Guest
home
beatmaps
rankings
community
store
help
beatmap discussion
discussion

JUST LIKE WE NEVER SAID GOODBYE

SOPHIE

1.75
[4K] Mich's NORMAL
1.75
[4K] Mich's NORMAL guest difficulty by Mich_
2.49
[4K] Drater's HARD guest difficulty by DraterTD
2.91
[4K] Bei's ADVANCED guest difficulty by Bei
3.09
[4K] GOODBYE
Filter by user
Everyone
AndreyChomik
DraterTD
fvrex
Maxus
Mich_
peppy
Relae
snomi
the blue frawog
Mine
0
Notes
0
Resolved
3
Pending
2
Praises
23
All
29
Guest difficulty by Mich_
2:44
143
257
419
mapped by Chappell Roan
submitted
last updated
Beatmap Page
Hype Train18 / 5
Nomination Status0 / 2
Disqualified by peppy with new problem #4826132 (
Unrank request (difficulty spread and other issues)
).
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Hype
Sign in and hype this beatmap to make it more visible for nomination and ranking!
PraiseSuggestionProblem
Discussions
Sort by
Maxus

Hello.

We are here to expand on the recent unrank that occurred, to give some insight on the issues that caused the map to be unranked.

Right now, the top difficulty has plenty of long jacks at 143 BPM. The difficulty by itself is undoubtedly not an Insane, reaching Extra territory. In turn, this makes the spread gap skip the Insane difficulty and make the spread unrankable as a result, on top of the difficulty spikes it creates. The last longjack at 02:37:806 in particular, reaching a total of 64 notes, caused the biggest of gaps and difficulty issues.

Moreover the extremely long one hand trill in Drater's HARD on the same timestamp is also not appropriate for its difficulty.

--------

To solve the issues of this unrank:

  1. Add a difficulty between Drater's HARD and GOODBYE difficulty. This may depend on how much the top difficulty gets nerfed in the process.

  2. The 64 notes long jack needs to go. They need to be replaced by more spread out jackhammers that are easier to hit and don't cause an inappropriate difficulty spike. This also applies to the Hard difficulty's long trill at the very end.

Last edited by Maxus .
permalink
Akasha-

Reposting this from maniahub thread discussion for a bit of transparency. Here's a crafted idea that you can go with considering the map's nature
02:37:806 - till 02:41:163 -

02:41:163 - till 02:44:520 -

permalink
Chappell Roan

I followed Akasha's idea. I will upload the map with the remapped ending.

permalink
Relae

for the hard difficulty it can just follow the top diff by mirroring the pattern on the other hand or it does need at least a 1/2 pause between? just to make sure

Last edited by Relae .
permalink
Akasha-

that'll also heavily depend on the diff that bridges between Hard and top diff
since jack and trill are 2 different categories, It would have been better that they get split out evenly
For example, the new Insane can use 4 jacks and switch col on each 1/1, and then hard diff can be nerfed into minijack or we can have the trill like above

see what's in between them first then decide the best outcome

permalink
peppy

Unrank request (difficulty spread and other issues)

Denied from obtaining kudosu.
permalink
RandomeLoL

For the record:

  • This was requested by us (osu!mania NAT), peppy facilitated the unrank. Please do not throw them any shade.
  • Map currently suffers from a spread gap between Drater's HARD and GOODBYE far too big to ignore. The current longjacks (particularly 02:37:806) are unfitting for an Insane difficulty. Moreover, the gap created with the previous difficulty is unreasonably big in no small part because of the top diff's reliance on long and straining jackhammers.
permalink
Chappell Roan

never once in my mapping experience would i expect peppy to unrank my map

permalink
snomi

oops.

permalink
/