Guest
home
beatmaps
rankings
community
store
help
forum
  1. Forums
  2. Beatmaps
  3. Ranked Beatmaps (Archived)

Regina Spektor - The Call

posted
Total Posts
43
Mok
1,226 posts
Joined August 2009
Topic Starter
Mok
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on martedì 31 gennaio 2012 at 13:32:25

Artist: Regina Spektor
Title: The Call
Source: The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian
Tags: Trilogy Soundtrack DiamondCrash
BPM: 91
Filesize: 4763kb
Play Time: 02:58
Difficulties Available:
  1. DC's Easy (1,83 stars, 204 notes)
  2. Hard (2,17 stars, 213 notes)
  3. Normal (1,91 stars, 205 notes)
Download: Regina Spektor - The Call
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
Trying to map something new from my style :3
Timing by Selee, thanks <3

[Easy]: Done, by DiamondCrash, thanks! <3
[Normal]: Done!
[Hard]: Done!
Open to guest difficulties. Move to Pending!
Any help will be appreciate!
Last edited by Mok , edited 30 times in total.
Selee
1,556 posts
Joined February 2010
Selee
Timing:

1st redline:

BPM: 91.00
Offset: 1,430
(Because vocals are often off time about 20~30ms....That's the best I can have...)

2nd redline:

BPM: 78.000
Offset: 176,805
..

One of my fav songs..so star~
Mok
1,226 posts
Joined August 2009
Topic Starter
Mok
Thanks a lot! *^*
aRiskOfRain
osu! Alumni
1,367 posts
Joined June 2009
aRiskOfRain
yo.

Download: Regina Spektor - The Call (Mok) [DC's Easy].osu
cesc
1,066 posts
Joined August 2008
cesc
Bella bella bella.

[General]
- tutto ok, le difficoltà sono semplici ma non si potrebbe fare altrimenti, vero? Se riesci a trovare dei nomi originali da dare alle difficoltà sarebbe molto meglio secondo me

[DC's Easy]
- nice.

[Normal]
- secondo me è troppo vicina alla Easy come difficoltà, aumenta di 1 l'HP Drain Rate. (suggerimento spasimato, almeno il criterial gli da un pò di distacco e in gioco quasi non si sente)
- qualche NewComboMod, per evitare che a volte le combo arrivino fino a 12, ovviamente si tratta di suggerimenti:
SPOILER
00:31:759 (8) - Add
01:44:946 (5) - Add
02:24:177 (7) - Add
02:35:056 (9) - Add
02:53:517 (8) -
- gli hitsounds sono un pò senza sapore ma per me vanno bene. (Ci ridarei un'occhiata comunque)

[Hard]
02:29:616 (2) - scusa ma questo va fuori tempo secondo me

Non c'è tanto da segnalare, io avrei fatto in modo diverso Combo e HitSounds...spero che vada bene anche ai capi in alto...
Comunque bella sì, ma ti fa venire un sooonno!
narakucrimson
osu! Alumni
1,713 posts
Joined March 2010
narakucrimson
What a beautiful song ;w;

[General]
  1. I get the feeling that the volume until 43:462 should be a little louder. Consider rising it by a tick, or maybe a little less.
  2. I'd never seen a map with 3 diffs with just two stars xD
[Normal]
  1. 04:726 (6) - I think moving this one grid down and one grid left would look more consistent.
  2. 16:924 (4) - Moving this two grids right would make it look more symmetrical.
  3. 35:056 (4) - Add a whistle? :)
  4. 01:05:386 (1-5) -
    SPOILER
    Also, add a whistle on (5).
  5. 01:10:990 (4) - Whistle again (just in the beggining)
  6. 02:16:594 (2) -1 grid right (with grid level 3 on, that is)
  7. 02:40:331 (x) - Add a circle, maybe?
[Hard]
  1. 01:759 (3) - Symmetry nazi :3
    SPOILER
  2. 01:38:353 (2) - This could be more symmetric, too. And (4) too.
  3. 01:52:858 (5) - ^
  4. 01:58:133 (3) - ^
Not muchto say in general. It's pretty cool.

Have a star
Aleks719
osu! Alumni
2,436 posts
Joined May 2010
Aleks719
General
uh-oh. I don't like this timing (+20 - +50 ms early), but I can't suggest anything better.

DC's Easy
good for me

Normal
too quiet hitsounds, I can't hear majority of them
00:21:869 (6) - add whistle
00:22:529 (1) - remove whistle, add finish
00:27:473 (4) - add whistle
00:27:803 (5) - remove whistle from the start, add finish at the start
00:37:034 (7) - add whistle
02:00:111 (4) - this slider is potential combo-breaker) I was waiting only 1 reverse. Fix it, if you can
02:15:605 (6) - replace it on to 02:15:276 (1/2 early)
02:44:287 (4) - remove reverse
02:45:276 (x) - add note here

Hard
too quiet hitsounds again
00:46:594 (8) - nc ?
00:53:847 (7) - add finish
00:54:506 (1) - remove finish, add whistle
00:54:177 (8) - add note + nc here?
00:55:166 (3) - remove whistle from the start, add finish at the start
00:57:803 (5) - add finish
02:02:089 (4) - remove whistle
02:15:935 (5) - add finish
02:24:506 (x) - add note


that's all, star
Kurai
osu! Alumni
7,734 posts
Joined March 2009
Kurai
General
- Capitalize the "t" in "the Prince Caspian" in the source ?
- Disable the countdown in all difficullties, you don't use it.

Normal
01:05:056 - Add a circle here ?
02:40:001 (5) - I think this note don't suit the song, and I suggest you to remove it

Hard
00:47:254 (9) - New combo ?
01:16:594 - Add a note here ?

Star~
Mok
1,226 posts
Joined August 2009
Topic Starter
Mok
Thanks guys :D
Thunderstorm
437 posts
Joined May 2009
Thunderstorm
ThunderMod

Some suggestions, that can be ignored as well

<<Overall>

EEE pattern... Original stuff, never see something like it =)

<<DS's Easy>>

00:14:616 (5) - new combo?
00:16:594 (1) - remove new combo?
00:17:913 (3) - new combo?

Some notes here is going almost outside of the screen/touching HP bar. Maybe respace it?
Following samples:
01:12:309 (3,4)
01:13:957 (1)
01:24:506 (1)
01:56:155 (3)
02:01:759 (1,2)
02:36:704 (3,4)

<<Normal>>

00:11:979 (7,1) - swap new combo?
01:04:726 (7,1) - ^
02:03:408 (6) - new combo?

<<Hard>>

00:35:056 (6) - I'd suggest to delete these slider and put some notes/sliders instead here 00:35:056; 00:35:715; 00:36:045; 00:36:375; 00:37:034
00:43:627 (4) - new combo?
Some notes here is going almost outside of the screen/touching HP bar. Maybe respace it?
Following samples:
01:16:924 (2,3)

That's all
Mok
1,226 posts
Joined August 2009
Topic Starter
Mok
Fix'd some, i suppose DC will fix on his own. :)
lolcubes
osu! Alumni
4,437 posts
Joined November 2010
lolcubes
Hey, here's my mod. Green stuff can be ignored completely, they are merely design opinions and some nazi stuff.

[General]:
  1. I suggest that you rename the diffs, you can't make a 'Hard' diff for this kind of map.
[DC's Easy]:
  1. 01:54:836 - Add a timing section here which increases the volume of the hit sounds a little. The song gets progressively louder here and increasing the hit sound volume would sound better (not by much though).
  2. 02:00:111 - ^
  3. 02:02:748 - Revert back to normal volume here, the one you used before 01:54:836.
[Normal]:
  1. 00:08:353 (4) - I don't like how this slider looks. Try this.
  2. 00:11:979 (7) - ^
  3. 00:22:528 - Add a timing section here and increase the volume by a little.
  4. 00:31:759 (1,2,3,4) - Spacing. Move 2,3,4 by 1 grid to the left. You can try using grid level 4 to space this better as well.
  5. 01:05:386 (2,3,4,5,6) - Spacing. Use grid level 4, it will be much easier to shape a star without spacing issues. Like this.
  6. 01:13:957 (1) - I don't know if this was your intention, but remove whistle from the slider. Instead, add whistle to the start, middle and end points. Sounds better.
  7. 01:54:836 - Add a timing section here which increases the volume of the hit sounds a little. The song gets progressively louder here and increasing the hit sound volume would sound better (not by much though).
  8. 02:00:111 - ^
  9. 02:02:748 - Revert back to normal volume here, the one you used before 01:54:836.
[Hard]:
  1. AR -1. I know that you're trying to make it hard, but that just doesn't fit with the song.
  2. In general I think you used too many long sliders. Most of them can be shortened and filled with circles in between them. I will not say which ones exactly cause you wanted to map like this, so it's just a suggestion.
  3. 00:22:528 - Add a timing section here and increase the volume by a little.
  4. 00:37:364 (7,8,9) - Spacing. I know that grid allows (9) to be placed like this, but rather mirror it with (7). So, 1 grid to the left on (9).
  5. 00:43:627 (1) - (nazi) 1 grid up so it mirrors (8) from the last combo.
  6. 01:15:276 (1) - I don't know if this was your intention, but remove whistle from the slider. Instead, add whistle to the start of the slider.
  7. 01:17:913 (4) - ^
  8. 01:31:100 (1,2,3,4) - Why stack these? Just split them up, it's 'Hard' we're talking about here. Try this.
  9. 01:52:858 (5) - Remove whistle, then add whistle to the start, middle and end of the slider only.
  10. 01:54:836 - Add a timing section here which increases the volume of the hit sounds a little. The song gets progressively louder here and increasing the hit sound volume would sound better (not by much though).
  11. 01:58:133 (3) - Remove whistle, then add whistle to the start, middle and end of the slider only.
  12. 02:00:111 - Add a timing section here which increases the volume of the hit sounds a little. The song gets progressively louder here and increasing the hit sound volume would sound better (not by much though).
  13. 02:08:023 - Revert back to normal volume here, the one you used before 01:54:836.
  14. 02:15:935 (5) - New combo.
  15. 02:17:254 (7) - Remove this slider. Make 3 circles at 02:17:254, 02:17:583 and 02:18:243 instead.
  16. 02:57:381 (5) - Remove this slider. Add a circle at 02:57:574, a circle at 02:57:958 and a circle at 02:58:343 instead.
  17. 02:58:535 - Add a spinner here and make it last until 03:00:651. Also, make this spinner silent.
That's about it. The song is hard to map cause it's slow and timing change sometimes, so here's a well deserved star. :3
Kurowolfe
459 posts
Joined June 2010
Kurowolfe
Hi there~
Sorry for the late response. Got migraine suddenly... :?

Nway, your song's quite unique, coz all of them are Easy. A bit confusing though. Here's my take on your maps:
kurohacker's mod (^^)
[DC's Easy]
Some of the notes and sliders are too close to the top and bottom of the screen, IMO. You can reduce the distance spacing to 0.9x
to preserve the arrangement of the notes (which I like) and readjust everything to this spacing. A lot of work, but it'll be worth the effort.

1:45:935 - 2:02:089 - I think the hitsounds' volume can be increased during this period, since the horn is quite loud.
Maybe use normal hitsounds, but with a lower volume?
1:55:495 [2] - Kinda out of place comparing with the violin, maybe you could remove this one?
2:00:440 [7] - New combo here.
2:09:671 [3] - New combo here.
2:23:517 [1,2,3] - Shorten slider [1] by having it end at 2:24:012, and pull both [2] and [3] 1/4 beat earlier. This fits better with the singer.
2:47:583 - Maybe a circle here?

[Normal]
I think the hitsounds' volume can be increased throughout the whole song. You can use DC's Easy map for reference of changing
hitsound volume.

0:03:408 - Maybe a circle here?
0:34:397 - Same as above.
0:39:342 [2,3] - How about arranging them like so --->
0:48:572 [4] - New combo here.
1:36:375 [spinner] - Add a finish here.
1:41:320 - Maybe add a circle here?
1:51:539 [1] - Try adding another reverse here.
2:15:276 [6] - New combo here.
2:23:188 [5] - Same as above.
2:31:759 [4] - Pull this one to 2:31:429 instead. And make it a new combo.
2:36:045 [2-3] - Delete [2], and pull the old [3] two 1/4 beats forward.
2:40:331 - Maybe add a note here?
2:52:199 [5] - New combo here.
2:54:836 [4] - Same as above.

[Hard]
Same advice for the hitsounds here.

0:10:660 [1] - Delete new combo here, and....
0:11:649 [2] - Start here instead.
0:22:858 [3,4] - Maybe delete the [3] here, and pull the old [4] to this spot. Add a circle two 1/4 beats later.
0:30:440 - Maybe new combo here.
0:34:397 [5] - Same here.
0:46:594 [1] - Delete new combo here, and....
0:47:254 [2] - Start here instead.
1:19:232 [5,6] - Push them two 1/4 beats later.
1:36:704 [spinner] - Add a finish here.
2:26:484 [1] - Delete new combo here.
2:37:034 [4-6] - I suggest you change them into --->
2:57:381 [5] - Extend the slider to end at 2:59:881 instead.

I really love the song, so one star for you~
All the best with your maps! :)

Mok
1,226 posts
Joined August 2009
Topic Starter
Mok
Thanks! DC will fix on his own :2
XepherX3
625 posts
Joined September 2008
XepherX3
very nice and calm song

x3 mod log:

bpm = 91,300

star from moi
IceBeam
osu! Alumni
1,957 posts
Joined December 2009
IceBeam
I love her,not sure if I'm too late,but'll try to mod it.

Normal is the only difficulty with enabled countdown,disable?

Add DC to Tags?

[Easy]
Well,I understand that it's hard to map without rhytm in the song,but still it could be easier,I believe.
00:35:715 (3) - Why distance is so wrong? You can depend only on distance here,and that's why I missed.Please fix it.
01:17:913 (3) - ^
01:28:462 (3) - ^

[Normal]
01:51:539 (1) - Not a big deal,but it's the first overlap I've seen in the map,so it looks more like untidy.

I'd suggest to use finishes as DC did like from here 02:29:122~ They'd fit this epic part.

[Hard]
Don't have much to say.
As I said above this map is about following clear distance spacing.There're really few moments I was depending on music/vocals.
So different spacing and jumps make it not hard to play,but to read.A lot.
And probably 1/4 is overmap.

I really love Regina Spektor,and I deeply respect people who tries to map songs that seem unmappable to others.

But I'm not sure if I can help anyhow,so just take my star and good luck.
Mok
1,226 posts
Joined August 2009
Topic Starter
Mok
Thanks a lot for you're mod, and sorry if my map is overmapped, i only map as i feel the song, but i accept every kind of consideration on it, so state if it is really overmapped, and in which parts. >_<
IceBeam
osu! Alumni
1,957 posts
Joined December 2009
IceBeam
Nah,it's okay,the only thing is:

IceBeam wrote:

And probably 1/4 is overmap.
But as I remember there were few of it,and what's about spacing,just to me,it was hard to read some jumps because I can't really depend on music/rhytm. I was used to read your rhytm only from straight spacing.

But yeah,it's Hard,it's used to be so.

Just wanted to say that not every map should be hard.Beautiful song,it's relaxing,so maybe Normal was enough.
Well,it's only my opinion ;)
rEdo
809 posts
Joined November 2008
rEdo
[DC's Easy]
nothing really. (:

[Normal]
0:04:726 (6) - spacing
0:22:528 (x) - 20% at that point is just too loud, i'd suggest trying 15%, and than adding 20% at 0:43:627.
0:43:627 (1) - finish at its beginning?
1:39:671 (4) - spacing
1:59:451 (2) - spacing
2:00:111 (4) - kinda useless volume boost at that point u.u
2:47:254 (7) - move it a grid higher?
2:49:232 (2) - ^

[Hard]
0:22:528 (x) - pretty much like before
1:52:199 (4) - new combo?
2:26:155 (3,4) - is this jump making any sense? u.u
2:29:616 (2) - this 1/4 note doesn't follow music at all, i'd try moving it onto the previous red tick
2:57:574 (5) - make it 1/1 length, and place it at the white tick.


you've chosen a hard song to map, but yet you did some good work with it :3
good luck!
wcx19911123
3,862 posts
Joined June 2010
wcx19911123
HI

[General]
offset-5?

[DC's Easy]
awesome diff

[Normal]
01:05:386 (2,3,4,5,6) - spacing

[Hard]
00:53:847 (7,1,2) - spacing
01:38:353 (2) - symmetrical?
01:40:990 (4) - ^
01:52:858 (2) - ^
01:58:133 (3) - ^

Maybe that's all
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply

0
1 / 43