1. Advanced (4.63 stars, 258 notes)
2. Expert (4.91 stars, 315 notes)
3. Shulin's Soft (2.48 stars, 128 notes)

shikyu wrote:

Request from my queue:

[General]
- Ask someone who good at timing check, recent offset make some notes placed at blue tick and it's no good for easiest diff Blue ticks are okay for Easy diffs and that's no indication the timing is wrong
- Combo color 1 & 5 are nearly same at gameplay, can you make combo color 1 darker?

A little mod:

[Shulin's Soft]
00:45:761 (1) - move it somewhere else, beginner will confused since it has same shape as 00:43:188 (1) No they won't, they'll know exactly what to do because it's the same shape as 00:43:188 (1)
01:11:496 (1) - move it somewhere, some parts ovelapped by scorebar It's nowhere near the scorebar...
01:41:090 (1) - ^ Moved down a bit

That's all, I can't mod it all now. Please PM me if timing already checked, I'll mod it again

1. nice storyboard, and nice song ^^

1. 00:37:237 (1) - move endpoint to (96,160)?
2. 02:31:273 (1) - move start point to (364,254)?

1. 1.5x ds in advanced orz...
2. 00:22:600 (3) - spacing? it's already 1.5x, don't make it too far away then
3. 00:37:558 (4,5) - ... can you don't stack this
4. 00:38:363 (2,3) - spacing?
5. 01:07:475 (4) - ^? can be hard to normal players...
6. 01:20:985 (3) - spacing too large

1. HP drain -1 or -2 please, having atrocious drain and making people randomly fail is not fun at all...
2. 00:45:440 (2) - I feel this backjump doesn't fit, maybe move to somewhere else?
3. 01:13:587 (3,4) - ctrl+r? then it fits the song more, and easier not to be confused
4. 02:02:643 (6) - ... unfitting jump, jump to somewhere else plz

[CSGA]Ar3sgice wrote:

SPOILER

Hi, from my queue


[General]

1. nice storyboard, and nice song ^^

[Advanced]

1. 1.5x ds in advanced orz... fixed it 1x now +_+ I just set it 1.5x for spacing persistency (w/o 1.5x notes r still put in that way = =) did it trouble u that much? o_O
2. 00:22:600 (3) - spacing? it's already 1.5x, don't make it too far away then yea.. i put that jump intentionally.. this is a hard diff no?
3. 00:37:558 (4,5) - ... can you don't stack this y? O_o lol ok
4. 00:38:363 (2,3) - spacing? yea?
5. 01:07:475 (4) - ^? can be hard to normal players... this is a hard diff ._.
6. 01:20:985 (3) - spacing too large nah it's fine here

[Expert]

1. HP drain -1 or -2 please, having atrocious drain and making people randomly fail is not fun at all... lol HP -1 then
2. 00:45:440 (2) - I feel this backjump doesn't fit, maybe move to somewhere else? hmm.. i dont know where to move it... O_o may be w8 for some more ideas?
3. 01:13:587 (3,4) - ctrl+r? then it fits the song more, and easier not to be confused nah it's a trap here o_o but i dont think it's that confusing
4. 02:02:643 (6) - ... unfitting jump, jump to somewhere else plz i'll consider this =/

Good luck~

Thx for modding ^^

Starry wrote:

SPOILER

Request from queue


[Advanced]

00:40:614 (5) - New combo here cause music starts over. k
01:47:524 (5) - ^ fixed
02:17:923 (4) - ^ nah it's fine here
00:44:475 (2) - Make this slider reverse. lol no

[Expert]

00:42:384 (5) - I don't think this note is needed. hmm..
00:58:629 (5) - Why not make this one reverse too since you reversed this one too 00:56:055 (4) - and they sound similar yea, but i wanna make them different =/
01:21:790 (1) - Remove new combo? nah
02:41:567 (1) - ^
02:01:035 (3) - I think two circle fit here better. done

Done!!
Good luck hope I helped! <3

thx 4 modding

112,300,104951,2,0,B|260:420|408:296,2,320,8|8|8

wmfchris wrote:

SPOILER

[General]
In [Adv] the break starts at 01:22:111 (artificially), while in [expert] starts the break in 01:21:990, similiar case happened for the end of this break. Try to start and end the break at the same time for both diffs :3 ok

Also the difficulty gap between [Soft] and [Advanced] might be a bit large, though it's ok for me.

[Expert]
00:44:475 (3) - clap because I heard there's a bass sound there. i forgot lol
00:57:824 (2,4) - stack properly. fixed o3o

[Advanced]
02:41:567 (3) - I prefer a new combo here as it sounds belonging to the next phrases. k

P.S. kd only if ^ sounds useful.

thx alot for modding xD

[CSGA]Ar3sgice wrote:

[Shulin's Soft]

1. 00:37:237 (1) - move endpoint to (96,160)? I think it's fine
2. 02:31:273 (1) - move start point to (364,254)? ^

Starry wrote:

[Shulin's Soft]

00:52:677 (1,2,3,4) - orz, This pattern gets BORING when you repeat it a lot. Put some variation D: Make it more fun. Well it only repeats once but I take your point. I've removed the 1 repeat and mapped it.
01:17:929 (2) - New combo here. No, it looks awful.
01:21:790 (3) - ^ No, its pointless for one note.

wmfchris wrote:

[Soft]
01:44:951 (3) - even this is a single slider I prefer putting a NC here becoz it sounds like the a different pharse from (1,2). Also a bit nazi here try to raise the third point of slider up 1 grid lv4 so that both the starting circle and reverse circle lies on y:300. Okay I've added a new combo and used the code. That is:

112,300,104951,2,0,B|260:420|408:296,2,320,8|8|8

AoiX wrote:

Request from Queue

Aoi's Mod

Easy

1. 00:43:188 (1) - this slider not fit grid perfectly.use ctrl+H to adjust it It looks worse if I make the slider points perfectly symmetrical. Looks fine in game anyway.
2. 00:45:761 (1) - ^
3. 01:10:209 (3) - whistle.to let it same with (2) Okay, also added it later.
4. 01:41:090 (1) - also need more adjust It's not grid snapped... it looks fine as is =|

STAR for Yanni and awesome work~

air111 wrote:

SPOILER

Sweet map :3

[Advanced]
Pretty solid diff exept
1:15:356 (1,2,3,4,5) - this combo seems too heavy, and with no arguments, plus it follows after "normal" 1:11:817 (2,3,4,5) and 1:14:873 (3,4) which makes it so more heavily hmm.. ok i fixed this
2:35:133 (1,2,3,4,5) - same as ^ i think at this point ppl already get used to the rhythm so it's fine

[Expert]
1:02:167 (3, 4) - seems confusing for me, but anways ~exepert~ lol
1:09:244 - 1:10:629 That combo makes this diff expert, exept this combo map diff seems "heavy" to me. nah it's fine (it's only further by a few grids +_+)
2:36:420 (1,2,3,4,5) - same as ^

I hope this helps ~cheers

thx for ur help

nich95 wrote:

SPOILER

Hi, kazumikos

From my modding queue

[General]
No problem.

[Advanced]
00:22:279 (2,3) - Spacing is too far. Recommended to reduce Spacing to 2.1x. fixed
00:34:181 (2,3,4) - Here as well. Adjust the Spacing is 1.5x. (The overlap with 00:35:950 (1)) it's fine here
00:38:235 (1) - Move to x:124 y:72 to keep the equal spacing. then 00:40:614 (1,2) - will be too close =/
01:04:901 (4) - Move to the top of (3,5) is better. done

[Expert]
00:45:440 (2) - Maybe move to the end of the slider. Then adjust the spacing of (2,3) again would be better. ok since many ppl have complained abt this i decided to move this note

That's all that I can find them.

Good luck.

thx for da mod

nich95 wrote:

[Shulin's Soft]
OD -1 (Suggest that OD is less than AR would be better.) I think OD being the same as AR is fine.
The rest is no problem.

Mustaash wrote:

[Easy]

02:02:965 (1) - Touching the HPBar, please fix that ! Okay, I've fixed this! ^_^

Fine, Awesome Easy !

Mustaash wrote:

SPOILER

Ok let's go ~

[Advanced]

So firstly i think you can add more HitSounds in this difficulty, something like this? thx for suggestions ^^ i'll consider to add more hitsound and it'll take a while to fully decide lol

01:00:398 (4,5) - I think the spacing between these notes is too much high because the most of the diff use a lower spacing generally k

Overall, this difficulty looks really good too !

[Expert]

00:41:097 (2) - I think this note is too much behind the slider (1) i should be you, i rearrange more down ( like 6grid down (Lv4) ) done
01:41:090 (4) - I suggest to make a new combo because the ryhthm is different. hmm ok

I really had fun to play this difficulty and the whole mapset, your mapping style and Shulin's Easy Skill are awesome. Keep it up, Greaaaaat Work !

thx alot for modding

Samah wrote:

SPOILER

From queue:

This is the first mod I've done where I've played all the difficulties and couldn't find a single thing wrong, or to even offer any suggestions.
Sorry I can't be of much help...
If I were a MAT I'd bubble it, but you'll just have to make do with these stars instead. <3
No kd, of course, but if I can think of something I'll post later.

It's ok :3
thx for those stars
Im really looking forward to ur future mod post ^^

Wiinter wrote:

SPOILER

Modding as requested~

General
the kiai times should be the same in all diffs i thought they were the same? O_o

[Advanced]
00:21:313 (2,1,2) - would look better if you shaped (1) like this http://puu.sh/dxza (or something like that) instead. that little overlap looks a bit ugly imo >< well.. ok
02:00:874 (3) - use distance snap? i did o3o
02:15:832 (1,2,3) - place (2) and (3) like this? looks better imo like wot? O_o
02:20:657 (2) - fix spacing? D: k
02:25:322 (1) - ^ k
02:30:469 (4) - place this in a way it doesn't touch the previous slider D: done.. (i think)

[Expert]
00:34:181 (3,4) - place it like this http://puu.sh/dxEM? k
00:45:440 (2) - ugly overlap D: lol k

well, it was mostly spacing suggestions. i wasn't a really big fan of the overlaps nice mapset though

Thx for modding

Mystica wrote:

SPOILER

Here comes my Mod

[soft]
good for me

[advanced]
00:25:174 (1,2,3) - this three sliders are a little hard for a normal diff(even a hard diff) uhm yea.. this is a hard diff, and i kinda tried to make it look like a hard >_>

[expert]
AR seems not fit it...may use ar7? then ar will be too low =/ (tested)
other seems no problem.

In my mind.I think taiko hitsound will fits more.Also the volume seems too low for me.... I also thought of taiko hitsound but after a few tests i decided not to use it. I assume this is personal preference? O_o

But it's a nice map yet.

• Hi hi~ request from my queue~
  
  General :

1. Tags " If I Could Tell You" ...What's this mean....
2. 01:21:790 ~ 01:23:076 all diff need to change like "Shulin's Soft" diff
   　
   Shulin's Soft :
   　
3. 00:43:188 (1) - Maybe try this
   
   

   348,240,43188,6,0,B|352:144|256:72|160:144|164:240,1,320,0|8

   
   Advanced :
   　
4. Looks good for me!!
   　
   Expert :
   　
5. Looks good for me!!
   　
   
   You must read~!

   red:I think it is unrankable issue. bule: need to discuss. Black: just suggest.

Awesome map! Awesome song! Awesome mapest!!!
Maybe add this soft-hitnormal sounds better
have my star and Good luck :3

bossandy wrote:

SPOILER

• Hi hi~ request from my queue~
  
  General :

1. Tags " If I Could Tell You" ...What's this mean.... uhm.. it's album title...
2. 01:21:790 ~ 01:23:076 all diff need to change like "Shulin's Soft" diff done
   　
   Shulin's Soft :
   　
3. 00:43:188 (1) - Maybe try this
   
   

   348,240,43188,6,0,B|352:144|256:72|160:144|164:240,1,320,0|8

   
   Advanced :
   　
4. Looks good for me!!
   　
   Expert :
   　
5. Looks good for me!!
   　
   
   You must read~!

   red:I think it is unrankable issue. bule: need to discuss. Black: just suggest.

--------------------------------------------------------
Awesome map! Awesome song! Awesome mapest!!!
Maybe add this soft-hitnormal sounds better
have my star and Good luck :3

thx for modding
and star~ xD

bossandy wrote:

• Shulin's Soft :
  　

1. 00:43:188 (1) - Maybe try this I think this slider is fine =P
   
   

   348,240,43188,6,0,B|352:144|256:72|160:144|164:240,1,320,0|8

rockleejkooo wrote:

[Shulin's Soft]
• 00:37:237 (1) - maybe finish at the start? o.o Sounds strange to me
• 00:52:677 (1) - clap? Hmm... no I want to keep the hitsound pattern for this part =P
• 01:58:140 (3,4,5) - whistles? Too much whistle imo, it sounds a bit heavy
• 02:01:035 (2) - ^ at the start and end ^
• 02:35:615 (2) - clap at the end Sure, sounds good

rockleejkooo wrote:

SPOILER

Hello from our queue

[Advanced]
• 00:57:824 (1) - maybe remove nc and put on 00:58:146 (2) - k
• 01:08:922 (3) - nc? (sound changing) fixed
• 01:59:105 (1) - remove nc and put on next slider? hm.. k
• 02:16:958 (2) - maybe better to not overlap it here? something like this http://puu.sh/elr3 k


[Expert]
• 02:08:112 (4) - nc
• 02:09:077 (1) - remove nc
• 02:09:398 (2) - nc
• 02:10:685 (5) - nc
thx for suggestions, i fixed nc things

perfect mapset *O* hope it will get ranked soon :3

thx for modding

DivineRage wrote:

I love this song ;.; I have no star but you can have a ♥

Shulin wrote:

SPOILER

Modding as requested everything is just suggestions, suggestions, suggestions...

Soft:

See attached.

Advanced:

00:54:768 (3) - Finish start?
01:09:887 (3) - Whistle start?
02:00:391 (1) - Move this up 2 grids or so? The overlap with 01:59:105 (8) - looks messy
02:01:035 (3) - Move this down 2 grids if you do ^
02:14:384 (2) - Finish end?
02:29:503 (1) - Whistle end?

Expert:

00:41:097 (2) - Move down 2 grids to align with 00:41:258 (3) -
00:42:384 (5) - Move down 2 grids to reduce overlap with 00:41:901 (4) - It looks neater.
00:50:908 (7) - New combo?
00:54:768 (3) - Add finish to keep the hitsound pattern?
01:09:887 (4) - Whistle?
01:11:174 (4) - ^
01:11:496 (6) - I think there should be a new combo here so it follows 01:12:782 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) -
01:44:951 (1) - The curve is kind of ugly, maybe make it rounder?
01:50:580 (2) - I think it's better if you move this down 2-3 grids and reduce overlap with 01:50:098 (1) -
02:11:972 (4) - Clap?
02:21:944 (3) - Finish + clap at the end? (Like 02:16:797 (3,4,5) - and 02:19:371 (1,2,3) - )
02:29:664 (2) - Whistle?
02:30:951 (1) - ^
02:30:951 (1) - Remove new combo? Add new combo at 02:31:273 (3) - if you do this.

fixed (almost) everything, except 4 the ugly curve :< I dont know wot to do with it = =

Keep going! It's only 9 more months to November ~ Yea~~ 9 months to go *_*

1. One of your SB elements is not in .png. black.jpg, fix it, please, and do fullsubmit.
2. I suggest you not to use pure white combo color.
3. Make the kiai time consistent in all diffs.
4. You should make Normal diff to balance your diff spread.

1. 01:21:790 (3) - start break right away after this note.
   Nothing to say. Beautiful, just beautiful.

• Is it Hard? Maybe make it more easier? You have Insane, so maybe make the spacing here less and remove some jumps.

1. 00:23:887 (3,4) - because of osu! bag, stacking doesn't occur here,so you have to make a manual stack by moving one of the objects for some pixels or 1 grid (lvl4) off or you may change them in another way.
2. 00:35:467 (5) - nc
3. 01:16:643 (1,2,3,4,5) - hard :<
4. 01:21:468 (4) - start break right away after this note.
5. 01:48:811 (3,4,5,6) - don't stack, it's hard
6. 02:35:133 (1,2,3,4,5) - meh.

1. 01:21:790 (1) - same as in other diffs.

Reiji-RJ wrote:

SPOILER

Hello..

[General]

1. One of your SB elements is not in .png. black.jpg, fix it, please, and do fullsubmit. hmm i dont think it does matter O_o but ok
2. I suggest you not to use pure white combo color. but the BGs are dark, it suits white combo color D:
3. Make the kiai time consistent in all diffs.they r not? ;_;
4. You should make Normal diff to balance your diff spread.

[Shulin's Soft]

1. 01:21:790 (3) - start break right away after this note.
   Nothing to say. Beautiful, just beautiful.

[Advanced]

AR, OD, HP -1.

• Is it Hard? Maybe make it more easier? You have Insane, so maybe make the spacing here less and remove some jumps. Yes this is a hard diff I know it's not really hard but more or less I dont wanna change it into normal =/
  Anything related to "..too hard, fix?" will be remained, sorry >_<

1. 00:23:887 (3,4) - because of osu! bag, stacking doesn't occur here,so you have to make a manual stack by moving one of the objects for some pixels or 1 grid (lvl4) off or you may change them in another way.
2. 00:35:467 (5) - nc I think it's fine here o_O
3. 01:16:643 (1,2,3,4,5) - hard :<
4. 01:21:468 (4) - start break right away after this note. waiting 4 Shulin's reply, if he changes i'll follow
5. 01:48:811 (3,4,5,6) - don't stack, it's hard
6. 02:35:133 (1,2,3,4,5) - meh.

[Expert]

AR, HP, OD -1.

1. 01:21:790 (1) - same as in other diffs.

Not bad overall, but I suggest you to work more on patterns, to make map more beautiful.

ok thx for modding ^^

Reiji-RJ wrote:

[Shulin's Soft]

1. 01:21:790 (3) - start break right away after this note. Sure why not =P
   Nothing to say. Beautiful, just beautiful. Thanks ^_^

[Ryuu] wrote:

rock asked me to play it о.о
i played o.o
and i love it *333*
star ~

Kanon wrote:

Shulin's Easy:
01:08:922 (2) - use green line change volume 20% 30% 40% sounds nicer Changed to 40-40-30 for this.
01:10:209 (3) - ^
01:11:496 (1) - add a default soft finish? Sounds out of place
01:20:503 (2) - add whistle to the reverse point? Nah I want emphasis on 01:21:790 (3) -
02:01:678 (3) - add whistle Nope following the same hitsound pattern as 00:35:467 (3) -
02:28:699 (2,3) - same as 01:08:922 (2) - Done as 40-40-30

Kanon wrote:

SPOILER

Sorry for the delay...busy with exams.
Here is my mod.

Advanced:
00:35:950 (1) - instead a curve slider here? nah
01:44:468 (3) - stack it manually done

Extreme:
02:17:119 (5,1,2) - split them up would be nice. now is quite confusing. fixed

Good map. Personally I would like to add some more whistle in it. But now is fine too.
Good luck ~

thx for modding ^^

gaodeng wrote:

I'm Yanni's fan.Hope it can be ranked.star~

gaodeng wrote:

I'm Yanni's fan.Hope it can be ranked.star~

Tony wrote:

same here good luck kazumikos~

oh ty~

Leorda wrote:

SPOILER

Hello

General
* Inconsistent kiai time http://puu.sh/ioeE ok o3o
* Inconsistent combo colors http://puu.sh/ioePbut i used different BGs D:

thx for modding ^^
update soon

Leorda wrote:

Shulin's Soft
* Would be better if diff name changed into "Shulin's Basic"

01:14:069 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - Too much repeating sliders are boring, try make another pattern

Garven wrote:

[General]
02:32:559 - Ugh, the mp3 sounds horrible here. :< It's pretty bad in other areas too, but this spot was the worst. Can you find a better mp3?
yes... i can a new one but im not sure my new mp3 is good enough though o_O

[Advanced]
00:48:817 (2,3) - I don't like how much of the repeat arrow is covered by the 2 slider. ok fixed
gonna update a new audio file soon updated
thx for modding ^^

Minty Gum wrote:

Such a pretty map and storyboard. I hope to see more from you in the future. Congrats!