1. Futsuu (1.67 stars, 146 notes)
2. Kantan (1.05 stars, 101 notes)
3. Muzukashii (2.46 stars, 213 notes)
4. Oni (2.68 stars, 304 notes)

1. 00:24:104 (54) - how about k there? but, if you want to use "d" pattern, just ignore this c:
2. 00:29:632 (69,70) - dd, to make a good structure. before that at (57)~(63) you used "k" patterns, and at the (64)~(70) you used same notes like (57)~(63) but with d dd dd kk. so how about the last at (69) and (70) you used dd? so (57)~(70) are be k kk kk kk d dd dd dd
3. 00:33:697 (82) - k here
4. 00:47:681 (110) - how about add k there? c:
5. 01:01:502 (153) - k and then 01:01:340 (152) - add k there. to follow the flute sounds
   
   try this~
   01:01:990 (154,155) - add k's there and then 01:02:478 (156) - k too
   
6. 01:02:966 (157) - add a note here
7. 01:18:088 (197) - k is much better than d
8. 01:24:917 (213) - d, k isn't fit well
9. 01:38:413 (241) - add k here

1. 00:15:161 (66,67) - how about give finishes here ?
   
   try this~
   00:15:974 (68,69) - add d k and then 00:16:462 (70) - add d
   
2. 00:24:185 (98) - k, much better than d (too monotonic if d)
3. 00:28:657 (115,116) - kk and then 00:29:795 (120) - d
4. 00:33:697 (132) - k
5. 00:36:949 (145) - add d here
6. 00:38:413 (151,152,154) - k's here much better.
7. 00:41:990 (160) - add d here
   
   try this to~
   00:46:380 (169,172) - use k's
   00:47:681 (174) - add d
   00:47:844 (175) - use finish
   00:48:657 (177) - use d
   
8. 00:49:632 (179,180) - kd much better than dk. hear the music carefully. 00:49:632 (179) - has higher pitch sound than 00:49:795 (180) -
9. 01:24:429 (26) - k here
10. 01:29:145 (44,45,47) - k's here. like 00:38:413 (151,152,154) -(if you use my mods before)
11. 01:32:722 (55) - add note here (d)
    01:40:527 (75) - d. the reason same like 00:49:632 (179,180) - (if you use my mods before)

• [Kantan]

1. 01:38:575 (23) - big don here
   
   [Futsuu]
2. 01:17:112 (15) - don
3. 01:38:575 (47) - same as kantan, change this to a big don
   
   [Muzukashii]
4. 00:31:584 (76) - delete (?)
5. 01:38:575 (236) - same as kantan and futsuu, big don
6. 01:40:527 (241) - don
   
   [Oni]
7. 00:31:258 (122) - change this to don
8. 00:31:584 (123) - delete this (?)
9. 00:41:990 - add don here because there's a beat in the music here
10. 01:01:340 (210) - don
11. 01:32:722 - add don here because there's a beat in the music (same as 00:41:990)
12. 01:40:527 (74) - don

Jerry wrote:

Here's the mod that you requested for :3

Most of these are just suggestions, you can choose to ignore some of them if you want to.

• [Kantan]

1. 01:38:575 (23) - big don here - nope because don higher pitch
   
   [Futsuu]
2. 01:17:112 (15) - don -omg ok
3. 01:38:575 (47) - same as kantan, change this to a big don -same with kantan but i change this to don
   
   [Muzukashii]
4. 00:31:584 (76) - delete (?) -looks better
5. 01:38:575 (236) - same as kantan and futsuu, big don -same with kantan and futsuu
6. 01:40:527 (241) - don -looks good
   
   [Oni]
7. 00:31:258 (122) - change this to don -looks better
8. 00:31:584 (123) - delete this (?) -^
9. 00:41:990 - add don here because there's a beat in the music here -okie
10. 01:01:340 (210) - don -changed and a little change
11. 01:32:722 - add don here because there's a beat in the music (same as 00:41:990)-okie
12. 01:40:527 (74) - don -okie

I love this song haha
AN AN AN tottemo daisuki doraemon~ >w<

Good luck on rank!

1. Don only !? i want Kat sounds... but this is a proposal :3
2. 00:21:502 (15) - k
3. 00:23:454 (17) - ^
4. 00:27:356 - add note
   00:29:307 - ^ same as 00:16:624 (10,11,12,13)
5. 00:31:258 (22) - k
6. 00:33:210 (24) - ^
7. 00:46:868 (35) - ^
8. 01:05:405 (1) - spin end time = 01:06:380 and 01:07:356 - add d
9. please after that the same rhythm. the rhythm without unity is so hard for beginner.

1. i felt quite hard in comparison with Kantan.
2. 00:01:502 (2) - 00:02:478 (3) - 00:03:454 (4) - 00:05:405 (7) - 00:06:380 (8) - 00:07:356 (9) - del
3. 00:17:112 (21) - 00:19:063 (24) - ^
4. 00:26:868 (37) - 00:28:819 (40) - ^
5. 00:36:136 (49) - D
6. 00:37:112 (50) - k
7. 00:36:624 (50) - 00:37:600 (51) - del
8. 00:52:234 (70) - 00:53:210 (71) - ^
9. 01:00:039 (80) - 01:01:014 (81) - ^
10. 01:05:405 (1) - spin end time = 01:06:868 and 01:07:356 - add d

1. 00:15:161 - add d
2. 00:24:104 (54) - move to 00:24:185 same as Oni
3. 00:39:063 (92) - k
4. 00:47:844 (109) - D
5. 00:50:608 - add d

1. 00:08:332 (44) - not finish is better. same as 00:04:429 (22) -
2. 00:17:925 (73) - d
3. 00:20:039 (81) - k
4. 00:25:567 (103) - del
5. 00:29:632 (115) - d
6. 00:38:901 (147,148) - d k
7. 00:47:844 (168) - finish. same as Muzukashii

TKSalt wrote:

hi :3
i want doraemon's tools.

this mod is first verse only.

[Kantan]

1. Don only !? i want Kat sounds... but this is a proposal :3
2. 00:21:502 (15) - k - low pitch
3. 00:23:454 (17) - ^ - ^
4. 00:27:356 - add note -don't make newbie player sad please ;w;
   00:29:307 - ^ same as 00:16:624 (10,11,12,13) - ^
5. 00:31:258 (22) - k -looks better
6. 00:33:210 (24) - ^ -looks better
7. 00:46:868 (35) - ^ -looks better
8. 01:05:405 (1) - spin end time = 01:06:380 and 01:07:356 - add d - no change because the spinner already good
9. please after that the same rhythm. the rhythm without unity is so hard for beginner.

[Futsuu]

1. i felt quite hard in comparison with Kantan.
2. 00:01:502 (2) - 00:02:478 (3) - 00:03:454 (4) - 00:05:405 (7) - 00:06:380 (8) - 00:07:356 (9) - del
3. 00:17:112 (21) - 00:19:063 (24) - ^
4. 00:26:868 (37) - 00:28:819 (40) - ^
5. 00:36:136 (49) - D
6. 00:37:112 (50) - k
7. 00:36:624 (50) - 00:37:600 (51) - del
8. 00:52:234 (70) - 00:53:210 (71) - ^
9. 01:00:039 (80) - 01:01:014 (81) - ^
10. 01:05:405 (1) - spin end time = 01:06:868 and 01:07:356 - add d

i changed some of it and delete some note

[Muzukashii]

1. 00:15:161 - add d -oh i forgot
2. 00:24:104 (54) - move to 00:24:185 same as Oni -looks better
3. 00:39:063 (92) - k -looks better
4. 00:47:844 (109) - D -^
5. 00:50:608 - add d -nope because too hard

[Oni]

1. 00:08:332 (44) - not finish is better. same as 00:04:429 (22) - woops fix
2. 00:17:925 (73) - d -^
3. 00:20:039 (81) - k-^
4. 00:25:567 (103) - del -nope because it still have sound
5. 00:29:632 (115) - d -looks better
6. 00:38:901 (147,148) - d k -^
7. 00:47:844 (168) - finish. same as Muzukashii -

sorry noob modding and poor english.

goodluck

Fraolinch wrote:

Hey, pretty good mapset. Didn't really see anything that needed fixing, so here's one of my famous one-line mods o/

OMG LOOK AT THESE WALLS OF TEXT. HOW DO I CLIMB THEM

General

Set a Slider Tick Rate of 3 on all diffs since the song is snapped on 1/3

Scary I know.

tetsutaro wrote:

@vahn10: DS1, not DS2. DS2's Doraemon song is the notoriously underrated Yume wo Kanaete Doraemon.

Now back to the regularly scheduled mod

[General]
Taiko cut why. Because .... D:
Observe a higher degree consistency please. ;w;
Preview Time: I believe more people recognize the song from 00:16:624. ok

[Kantan] Perceived difficulty rating: 1* Kantan
Too much notes at 2 beat. Add some in between to rack things up.
The pattern of d_d_ddd_ at 1 beat is very suitable in Melody A and Interlude. Add them in.
00:02:478 and 00:03:941; 00:06:380 and 00:07:844 - Notes here following the background hum
00:12:722 (7) - wrt. to the spiraling pitches, drumroll/denden until 00:14:673.
00:15:161 (8,9) - Drum beat. Large don
01:05:405 (1) - End 1 beat early and note at original end. Denden usually completes early and a void will be created there.
01:35:161 - Note for "An-an-an" and consistency

[Futsuu] Perceived difficulty rating: 3* Futsuu
00:15:161 and 00:15:649 - Drum beat. Large don
00:16:624 (26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33) - kdddkdkd
00:26:380 (42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52,53) - Stay consistent with previous iteration
00:35:649 - Note here. Trombone progression. -it will be hard
00:40:039 (64) and 01:30:771 (36) - Large -nope
00:41:990 (65) - Remove, since you didn't put notes on the pulpy (?) places. -nope because it's high pitch for me
01:05:405 (1) - End 2/3 to 1 beat early and note at original end. Denden usually completes early and a void will be created there.
01:26:868 (29,30) - Not large.

[Muzukashii] Perceived difficulty rating: 4* Muzukashii
00:08:819 (21,22,23,24) - Notes at 1 beat too. - i want to make break here
00:15:161, 00:15:649 (30) - Drum beat. Large don -
00:24:429 (55) and 00:34:185 (82) and 01:15:161 (187) - 3-beat drumroll/denden across the whole cluster of notes 34:185 nope
01:01:502 (150,151) - Suddenly void region. Notes at 01:01:828 and 01:01:990 and 01:02:315 -i put break here
01:21:014 (201,202) - Suddenly void region. Notes at 01:21:502 and 01:22:478 and 01:22:803 - ^
01:30:771 (225) - Large -nope

[Oni] Perceived difficulty rating: 3* Oni (same as authentic in AC14)
Too lenient. Follow the background music more closely.
00:01:015 ~ - Perhaps kkdddkkkdddkkkdddkkkdd -yes but -> kdddkkkdddkkkdddkkddkk no
00:08:819 ~ - Notes following the chirps (?) ddkdkkddkdkkddkdkkddkdkk -i put break here
00:12:722 ~ - Perhaps kkdkddkkdkddd -ok
00:15:974 and 00:16:136 and 00:16:462 - Notes. - i put break
00:26:380 (106,107,108,109,110) - Suddenly percussion-based while surrounding regions are lyrics-based. Notes at 00:26:706 and 00:27:193.
00:51:746 ~ - Suddenly reduction in difficulty, like much less mixed 1/3 clusters. If you want to create variety, start with no mixed clusters before this point and then proceed with more mixed clusters. -nope because this is my style :8):
00:58:575 (201,202,203) - More notes at 1/3, following background stream closely -i hate too many stream
01:02:966 - Note. A small tick is present in the percussion. - i put break
01:05:405 (1) - Notes. Suggests dddkkkd_dd_dd at 1/3 -sorry i changed this before u mod it lol

Mithost wrote:

Fun 'Fact'! Doraemon no Uta can be loosely translated to "Where gods fear to tread". I'm dead serious no i'm not. Why you decided to map this, I may never know, but keep in mind that this is probably the best song in osu!.

From the Productive Mod Team's Queue

I will color any major things like difficulty faults or unrankable sections. Everything else is pure suggestion to make the map 'feel' better to the player.

General

You have 4 kiai time triggers, when the rule of thumb in ranking criteria is 1 trigger per 1 minute of drain time. In taiko, kiai doubles score, so please abide by this guideline. Because the chorus have 4 part

Is it just me, or is the timing just slightly off? Listen to it in 25% and see if you can hear it. no change because Taiko ♥

Kantan

00:04:917 (6,7,8,9,10) - Kantan players will find it nice if these are kat notes, as the pitch of the song calls for it. -nope because it will be hard (nb: kantan don't have many kat but have many don)
00:17:600 (19,21,23) - Same as above. -nope
00:33:210 (32,33) - I think you could get away with a dkd pattern here instead of a k k pattern.-nope
00:36:136 (34,37) - Same as 00:17:600 -nope
00:36:136 (34,37) - Same as above -^
00:58:575 (54,55) - ^^-^
I believe you get the point: moar kats when the vocals or instruments get noticeably higher in pitch. Great sence of difficulty here though.

i'm seriously for kantan have more don than katsu

Futsuu

00:04:917 (5,6,7,8) - Switch these so the dons are where the kats are and vice versa. Pitch relevance is the cause. -no change
00:32:722 - Feel free to put a don here. Futsuu is the difficulty that teaches players ddd/kkk style patterns, so it won't hurt to put one here. -too hard
00:36:136 (46) - This finish might be a beeet to hard for Futsuu players. Other modders might ask you to remove it. -finish higher pitch with clap
01:09:307 (2,3,4,5) - This ddd k pattern could be switched to dkddk if you wish, or it could be changed to dkd k. -its already better for me
01:25:893 - A don here is ok difficulty wise. Keeps the player interested. -i put break here
01:37:112 - Kat here to fit with the song. - changed not in there

Muzukashii

Please raise the Slider Velocity up to 1.50. on songs with such a slow bpm, more advanced patterns get harder to read. -nothx

00:09:307 - For difficulty increase, a kat here would feel great. Goes great with the 'marching band' feel the song has when playing. - i put break
00:10:283 - ^ - ^
00:11:258 - ^ - ^
00:16:624 (32) - The vocals kinda build up pitch here, yet you had the same pitches for each note. Put a don on the first one to make a dkk pattern. -nope
00:19:063 (38) - Kat here for pitch relevance -^
00:31:258 (75) - People might complain about potential difficulty fault, but a kat here would sound great. -^
00:34:673 ~ 00:35:649 - a simple 1/1 snap dkd pattern here would be nice. - i am following the sound of the singer
00:46:380 (104) - Kat here for pitch relevance -nope
00:55:649 (131,134,141) - Same as above -^

Oni

For the same reason as the Muzukashii, please raise the slider velocity to 1.60. I had a bit of trouble reading the first patterns due to the slow scroll speed. -nothx

Because I've already said pitch relevance everywhere else on this mod, I'll leave it to you to point out the common places where dons can be kats and vice versa.

00:07:844 (41,42,43,44) - Change this from kdkd to dkdk for pitch relevance. The rest of the stream there was perfect! -the perfect is my style huehue nothx
00:09:307 (46,47,48,49,50,51,52) - On the 1/3 tick before every note here, place a kat and see how it plays. This is a very common 1/3 pattern for Oni.
- it will be inner oni if i use that lol
00:37:112 (141,142,143,144) - After the two finish notes, it feels better if this pattern is dddk. -nope
00:47:681 - A kat here would go great with the song and it's existing patterns. -^
00:50:283 - I feel like I should be playing something here. -^

<3

1. *for Kantan/Futsuu* Set HP/OD at least 4 since the Ranking Criteria says so.
   

   Taiko Ranking Criteria wrote:

   All rules are exactly that: RULES. They are NOT guidelines and may NOT be broken under ANY circumstance.
   ◾Difficulty settings and song setup
   
   Overall difficulty and HP drain rate should be between 4~7. Exception: Maps exceeding the usual draining time should have a life drain between 1~4 depending on length and numbers of notes.

1. 00:12:722 (15) - I highly recommend removing this slider. (and replace into a spinner?) Since the BPM is 123, which is smaller thsn 125, the slider beat is 1/8 tick, not 1/4 tick. This is super crazy hard...
2. 00:24:429 (26) - And this slider is also...... Try removing it and add d d d from here in 1/1 beat.
3. 01:01:502 (57) - meh. replace into k k k?
4. 01:05:405 (60) - replace into spinner?

1. 00:04:429 - having another d sounds nice
2. 00:26:868 (34) - remove this...? 00:17:112 - doesn't have it so.
3. 01:05:405 (83) - please replace this into something ;3
4. 01:32:722 - add d?

1. 00:23:779 (54,55) - umm... instead of using this complicated pattern, use simple one like 01:14:185 (185,186) - ?
2. 00:24:429 (56) -
3. maybe missing beats on 01:17:437 - and 01:17:925 -

1. Use OD 5? 6 is too much for this slow song... maybe.
2. 00:14:673 (65) - try k? It could emphasize the DONs
3. 00:25:893 (105) - d?
4. 01:33:697 (56,57) - They can be tied; try fill the space with dddd?

Naryuga wrote:

Hi :3 from my Taiko modding queue~

Marks:
"d" = don (red note)
"k" = kat (blue note)
"D" = Big Don (red + finisher)
"K" = Big Kat (blue + finisher)
"^" = same as above

[General]

1. *for Kantan/Futsuu* Set HP/OD at least 4 since the Ranking Criteria says so.
   

   Taiko Ranking Criteria wrote:

   All rules are exactly that: RULES. They are NOT guidelines and may NOT be broken under ANY circumstance.
   ◾Difficulty settings and song setup
   
   Overall difficulty and HP drain rate should be between 4~7. Exception: Maps exceeding the usual draining time should have a life drain between 1~4 depending on length and numbers of notes.

Fixed

[Kantan]

1. 00:12:722 (15) - I highly recommend removing this slider. (and replace into a spinner?) Since the BPM is 123, which is smaller thsn 125, the slider beat is 1/8 tick, not 1/4 tick. This is super crazy hard... -fixed
2. 00:24:429 (26) - And this slider is also...... Try removing it and add d d d from here in 1/1 beat. -changed
3. 01:01:502 (57) - meh. replace into k k k? -slider is good ♥
4. 01:05:405 (60) - replace into spinner? -fixed

[Futsuu]

1. 00:04:429 - having another d sounds nice - i'm not sure with this if another said so i will change it
2. 00:26:868 (34) - remove this...? 00:17:112 - doesn't have it so. -fixed
3. 01:05:405 (83) - please replace this into something ;3 -spinner? lol
4. 01:32:722 - add d?

-fixed

[Muzu]

1. 00:23:779 (54,55) - umm... instead of using this complicated pattern, use simple one like 01:14:185 (185,186) - ? -fixed
2. 00:24:429 (56) - - changed to d d
3. maybe missing beats on 01:17:437 - and 01:17:925 -omg fixed

[Oni]

1. Use OD 5? 6 is too much for this slow song... maybe. - OD6 not too much because 300K+ [Auto without mods]
2. 00:14:673 (65) - try k? It could emphasize the DONs - k looks nothing and i more prefer d in there
3. 00:25:893 (105) - d? -looks better
4. 01:33:697 (56,57) - They can be tied; try fill the space with dddd? - i use d dd

Good luck .w.

ts8zs wrote:

You can take a look on this map:3
http://puu.sh/3AXBo.osz
Taiko made by me(although not recived by creator because oni isn't very good,but other diffs you can have a look)
turn Volume 50% It too noisy now:3
Oni
00:07:844 (41,42,43,44) - dkdk? - changed to dkkd
00:30:283 (118,119,120) - k dk -nope
00:32:234 (125) - k -low pitch in here so i use d
00:46:218 (163,164,165,166,167,168) - kd dk kd? -nope
01:01:990 (213) - k -nope
01:36:949 (63,64,65,66) - dk kd -nope
01:07:356 (1,8,15) - k? -nope
Muzu
00:30:283 (71,72,73) - k kk -nope
00:46:380 (104) - k? -^
00:46:706 (105,106) - kk -^
00:59:063 (142) - k -d looks better than kat in here
I think you need more change:3 - i think no lol
Fut
00:18:575 (23) - k -low pitch in here so i put d
00:28:332 (35) - k -^

taiko_maniac1811 wrote:

Here comes M4M from Malaysian Taiko Queue

Dorae~mon~ :3

MOD

• [General]

1. delete "taiko" from tags as it is not necessary anymore.. - i will delete it if 2 other people said that too
   
   [Oni]
   
   00:07:844 (11,14) - k? plays better imo - just 14 because 11 looks better if d
   00:23:819 (94) - so weird here @@ move this to 00:23:779 (1/3 snap) - same with muzukashii
   00:25:730 (104,105) - d k? -looks better
   
   [Muzukashii]
   
   00:23:819 (53) - same as Oni, move this to 00:23:779 (1/3 snap) - i follow singer's sound
   
   [Kantan & Futsuu]
   
   plays fine~

- Are you serious? D:

Great map :3
good luck~

MMzz wrote:

[Oni]
00:23:819 (94) - Snap to 00:23:779 - fixed
00:24:185 (95) - Snap to 00:24:104 - fixed
00:45:893 (162,163,164,165,166,167,168) - No kat variations? - because kat doesn't fit in there
01:07:356 (1) - This section should have more color variations to match the vocals like before at: 00:16:624 (68) - Or make those patterns at 00:16:624 (68) - consistent with this section. It makes no sense to make similar parts of the music more/less difficult than each other. This goes for the rest of the map at this point of the song. With no color variations at this point your map just turns into Muzukashii. -changed like 00:16:624 - and some changes

[Muzukashii]
00:23:819 (53,54) - Snap these the same as in Oni. - fixed

ReySHeL wrote:

M4M

[Oni]

1. 00:14:673 (65) - k sound is better - don fit with the song
2. 00:22:966 (91) - k follow the vocal -looks better
3. 00:31:746 (123) - ^ -sure why not

[Muzukashii]

1. 00:22:966 (51) - same as Oni -same as oni

Kantan and Futsuu looks good.
GL~

- Not bad technically. Plays fine in general

- Not bad, just these little things

1. Be Careful with the usage of drumrolls (sliders) here. Drumroll acts as 1/8 streams (due to the low BPM), and generally they don't fit with the song during the gameply, sometimes is better to use shakers (spinners) instead of drumrolls.
2. Do Not focus that much in vocals when you map (especially in Muzu and Oni). Sometimes you focused a lot in vocal mapping, and you despised some important things in the instrumental (for example 00:40:201 - 00:41:828 in Muzu, I find this section totally mapable and some other too), try to give it a look over the map and try to cover some important sections of the instrumental.

Well, that's all from me..
Actually, I think you can work more over the difficulties, anyway hope my mod can helps you!
Good Luck!

aabc271 wrote:

I somehow have some free time today, so I'm gonna start modding again
September is indeed very busy for me, so I hope you don't mind this mod coming late ;w;
Anyway, let's go ~

Blue~ Critical issues. You must fix this
Purple~ It's better to fix this
Pink~ Suggestions only. Change only if you want to
Grey~ Explanations of my suggestions

-----------------------

[General]

• Use slider tick rate 3 for all diffs. This changes the sliders to have 1/6 hits instead of 1/8. For now there's no solution on making slider hits to become 1/3 due to BPM <125, but at least this will make the sliders a bit better

-----------------------

[ Oni]

• 00:08:819 ( 45~52 ) - Maybe you can add some 4-plets 1/3s here. For now 1/1 d varies quite a lot with the 1/3 streams without much reason ? One example of change is this, but it's your choice whether to change -for break

• 00:16:462 ( 70~93 ) - Personally I don't really understand your reasoning on hitsounds as imo they're quite random and don't fit the music well. It'll nice if you can explain a bit about your ideas on these hitsounds, or change them a bit

Suggested patterns ~

Here are the minor suggestions of patterns / hitsounds. It's your own choice whether to follow these suggestions.

00:24:104 ( 98 ) - Blue note ? ( Judging from 94~97, I guess you're trying to fit the vocal pitch. If so, 98 k can fit the pitch increase better. Listen to 96~98 if you don't understand what I mean ) - but the pitch increase a bit so i don't want to change it

00:38:575 ( 150 ) - Blue note ? ( I think this part is really suitable to follow the vocal. It has obviously a higher pitch than 149 so I think dk dk sounds better )
01:29:145 ( 44~47 ) - ^, oo oo ? ( Basically the same thing )

00:43:941 ( 162~164 ) - O O O / O O O ? ( Again, such emphasis of vocal in the music makes me think that K D D sounds a lot more natural. Or use K K K to fit 01:34:673 (59~61) )

00:45:893 ( 165 ) - Red note ? ( Similar to above, vocal pitch difference makes me think d dk fits a lot better. Note that there's a very significant pitch difference at 165,167 ) - looks better for me

I'm quite lenient on hitsounds this time because I found many parts of hitsounds are different from my style, which means it'd be too long if I list everything here. Maybe you should double-check about the hitsounds ? I may mention more about hitsounds when I recheck

Technically fine, but I personally think the hitsounds don't really fit the music well
Although it's true that 100% following vocal might not be the best idea at most time, I'll say this song does fit with vocal-based mapping
This is because the vocal is easily heard and leads the main rhythm of the song, and so you may consider adjusting the hitsounds a bit, if you want to

-----------------------

[ Muzukashii]

• It'll be nice if you can simply the difficulty of this muzu a bit. Diff spread between futsuu and this is quite big

• 00:21:340 ( 45, 49 ) - Delete these ? ( Considering 32~41. They have fewer usage of 1/3s, and suddenly using many in this section widens the diff spread quite much. I believe deleting these 2 will fix this issue well )

• 00:26:380 ( 57~78 ) - Again, I can't really understand the reasoning of using such hitsounds. I'd like to hear how you think about the hitsounds, and maybe change them as well ?

• 00:51:746 ( 1~69 ) - This part seems to be suddenly widening the diff spread due to the frequent uses of 1/3s. I'd suggest simplifying this part a bit ( eg by deleting 00:53:535 (8). Try to increase the note density gradually rather than instantly )

• 01:21:014 ( 89~91 ) - This part sounds so empty because the previous part is dense but not here. Try to add a few notes here ? -this part is for break

Suggested patterns ~

Here are the minor suggestions of patterns / hitsounds. It's your own choice whether to follow these suggestions.

• 00:14:673 ( 29 ) - Blue note ? ( It has an even higher instrumental pitch than 28, so k fits better imo ) - changed pitch

00:24:429 ( 55 ) - Blue note ? ( Suggested this based on vocal pitch variation. d x 4 sounds too monotonous for me ) -nope because same pitch

00:43:291 ( 98,99 ) - oo ( Comparing with 96,97, you can notice the instrument sounds higher pitched here. Therefore dd kk fits better imo ) -same pitch with the last note

00:46:380 ( 104~108 ) - o oo oo ? ( All d sounds too monotonous for me again. Maybe this can fit the music better, especially on the vocal side ) -

01:01:990 ( x,37 ) - Try this ? ( See what I highlighted. The empty part sounds quite empty for me, and so imo adding a note will be better )

01:26:868 ( 100,101 ) - O O ? ( The vocal, which is very significant, is just too high-pitched to be D D, so imo K K just fits better )

Similar comment with oni, but this time the hitsounds are overall more understandable for me
I'd suggest you having some rechecks on hitsounds and diff spread

-----------------------

[ Futsuu]

Seems better. But there are still some odd hitsounds imo. See the box below for details

Suggested patterns ~

Here are the minor suggestions of patterns / hitsounds. It's your own choice whether to follow these suggestions.

00:16:624 ( 22~27 ) - o o o o o o ( I personally don't understand the reasons for using current hitsounds. What I suggest follows the vocal better and see if you like it ) - hear carefully to background music

00:26:380 ( 33~44 ) - Try this ? ( See what I highlighted. Be note that the note arrangement is a bit different from your current version ) -changed by my style

01:17:112 ( 13~25 ) - Try this ? ( Once again the hitsounds are quite odd for me. What I suggested is based on vocal ) -changed by my style

01:26:868 ( 26~28 ) - o o o ? ( Fitting vocal better. Also makes a comparison with incoming d d k )

-changed the 26 only

Overall better than muzu and oni because the hitsounds are more natural overall, but there's still room for improvement.

-----------------------

[ Kantan]

• 01:01:502 ( 12 ) - I don't think a slider fits here, since the song indicates no ending or lengthened sounds. Normal notes will just fit well

Suggested patterns ~

Here are the minor suggestions of patterns / hitsounds. It's your own choice whether to follow these suggestions.

00:04:917 ( 6 ) - Blue note ? ( Due to instrument's rising pitch. Also fitting 9~11's d d k )

00:21:502 ( 8~16 ) - Try this ? ( Once again, fixing odd hitsound sections by using vocal-based mapping. Also changed the note arrangements a bit )

00:33:210 ( 18~20 ) - o o o ? ( Fitting the vocal better. I guess it's ok to add d k d here, since it's not connected with other dense parts )
01:23:941 ( 12~14 ) - ^ ( Same reason )

00:46:868 ( 30 ) - Blue note ? ( Since 29~31 all d sounds too monotonous in this song section, I'd suggest k here )
^ low pitch that i use
01:04:429 ( 14 ) - Blue note ? ( Again 13,14 sounds quite monotonous )-low pitch

01:12:234 ( 3~6 ) - o o o o ? ( Just to fit the vocal better. I don't see any special reasons supporting d k k d )

01:18:088 ( x ) - Add a blue note ? ( It sounds so empty because a significant vocal lies here. Sounds better when this is added imo ) - following 01:07:356 -
01:20:039 ( x ) - ^ ( Same reason ) - same reason

01:21:990 ( 10 ) - Blue note ? ( The pitch is higher than 9 and 11, so k fits better imo )

01:26:868 ( 15 ) - Either add finish, or delete finish at 00:36:136 ( 21 ) ( This is for the consistency of use of finish at same song parts ) - omg nobody told me before

01:29:795 ( 18 ) - Blue note ? ( It has a higher pitch when compared with 17, so k sounds better than d, which makes this section d x 4 and quite monotonous )

-

The hitsounds are still quite random for me
Maybe it's me, but I think quite many of them are used with unknown reason

-----------------------

I'll say all 4 diffs still need more work on hitsounding, and sometimes note arrangements

Try to listen to the song more, and consider more possible solutions to the hitsounds

Find me again when you think the hitsounds have improved. I'll see if I can bubble this then

Star and good luck ~

OzzyOzrock wrote:

[Oni]
00:33:047 - add d? - for 1/1 (break)
00:54:023 (10,11,12,13) - dk kk? I'm trying to ignore some of your pitches, as you seem to have your own style with them or something. -dk accepted but kk not sure because kd looks better
00:55:649 (17,18,19,20,21,22) - for example, these are quite clearly k dd, k dd. I believe you even did this in muzu? -looks better
01:01:828 (38,39,40,41,42) - kkdkk would be better etc -yup

However, this is a very nice map.
[Muzukashii]
Everything looks nice here. Simple and clean.

[Fuutsu]
I'd rather not question your patterns. But they're not bad.

[Kantan]
01:01:502 (12) - The only slider and I don't see it fitting as well here than it would in other parts. - i think it's fit

A hard map to find anything wrong with. Just some weird pitch mapping.
Good luck!

Hanjamon wrote:

Well I'm not good in modding, but i will try :3 (My first time modding xD)

[Kantan]

For me is good :3

[Futsuu]

00:07:844 (9,10) - hmm k d sounds better for me xD - accepted (9) but (10) really bad because same pitch with (9)

[Muzukashii]

00:38:575 (89) - Maybe here, k ? - seems it's hard for muzu player

[Oni]

00:38:901 (151) - I think this is better with k - same pitch with (149)

00:39:063 (152) - and this with d http://puu.sh/4T0eF.jpg -same pitch with (150)

00:41:014 (154,155,158) - Katsus http://puu.sh/4T0jQ.jpg -same pitch anyway and i don't really like your version

01:31:746 (50,51,54) - The same katsus xD http://puu.sh/4T0qP.jpg -same with before

01:40:364 (74,75) - hmm i think sounds better with d k -hear more carefully which low and high pitch

1. HP -1
2. 00:26:868 (34,35) - change to d k?
3. 00:43:941 (55,56,57) - remove finishers? don't know why you accentuate this part
4. 01:34:673 (35,36,37) - ^

1. 00:43:941 (98,99,100) - remove finishers?
2. 01:34:673 (115,116,117) - ^

1. 00:17:600 (75) - change to k?
2. 00:17:925 (76) - ^
3. 00:43:941 (162,163,164) - remove finishers?
4. 00:44:429 (163) - change to k (or K if you didn't removed the finishers)
5. 00:51:746 (1) - change to k?
6. 00:53:697 (9) - ^
7. 00:54:023 (10,11,12,13) - kk kk?
8. 00:59:551 (29) - k?
9. 01:34:673 (59,60,61) - remove finishers?
10. 01:36:949 (63) - remove?
11. 01:37:112 (64) - k?
12. 01:37:925 (67) - k?
13. 01:38:575 (70) - d?

dialgadu77 wrote:

Hello Frans Niko! Let's mod your map!

[Kantan]

Nothing to say.

[Futsuu]

1. HP -1 -ok
2. 00:26:868 (34,35) - change to d k? - 35 changed
3. 00:43:941 (55,56,57) - remove finishers? don't know why you accentuate this part - because it's look better with finishers
4. 01:34:673 (35,36,37) - ^ - ^

[Muzukashii]

1. 00:43:941 (98,99,100) - remove finishers?
2. 01:34:673 (115,116,117) - ^
   same with Futsuu

[Oni]

1. 00:17:600 (75) - change to k? - looks better
2. 00:17:925 (76) - ^ -^
3. 00:43:941 (162,163,164) - remove finishers? -same with futsuu
4. 00:44:429 (163) - change to k (or K if you didn't removed the finishers) -changed
5. 00:51:746 (1) - change to k? - standard pitch anyway
6. 00:53:697 (9) - ^ - same pitch with before
7. 00:54:023 (10,11,12,13) - kk kk? -hear carefully the pitch
8. 00:59:551 (29) - k? - standard pitch like (1)
9. 01:34:673 (59,60,61) - remove finishers? - same with futsuu
10. 01:36:949 (63) - remove? -it fits
11. 01:37:112 (64) - k? -same pitch with her sound
12. 01:37:925 (67) - k? - ^
13. 01:38:575 (70) - d? -same pitch with 69

That's all!

Good luck for rank!

lZenxl wrote:

From lZenxl's Mod Queue ( Doraemon Nostalgia hit me )

d = Don
k = Kat
D = Big Don
K = Big Kat
">" = Change to

Timing Check

Offset

No Problems

BPM

No Problems

Oni

Hit-Sound Check/Addition of Notes

00:29:145 (117) - | d > k | Vocal here is higher pitched than the next note, you might want to emphasise - looks better
00:32:071 (127) - | d > k | Same here -^
00:42:803 | + d | Feels empty, should follow the violin - for a little break
00:43:291 | + d | Same here - ^
00:43:779 | + d | Same here - ^
00:54:510 (12,13) - | k,d > d,k | Note 13 is higher pitched than 12 - hear more carefully because dk kd looks better on this note
01:33:535 | + d | Feels empty, should follow the violin -for a little break
01:34:510 | + d | Same here - ^
01:40:527 (74) - | d > Spinner | The vocal drags on, I strongly suggest a spinner - If so, make sure every diff. ends with one - looks at taiko no tatsujin version

Kiai Time Check

No Problems

General

Ranking Criteria Check

No Problems

AiMod

No Problems

Title Check

Not really at the standard Oni, but fitting with the difficulty spread!

Muzu has pretty much the same problems as Oni, it has too little emphasis on high-pitched notes, I suggest you review it, don't need to add additional notes in my opinion, just change some hit-sounds.

Kantan/Futsuu, I suggest emphasis kat or high-pitched don or low-pitched sounds, since you can't make significant rhythms with low bpm and low difficulty difficulties.

Overall, well placed notes, it's just that some notes needs to be added at harder difficulties, and some wrongly hit-sounded parts.

Good luck ranking this :3

1. [Events]
   //Background and Video events
   0,0,"Doraemon-0.jpg",0,80

2. https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1164600 (0.0)=> https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1164601 (0.80)

1. HP or OD -1 ?

1. Good map

1. Good map

1. 00:21:004 (87,88) - Change color ?
2. 00:32:549 - add d ?
3. 00:35:313 (139) - Del ?
4. 01:03:281 (43) - k , 01:04:257 (47) - d ?
5. 01:25:557 (31) - Del ?

toara_fict wrote:

Hey :3

[General]

1. [Events]
   //Background and Video events
   0,0,"Doraemon-0.jpg",0,80

2. https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1164600 (0.0)=> https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1164601 (0.80)

fixed

[Kantan]

1. HP or OD -1 ?

- nope because it's fit with kantan

[Futsuu]

1. Good map

[Muzu]

1. Good map

[Oni]

1. 00:21:004 (87,88) - Change color ? - no change because it's fit
2. 00:32:549 - add d ? -for a simple patterning :3
3. 00:35:313 (139) - Del ? - nope because it's better than doublet in there
4. 01:03:281 (43) - k , 01:04:257 (47) - d ? - looks good
5. 01:25:557 (31) - Del ?

-same with before

Good Luck ~ !

1. no,pe (:3]__) Clean ^^ but at kantan i see the spacing is not good :/ and 1/3 pattern \:D/

1. Kats Suggestion
   
   
   • 00:46:858 (30) - i guess u should add k here for more consistency with the music
     done :3

1. Delete/Add Suggestion
   
   
   • 00:26:370 to 00:30:273 - feel so empty here. consider add circle that fits/pitch the music/instru
     00:40:029 to 00:43:931 - so empty D:? feel the imo i think you should add spinner on here?
     Same at the 2nd kiai, add spinner.

1. Other Suggestion
   
   
   • Clean (:3]__)

1. Kats Suggestion
   
   
   • 00:24:419 (31) - i suggest should add kat here because no double kat - so not good imo at playing.
     00:26:858 (34) - too many kat, and too emphasis. maybe consider delete kat should more good at kdk. then mirroring at pitching 00:28:322 (36,37,38) - should add kat in (37)
     01:01:980 (16) - delete kat because not higher than (15) and (17)
     01:10:273 (4) - add kat. don't misunderstand what i thinking with 00:26:858 (34) - because katting at 1/1 in not perfect pitch.

1. Delete/Add Suggestion
   
   
   • Clean (:3]__)

1. Other Suggestion
   
   
   • about rhythm is little akward. but different spacing is good ^^

1. Kats Suggestion
   
   
   • some suggestion in other suggestion.

1. Delete/Add Suggestion
   
   
   • Clean (:3]__)

1. Other Suggestion
   
   
   • 00:03:931 (7,8,9,10) - at music, so empty about dddd. while reading pitches, i suggest you should change it to kkdd feel like the music.
     00:04:907 (11) - so example like at kantan and fuutsu, consider add kat here.
     00:07:834 (17,18,19,20) - like 00:03:931 (7,8,9,10) suggestion, but swap it. consider make ddkk while on the pitches. ^^
     00:57:915 (18,19,20,21) - dk dk to follow the pitch.
     k clean (:3]__)

1. Nothing (:3]__) It's special!

DenoisoGoiso wrote:

Yeah. i'm the 2 kudosu :3 omg fark nostalgia with doraemon `-`
Hi~ from your request wwww :3

[General]

1. no,pe (:3]__) Clean ^^ but at kantan i see the spacing is not good :/ and 1/3 pattern \:D/

[Kantan]

1. Kats Suggestion
   
   
   • 00:46:858 (30) - i guess u should add k here for more consistency with the music - how about background sound???? i use it
     done :3

1. Delete/Add Suggestion
   
   
   • 00:26:370 to 00:30:273 - feel so empty here. consider add circle that fits/pitch the music/instru - following the instrument
     00:40:029 to 00:43:931 - so empty D:? feel the imo i think you should add spinner on here? - i'm not sure because i want a break for newbie player
     Same at the 2nd kiai, add spinner - BIG NO because seriously with before
     .

1. Other Suggestion
   
   
   • Clean (:3]__)

[Futsuu]

1. Kats Suggestion
   
   
   • 00:24:419 (31) - i suggest should add kat here because no double kat - so not good imo at playing. -anyway its fit (>not good? im not sure anyway because its fit)
     00:26:858 (34) - too many kat, and too emphasis. maybe consider delete kat should more good at kdk. then mirroring at pitching 00:28:322 (36,37,38) - should add kat in (37) -higher pitch anyway and same with before
     01:01:980 (16) - delete kat because not higher than (15) and (17) - its higher anyway and same pitch with 17 hear more carefully
     01:10:273 (4) - add kat. don't misunderstand what i thinking with 00:26:858 (34) - because katting at 1/1 in not perfect pitch. - changed by my pattern (not the 4)

1. Delete/Add Suggestion
   
   
   • Clean (:3]__)

1. Other Suggestion
   
   
   • about rhythm is little akward. but different spacing is good ^^

[Muzukashii]

1. Kats Suggestion
   
   
   • some suggestion in other suggestion.

1. Delete/Add Suggestion
   
   
   • Clean (:3]__)

1. Other Suggestion
   
   
   • 00:03:931 (7,8,9,10) - at music, so empty about dddd. while reading pitches, i suggest you should change it to kkdd feel like the music. - its hard anyway for muzukashii player
     00:04:907 (11) - so example like at kantan and fuutsu, consider add kat here. - i won't because i use 1/1 pattern like Oni (but oni use 1/3)
     00:07:834 (17,18,19,20) - like 00:03:931 (7,8,9,10) suggestion, but swap it. consider make ddkk while on the pitches. ^^ - its hard anyway like before
     00:57:915 (18,19,20,21) - dk dk to follow the pitch. - im not sure if muzukashii can use too many dk / kd because its hard
     k clean (:3]__)

[Oni]

1. Nothing (:3]__) It's special!

Can't say again.... this map is good (:3]__)
Good luck ^^