xd

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

00:00:513 (513|1) - would move this note to col3 to emphasis the special melody https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18510397/564b

permalink
permalink

oki added

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

implemented in my own way

permalink

ok

permalink

00:04:418 (4418|0,4595|1) - 00:04:773 (4773|2,4950|3) - 00:05:128 (5128|0,5305|2) - these note can on the same column because they have same pitches

permalink

added

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse
  • idk if you recharted in another way this section, but i agree with this suggestion, do something like 02:37:258 (157258|0,157436|0) - ( obv without ln's that's just a example )
permalink
Reopened by Relae

ye i had originally mapped it like this after this mod, but a little misunderstanding on my part later happened, but should be fixed now

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

00:05:483 (5483|1,5660|1) - this doesnt necessarily need to be a jack (the two notes are different pitches) but you can keep it plays fine

permalink

removed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

00:10:098 - I hope the location of the long notes is in the order of 2,1 instead of 1,2 col.
https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18526124/c5a7

permalink

added

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

I think this note need to be remove 00:10:453 (10453|2) - and this Ln 00:10:276 (10276|1) - should end here 00:10:631 according what you are trying to emphazise

permalink
permalink

Well.. also here 01:18:442 (78442|2,78619|3) - 01:29:802 (89802|2,89980|1) - and maybe some other

permalink

hm i think ill keep as is as there is a clear sound here 00:10:453 - in a slightly different pitch than the one before

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

00:11:518 - on many of the sounds like this (other examples include 00:12:939, 00:14:359, 00:17:199, etc.) theres a sound that ends on the red line so i'd suggest making one of the notes that's part of these chords a 1/2 ln (while keeping the original 1/1 ln)

permalink

added, also to similar parts

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

00:17:021 any reason you don't map this as a double? it sounds like a snare is here, a noise you have mapped with doubles.

permalink

ok added for similar parts as well

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

[ if you apply this mode here do something similar at 01:18:264 / 01:29:625 / 02:26:430 / 03:48:797 ]

permalink

ok added

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

00:36:903 sounds like a snare is here to me so why is it represented as a single?

permalink

added

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

00:40:631 - missed double, and move 00:40:808 (40808|1) to col4

permalink
permalink

Maybe you omitted it for a reason, but I think it should be mapped

permalink

Done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

Consistency issue 00:43:116 (43116|2) - This Ln is unnecessary if you are mapping the vocal it should be normal note instead and this 00:42:939 (42939|0) - should be extended to 00:43:294 or 00:43:471 according to what you did for this 00:37:081 (37081|3,37258|2,37436|0,37436|3) - using the earlier reason this part 00:38:501 (38501|3,38678|2,38856|0,38856|1,39033|2) - should also be changed. Well choose one

permalink

Same goes for these 01:45:424 (105424|3) - 01:46:666 (106666|3) - 01:50:927 (110927|2,111104|0) - and maybe some more

permalink

agreed with first part so added but the two parts mentioned have different vocals with different hold times

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

00:45:601 - triples feel far too intense for this section, singles are enough to represent the music and they differ from the previous section enough to emphasize the calmness

permalink

re: this can also be combined with #3644737 so you'd remove the triples and instead represent some of the countermelody

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

00:46:134 -> 00:46:844 I find it odd that you don't represent the melody on the red ticks as its very audible. if you are concerned about the jacks that will come from it then I can see why but it shouldn't be too hard for players to hit since its relatively not that hard of a pattern.

permalink

if you do this suggestion, you can add notes at 00:47:554 -> 00:48:264, 00:48:974 -> 00:49:684, 00:51:104, (skipped 00:50:039 since it's really quiet) 00:51:814 -> 00:52:524, 00:53:234 -> 00:53:944, 00:54:655 -> 00:56:430

permalink

tried to make it interesting now, added

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

moved to col 1

also yes it was intentional, but i think i can make it better

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

If it like what it is now the pattern is very hard compare to the rest of the map should be rearrange but I dont think it a problem keeping it

permalink

00:57:850 - In this section, I would double 00:57:939 - and single 00:58:027 - because it is a kick-snare-kick section. Like https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18510409/6e38

permalink

00:59:359 - // 01:00:779 - // 01:02:199 - // 01:03:619 - ...etc

permalink

in this particular section the doubles represents not the snares, but i understand your point

i will keep open to for other opinions, as im not 100% sure

permalink

Closed, feel free to reopen

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

00:58:205 - maybe double? It is a snare

permalink

#3641395/9774857 same as here

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

01:02:288 (62288|3,62288|0,62643|0,62643|3) - Is there any special reason to use 2 LNs?

permalink

removed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

02:10:453 - same here

permalink

01:31:045 you can add a double here since the kick here is loud enough + you map kicks of the same intensity right after with doubles.

permalink

agree

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

01:48:086 - it is the only triple in the section. Make sure it is reasonable

permalink

00:39:743 - made double here aswell

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse
permalink

fix

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

fix

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

02:44:625 (164625|3) - maybe on 02:44:714 - ? or as the only 1/4 jack I would avoid it

permalink

changed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

02:52:347 - should be double i think

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

03:04:418 (184418|0) -
03:10:098 (190098|0) - Subjective, I think it can be replaced with a circle to express the piano, to distinguish the vocals

permalink

yes added

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

It still Ln not circle or you didnt update it yet

permalink

should be updated now

permalink

How about underpowering this part a bit 03:26:430 (206430|2,206607|3,206785|1,206785|0,207140|3,207140|2,207140|1) - because it like a bridge to the peak of the map maybe making it smaller would make the chorus feel wayyy better. Maybe remove 03:26:607 (206607|3) - 03:26:785 (206785|1) - 03:27:140 (207140|1) -

permalink

ty for mods also would like to keep for consistency sake, but ill ask for 2nd opinion c:

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

03:52:879 - There is the same thing as this one 03:52:169 (232169|1) here

permalink

in this section the notes were mainly placed for the du sound, but i agree that these sounds should be represented so added

permalink
Marked as resolved by Chrisse

made some changes here in general

permalink
/