Rakuen wrote:

Hi~

M4M from your queue~

My map: CLIFF EGDE feat. Nakamura Maiko - Endless Tears

A few suggestions here

[General]
It's nice but the SV is a little too hard for me >w<
The BGs is nice, but I suggest maybe some "Natural scenery" or something that makes you wanna cry like "Pity/Poor family" or "someone died and you cry"
If you get what I mean
I think it fine, double SV for music below 100 BPM >w<
[Beginner]
How can you treat Beginner with that SV T_T
Maybe increase AR?
Okay here
02:24:610 - Add circle to match set with 02:19:761 (2,3,4) -
02:25:216 - ^
Fixed all diff owo

[Standard]
01:15:216 (1,2,3,4) - Put 4 more circles, spam it! It makes more fun cuz it's a smooth music (whateva smooth means)
01:34:610 (1,2,3,4) - ^
Disagree here, coz it will make this diff spend hard too much ._.
01:38:246 (2) - No more clap starts here until here 02:04:307 - ? Consider adding custom hitsounds
I'll add later <3
02:17:337 (4,5) - Swap their place and then stack the circle on head of the slider
Okay.
02:26:125 (2) - Ctrl+G
Okay.

[TuHard]
KIAI times
That's all >w<
Added.

[Challenge]
00:51:580 (3) - Move little more up
01:55:822 (8,9) - NC (heavy hitsound and far timing distance)
02:10:064 (5) - Ctrl+G, make it like flower, prettier (dont worry, players wont get bored but enjoyable)
Fixed all :3

Hope it helps.

1. Don't you think 1.8x SV is quite fast, even though the song's BPM value is just 99? And what's more, the DS is only 0.6x... It's quite unbalanced, you know, since the sliders are fast but the spacing is small. It makes this diff a little uncomfortable to play. But no need to remap, I guess. Just saying my opinions.
2. 01:02:792 (1,2) - Swap NC? This pattern is similar to 01:12:489 (4,1), and you NC'd the object that starts at the beginning of a new stanza instead of the one before it, so do it to make the combo pattern consistent, please.
3. 01:11:580 (3,4,1) - Try this? Gives a nicer flow and makes the pattern look neater.
4. 01:47:943 (2) - Since the instruments are strong on the white and red ticks here, why not mapping them instead of making a 3/4 slider? The instrument on the blue tick is weak, and it may confuse players since the stronger instruments aren't mapped. (Applies to all 3/4 sliders, actually; they feel quite forced here.)
5. 02:10:974 (1) - You can improve the blanket with 02:09:761 (2) here by moving this slider one grid up and left.
6. 02:18:246 (1,2,3,4,1) - Aren't these notes a little too hard for Easy players? I mean, it's a 5-note 1/2 stream here, and it can be too quick for them.
7. 02:27:943 (1,2,3,4,1) - ^

1. Whoa, now. The average (SV * BPM) value for Normal diffs are, from my observation, around 170 points. But in your map, the value is 237.6 (99 * 2.4)... I really want you to consider making the SV lower now, since it's just too fast. The SV you use here is actually bordering to what would be used in a Hard diff.
2. 01:21:883 (3,4) - The flow can be better if you moved (3) to (52,304) and (4) to (164,348).
3. 01:32:186 (1) - Make the blanket here better by moving the middle node to (44,232) and the last one to (132,148)?

1. 00:19:458 (1,1) - I don't really like the overlap here. You can easily move the circle to the right, you know?
2. 00:24:913 - Just saying: There's a strong instrument sound here, and yet you mapped the weaker ones around it, resulting in confusion for the players while hitting the slider. This happens occasionally throughout the diff, so I guess it's intentional, but it's just... awkward to play because of how you made the rhythm here.
3. 00:37:186 (4) - The instrument at 00:37:034 makes it feel like as if this slider is placed there instead of at 00:37:186, making 00:36:883 (3,4) feel like a 1/4 jump. This is related to the previous point: You mapped the weaker instruments in a way that skips the strong ones and makes the players confused. I'd do something like this here, instead.
4. 00:43:701 (2,3) - The flow is kinda strange here, because you had to hit 00:43:549 (1) first, then hold the short (2) slider, and you suddenly have to make a wider move to 00:44:004 (3). Just make the spacing consistent, I suppose?
5. 01:27:792 (2,3) - Similar to 00:37:186 (4). This thing happens occasionally too across the diff, and it's kinda problematic. In the end, I just don't really like how you made the rhythm here; the other things are pretty fine. It's just the rhythm that can be confusing at times.
6. 01:38:549 (2,3) - Make the spacing 0.8x, since that's the spacing you usually use if you want the 1/4 notes to touch each other?

21:42 Backstep: owo
21:42 Backstep: xD
21:42 Hinsvar: :D/
21:42 Hinsvar: I'm planning for an M4M with you actually lol
21:43 Backstep: Ah... I see and which your map o.o?
21:44 Backstep: I'll mod now before i'm busy with my homework :/
21:44 *Hinsvar is listening to [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/331138 BoA - Winter Love]
21:45 Backstep: Oh... I see your map now xD
21:45 Hinsvar: Uh, do you want an IRC mod for the Challenge diff instead?
21:45 Hinsvar: :D/
21:45 Hinsvar: Oh wait, you're about to mod my map now? o.o
21:45 Backstep: Sure, why not owo
21:45 Hinsvar: Oh, okay.
21:46 Hinsvar: Because I think it'll be easier to mod the diff this way.
21:46 Hinsvar: First off, I know this diff has a lot of jumps and the spacing is big in general, but...
21:46 Hinsvar: Why AR9?
21:47 Hinsvar: It just doesn't feel quite right, even with how intense the map is.
21:47 Hinsvar: I personally find myself more comfortable with AR8.
21:49 Backstep: Ah.. you're right D:
21:49 Backstep: fixed <3
21:50 Hinsvar: lol okay :D
21:50 Hinsvar: Hmm, let's see...
21:52 Hinsvar: 00:25:216 (5,6) - I prefer to see these two notes reversed (Ctrl+G).
21:52 Hinsvar: It flows better that way.
21:52 Hinsvar: The flow between 00:25:368 (6,7) - will be somewhat weird, though.
21:53 Hinsvar: Feel free to leave (5,6) unchanged if you don't want to rework the pattern lol
21:54 Backstep: haha I don't change here, coz i think my pattern flow better lol
21:54 Hinsvar: Fine then :P
21:55 Hinsvar: 00:26:580 - I'd add a note here; the instrument is relatively loud.
21:55 Hinsvar: Feels empty, you know.
21:56 Backstep: I agree, but if I add note what should I paste... cover with 00:26:731 (1) ? lol
21:58 Backstep: However I want player to rest a bit of stream :/
21:59 Hinsvar: Hmm, it doesn't feel like the correct time to give a rest, though.
22:00 Hinsvar: 00:23:852 (8) - I'd remove this one instead, since the instrument is very faint.
22:00 Hinsvar: That will allow a short time to rest, I suppose.
22:02 Hinsvar: For 00:26:580 - ...maybe [http://puu.sh/5MkHt.jpg this] will work?
22:04 Hinsvar: 00:28:549 (7,8,9,10) - Maybe make them a square? Flows way better than the previous pattern, where 00:28:246 (5,6,7,8) - is too linear, IMO.
22:05 Hinsvar: 00:37:943 (5) - I know you want to make the end stacked with 00:36:428 (1) - , but this makes the spacing inconsistent.
22:06 Hinsvar: Also, because of how intense the map is, it can easily be readable as a 1/4 jump...
22:06 Hinsvar: Especially with the instrument at 00:37:792 - .
22:10 Backstep: 00:28:549 (7,8,9,10) - About this I think it fine... but 00:28:701 (8,9) - will hard to see note a bit :/
22:11 Hinsvar: Yeah, exactly what I have in mind too.
22:11 Hinsvar: It's kinda hard to make a square without getting stuff overlapped.
22:13 Hinsvar: 00:47:186 (6) - Make it like [http://puu.sh/5Mlcp.jpg this]? Again, nicer flow~
22:14 Backstep: Ah... okay ^
22:15 Hinsvar: 00:52:337 (5,6,7) - I'd make a triangle like [http://puu.sh/5MljP.jpg this] to make the flow better.
22:15 Hinsvar: ...I'm talking about flow a lot today lol
22:16 Hinsvar: There's a chance that (7) will overlap 00:53:398 (12) - , though.
22:16 Hinsvar: This is difficult lol
22:17 Backstep: lol
22:17 Hinsvar: 01:02:186 (5) - Move this to (324,48)? :P
22:17 Hinsvar: I think you know the reason already.
22:17 Hinsvar: I'm bored of saying "flow" all the day ``
22:18 Hinsvar: Not that the flow is really bad though; just had a lot of ideas to improve it today.
22:18 Backstep: It should be 324, 42 orz owo
22:19 Hinsvar: Do as you wish :P
22:19 Hinsvar: 01:04:155 (6,7) - Ctrl+G?
22:19 Hinsvar: The current flow feels pretty forced lol
22:21 Hinsvar: 01:14:004 (4,1,2,3,4) - I'd make a star or a polygon to follow how the instruments are played, instead.
22:21 Hinsvar: It's hard to explain, but it does feel better.
22:22 Backstep:  I think I can do it :3
22:22 Hinsvar: Go ahead then :P
22:25 Hinsvar: Oh good, my parents are starting to tell me to go off.
22:25 Hinsvar: I'll try to keep modding, but I think I won't have the time to post the log lol
22:26 Hinsvar: 01:42:792 (5) - http://puu.sh/5MlLt.jpg ?
22:26 Hinsvar: For flow, yep.
22:26 Backstep: save your log first before go to bed :0
22:27 Hinsvar: I'll save it of course :D
22:27 Hinsvar: 01:56:883 (2,3) - Don't you think players will mistake (2) to be the head of the slider, while it's actually (3)?
22:29 Hinsvar: 02:22:186 (7,8) - The flow will be better if they were reversed/Ctrl+G'd, but it will break the pattern here, I guess.
22:29 Hinsvar: Okay, that's all.
22:29 Hinsvar: The other things look fine to me.
22:31 Backstep: Thanks for IRC mod :3
22:31 Hinsvar: No problem :D
22:31 Hinsvar: I have to be quick.

Combo3 : 193,132,255
Combo4 : 193,132,255

SPOILER

SPOILER

216,260,123701,6,0,B|256:232|44:172|136:116|152:12|256:88|256:88|360:12|376:116|468:172|256:232|256:356,1,750,0|8,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
232,120,123701,102,0,B|240:88|216:40|128:48|100:124|72:172|208:216|256:288|256:288|304:216|440:172|412:124|384:48|296:40|272:88|280:120,1,750

SPOILER

SPOILER

gokugohan12468 wrote:

osu! needs more DJ Okawari

Artist is DJ Okawari feat. Chieko Kinbara

1. 00:43:852 (2,4,6) - น่าจะให้มันเรียงตรงกันไปเลย
2. 00:43:701 (1,3,7) - ^
3. 01:00:822 (1,2) - ยัง blanket ไมค่อยดี http://puu.sh/b0jP7/9b92334967.jpg
4. 01:02:943 (8,1) - ยัง blanket ไม่ค่อยดีhttp://puu.sh/b0jSp/038ddf3576.jpg
5. 01:05:368 (10,2) - ให้มันเรียงตรงกันดีกว่านะ เราว่า เพราะตรงนี้ 01:05:519 (1,3) - ก็อุตส่าเรียงตรงกันละ
6. 01:10:519 (2) - y=322 ตรงนี้ 01:10:519 (2,3,4,5) - จะได้โค้งสวยขึ้น
7. 01:11:580 (7) - จังหวะดูไม่เข้าเท่า 01:11:883 (8,9,10) - นะ ลองแปลง เป็นวงกลมดู http://puu.sh/b0kHw/874049c999.jpg
8. 01:21:125 (3) - น่าจะ NC เพราะ มันเริ่ม jump และเวลามี waypoint ของโน๊ต 2 ตัวนี้ 01:20:368 (2,3) - มันดูยังไงๆอยู่
9. 01:33:398 (1) - NC เพราะ มันดูดีกว่านะถ้าไม่มี waypoint ของ 01:33:246 (6,7) -
10. 01:37:034 (1) - เอา slider โค้งๆดีกว่าเราว่า มันตรงแล้วมันดูไม่เหมาะกับเพลงเลย
11. 01:55:368 (5,6) - เรียงให้ตรงกันจะได้เหมือน 01:55:822 (1,2) -
12. 01:55:822 (1,2) - Rhythm ไม่เหมือน ตรงนี้อะ 00:37:943 (5,6,7) - เราว่าเอาให้มันเหมือนกันแต่วางโน๊ตต่างกันก็ยังดีนะ
13. 02:03:701 (1) - ลองจบ slider ตรงนี้ไหม 02:06:125 - ตรงจังหวะตามเพลงดี
14. 02:29:004 (4,5,6,7) - เรียงตรงกันดีกว่านะเราว่า
    สำหรับ diff นี้ ที่จริงจะให้ลอง NC บางจุดอยู่แต่เห็นมันดูเยอะแล้วไม่ค่อยจำเป็นเพราะเราแค่อยากให้ NC จะได้ ลบ waypoint จากโน๊ตตัวก่อนหน้าโน๊ตตัวนั้นเช่น 01:24:155 (8,9,10,11,12) -

• AR 8.5 เลยหรอ เราว่า 8 ดีกว่า เพราะ AR ของ Standard = 6 เพิ่มมาตั้ง 2.5 (เราว่าเยอะไปนะ)
  ็HP=7 OD=7 แต่ star diff=2.83 ดูไม่ค่อยเข้ากันนะ

1. 00:38:095 (5,6,7,8) - เราเปลี่ยนเป็น slider แบบนี้ดีกว่า มันดูเข้ากับเพลงมากกว่า http://puu.sh/b0lHA/42f6783f50.jpg
2. 00:59:761 (6) - เอาขึ้นมานิดนึงวางต่ำเกินไป
3. 01:01:580 (4,5,6,9) - น่าจะ stack
4. 01:41:580 (6,1) - น่าจะเรียงตรงกัน
5. 01:45:822 (4) - NC เพราะ spacing เปลี่ยนแปลง
6. 02:03:701 (1) - เหมือน Another
   สำหรับ diff นี้เราว่า ตรงนี้ 01:56:428 (1,2,1,2) - ดูง่ายไปหน่อย อย่างอื่นก็โอเคละ

1. 00:22:792 (2) - เอียงหางไปทางขวานิดนึง flow เกือบจะโอละ
2. 00:46:125 (1,2) - พยายามอย่าเปลี่ยน rhythm ดีกว่า เพราะ คนเล่นจะงงเอา
3. 01:01:580 (4,5) - น่าจะขยับขึ้นนิดนึงจะได้โค้งกับโน๊ตตัวก่อนหน้านั้นสวยขึ้น ลอง x=171 y=336
4. 01:06:731 (5) - ลองโค้งหางอีกนิด หรือ เอาให้มันโค้งคล้ายๆกับ 01:07:337 (6) -
5. 01:33:398 (5) - น่าจะ NC นะ 8 combo ดูจะยาวไป และนายก็เปลี่ยน pattern ด้วย
6. 02:03:701 (1) - เหมือน Another
7. 02:27:640 (4,1,2,3) - ดูโค้งไม่ค่อยสวย ลองย้าย (1) ไป x=197 y=321
   diff นี้ใช้ได้อยู่

CelsiusLK wrote:

Hello there frommy modding queue

[General]
Fine

[Another]
ทำไมไม่เอา HP=7 ไปเลย?
มันไม่จำเป็นหรอกนะเราว่า 7.2 กำลังดีเลย ไม่เร็ว ไม่ช้าเกินไป

1. 00:43:852 (2,4,6) - น่าจะให้มันเรียงตรงกันไปเลย
   เรียงเป็นรูปสี่เหลี่ยม กะรูปห้าเลี่ยมติดกัน (คงไม่แก้ล่ะ)
2. 00:43:701 (1,3,7) - ^
   ตาม คห. ด้านบน
3. 01:00:822 (1,2) - ยัง blanket ไมค่อยดี http://puu.sh/b0jP7/9b92334967.jpg
   แก้ละ
4. 01:02:943 (8,1) - ยัง blanket ไม่ค่อยดีhttp://puu.sh/b0jSp/038ddf3576.jpg
   นิดหน่อยคงไม่เป็นไรม้างง
5. 01:05:368 (10,2) - ให้มันเรียงตรงกันดีกว่านะ เราว่า เพราะตรงนี้ 01:05:519 (1,3) - ก็อุตส่าเรียงตรงกันละ
   เลื่อนเรียบร้อย
6. 01:10:519 (2) - y=322 ตรงนี้ 01:10:519 (2,3,4,5) - จะได้โค้งสวยขึ้น
   โอเช
7. 01:11:580 (7) - จังหวะดูไม่เข้าเท่า 01:11:883 (8,9,10) - นะ ลองแปลง เป็นวงกลมดู http://puu.sh/b0kHw/874049c999.jpg
   แก้ฮะ
8. 01:21:125 (3) - น่าจะ NC เพราะ มันเริ่ม jump และเวลามี waypoint ของโน๊ต 2 ตัวนี้ 01:20:368 (2,3) - มันดูยังไงๆอยู่
   อ่าโอเคๆ
9. 01:33:398 (1) - NC เพราะ มันดูดีกว่านะถ้าไม่มี waypoint ของ 01:33:246 (6,7) -
   ^
10. 01:37:034 (1) - เอา slider โค้งๆดีกว่าเราว่า มันตรงแล้วมันดูไม่เหมาะกับเพลงเลย
    แล้วแต่คนชอบนะแต่ คหสต คิดว่ามีแต่โค้งๆ map จะดูน่าเบื่อนะ มีสไลด์รูปแปลกๆบ้างก็ดี
11. 01:55:368 (5,6) - เรียงให้ตรงกันจะได้เหมือน 01:55:822 (1,2) -
    โอเช
12. 01:55:822 (1,2) - Rhythm ไม่เหมือน ตรงนี้อะ 00:37:943 (5,6,7) - เราว่าเอาให้มันเหมือนกันแต่วางโน๊ตต่างกันก็ยังดีนะ
    มันไม่จำเป็นเลยที่ต้องทำจังหวะแพทเทิลเดียวกับอันก่อนๆ แปลกๆบางก็ดีเพราะเพลงนี้รัว 1/4 เกือบทั้งเพลง เหมือนให้คนเล่นพักมือด้วย
13. 02:03:701 (1) - ลองจบ slider ตรงนี้ไหม 02:06:125 - ตรงจังหวะตามเพลงดี
    อันนี้ขอไม่แก้เน้อ
14. 02:29:004 (4,5,6,7) - เรียงตรงกันดีกว่านะเราว่า
    ไม่แก้นะครับ ไว้ jump ท้ายเพลง
    สำหรับ diff นี้ ที่จริงจะให้ลอง NC บางจุดอยู่แต่เห็นมันดูเยอะแล้วไม่ค่อยจำเป็นเพราะเราแค่อยากให้ NC จะได้ ลบ waypoint จากโน๊ตตัวก่อนหน้าโน๊ตตัวนั้นเช่น 01:24:155 (8,9,10,11,12) -

[Hyper]

• AR 8.5 เลยหรอ เราว่า 8 ดีกว่า เพราะ AR ของ Standard = 6 เพิ่มมาตั้ง 2.5 (เราว่าเยอะไปนะ)
  ็HP=7 OD=7 แต่ star diff=2.83 ดูไม่ค่อยเข้ากันนะ

1. 00:38:095 (5,6,7,8) - เราเปลี่ยนเป็น slider แบบนี้ดีกว่า มันดูเข้ากับเพลงมากกว่า http://puu.sh/b0lHA/42f6783f50.jpg
   โอเช
2. 00:59:761 (6) - เอาขึ้นมานิดนึงวางต่ำเกินไป
   โน้ตนี้ที่วางต่ำ เพื่อลากเป็นเส้นให้ตรง (7)
3. 01:01:580 (4,5,6,9) - น่าจะ stack
   โอเช
4. 01:41:580 (6,1) - น่าจะเรียงตรงกัน
   ^
5. 01:45:822 (4) - NC เพราะ spacing เปลี่ยนแปลง
   อ่าหะ
6. 02:03:701 (1) - เหมือน Another
   เหมือน Another เช่นกัน lol
   สำหรับ diff นี้เราว่า ตรงนี้ 01:56:428 (1,2,1,2) - ดูง่ายไปหน่อย อย่างอื่นก็โอเคละ

ให้คนเล่นได้พักมือบ้างก็ได้นะ =...=

[Standard]

1. 00:22:792 (2) - เอียงหางไปทางขวานิดนึง flow เกือบจะโอละ
   แก้ละ
2. 00:46:125 (1,2) - พยายามอย่าเปลี่ยน rhythm ดีกว่า เพราะ คนเล่นจะงงเอา
   มันเป็นจังหวะลากยาว การใส่ rhythm ที่ซ้ำ pattern เดิมๆ คนเล่นอาจเบื่อได้นะเออ = =
3. 01:01:580 (4,5) - น่าจะขยับขึ้นนิดนึงจะได้โค้งกับโน๊ตตัวก่อนหน้านั้นสวยขึ้น ลอง x=171 y=336
   แก้ละ
4. 01:06:731 (5) - ลองโค้งหางอีกนิด หรือ เอาให้มันโค้งคล้ายๆกับ 01:07:337 (6) -
   ^
5. 01:33:398 (5) - น่าจะ NC นะ 8 combo ดูจะยาวไป และนายก็เปลี่ยน pattern ด้วย
   รับแซ่บ!
6. 02:03:701 (1) - เหมือน Another
   เหมือน Another เช่นกัน lol
7. 02:27:640 (4,1,2,3) - ดูโค้งไม่ค่อยสวย ลองย้าย (1) ไป x=197 y=321
   ไม่แก้เน้อ
   diff นี้ใช้ได้อยู่

[Beginner]
ทำออกมาได้ดีสุดละ diff นี้

โอเคแค่นี้
แมพถือว่าทำออกมาได้ดีมาก แก้บางจุดก็โอสำหรับเราละ HS เราว่าโอเคละ
Nice mapset

Good luck

• 
  It would be enough to use AR5, it's only a standard diff, and AR6 might be a bit fast after AR3.

1. In general I think that this difficulty has too much 1/2, and I know that it's only 99 BPM but it is still a lot, try to reduce them, I'll mention a few parts, but not all.
2. 01:19:761 (4) - remove this to put some break because there are too many 1/2 objects and because the music is soft here
3. 01:24:307 (4) - you could use a hit circle instead of a slider here because of the previous reason - http://puu.sh/b50dG/2c3eebeb0f.jpg
4. 01:27:034 (3) - remove this too because of what I mentioned
5. 01:28:549 (4,5) - try to use less objects because of what I said - http://puu.sh/b50nJ/c1ddb1342a.jpg
6. 02:02:489 (2,1) - this is too hard to read in my opinion not only because of the stack but also because the beginning and ending of the heart-shaped slider is too close and it's hard to tell where the sliderball will go so I think you should try to change this --> https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1959133 - you'll have to rearrange the previous pattern a bit though, I can give you a code for this if you want, you don't have to use it if you don't want to:
   

   244,180,120064,2,0,P|188:142|133:121,2,112.5,0|0|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
   340,228,121277,6,0,P|377:173|422:134,2,112.5,0|0|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
   404,312,122489,2,0,P|444:272|474:225,2,112.5,0|0|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
   300,320,123701,6,0,B|304:228|388:207|448:144|432:80|400:0|304:0|256:48|256:48|208:0|112:0|80:80|64:144|132:207|208:228|216:320,1,900,0|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

   of course you'll have to change the upcoming part too a little but since there will be a short break I think it's not that troublesome, you can just try to flip them horizontally and replacing it a bit: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1959152
7. 02:27:640 (4) - remove this because there is nothing loud here and the difficulty is full of 1/2 so put little breaks like this to make it easier
8. 02:28:549 (3,4,5,6,1,2) - I don't really like how this looks like because of the stacks and I also think that there are too many circles here so you should make this easer and nicer by replacing 02:29:155 (5,6,1,2) - with sliders - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1959170

1. 01:37:489 (2,3) - very small thing but try to make this blanket nicer xD place this 01:38:246 (3) - x:120 y:176 and ofc replace 01:38:701 (4) - together with it
2. 01:43:095 (3,4) - while playing I could hardly decide what you mapped to here, and I think that it doesn't fit so you should try this - http://puu.sh/b5KcJ/d24715cefc.jpg - this would fit a lot better to the rhythm because of the fast piano sound and because 01:43:701 - there is a big beat here that you didn't hit and the slider being on red and white ticks fits a lot better
3. 01:47:943 (3,4) - similar as above ^ - http://puu.sh/b5KwV/c91d255630.jpg . this rhythm would fit better also because the melody ends on the red tick and not on the blue tick 01:48:852 -
4. 02:07:640 (2) - this slider looks weird, you should delete it and remake it - http://puu.sh/b5Kp9/799994ceed.jpg

1. 00:32:640 (4,5,6,7) - I think this would play better because the sliders would start on big beats (red and white ticks) - http://puu.sh/b66vd/f3a45378d8.jpg
2. 00:37:943 (5) - it's a little annoying that you missed to hit the piano sounds which start in the middle of the slider, so I think you could use 3 hit circles instead of a slider here
3. 00:40:671 (7,8,9) - I would rather make this a slider because it feels like it's overmapped (even though I know you mapped it to the soft ticking sound but it's so soft that I really don't see hit circles fitting to that :S) and there is that long violin sound too so try to do this - http://puu.sh/b66O8/ba89e61e3b.jpg
4. 00:43:701 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - similar suggestion to the one I did above ^ try to use less circles to make it match better to the music - http://puu.sh/b66TP/f4822aff47.jpg
5. 00:52:337 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - I think the jumps here don't fit, the music is really soft, it doesn't "ask" for a jump, suggestion - http://puu.sh/b67Jc/eef8d075c6.jpg
6. 00:59:913 (8,9,10) - the previous sliders fit the violin so you adding these sliders are weird imo and I think they don't fit, so I would rather try this - http://puu.sh/b67Sb/7187f636cd.jpg (and you also ended the sliders on big beats)
7. 01:02:943 (8) - I think it would be better if you removed this because it would emphasize 01:03:095 (1) - this better, and the sound there is so soft, I think it shouldn't me emphasized with a hit circle
8. 01:03:852 (4,5,6) - I would make this a slider instead because the circles feel unnecessary because the music is soft
9. 01:04:761 (8,9) - they don't really fit to the music imo, they start on blue ticks and there is nothing loud at the beginning of the sliders I would rather do this - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1962822
10. 01:06:580 (4,5,6,7) - same issue I mentioned, I think you could make this fit better to the music by putting them on red and white ticks - http://puu.sh/b6fgz/b67d7d0521.jpg
11. 01:54:458 (2,3,4,5) - it would fit better if you started the slider on white/red ticks - http://puu.sh/b6iho/2ccda714c2.jpg for same reason as I said
12. 02:09:458 (3,4,5,6,7) - here again, there is soft music and the previous objects were long sliders and just suddenly using 1/4 sliders, I think they don't fit sorry :C sometimes you map to violin sometimes to piano sometimes background, it's weird sometimes (I made someone else play it too and he thought similarly in general and not exactly this pattern) and for here I think this would fit better than those short sliders - http://puu.sh/b6iyZ/e492f570b8.jpg
13. 02:19:307 (4,5,6,7) - same as I mentioned before, try not to start them on blue ticks
14. 02:23:549 (2,3,4,5,6) - same as above ^
    
    Well I didn't mention anything, but in general I think this difficulty has too many hit circles and jumps, the map is only 99 BPM and you map to those really really soft sounds, so I hope you do consider changing and looking through your own map too and also those sliders starting on blue ticks, apart from these the map was fine.

Mystyk wrote:

Hi! Mod from my modding queue.

[General]
You could make the reversearrow a bit nicer in my opinion, to me it was pretty annoying that the "body" of it wasn't straight, it looks like it has a slight curve in it, and you could make put a little bigger shadow on it so that it will be easier to notice because at kiai times when the yellow combo flashes the really thin body of the reverse arrow can be a bit hardly seen.

[Beginner]
Looks fine to me.

[Standard]

• 
  It would be enough to use AR5, it's only a standard diff, and AR6 might be a bit fast after AR3.
  Ah... okay.

1. In general I think that this difficulty has too much 1/2, and I know that it's only 99 BPM but it is still a lot, try to reduce them, I'll mention a few parts, but not all.
2. 01:19:761 (4) - remove this to put some break because there are too many 1/2 objects and because the music is soft here
   Fixed.
3. 01:24:307 (4) - you could use a hit circle instead of a slider here because of the previous reason - http://puu.sh/b50dG/2c3eebeb0f.jpg
   Sure why not ?
4. 01:27:034 (3) - remove this too because of what I mentioned
   okay.
5. 01:28:549 (4,5) - try to use less objects because of what I said - http://puu.sh/b50nJ/c1ddb1342a.jpg
   okay.
6. 02:02:489 (2,1) - this is too hard to read in my opinion not only because of the stack but also because the beginning and ending of the heart-shaped slider is too close and it's hard to tell where the sliderball will go so I think you should try to change this --> https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1959133 - you'll have to rearrange the previous pattern a bit though, I can give you a code for this if you want, you don't have to use it if you don't want to:
   

   244,180,120064,2,0,P|188:142|133:121,2,112.5,0|0|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
   340,228,121277,6,0,P|377:173|422:134,2,112.5,0|0|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
   404,312,122489,2,0,P|444:272|474:225,2,112.5,0|0|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
   300,320,123701,6,0,B|304:228|388:207|448:144|432:80|400:0|304:0|256:48|256:48|208:0|112:0|80:80|64:144|132:207|208:228|216:320,1,900,0|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

   of course you'll have to change the upcoming part too a little but since there will be a short break I think it's not that troublesome, you can just try to flip them horizontally and replacing it a bit: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1959152
   Good work! I like it <3
7. 02:27:640 (4) - remove this because there is nothing loud here and the difficulty is full of 1/2 so put little breaks like this to make it easier
   Sure.
8. 02:28:549 (3,4,5,6,1,2) - I don't really like how this looks like because of the stacks and I also think that there are too many circles here so you should make this easer and nicer by replacing 02:29:155 (5,6,1,2) - with sliders - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1959170
   Nice idea! it's make more flow.

[Hyper]

1. 01:37:489 (2,3) - very small thing but try to make this blanket nicer xD place this 01:38:246 (3) - x:120 y:176 and ofc replace 01:38:701 (4) - together with it
   Haha sure.
2. 01:43:095 (3,4) - while playing I could hardly decide what you mapped to here, and I think that it doesn't fit so you should try this - http://puu.sh/b5KcJ/d24715cefc.jpg - this would fit a lot better to the rhythm because of the fast piano sound and because 01:43:701 - there is a big beat here that you didn't hit and the slider being on red and white ticks fits a lot better
   Nice idea!
3. 01:47:943 (3,4) - similar as above ^ - http://puu.sh/b5KwV/c91d255630.jpg . this rhythm would fit better also because the melody ends on the red tick and not on the blue tick 01:48:852 -
   Same above too.
4. 02:07:640 (2) - this slider looks weird, you should delete it and remake it - http://puu.sh/b5Kp9/799994ceed.jpg
   Yup, my mistake D:

[Another]

1. 00:32:640 (4,5,6,7) - I think this would play better because the sliders would start on big beats (red and white ticks) - http://puu.sh/b66vd/f3a45378d8.jpg
   Okay.
2. 00:37:943 (5) - it's a little annoying that you missed to hit the piano sounds which start in the middle of the slider, so I think you could use 3 hit circles instead of a slider here
   Okay and remake arrange notes.
3. 00:40:671 (7,8,9) - I would rather make this a slider because it feels like it's overmapped (even though I know you mapped it to the soft ticking sound but it's so soft that I really don't see hit circles fitting to that :S) and there is that long violin sound too so try to do this - http://puu.sh/b66O8/ba89e61e3b.jpg
   Sure!
4. 00:43:701 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - similar suggestion to the one I did above ^ try to use less circles to make it match better to the music - http://puu.sh/b66TP/f4822aff47.jpg
   Same above.
5. 00:52:337 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - I think the jumps here don't fit, the music is really soft, it doesn't "ask" for a jump, suggestion - http://puu.sh/b67Jc/eef8d075c6.jpg
   lol, I think someone tell me about this soon... so I use your pattern but make my own style arrange notes.
6. 00:59:913 (8,9,10) - the previous sliders fit the violin so you adding these sliders are weird imo and I think they don't fit, so I would rather try this - http://puu.sh/b67Sb/7187f636cd.jpg (and you also ended the sliders on big beats)
   Nice idea, fixed.
7. 01:02:943 (8) - I think it would be better if you removed this because it would emphasize 01:03:095 (1) - this better, and the sound there is so soft, I think it shouldn't me emphasized with a hit circle
   okay.
8. 01:03:852 (4,5,6) - I would make this a slider instead because the circles feel unnecessary because the music is soft
   I think it's fine coz these notes will continue (2,3) until next violin sound (7)
9. 01:04:761 (8,9) - they don't really fit to the music imo, they start on blue ticks and there is nothing loud at the beginning of the sliders I would rather do this - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1962822
   okay.
10. 01:06:580 (4,5,6,7) - same issue I mentioned, I think you could make this fit better to the music by putting them on red and white ticks - http://puu.sh/b6fgz/b67d7d0521.jpg
    Fixed.
11. 01:54:458 (2,3,4,5) - it would fit better if you started the slider on white/red ticks - http://puu.sh/b6iho/2ccda714c2.jpg for same reason as I said
    Fixed like your pattern but apply a bit.
12. 02:09:458 (3,4,5,6,7) - here again, there is soft music and the previous objects were long sliders and just suddenly using 1/4 sliders, I think they don't fit sorry :C sometimes you map to violin sometimes to piano sometimes background, it's weird sometimes (I made someone else play it too and he thought similarly in general and not exactly this pattern) and for here I think this would fit better than those short sliders - http://puu.sh/b6iyZ/e492f570b8.jpg
    Ah.. I can feel your felt now D:
13. 02:19:307 (4,5,6,7) - same as I mentioned before, try not to start them on blue ticks
    Fixed.
14. 02:23:549 (2,3,4,5,6) - same as above ^
    Fixed.
    
    Well I didn't mention anything, but in general I think this difficulty has too many hit circles and jumps, the map is only 99 BPM and you map to those really really soft sounds, so I hope you do consider changing and looking through your own map too and also those sliders starting on blue ticks, apart from these the map was fine.
    Yes, this song is really soft sound and I trust your modded but somewhere I feel empty :/

Good luck!

IamKwaN wrote:

Hi, from my queue here.

General

1. I don't know if your romanised title is correct or not. I can't find a source for the (Short Ver.) thing. As stated in the ranking criteria, it can be used only if official one has (Short Ver.). So, please provide a reference for this lol. Btw, I found something on iTunes, (feat. Kimbara Chieko) should be added on both title and romanised title as it's the official title.
   Reference: https://itunes.apple.com/us/album/kalei ... d447115967
2. If you have applied the above, remove "Chieko Kinbara" from tags.
   I'll fixed this later.[color=#FF0000]EDIT: fixed.[/color]
3. According to https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Skinning, You need a "approachcircle.png" to achieve a complete Hitcircle set.
   Added.
4. Snap your preview time to 00:58:095, it's now unsnapped.
   Sure!
5. Disable widescreen support for all diffs as there're no storyboards.
   Okay.

Another

1. Gap between Another and Hyper is quite large imo, OD7 and HP7 would work fine, while you can lower both OD and HP of Hyper to 6.
2. 00:32:640 (4,5,6,7,8) - I feel more comfortable if you can CTRL+G all these on the timeline basis as the stresses can be captured by the slider heads. Same for 00:42:337 (4,5,6,7,8). I saw several patterns the same at the back, I don't mention them one by one but I hope u can try adjust and test them before rejecting my views.
3. 00:52:489 (6) - Maybe a NC here to reduce the huge number of combo number.
4. 01:14:307 (8) - NC also for indicating the back and forth circles. In fact, it's recommended to NC every half white tick instead of one, coz many of the combo numbers are too large.
5. 02:30:368 (1) - Adding a normal finish with lower volume fits better, like Hyper.
   My mistake lol
6. 02:32:792 (1) - Lower the volume by 20% please, it's quite inappropriate since the music is only of small volume.
   Okay.
7. Nice hitsounds! I love it! <3
   Thanks <3

Hyper

1. 00:36:428 (1,2) - The rhythm here is weird, as it ruins your 2-4 clap pattern. Something like this would be more sensible:
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:51:580 (2,3,4) - CTRL+G these on timeline basis plays more comfortable and matches the feeling better coz the instrument prolongs since 00:51:883.
   Nice idea!
3. 01:41:277 (4) - Clap missing. Same for 01:46:125 (3) and 01:50:974 (5) .
   Thanks for looking this... my mistake ._.
4. 01:43:549 (4,1) - Flawed blanket. Same for 01:48:398 (4,1).
5. 01:45:822 (1) - Seems this NC is redundant, it isn't a jump nor something really needs to be taken care of.
   Added NC.
6. 02:03:701 (1,2) - Lower the volume, as TR2 makes it quite noisy which contradicts the music.
   Okay.
7. 02:32:792 (1) - Lower the volume by 20% please, it's quite inappropriate since the music has only a small volume of sound.
   Fixed.

Standard

1. Standard has a quite high setting too, if it's a Normal diff. How about AR5, OD&HP4 since the BPM is very low. Also, it helps reduce the gap between E and I.
   Reduce a bit from Mystyk suggestion.
2. 00:44:913 (3) - Quite odd to sacrifice the clap on 4th tick, how about this?
   
   SPOILER

   
   fixed with my own way owo.
3. 01:37:034 (1) - Mentioned above, try to alter the rhythm or simply use slider tick to capture it:
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 02:32:792 (1) - Mentioned in Another.

Beginner

1. 02:03:701 (1) - Extend it to 02:07:943? The drum there is much obvious and weighty.
   Sure! why not?
2. 02:32:792 (1) - Mentioned in Another.

I hope some of these help! Good luck!

Thanks for modded
P.S. Some your suggestion I was fixed by Mystyk so I'll not write any message in some your suggest.

1. title: Represent feat.Chieko Kinbara
   (Romanised title is the same)
2. Airtist: DJ OKAWARI

1. 01:21:883 (4,1) - check blanketting

1. 01:01:580 (4,5) - I think this stack is unnecessary
2. 01:33:398 (1,2,3,4) - curve more like 01:32:186 (1,2,3,4) -

1. 01:43:095 (3,4) - why not DS 1.0x?
2. 01:47:943 (3,4) - ^
3. 02:01:277 (1,2) - I prefer the same rhythm as 02:00:064 (3,4) -

1. 01:07:943 (1,4) - stack correctly
2. 01:11:580 (7,8) - I prefer to exchange their positions
3. 01:54:913 (2,3) - hard to find rhythm, imo. I suggest to increase DS more

RandomEffect wrote:

From my queue~

[General]

1. title: Represent feat.Chieko Kinbara
   (Romanised title is the same)
2. Airtist: DJ OKAWARI

I'm not sure. please ask to JP BAT
(but japanese title is obviously worng)
I changed to... DJ Okawari - Represent feat. Chieko Kinbara and remove represent Japanese title.
[Beginner]

1. 01:21:883 (4,1) - check blanketting
   Okay.

[Standard]

1. 01:01:580 (4,5) - I think this stack is unnecessary
   Re-arranged notes.
2. 01:33:398 (1,2,3,4) - curve more like 01:32:186 (1,2,3,4) -
   Okay.

[Hyper]

1. 01:43:095 (3,4) - why not DS 1.0x?
2. 01:47:943 (3,4) - ^
   My mistake lol
3. 02:01:277 (1,2) - I prefer the same rhythm as 02:00:064 (3,4) -
   I think it unnecessary coz that rhythm it isn't same your suggestion.

[Another]

1. 01:07:943 (1,4) - stack correctly
   Fixed.
2. 01:11:580 (7,8) - I prefer to exchange their positions
   Sure!
3. 01:54:913 (2,3) - hard to find rhythm, imo. I suggest to increase DS more
   You're right! fixed.

beautiful custom hitsound <3
~Good Luck~

Hollow Wings wrote:

from Scorpiour's Modding Queue

Another

1. 00:24:004 (9,10) - ctrl+g
   Okay.
2. 00:25:974 add a note at 00:25:519 (7) - 's end
   Okay
3. 00:37:943 (5) - set this note at 00:37:337 (4) - 's end
   Added @ another place...
4. 01:02:489 (8,1) - larger ds, and same places with that 1/2 gap for u have lots of big jumps other sides
   That looks like hard.. but I'll try
5. 01:44:155 (10) - stack at 01:43:246 (6) - is better imo, for following that violin's melody
   Okay.
6. 02:07:034 (2) - ctrl+g
   Sure!
7. almost all jumping patterns in ur map, and some kind of lack of organizations maybe. try to make some patterns on purpose, u'll find a new world imo w
   That's true... but I'll try, thanks for advice :3

Hyper

1. 00:26:580 this beat should not be missed imo, and lots of same issues like this, that's too weird to miss them indeed
   Added.
2. 01:37:489 (2,3) - blanket each other
   Sure!
3. 01:49:610 (2,3) - blanket perfect
4. 02:09:155 (2,3) - parallel perfect
   Thanks for suggestion lol
5. same feeling as another diff

Standard

1. 01:06:731 (5,6,1) - maybe blanket
   Sure!
2. this diff's better mapped imo

Beginner

1. 01:38:246 (2,3) - blanket?
   I think it's fine D:
2. fine

beautiful song, thou those violin's tracks r really hard to be followed in a mug game, u can still try that

good luck

Thanks for modded and hope you like this song

gokugohan12468 wrote:

No No No~

I think Chieko Kinbara add in Artist~

Lanturn wrote:

No problem. Make sure to change DJ Okawari to DJ OKAWARI (all caps) though.

[ Setsuna ] wrote:

came from my modding queue, er hi.

*=Personal Opinion
**=Should Fix
***=FIX NOW LOL

Beginner

**00:24:307 (1) - Change this, as your missing a strong beat in the middle of it.
I think it unnecessary :/
*00:41:277 (3) - Change this to a more er, creative, slider. (Use red anchors)
Smooth curve make more flow :3
*01:04:307 (2) - Move this to the left a bit more.
Fine for me~ not changed.
**01:12:792 (1) - Add a "Finish" Hitsound on the reverse on this.
It's make rhythm weird, so no changed.
*02:03:701 (1) - Change puu.sh/bo1R8/37ce9c309d.jpg to puu.sh/bo1Sy/220c7fbc73.jpg
Spinner length I think it's fine (however it's so long for newbie, but that's easy.)

Notes: Should be rankable, YOU CAN DO IT

Standard

***IMO This is overmapped for Normal
*00:22:792 (2,3) - Don't be afraid of straight sliders lol
Fixed with same pattern of (2) and rotate a bit.
**Move 00:36:731 (2) to where 00:35:519 (4) started.
02:03:701 (1) Not a mod, just want to note how awesome this is lol
Move these note with my own.
**Make 02:25:519 (1) the same as 02:26:125 (2).
Use same pattern = player bored... more slider style will make map fun! :/
*02:30:368 (3) - The hitsound on this is a bit weird.
I think it fine here.

Notes: Overmapped for a normal, Normal's should have OCCASIONAL red tick beats. This feels like a hard if you teak the AR,OD,HP.
But, it's still good.

IT"S NOT OVERMAPPED!!! owo

Hyper

*00:48:246 (6) - This is put way to far imo put this in the same place as 00:48:549 (1).
Usually I would put 00:50:368 (5,6,7,8) as a mod, but as this BPM it is rank able.
A bit jump with 1/2 it's make more a bit difficult but not over hard...
*01:17:640 (1) - Curve this slider?
Fixed.
*02:11:428 (2) - Move this to the left a bit lol
Fixed.
Notes: Good Map , Fun to DT.

Thanks for testplay :3

Another

Mapping is to sugoi, can't mod D:. No but srsly this is amazing.

ts8zs wrote:

[Another]
00:22:943 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2014820
Fixed with my own.
01:25:671 (3) - Ctrl+G
ok
01:37:640 (3,4) - swap?
I think it fine, so not changed.
02:07:640 (1) - Ctrl+G
ok
[Hyper]
[Standard]
01:07:337 (6) - blanket
ok
[Beginner]
01:49:155 (3) - blanket
ok
02:26:731 (2) - blanket
ok

Good luck:3

Sieg wrote:

Hello Backstep

General

1. CS jump from 4.2 to 3 considering that you have 4 diffs is quite strange. Think about adjusting CS
   I think CS 4.2 > 3 it's too Easy for Hyper, so change to 4 it's look better than 3.
2. pay attention to difficulty gap between Another and Hyper, some adjustments may be needed there

Beginner

1. 00:46:125 (4) - consider to split this to slider + 2 circles, this will allow player to actually play stress beat on 00:48:549 () - which quite important in music
   
   SPOILER

   
   Sure nice idea!
2. 02:03:701 (1) - according to t/241019 you should shorten your spinner. It's not in RC yet but there was many maps unqualified recently because of this

Fixed.

Standard

1. OD - 1, it's good to keep OD 1 tick lower than AR, also your other diffs follow this
   changed.
2. 00:41:277 (1) - repeat is following violin I guess but there is stronger beat on 00:41:883 () and also hit-normal on repeat sounds awkward
   Fixed with sample soft hitsound with 25% + whistle.
3. 00:44:913 (3) - ^ also instead of removing repeat from offbeat you can add silenced hitnormal and put it here + whistle
4. 01:29:761 (1) - 01:37:034 (1) - 01:39:458 (1) - 02:08:549 (2) - ^ same here
5. 01:56:428 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - ^
   Same above.
6. 01:15:216 (1) - pay attention to rest after this spinner too
7. 01:34:610 (1,1) - ^
   Fixed all spinner!
8. 01:20:064 (1,2) - would be great to see some kind of *spoilerbox* pattern here
   
   SPOILER

   

Sure, why not?

Hyper

1. no issues here, despite fact that I don't really like 01:37:034 (1) - part but it sounds better than offbeats in Standard diff thanks to general rhythm density
   Fixed like Standard pattern.
2. look at CS suggestion in general section

Another

1. 00:25:974 (8) - that stop is quite annoying consider to move *spoilerbox*
   
   SPOILER

   
   Haha, okay changed.
2. 00:53:095 (2,3) - hard to read antijumps here, also you use same distance from 00:52:489 (6) - to 00:52:792 (1) - and from 1 to 2 it actually does not help to read this all properly
   Fixed.
3. 01:33:398 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - try to make curve here
   Fixed. (but not sure, need someone nazi mod here.)
4. jump is so forced here but song such calm :\

Nice mapset. Good Luck!

1. Nothing apparent. Nice use of hitsounds.

1. 00:19:458 (1,2) - For the starting pattern, this straight slider and curved slider do not flow well. Maybe try something like this instead?
   
   
   ~
2. 01:03:095 (1) - Try to slightly curve this slider?
3. 01:56:428 (1,2,3,4,1,2) - There is no use of the 1/2 until 2 minutes into the map. This is problematic for the Easy difficulty because the player is not introduced to the 1/2 beforehand and it may also be considered unrankable. It fits the song well, but I do not think it fits the difficulty. Please consider using a different pattern like e.g: 01:51:580 (1,2,3,4) -.

1. General: HP5 is too high. Your current spread is: Beginner: HP2 -> Standard: HP5 -> Hyper: HP7 -> Another: HP7.2. Please try to balance them.
2. 00:37:943 (4) - Instead of a straight slider here, try to curve it with the next Slider 1 as a guide.
   
   
   ~
3. 00:41:883 - Missing a hitsound here? It sounds off compared to the rest of the map.
4. 00:45:519 - Same here. Please check your hitsounds.
5. 01:09:155 (3) - Try moving Slider 3 a little more to the right, it cannot be too close to Slider 1.
6. 01:47:943 (3,1) - This may be for emphasis, but I find it somewhat confusing(?) to play. Maybe give the sliders red vertices?
7. 02:16:428 (3,4) - I think it plays better like this instead, giving flow from Slider 3 to Slider 4 and a blanket from Slider 4 to Circle 1:
   
   
   ~
8. Nothing else, it's decent~

1. General: Some patterns feel repetitive... maybe change some things?
2. About AR: For this difficulty, I would try AR7.5. I think it is best.
3. 00:37:034 - I think there needs to be a hitsound here.
4. 02:00:064 (3,4,1,2) - This may not be rankable. If possible, try to use a different pattern.
5. 02:23:398 (3,4) - Give these objects the same slope.

Project Railgun wrote:

Hello from Railgun's Quality Appreciation Queue,

[General]

1. Nothing apparent. Nice use of hitsounds.
   Thanks :3

[Beginner]

1. 00:19:458 (1,2) - For the starting pattern, this straight slider and curved slider do not flow well. Maybe try something like this instead?
   
   
   
   ~
2. 01:03:095 (1) - Try to slightly curve this slider?
3. 01:56:428 (1,2,3,4,1,2) - There is no use of the 1/2 until 2 minutes into the map. This is problematic for the Easy difficulty because the player is not introduced to the 1/2 beforehand and it may also be considered unrankable. It fits the song well, but I do not think it fits the difficulty. Please consider using a different pattern like e.g: 01:51:580 (1,2,3,4) -.

[Standard]

1. General: HP5 is too high. Your current spread is: Beginner: HP2 -> Standard: HP5 -> Hyper: HP7 -> Another: HP7.2. Please try to balance them.
2. 00:37:943 (4) - Instead of a straight slider here, try to curve it with the next Slider 1 as a guide.
   
   
   ~
3. 00:41:883 - Missing a hitsound here? It sounds off compared to the rest of the map.
4. 00:45:519 - Same here. Please check your hitsounds.
5. 01:09:155 (3) - Try moving Slider 3 a little more to the right, it cannot be too close to Slider 1.
6. 01:47:943 (3,1) - This may be for emphasis, but I find it somewhat confusing(?) to play. Maybe give the sliders red vertices?
7. 02:16:428 (3,4) - I think it plays better like this instead, giving flow from Slider 3 to Slider 4 and a blanket from Slider 4 to Circle 1:
   
   
   ~
8. Nothing else, it's decent~

[Hyper]

1. General: Some patterns feel repetitive... maybe change some things?
2. About AR: For this difficulty, I would try AR7.5. I think it is best.
3. 00:37:034 - I think there needs to be a hitsound here.
4. 02:00:064 (3,4,1,2) - This may not be rankable. If possible, try to use a different pattern.
5. 02:23:398 (3,4) - Give these objects the same slope.

I cannot mod the Another difficulty because I cannot pass it. The patterns look interesting though. For places like 01:30:064 (2,6) -, Ctrl+G the slider 2 in order to get the exact coordinates needed for Slider 6. Example: 01:30:974 (6) - needs to be x:258 y:111 for a proper stack. Also: Try curving one of the sliders on 01:29:307 (8,1) -?

Good luck!

Fixed most of your suggestion... except hitsound

Thanks for modded.