forum

fripSide - holy night magic (Short Ver.) [Osu|Taiko]

posted
Total Posts
53
Topic Starter
NewRulerNA
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 2012年12月13日 at 15:24:55

Artist: fripSide
Title: holy night magic (Short Ver.)
Source: Merichri ~Juunenburi no White Christmas~
Tags: nao whirlpool visual novel eroge opening merry christmas xmas SakiK jih7491 Jing
BPM: 117
Filesize: 18751kb
Play Time: 02:11
Difficulties Available:
  1. Easy (1.65 stars, 114 notes)
  2. Jing's Taiko (4.78 stars, 621 notes)
  3. Merry Christmas (4.96 stars, 326 notes)
  4. Normal (4.17 stars, 207 notes)
  5. SakiK's Hard (4.74 stars, 332 notes)
  6. Taiko Oni (4.89 stars, 614 notes)
Download: fripSide - holy night magic (Short Ver.)
Download: fripSide - holy night magic (Short Ver.) (no video)
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
リ☆リ ~10年ぶりのワイトリスマス~
Opening: holy night magic

Hard - SakiK
Taiko - Jing



Nov 6, 2012 - changed video. thanks h-728

modder list
NewibornCLivee
noclip
Guy
Cuvelia
blissfulyoshi
Dagger-Gazel
Garven
ykcarrot
Melophobia
Neptune
I totally love this song, I hope this map is going to be awesome! :)
take my star already. :3
Topic Starter
NewRulerNA
Thanks Neptune~ <3
Jing
Taiko diff Completed :D

diff link → http://puu.sh/1ht44

Taiko BG:
Topic Starter
NewRulerNA
added~
and some tag was added
SakiK
here is my diff. thx IRC mod
and thx join my diff


http://puu.sh/1jGQ6
Topic Starter
NewRulerNA

SakiK wrote:

here is my diff. thx IRC mod
and thx join my diff


http://puu.sh/1jGQ6
updated
-xNaCLx-
Req. taiko mod from my queue ;)

All of them are suggestions.

[Jing's Taiko]
The volume is quite high, adjust it lower especially for the first part and the last part of the song which have no lyrics.

00:18:543 - K , just like in 00:30:081
00:21:107 - k
00:29:312 - k
noclip
Insane:

00:43:269 (1,3) - stand by each other. pretty inconvenient
00:54:299 (5,6) - Arrange the notes away
01:32:019 (6,9) - new combo?

Hard:

00:02:645 (2,3) - distance
I advise you to work with a combo. They obviously placed incorrectly
Guy
from #modreqs~
いつもお世話になっているのでModさせてもらいます!

 

Easy


 ● SliderMultiplierが0.7999999999...となっているので0,8にしましょう
 ● 00:52:754 (1,2) - 下の画像のような感じでy軸を揃えるような配置にしてみてはどうでしょう?
 ● 01:09:740 (1,2) - 音取りの提案です

 ● 01:11:504 (3,4) - ここも上記のような音取りのほうが自分は好みです

 

Normal


 ● 00:47:019 (5) - ここのスライダーは曲げないほうが見栄えが良いと思いました
 ● 01:49:446 (3) - 下の画像のように(2)のスライダーをフォローするようなスライダーにしてみてはどうでしょう?

 

SakiK's Hard


 ● 00:03:158 (3) - distanceがx1.80くらいになってますが、00:05:209 (3) - こっちは特に離していないので00:03:158 (3) - こっちも近づけてみてはどうでしょう?
 ● 00:17:774 (1) - 少し星の形が歪んで見えるので(1),(6)の位置を少しずらせば綺麗になると思います
 ● 00:44:151 (7) - 下の画像のように00:43:269 (5) - ここのスライダーをコピーして、Ctrl+H,Ctrl+Gした後角度を-70°して同じ位置に配置すると綺麗に見えます。
 ● 01:16:799 - note追加?
 ● 02:12:387 (4) - finish?

 

Merry Christmas


 ● 00:49:887 (2) - このスライダーも(3)同様曲げてみてはどうでしょう?
 ● 01:30:475 (1) - backにいろんな音があるので長いスライダーにしてしまうのはもったいない気がするのでいくつか提案します~


以上です~Nice song Nice map!
頑張ってください ;)
Topic Starter
NewRulerNA

noclip wrote:

Insane:

00:43:269 (1,3) - stand by each other. pretty inconvenient
:arrow: fmm.....I do not think it....but I made ​​a little adjustment.
00:54:299 (5,6) - Arrange the notes away
:arrow: no changed. these note are placed to follow the volume of the vocal. and note are making continuous triangle.
01:32:019 (6,9) - new combo?
:arrow: why? I think this suggestion make to break NC pattern

Guy wrote:

from #modreqs~
いつもお世話になっているのでModさせてもらいます!

 

Easy


 ● SliderMultiplierが0.7999999999...となっているので0,8にしましょう
:arrow: peppy & mm201曰くosuファイルの直接編集はその項目に関してはしてはいけないらしいのでno changed
これが問題を持つこともなく、僅かな問題を生み出す可能性を持っています・・・・orz

 ● 00:52:754 (1,2) - 下の画像のような感じでy軸を揃えるような配置にしてみてはどうでしょう?
:arrow: 00:52:313 (5,1,2) - で正三角形をここで使用しており、そのバランスを崩してまで使用する必要性を感じなかったのでこのままで
 ● 01:09:740 (1,2) - 音取りの提案です

:arrow: 単調さを崩すことができ、プレイにもそれが悪い影響をもたらすことはないので採用
 ● 01:11:504 (3,4) - ここも上記のような音取りのほうが自分は好みです
:arrow: fixed

 

Normal


 ● 00:47:019 (5) - ここのスライダーは曲げないほうが見栄えが良いと思いました
:arrow: no changed. この難易度は直線よりも曲線的なスライダーが多く使われており、この箇所に関してもサークルをフォローした配置にさせるほうが一貫性をもたせるほうが理にかなっています
また流れとしてみても00:46:578 (3,4,5,6) が緩やかなカーブを描いており、そこに直線を混ぜることで中途半端なカーブとなってしまう可能性を持っています
上記2点の理由から私はその提案を採用せず、現状維持します

 ● 01:49:446 (3) - 下の画像のように(2)のスライダーをフォローするようなスライダーにしてみてはどうでしょう?
:arrow: fixed

 

Merry Christmas


 ● 00:49:887 (2) - このスライダーも(3)同様曲げてみてはどうでしょう?
:arrow: 一応変更はしましたが、あまりよい配置が浮かばず、Distanceのバランスなどを考慮していくと元に戻してしまうかも知れません
 ● 01:30:475 (1) - backにいろんな音があるので長いスライダーにしてしまうのはもったいない気がするのでいくつか提案します~


:arrow: 後者の案を採用
Thanks guys
Cuvelia
Hi ~ , Random Taiko modding ~ .

These are all suggestion. If you don't like them , you could ignore

| d = don | k = kat | D = BIG DON | K = BIG KAT | re = remove |


[Jing's Taiko]
  1. 01:45:254 (1) - K
  2. 01:50:218 (1) - k
  3. 01:54:740 (1) - K

    nice taiko diff :)

[Taiko Oni]
  1. 00:18:543 (1) - D
  2. 00:33:343 (1) - k
  3. 00:48:784 - add D
  4. 00:54:740 (2) - d
  5. 00:59:372 (1) - D
  6. 01:20:549 (2) - k
  7. 01:23:968 (2) - re
  8. 01:47:460 (2) - k
  9. 01:59:372 (4) - K

good luck !!
Topic Starter
NewRulerNA

Cuvelia wrote:

| d = don | k = kat | D = BIG DON | K = BIG KAT | re = remove |

[Taiko Oni]
  1. 00:18:543 (1) - D
    :arrow: no changed. I thought this D do not follow song.
  2. 00:33:343 (1) - k
  3. 00:48:784 - add D
  4. 00:54:740 (2) - d
  5. 00:59:372 (1) - D
    :arrow: same as 00:18:543 (1)
  6. 01:20:549 (2) - k
  7. 01:23:968 (2) - re
  8. 01:47:460 (2) - k
  9. 01:59:372 (4) - K
I fixed all others. Thanks a lot
SakiK

noclip wrote:

Hard:

00:02:645 (2,3) - distance
I advise you to work with a combo. They obviously placed incorrectlyfix


Guy wrote:

 

SakiK's Hard


 ● 00:03:158 (3) - distanceがx1.80くらいになってますが、00:05:209 (3) - こっちは特に離していないので00:03:158 (3) - こっちも近づけてみてはどうでしょう?fix
 ● 00:17:774 (1) - 少し星の形が歪んで見えるので(1),(6)の位置を少しずらせば綺麗になると思いますfix
 ● 00:44:151 (7) - 下の画像のように00:43:269 (5) - ここのスライダーをコピーして、Ctrl+H,Ctrl+Gした後角度を-70°して同じ位置に配置すると綺麗に見えます。fix
 ● 01:16:799 - note追加?ここはちょっとしたジャンプの後+曲に切り替わりでスタックさせた上で少し止まらせて間空けるこだわりなのです・・・sorry、no
 ● 02:12:387 (4) - finish?fix
http://puu.sh/1nw49
thx modding~
Jing
Modification is completed → http://puu.sh/1o8Zf

Thx :)
Suimya
I just found out that you should change the artist to nao >< and add "fripside" to the tag ~~

ok that's all ~
Topic Starter
NewRulerNA

Sekai-nyan wrote:

I just found out that you should change the artist to nao >< and add "fripside" to the tag ~~

ok that's all ~
I know it. this song is available both names. but fripSide was highlighted in official and other. therefore I do not change it.
If you found other than video source, I might change it.
blissfulyoshi
Time to move on in my Christmas Queue.

I don't know how to mod taiko, so I probably won't give a bubble unless I am more confident that it is fine. (Also, some BATs were telling me about case on case scenarios for 2 taiko diffs, so I'll let someone else judge taiko stuff)

Easy:
Normal/Aesthetics Mod:
00:51:431 (4) - If possible move this note up a bit since it is slightly clipped by the bottom of the screen
01:09:740 (1,2) - these 2 sliders would look nicer if they did not overlap each other
01:18:784 (3) - Being nitpicky, but could you please move this slider down a bit so that it does not touch the hp bar. The overlap does not look that great.
01:43:490 (3,1) - Even though you barely see the overlap while playing, these 2 sliders would look nicer if they did not overlap each other

Combo mod:
00:47:019 (4) - Since all of your previous combos are 2 long white ticks long, I would add a new combo here. Also, since the music suggests it, I would just keep this combo 1 white tick long.
02:09:299 (1,2,3) - I feel that this area would follow the music better if the the combo on 1 is removed since 2 long white ticks have no passed yet, and add a new combo to 3 because of the difference in the way the music is played during that part.

Normal:
Normal/Aesthetics Mod:
01:06:872 (6) - Being nitpicky, but could you please move this slider down a bit so that it does not touch the hp bar. The overlap does not look that great.

Combo mod:
00:22:133 (1,2) - The combos fit the lyrics better if you remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 2
00:47:019 (5) - same as Easy
00:52:754 (1) - a lot of the lyrics from here to the end of the song could be separated into 2 combos like 00:55:181 (6) and 00:59:372 (4), so I advise you check the next section and add new combos where you think new combos are appropriate
01:03:343 (4,1) - since this didn't fit under what I said above, also remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 4 since that fits the lyrics better
01:26:725 (6,1) - remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 6to fit the lyrics better
02:11:725 (4) - same as Easy

SakiK's Hard:
Combo mod:
00:43:931 (6) - if you want to make the combo shorter, put a new combo here (don't really care if you do this or not)
00:53:857 (4) - new combo to be consistent with 00:50:328 (1) (I think you are against 2 short combos though, so again up to you)
01:07:975 (4) - ^
02:00:696 (7,1) - remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 7 to fit the music better

Jing's Taiko: Seems fine to me.

Taiko Oni:
00:48:122 (1,2,3,1) - I sort of want this consistent with Merry Christmas Diff, but whatever

Merry Christmas:
Normal/Aesthetics Mod:
01:34:225 (12,1) - This overlap looks messy
02:11:725 (1) - This slider will loop better if it didn't overlap the hp bar

Combo mod:
00:38:196 (1,2,3) - this combo is weird, since it is really short in comparison to some of the combos around it, 1 sounds like it belongs in the previous combo and 3 sounds like it belongs in the next combo. I highly suggest you rearrange some of the combos around here
00:43:269 (1,2) - remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 2 to fit the music better
02:08:637 (1.4) - I personally rather have the new combo on 4 instead of 1 to fit teh music better, but I am fine either way.

==========================
Standard maps seem pretty much fine. Sadly I don't know what other BATs want me to do about taiko, so I'll have to leave that alone for now.
Topic Starter
NewRulerNA

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Time to move on in my Christmas Queue.

I don't know how to mod taiko, so I probably won't give a bubble unless I am more confident that it is fine. (Also, some BATs were telling me about case on case scenarios for 2 taiko diffs, so I'll let someone else judge taiko stuff)

Easy:
Normal/Aesthetics Mod:
00:51:431 (4) - If possible move this note up a bit since it is slightly clipped by the bottom of the screen
:arrow: oh....ok, fixed
01:09:740 (1,2) - these 2 sliders would look nicer if they did not overlap each other
:arrow: fixed
01:18:784 (3) - Being nitpicky, but could you please move this slider down a bit so that it does not touch the hp bar. The overlap does not look that great.
:arrow: changed few grid
01:43:490 (3,1) - Even though you barely see the overlap while playing, these 2 sliders would look nicer if they did not overlap each other
:arrow: I think so too.add a small adjustment.

Combo mod:
00:47:019 (4) - Since all of your previous combos are 2 long white ticks long, I would add a new combo here. Also, since the music suggests it, I would just keep this combo 1 white tick long.
:arrow: ok
02:09:299 (1,2,3) - I feel that this area would follow the music better if the the combo on 1 is removed since 2 long white ticks have no passed yet, and add a new combo to 3 because of the difference in the way the music is played during that part.
:arrow: There is no reason to oppose. changed

Normal:
Normal/Aesthetics Mod:
01:06:872 (6) - Being nitpicky, but could you please move this slider down a bit so that it does not touch the hp bar. The overlap does not look that great.
:arrow: fixed

Combo mod:
00:22:133 (1,2) - The combos fit the lyrics better if you remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 2
:arrow: fixed
00:47:019 (5) - same as Easy
:arrow: fixed
00:52:754 (1) - a lot of the lyrics from here to the end of the song could be separated into 2 combos like 00:55:181 (6) and 00:59:372 (4), so I advise you check the next section and add new combos where you think new combos are appropriate
:arrow: okay....added substantial adjustment.
01:03:343 (4,1) - since this didn't fit under what I said above, also remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 4 since that fits the lyrics better
:arrow: fixed
01:26:725 (6,1) - remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 6to fit the lyrics better
:arrow: fixed
02:11:725 (4) - same as Easy
:arrow: fixed

Taiko Oni:
00:48:122 (1,2,3,1) - I sort of want this consistent with Merry Christmas Diff, but whatever
:arrow: no changed. 1/6 beat can follow the song than 1/4 beat. so did not change it.

Merry Christmas:
Normal/Aesthetics Mod:
01:34:225 (12,1) - This overlap looks messy
:arrow: fixed
02:11:725 (1) - This slider will loop better if it didn't overlap the hp bar
:arrow: fixed

Combo mod:
00:38:196 (1,2,3) - this combo is weird, since it is really short in comparison to some of the combos around it, 1 sounds like it belongs in the previous combo and 3 sounds like it belongs in the next combo. I highly suggest you rearrange some of the combos around here
:arrow: This NC followed the song. so this NC is right.
00:43:269 (1,2) - remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 2 to fit the music better
:arrow: fixed
02:08:637 (1.4) - I personally rather have the new combo on 4 instead of 1 to fit teh music better, but I am fine either way.
:arrow: fixed

==========================
Standard maps seem pretty much fine. Sadly I don't know what other BATs want me to do about taiko, so I'll have to leave that alone for now.
I see~

thanks!
SakiK

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Combo mod:
00:43:931 (6) - if you want to make the combo shorter, put a new combo here (don't really care if you do this or not)nmm..sorry don't want to make shorter
00:53:857 (4) - new combo to be consistent with 00:50:328 (1) (I think you are against 2 short combos though, so again up to you)^
01:07:975 (4) - ^^
02:00:696 (7,1) - remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 7 to fit the music betterfix,I did not notice thx
.
thx modding~ http://puu.sh/1tkTC
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply