1. Easy (1.16 stars, 33 notes)
2. Hard (2.33 stars, 75 notes)
3. Hitsounds (3.82 stars, 203 notes)
4. Lunatic (3.76 stars, 191 notes)
5. Normal (1.62 stars, 55 notes)

Vainslay wrote:

Hi~

I was looking for Touhou songs and I stumbled on this one. Nice, but a little short... :c

~Overrall about the song. Why is it Pending? I don't think it's finished yet

Nothing much, distance spacing and Placement is nice and You have an awesome hitsound set.

Hard
At 00:29:003 (1,2,3) - these first 3 sliders made me stumbled a little. Probably because you had reverse sliders before and this just sorta messed up with the flow. nothing else~ but make it like the others ok

Extra
Considering how hard this is, you need to change your difficulty

HP Drain: 7 or 8 (10 is really high.) I'll change it if everyone always mention this
Circle size: I guess you can keep it at 5, considering you mapped it like that.
Approach rate: 8 or 9 But you should probably choose 8 (6 is too low) actually I want to keep this, but people is always complaining about this
Overrall Difficulty: 9 is okay. ( I prefer 7 or 8 ) 9 is ok

At 00:04:321 (1) This note is too far from the others. (2.93x prev. ) Perhaps ctrl h and j this 00:04:700 (2) and move it up till
it's 1.3x-ish away from 00:04:131 (6) fixed
At 00:18:751 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13) - Continue this stream, fill in the blue ticks (Accoarding to the drums in the song. ) I like the current pattern D:

I guess that's about it. Good luck!

Cherry Blossom wrote:

Hai from my queue.
My mod is noooooob I don't think so, your mod is great XD

Just suggestion.

[Easy]
AR - 1 or 2

00:27:105 (4) - I don't really like this slider, maybe you can arrange with :

SPOILER

and 00:29:003 (1) - and the tail 1 or 2 grid up.

00:54:067 (5,6,7) - maybe you can do this ? : I don't think it needs

SPOILER

[Normal]

AR-1 ?
Fine.


[Hard]
OD 5 ? why ? Normal has 6, it's inconsistent.

00:29:003 (1) - You can do this.that would break the flow

SPOILER

00:41:915 (5,6) - Overlap, you can arrange these sliders.

[Lunatic]

00:02:802 (4) - You can arrange this slider :

SPOILER

00:36:219 (2) - Better blanket.
00:47:231 (1) - better blanket here, try second point 1 grid left, tail 1 grid left.
00:54:446 (4,5,6) - i suggest doing this, blanket (1,2,3) :

SPOILER

[Extra]

HP - 2 or 3, please no 10 because of OD9 and BPM, you can easily fail if you are not a good player with accuracy. people keep pushing about this, so ok

00:14:954 (1,3) - I don't really like this, you can make 2 blankets :

SPOILER

00:28:244 (7) - remove 1 reverse and add a note 00:28:814 it's better to play I'm not going to change this atm
00:54:826 (5,6) - why don't to make something like this ? :

SPOILER

That's all, it's little but i'm still noob, if it really didnt help you, feel free to no kd me please
I like this Touhou BGM (just look at my name)
Good Luck ~

happy30 wrote:

Testplay ~ no kudosu please
Replay

Extra
it's kinda short!
for an Extra I thought this was really easy. Especially since it's short there's not much of a challenge for the pros. it was challengin enough, but then Lunatic changed everything
I think there's still plenty of room for streams in the song and in this diff. you're right

The hitsounds are pretty nice, had to get used to it a bit though.
For the hitsounds of the chorus it felt a bit overdone. Maybe a bit too many whistles. I'm also missing the loud drum sound. you know, this hitsound:
http://puu.sh/3t3fV.wav
could you use it? okeh

GrayKaiser82 wrote:

Hey, from my queue

[Normal]
00:49:510 (3,4) - It looks nice, but overlapped. I'm doing it on purpose for distance

Nice diff ~
[Hard]
00:51:408 (3) - Ctrl+G? nah, it would be breaking the flow for the next note

Nice diff here too ~
[Extra]
00:28:244 (7) - reduce the repeat by one, and add note after it.
00:46:472 (6) - ^

-------------------
Perfect map ! Good Luck ~

DEAncientNaga wrote:

DEAncientNaga's Mod Queue

[General]
Nicely mapped, but it's too dead cuz distance snapped too much in harder difficulties (make some jumps in Hard / Lunatic / Extra)

The song is lesser than a minute, can consider making it harder

[Easy]
>.o)b

[Normal]
2.5 stars is easy rating, consider putting more notes instead of slider
Use more red ticks and some blue ticks if it suits
Spinner reduces the difficulty, replace with sliders or circles if possible
00:02:802 - Add circle
00:08:118 - Add circle
00:29:953 - Add circle
00:33:371 - Add circle
00:42:484 - Add circle
00:51:598 - Add circle
I'm going to remap some part

[Hard]
Ok

[Lunatic]
You can make some sliders to a reverse side to increase the confuse (Ctrl+G) , same as Extra

[Extra]
Approach Rate: +1
Try to raise the slider velocity in KIAI time, if possible (x1.25 - x1.75)
00:19:511 (12,13) - Make this the part of the stream too
00:38:022 - Add circle no need
00:38:497 (2,3,4) - Try to make these kind of circles distanced instead of stack, for example

Stack

or

00:41:915 (7) - Try to make it jump for example

Jump

Good luck on ranking >.o /

baldrace wrote:

Hi~from my queue
normal mod

General
0.0

Easy
AR-1
fine but
I think clap before 00:19:131 is really noisy the other diffs has the same
00:56:345 (1) - I think use N:C1 is better Soft is better

Normal
HP-1 OD-2
final spinner is a bit short and I think use N:C1 is better I agree that this is short, but soft is better
00:09:257 (4) - objects before this have incorrect spacing I don't really understand about this
00:23:117 (4) - spacing ^

Hard
00:55:396 (1) - I think use N:C1 is better same as above

Extra
OD-1 or 2 why 9....................... because this is an Extra diff
00:18:751 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - tream start at 00:19:131 is better,listen to the music
00:14:194 (4,5,6) - stream starts at white line like this is not very good,don't use it often,I feel uncomfortable when playing,maybe I'm so noob 0.0 I think it's fine
00:55:396 (1) - use N:C1 is better same as above

Lunatic
same suggestion about stream
00:55:396 (1) - use N:C1 is better same as above
00:05:650 (1) - why NC here 00:04:890 (6) - NC and00:06:219 (4) - NC
00:13:055 (1) - why NC here..
and I check other diffs there some same NC problems 0.0 I check other diffs and yeah you're right


that's all
good luck~

Verlaren wrote:

From my queue

[general]
deselect countdown

[easy]
SV 1.20 too hight for easy, please use 1.0 or less oh right. but 1.20 is fine I think
AR -1
00:40:396 (3,4) - in easy diff shouldn't be a stacked notes

[normal]
DR -1
OD -2
00:08:498 (2,3) - spacing error
00:08:878 (3,4) - ^
00:22:168 (3,4) - ^
00:30:143 (2,3) - ^
00:31:282 (3,4) - ^
I don't really understand about this

[hard]
00:23:307 - add note, sounds is really good it's quite hard and make it inconsitency for the next part
00:32:421 - ^ ^
00:51:408 (3) - ctrl+g for better flow I think it's fine like this
00:51:029 (2,3) - maybe swap these sliders? IMO better flow, try it ^

[lunatic]
00:14:194 (5) - move on x:128 y:134 for correct spacing between other sliders isn't that too close?
00:14:954 (1) - remove these note and add one repeat on 00:14:574(6) no need
00:17:232 (3,4) - maybe change on this shape? - no need, for better flow

SPOILER

00:35:459 (8) - stack tail on 00:34:320(4) ? ok

[extra]
oh, really good diff

That's all, I hope this can help you. And star for this map

1. 00:46:092- add whistle

• 
  OK!

1. 00:02:042- remove whistle

1. 00:02:042- remove whistle

1. 00:02:042- remove whistle
2. 00:52:927 (4,5,6,7,8,9) - it is better to make straight
   　●00:53:307 (7) - x:282 y:176
   　●00:53:497 (8) - x:324 y:108
   　●00:53:687 (9) - x:366 y:40

RandomEffect wrote:

Hi~
Thank you for request from my queue!
[Easy]

1. 00:46:092- add whistle no need I think

[Normal]

• 
  OK!

[Hard]

1. 00:02:042- remove whistle

[Lunatic]

1. 00:02:042- remove whistle

[Extra]

1. 00:02:042- remove whistle
2. 00:52:927 (4,5,6,7,8,9) - it is better to make straight
   　●00:53:307 (7) - x:282 y:176
   　●00:53:497 (8) - x:324 y:108
   　●00:53:687 (9) - x:366 y:40

The hitsound of Japanese-style is so good!
~Good luck~

fanzhen0019 wrote:

Hi :3
From my queue.

Hitsounds

1. 00:23:117 - Maybe remove whistle?and add whistle here:00:22:927 - no need, to consistency to the other diffs
2. 00:31:662 (4,5) - Same as above. ^
3. 00:40:776 (6,7) - Same as above. ^
4. 00:49:890 (2,3) - Same as above. ^

Arrangement & Design

1. 00:05:650 (1) - Consider remove this NC.
2. 00:23:687 (1) - Remove NC.
3. 00:41:915 (1) - To consist with other parts,remove NC here and add to 00:42:674 (3) -

Sorry for my poor mod...Symmetrical style is nice for you..
Your map is good enough.Consider ask for a BAT o.o no need to rush... I still want to improve my map

Legenda wrote:

→ Unrankable things, must fix
→ My human doubts, things to consider
→ Tips & Tricks to make your map better
♥ → Greetings
* → Just comments, not mods
Naked Lines → Mods

* No complaints on General Issues.

♥ You just made the [Easy] diff AWESOMELY AMAZING !!! With delicious Sliders I mean. Easy diffs like the yours are really Rare, hard to find ^.^ Well, the song helps too, but mapping skills are amazing !
* Easy diff is clean and very good!

[Normal]
00:16:093 (4) - It could be like → http://puu.sh/3xjTV.jpg → and the code for it is →

140,44,16093,2,0,B|196:20|256:100|256:100|320:20|380:44,1,279.999980926514,8|2,0:0|0:3,0:0:0:0:

[Hard]
♥ Amazing flow ♥ and patterns. I loved playing it

[Extra]
♥ Well made too, and very challenging.

[Lunatic]
♥ Well made too
* Feels a bit easier than [Extra] (and gives less score), but it's amazing too ♥

SPOILER

308,96,42674,6,0,B|360:132|346:203|346:203|401:157|458:186,1,240,4|8,0:3|0:0,0:0:0:0:
388,288,43814,2,0,P|277:294|253:186,1,240,0|8,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

SPOILER

252,68,44953,2,0,P|144:212|208:368,1,360,0|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

SPOILER

120,256,13435,1,2,0:3:0:0:
120,256,13814,2,0,B|188:284|256:256|256:256|324:228|392:256,2,280,2|8|6,0:3|0:0|0:3,0:0:0:0:

SPOILER

344,20,23117,2,0,B|412:68|388:140|388:140|440:136|476:192|476:192|440:248|388:244|388:244|412:316|344:364,1,490,10|4,0:0|0:3,0:0:0:0:

SPOILER

336,192,51788,6,0,B|364:192|364:192|392:176|392:176|400:208|400:208|428:192|428:192|464:192,2,160,0|4|8,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
176,192,52928,2,0,B|148:192|148:192|120:176|120:176|112:208|112:208|84:192|84:192|48:192,2,160,0|4|8,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

SPOILER

SPOILER

Harez wrote:

alo~
i found the sequel Gojou Kai - Ultimate Truth

[General]
Tambahin Customcolour warna Hijau dan Putih ndak perlu
Ga ada break? Disable Letterbox

[Easy]
Overall udah bagus
00:24:446 (3) - NC
00:42:674 (1,2) - mungkin dibikin lebih blanket lagi :3

SPOILER

308,96,42674,6,0,B|360:132|346:203|346:203|401:157|458:186,1,240,4|8,0:3|0:0,0:0:0:0:
388,288,43814,2,0,P|277:294|253:186,1,240,0|8,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

00:44:953 (3) - ngikutin blanket dari (2)

SPOILER

252,68,44953,2,0,P|144:212|208:368,1,360,0|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

00:51:788 (3) - NC
00:56:345 (1) - pindahin ke 256,124

[Normal]
AR+1? terlalu susah kayaknya
00:13:814 (3) - bikin lebih renggang?

SPOILER

terlalu renggang, jadi agak tak edit dikit

120,256,13435,1,2,0:3:0:0:
120,256,13814,2,0,B|188:284|256:256|256:256|324:228|392:256,2,280,2|8|6,0:3|0:0|0:3,0:0:0:0:

-- 00:13:435 (2) - stack ke (3)
00:23:117 (4) - mungkin kayak gini? xD

SPOILER

344,20,23117,2,0,B|412:68|388:140|388:140|440:136|476:192|476:192|440:248|388:244|388:244|412:316|344:364,1,490,10|4,0:0|0:3,0:0:0:0:

00:29:003 (1,2) - wogh jump wogh, emang sengaja

[Hard]
00:19:890 (1,2) - node kedua *titik yang ditengah* pindahin ke 376,196.. (2) Flip Horizontal dari (1) nggak perlu biar simetris
00:51:788 (1,2) - prefer ini daripada itu

SPOILER

.. (2) Flip Horizontal dari (1) err, tapi saya masih prefer yang itu

336,192,51788,6,0,B|364:192|364:192|392:176|392:176|400:208|400:208|428:192|428:192|464:192,2,160,0|4|8,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
176,192,52928,2,0,B|148:192|148:192|120:176|120:176|112:208|112:208|84:192|84:192|48:192,2,160,0|4|8,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

[Lunatic]
00:01:663 (1) - prefer 2 notes \o/ untuk awal note emang tak bikin slider
00:02:042 (3,4) - gimana kalo gini

SPOILER

00:03:561 (2) - prefer 2 notes \o/
00:04:321 (5) - karena di akhir slider suaranya merendah, lebih baik potong repeatnya dan bikin not baru + New Combo err... suaranya biasa aja kok

SPOILER

00:42:674 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - perasaan ga nyambung deh notnya orz nyambung ah.. tapi emang kayaknya agak jelek ya

[Extra]
starnya kurang dari Lunatic, why? ;w; tanyakan pada pepet
nothing to mention here. good enough \:D/ *alibi males modding*

oke gudlak

-Gamu- wrote:

hi~ 　Requests from here

[General]

●Nothing

[Easy]

●00:13:814 (3) - I think appearance is not so good. So, rotate by 25% (Direction: Clockwise. Origin: Playfield Centre) [Ctrl+Shift+R]
Please try this. Surely, it will be well.

[Normal]

●00:19:890 (1,2,3) - Slider of straight is no problem. But, there is no fun. Therefore, create an interesting shape?
●00:55:396 (1) - Beginners will play most Normal diff. This spinner is very short...D: Beginner is very weak spinner. Are you want to remove the spinner for a beginner? If you delete, you would add circle in 00:56:345. it is good.
●00:55:206 (4) - add new combo? sound was changed. no need

[Hard]

●00:06:979 (1) - remove new combo. And, 00:07:738 (2) - add new combo. This is correct. I think you are mistake..D:
●00:14:954 (1) - remove new combo. And, 00:15:333 (2) - add new combo. ^
●00:55:206 (4) - Same as Normal diff.

[Extra]

●OD9 is no good... OD 8 is good! I think so. 9 is fine, to make it quite challenging

Suggests of the NC

●00:02:802 (1) - remove new combo. And, 00:03:181 (2) - add new combo.
●00:04:321 (1) - ^. And, 00:04:700 (2) - ^
●00:05:840 (1) - ^. And, 00:06:219 (2) - ^
●00:07:359 (1) - ^. And, 00:07:738 (2) - ^
●00:08:878 (1) - ^. And, 00:09:257 (2) - ^
●00:10:397 (1) - ^. And, 00:10:776 (3) - ^
●00:11:916 (1) - ^. And, 00:12:295 (2) - ^
●00:14:954 (1) - ^. And, 00:15:333 (3) - ^
●00:16:473 (1) - ^. And, 00:16:852 (3) - ^
even tough they're on the down beat, I think whistles would fit to NC

●00:24:826 (2) - Move to x504? It will line up neatly with 00:24:446 (1).
●00:25:206 (3) - ^
●00:55:206 (6) - Same as Normal diff. ^

[Lunatic]

●Same as Extra diff (Suggests of the NC)
●00:03:181 (1,2) - It looks bad. widen the spacing?
●00:52:927 (1,2,3) - ^
●00:55:206 (6) - Same as Normal diff. ^

that's all.

I'm sorry for simple modding..;w;

xChippy wrote:

Hi~

[Lunatic]
00:10:017 (4) - remove NC OMG OMG OMG
00:34:700 (1) - NC

That's all =.=
General comment: Request a BAT o-o
Have a star =w=

Momochikun wrote:

dafuq udh ada Lunatic ada Extra pula o.o

pieguy1372 wrote:

hi, from my queue

[Easy]
00:33:560 (1,2) - just wondering why you have claps here, but on the other ones, you don't the others have

[Normal]
fine

[Hard]
fine

[Lunatic]
00:39:257 (1) - remove NC and put it on 00:40:396 (5) -

[Extra]
OD 9? holy crap, turn it down plz 0.0 it's an extra diff, but still got a lower star rating than lunatic. so I think OD9 is fine
AR +1? as it's extra diff and it's a somewhat fast song...plus you've already got OD9 so ..
00:30:143 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - http://puu.sh/3AVfy.jpg how about this rhythm
00:40:396 (6,1) - switch NCs for new measure
00:54:067 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - here might be a good place for jump ~

that's it, hope it helps
nice map and good luck

Satellite wrote:

[Easy]
00:44:953 (3) - end point forget hitsound? ( maybe Finish? clap?) Finish

[Normal]
00:33:371 - add note no need, 1/2 triplet on normal is quite hard
00:42:484 - ^ ^

[Hard]
nothing to say. really great

[Lunatic]
00:19:890 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - "I think" end point whistle remove. maybe fit.( All place...) it feels weird on the next note
00:42:674 (1,2,3) - not fit. More better rhythm,follow with lyrics,like this.

00:48:750 (6,7,8) - try this Rhythm


[Extra]
HP and OD -1 plz
try this? err.... timing please?


good luck

Leorda wrote:

Hello there

[Easy]
* Set the tick rate to 1, because this rhythm is based on 1/1. Having set the tick rate to 2 can have a bad visual during gameplay


[Normal]
* Same suggestion as Easy about tick rate


[Hard]
00:18:561 (1) - This short spinner is difficult for advanced player to complete it because this spinner is too extreme for Hard diff. Consider to extend it or replace it with slider?
00:48:751 (4) - Reverse this selection for making a spiral-flow pattern? the flow doesn't feel good to the next note
00:55:396 (1) - Same suggestion as 00:18:561 (1) it's fine I think, since this is a hard diff and the auto gets 3000 bonus points


[Lunatic]
00:17:992 (1) - Spacing too far between previous note, is this intentional? yes it is
00:32:801 (6,7,1) - Make a pattern like this to make spiral flow? Your current pattern looks like breaking the flow due the shape of slider make off-path of flow that would make the next note too far http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/863893


Good luck

CDFA wrote:

The time has come

Sorry it took so long ;A;.

Overall:
The whistle just by itself sounds really weird. Consider using regular hitnormal+whistle for this. It sounds way too top heavy otherwise. well yeah, because it using slider-whistle, so it sounds weird
00:19:890 - Make this an inherited section because it using different time signature, no change
00:56:345 - Make this an inherited section

LUNATIC:
00:01:663 (1,2) - Try making this into a more coherent pattern rather than just two random sliders
00:20:649 (3) - This feels like it's too close to (2)
00:30:902 (3) - Make this overlap more notable or get rid of the overlap. Right now it's too slight that it looks like a mistake
00:32:231 (5) - Make this right next to (4) instead of above it? It'll make it look more coherent. I want to make a little gap
00:41:345 (3) - Make this just a copy-paste of (2)
00:42:295 (5) - Make this the same curve as (4)

Extra:
00:26:345 (6) - Put this in line with (4) rather than below it. I want to make a little gap
00:32:231 (3) - Put this under (2) rather than to the left of it ^

Hard:
00:30:143 (2) - Touches HP bar
This diff seems incredibly easy compared to lunatic and extra.

Normal:
Fine, but really easy. It's kind of ironic since a lot of parts are similar to hard. I thought it was similar to easy orz

Easy:
Fine.

Moe moe nyan.

sheela901 wrote:

[Normal]
00:08:498 (2) - It won't confuse to newbies? changed a little

[Hard]
00:30:143 (2) - Ctrl + H? it makes next note too close

Sorry if it wasn't enough. Good Luck and star!

1. In my opinion~Extra diff should only be Another,Because Extra is very hard,and yours is easy to fc~

1. 00:23:307 - slider at this time point may adjust more batter~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/885161

1. 00:46:092 (4) - add whistle at slider end?

1. 00:54:067 (3) - ^

1. 00:41:915 - here may do like this? different distance in hard diff is permitted http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/885174

1. none

1. 00:02:422 (3) - the slider change to two circles more batter~like these 00:03:941 (3,4) -

1. 00:26:725 (1,2) - 2 may surround 1 batter

1. 00:32:231 (5) - slider does not look very good try this? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/885190

1. Perhaps add a muted normal-sliderslide.wav?

1. wtf why all settings get a 9? This diff isn't [extra] enough! So just raise down the hp/od for 1~2 (I'll recommend 2 or even 3)tick(s).
2. 00:02:042 - Add a whistle with drum additions? Just do something like 00:04:321 (1,2) - and the patterns after this, it'll be consistent with them afterwards. (Do this to every difficulties)
3. 00:04:131 (6,1) - Not sure about this, but why you change the spacing from 1.0x to 1.1x? If you want to make a jump, then use a bigger spacing; if you don't want to make a jump, just use 1.0x spacing to replace them >:
4. 00:04:321 (1,2,3) - The placement here is kinda messy imo. Try to re-place the pattern like the picture? (Don't forget to replace the following notes by using right distance spacing!)
   
   SPOILER

   
5. 00:17:232 (4,5) - I'll just copy (5), and make it rotate for 120 degrees to instead (4). Or you can copy (4) and do the same thing to instead (5), that's okay. Just make their shape consistent and it'd be much better o_o
6. 00:54:257 (3,4) - Is this a serious jump, seems nonsense
   I'll say this diff isn't "clean" at all, but it isn't bad.

• I don't get some big deals, but the nazi things aren't that nice at all.

1. 00:06:979 (5) - So ugly, reduce the curve of this slider pls
2. 00:31:282 (3) - ^
3. 00:41:915 (5,6) - To make the pattern more clean here, I'll suggest you to make (6)'s slider head and (5)'s sliderend as a straight line. I don't know how to explain, just take a look at the picture and fix it.
   
   SPOILER

   

Sweet Vanilla wrote:

Thank you for visit my moding queue~
whis it can help you~ poor english sry
[General]

1. In my opinion~Extra diff should only be Another,Because Extra is very hard,and yours is easy to fc~ touhou naming diff.. extra is fine

[easy]

1. 00:23:307 - slider at this time point may adjust more batter~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/885161

[Normal]

1. 00:46:092 (4) - add whistle at slider end? finish is enough

1. 00:54:067 (3) - ^ ^

[Hard]

1. 00:41:915 - here may do like this? different distance in hard diff is permitted http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/885174

[Extra]

1. none

[Lunatic]

1. 00:02:422 (3) - the slider change to two circles more batter~like these 00:03:941 (3,4) -

1. 00:26:725 (1,2) - 2 may surround 1 batter

1. 00:32:231 (5) - slider does not look very good try this? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/885190 that would make the next note hard to catch

That's all ,good luck~

Flask wrote:

Why E & N / H & I get same BG hey dai =w=

[General]

1. Perhaps add a muted normal-sliderslide.wav?

[Extra]

1. wtf why all settings get a 9? This diff isn't [extra] enough! So just raise down the hp/od for 1~2 (I'll recommend 2 or even 3)tick(s).
2. 00:02:042 - Add a whistle with drum additions? Just do something like 00:04:321 (1,2) - and the patterns after this, it'll be consistent with them afterwards. (Do this to every difficulties)
3. 00:04:131 (6,1) - Not sure about this, but why you change the spacing from 1.0x to 1.1x? If you want to make a jump, then use a bigger spacing; if you don't want to make a jump, just use 1.0x spacing to replace them >: new combo
4. 00:04:321 (1,2,3) - The placement here is kinda messy imo. Try to re-place the pattern like the picture? (Don't forget to replace the following notes by using right distance spacing!)
   
   SPOILER

   
5. 00:17:232 (4,5) - I'll just copy (5), and make it rotate for 120 degrees to instead (4). Or you can copy (4) and do the same thing to instead (5), that's okay. Just make their shape consistent and it'd be much better o_o
6. 00:54:257 (3,4) - Is this a serious jump, seems nonsense
   I'll say this diff isn't "clean" at all, but it isn't bad.

[Lunatic]

• I don't get some big deals, but the nazi things aren't that nice at all.

[Hard]

1. 00:06:979 (5) - So ugly, reduce the curve of this slider pls
2. 00:31:282 (3) - ^
3. 00:41:915 (5,6) - To make the pattern more clean here, I'll suggest you to make (6)'s slider head and (5)'s sliderend as a straight line. I don't know how to explain, just take a look at the picture and fix it.
   
   SPOILER

   

Get nothing on E/N, good luck~

winber1 wrote:

Sorry for the late mod.

Extra

OD9 is meh, so is the HP9. It makes it so the accuracy is more to worry about rather than the actual notes, cuz in general, this map is easy--very few jumps and little spacing and such.

1. 00:18:751 (5,1) - Probably will look better if the spacing was constant.
2. 00:33:465 - Would match the music more if you added a note here http://puu.sh/3Llfj.jpg you might have to do something different if this looks ugly to you.
3. 00:36:598 (1) - new combo isn't necessary imo, but still up to you if you want to keep it.

Lunatic

1. 00:02:422 (3) - I find it slightly weird that you put the claps on this somewhat awkward beats (aka the slider ends and stuff, unlike in Extra where you put them on 2 hitcircles all the time). I would consider that you try to do something simlar, you where you have some consistent pattern where you have the claps on. Also, you might want to remove the repeat on this note and add a hitcircle or something. The repeat seems a lttle random. http://puu.sh/3Llp6.jpg Probably isn't the best idea, but I'm just saying that a hitcircle works better imo.
2. 00:18:751 (5) - http://puu.sh/3LlrH.jpg Fits the music more and is more fun to play imo.
3. 00:28:908 - Add note
4. 00:33:465 - Consider adding a note here as well

Hard

1. 00:17:042 (2) - I would remove this note. The random increase in notes doesn't make sense since it's still the same section.

Normal

1. 00:03:181 (2,3,4) - WHat's with this spacing? THis is spacing that apparnetly you want the section to be in 00:08:498 (2,3,4) - I would consider making the spacing the same
2. 00:16:093 (4) - I would consider making this 3 notes 00:16:473 - sounds better if mapped imo.

Easy

Seems fine.

In general, the rhythm looks fine and flows well. Some weird overlaps and things in the Lunatic and Extra diffs. Couldn't find much to say, unless i was going to nazi about the repeat sliders and some aesthetics, which I decided not to. The only problem is that I'm not really getting the Extra or Lunatic feeling (or even the Hard feeling) from the map. All I'm saying is these difficulties are really quite easy... but you have a good difficulty gap between each difficulty. meh

Anyway, looks great! Hope this helps a bit.

From the QAT-queue

No KD please.

1. The easy diff could use a bit more interesting rhythm patterns. There are a bit too many sliders, of which some of them seem to drag out a bit long. Since the map is so short this makes the total object count to 26 sliders and 6 circles. This is a bit less, and more input would be appreciated.
   
2. The normal and Hard seem to follow the same structure. The symmetry in the maps feel a little forced. Everything seems to be copy-pasted at least once which makes only 50% (30sec) original map material.
   
3. The rhythm in Lunatic needs some work. It is a bit too bland and repetive. The pacing is in the whole difficulty the same, there are no slow or faster parts. You could blame the song for this, but you should try to pay extra attention to this as well to make it more interesting.
   
4. The hitsounds were okay in the easier difficulties, but a bit too spammy in Lunatic. But don't try to fix the hitsounds, try to improve the rhythm first.

1. tbh i thought you needn't to use kiai because there's nothing different to the music

1. there are two major issues in this diff
   
   1. the spammed normal whistle which are not suitable. I highly recommend to remove them all, or at least most of
   2. the triplets start on white tick but not red causes the beat odd. Theoretically, the third note of a triplet is the "significant one", that is, in general we expect the third one placed on a white tick, that is, the triplet should start on red tick like
      
      of course, triplets start on white tick is not forbidden, but please use it carefully in special cases where has support of music.
      
      so that, please review ALL this kinda triplets ( like 00:14:194 (4,5,6) - , 00:05:840 (1) - or 00:10:776 (3,4,5) - ). I won't mention it more in the mod.
2. 00:05:365 - add a note here, or remove 00:03:466 (3) - to make your beat consistent
3. 00:19:510 (7,8,9,10) - i suppose a 1/2 slider is better
4. 00:22:453 (3) - remove it? heard not as good as expect
5. 00:36:219 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - and this kinda placement is also ... hmm.. rigid i would say .. you can make it more smooth but not restrict to DS like:
   
   SPOILER

   
6. 00:41:345 (4) - similar to above, don't bind yourself to DS
   
   SPOILER

   

happy30 wrote:

From the QAT-queue

No KD please.

Hello, thanks for taking interest in the QAT queue. We decided that your map needs a bit more work.

1. The easy diff could use a bit more interesting rhythm patterns. There are a bit too many sliders, of which some of them seem to drag out a bit long. Since the map is so short this makes the total object count to 26 sliders and 6 circles. This is a bit less, and more input would be appreciated.
   
2. The normal and Hard seem to follow the same structure. The symmetry in the maps feel a little forced. Everything seems to be copy-pasted at least once which makes only 50% (30sec) original map material.
   
3. The rhythm in Lunatic needs some work. It is a bit too bland and repetive. The pacing is in the whole difficulty the same, there are no slow or faster parts. You could blame the song for this, but you should try to pay extra attention to this as well to make it more interesting.
   
4. The hitsounds were okay in the easier difficulties, but a bit too spammy in Lunatic. But don't try to fix the hitsounds, try to improve the rhythm first.

Kenterz9 wrote:

From your request ~

[Easy]
00:40:396 (3,4) - Blanket ? it would make previous note quite further
00:47:231 (1,2) - ^ ^

[Normal]
Nothing to say ^^

[Hard]
00:23:497 (5,6,7) - Surchage of hitsound "whistle + clap" =/ consistency of Lunatic
00:32:611 (5,6,7,8,9) - ^ ^
00:36:978 (4,1) - Distance Snap ? ok
00:51:788 (1,2) - Maybe something more simple ? uh well I thinnk it's simple enough

[Lunatic]
00:31:092 (8,1) - Make the same Distance snap as the previous circles new combo, I think it's fine
00:33:181 (5,6,1) - I don't like this patern, quite ugly =( agreed, but I couldn't find any better pattern orz. suggestion please
00:42:484 (6,1) - Distance Snap ? ok

Good Luck *u*

sjoy wrote:

From eggache0's queue
the reson you know
Easy:
It looks good
Normal:
00:02:802 add a note
00:05:840 ^
Hard:
00:08:878 (3) - ctrl+g?
00:30:143 (2) - ctrl+h? it would make bad flow for the next note
00:46:092 (4) - no repeat slider? repeat, so it doesn't sounds too silent
Lunatic:
00:03:181 (2) - ctrl+g
00:14:194 (4,5,6) - stack on the 330,201 and 00:14:384 (6) - ctrl+g?no need
00:34:890 (7,8,1) - I think it's not a good flow try to adjust 78

It's time to rank
Good Luck

HeShu wrote:

Hi :3

In General :

I'm not a big fan of whistle and I really think you use them too much. Maybe less use or calmer noise could be great
Greatly mapped, so my remark will be only aesthetic oh well, I love using whistles

[Easy]

00:24:067 Move square to x256 y332 that's not look blanket enough

00:54:446 and 00:54:826 Aligne them well I want to make some variation

[Normal]

00:06:219 Make it point toward 00:05:840 ok

00:11:916 It's like it's missing a beat... ok

00:29:763 You should align this slider with the previous one same as easy

[Hard] and [Insane]

Both great

BounceBabe wrote:

You should change these things on every difficultie:

Slider Tick Rate:
The tick rate has to be consistant on every difficultie! Currently it's 1 on Easy and Normal and 2 on the Hard and Insane. it's fine

Hitsounds:
The clap is a little loud to me. Can you reduce the volume of the hitsound? reduced by 1 db

Easy

- The combo colours should be shorter kept! NC should be on 00:06:219 (3) - , 00:13:814 (3) -

00:47:231 (1,2) - The curve could be better. Move the last dot of this 00:49:890 (2) - a few grids down.
00:55:396 - You could simply add a spinner here till 00:56:345 - . Wouldn't make the ending so empty. the spinner is too short, it would make the easy player can't finish the spinner

Very impressive sliderart! Nice easy difficultie to play. thanks

Normal

Same as Easy: The combo colours should be shorter kept, NC at 00:04:700 (5) - Remove 00:06:219 (1) - NC 00:08:498 (2) - NC 00:13:814 (5) -
Spacing inconsistancy happens a lot in here. Try fixing this please! For example this 00:02:802 (2) -

00:06:219 (1,2) - Spacing is wrong here. I can see your point for having it placed here but it might confuse and be missclicked.
Like Easy: 00:55:396 - You could simply add a spinner here till 00:56:345 - . Wouldn't make the ending so empty. same as easy

Again, very nice slideart (:

Hard

00:34:700 (2) - Done for symmetry, still the spacing should be consistant.
- 00:51:408 (8) - This jump is nice to play though and also fitting.

Insane

- On the other difficulties you have such nice curved slider, where are they? they are gone D:, I focused on rhythm rather than pattern
- Some parts are too overmapped, while this is such a soft song actually. Remove the following:
00:26:820 (2,5) -
- Very inconsistant jump, which i don't like. Between every NC or section there is a jump, ok, but then at least make them consistant so it doesn't confuse.
- For example 00:02:612 (4,1) - , 00:05:650 (6,1) - , 00:08:688 (8,1) - , 00:10:207 (6,1) - and so on fixed some spacing, even though they are still not consistant

00:07:359 (1,2) - This slight spacing change doesn't fit and the following pattern is so squeezed. Why not making a consistant spacing which is better readable.
00:18:561 (4,5) - First it has this spacing and then it goes 00:19:510 (7,8,1) - this odd squeezed way. Why? There is no need for changing.
00:24:257 (8,1) - Pattern looks very weird, and also plays weird. You have this kinda jump from 8 to 1 but its only a little difference between them spacing wise. I dont really think thats fitting. I think it's okay
00:28:814 (8,1) - , 00:36:788 (5,1) - , 00:39:257 (1,2,3) - , 00:47:041 (6,1) - Again, the slight spacing change isn't needed and so unnecessary. It feels weird when playing.
00:43:434 (4,1,2,3,4) - This is very bland to play, the linear pattern doesn't work good when you had such emphasizing patterns. Try curving it or something similar.

Read the "testplayers opinions" from our queue, to get more opinions about your map!

All difficulties are well made and the spread is fine. The Insane needs more work on consistancy but that's a minimal problem (:

1. Pink colours only make players' eye hurt, try to use different colours, maybe?
   
   try these colours!

   
   

   Combo1 : 123,169,202
   Combo2 : 255,128,255
   Combo3 : 201,156,245

1. 00:38:117 (1,3) - nazi - you could try to stack them. It's a very, very minor thing but it'd improve your flow
2. 00:56:345 (1) - feels a little bit awkward for me, I'd try to replace it with a slider started on 00:55:586, it'd help you to reflect that drum sound better, I think.
   
   Slider velocity feels kinda too fast for the [Easy], but what done is done and there's nothing we can do to fix it. It's still a nice diff, tho.

1. Try to reduce OD and HP by one tick, it'll make the diff more balanced.It's also fits better with your patterns, I think.
2. 00:01:663 (1,2,3) - spacing is inconsistent, symmetrical patterns are awesome, but you shouldn't frget about the DS! Try to make it a little bit mre consistent, i know, you can!
3. 00:11:536 (1,3) - players may see (1) as a slider. Don't believe me? Disable "snaking sliders" in video settings and test your map. It bugs me a lot.
4. 00:13:814 (5) - missed a new combo? feels like this combo is too long! Try to place NC here to keep your patterns more consistent.
5. 00:55:396 - same as [Easy]. A slider here would fit, I think.
   
   Nice diff, just a little bit more work on your patterns' appearance!

1. 00:32:611 (5,6,7,8,9) - feels kinda out of your pattern. Try to replace them with sliders, so it'll fit with your regular patterns much better!
   
   That's a nice diff, I like it. Well done!

1. HP Drain 8 feels a little bit too agressive for this diff, but song is short so it's probably ok to make it harder. Anyway, try to reduce it by one tick and see if you like it or not.
2. 00:01:663 (1,2) - awesome whistles. I love this sound!
3. 00:34:890 (7,8,1) - nazi - what was the point of reducing the DS here? You didn't do this earlier, so consider keeping the DS consistent here. Players may read it as 1/6, y'know.
   
   Nothing else to mention, good job!

-Bakari- wrote:

Thank you for your request, here's a mod as requested!

[General]

1. Pink colours only make players' eye hurt, try to use different colours, maybe?
   
   try these colours!

   
   

   Combo1 : 123,169,202
   Combo2 : 255,128,255
   Combo3 : 201,156,245

[Easy]

1. 00:38:117 (1,3) - nazi - you could try to stack them. It's a very, very minor thing but it'd improve your flow
2. 00:56:345 (1) - feels a little bit awkward for me, I'd try to replace it with a slider started on 00:55:586, it'd help you to reflect that drum sound better, I think.
   
   Slider velocity feels kinda too fast for the [Easy], but what done is done and there's nothing we can do to fix it. It's still a nice diff, tho. yeah, I just realized this after I finished this diff orz

[Normal]

1. Try to reduce OD and HP by one tick, it'll make the diff more balanced.It's also fits better with your patterns, I think.
2. 00:01:663 (1,2,3) - spacing is inconsistent, symmetrical patterns are awesome, but you shouldn't frget about the DS! Try to make it a little bit mre consistent, i know, you can!
3. 00:11:536 (1,3) - players may see (1) as a slider. Don't believe me? Disable "snaking sliders" in video settings and test your map. It bugs me a lot.
4. 00:13:814 (5) - missed a new combo? feels like this combo is too long! Try to place NC here to keep your patterns more consistent.
5. 00:55:396 - same as [Easy]. A slider here would fit, I think.
   
   Nice diff, just a little bit more work on your patterns' appearance!

[Hard]

1. 00:32:611 (5,6,7,8,9) - feels kinda out of your pattern. Try to replace them with sliders, so it'll fit with your regular patterns much better!
   
   That's a nice diff, I like it. Well done!

[Insane]

1. HP Drain 8 feels a little bit too agressive for this diff, but song is short so it's probably ok to make it harder. Anyway, try to reduce it by one tick and see if you like it or not.
2. 00:01:663 (1,2) - awesome whistles. I love this sound!
3. 00:34:890 (7,8,1) - nazi - what was the point of reducing the DS here? You didn't do this earlier, so consider keeping the DS consistent here. Players may read it as 1/6, y'know.
   
   Nothing else to mention, good job!

Pretty nice mapset, I enjoyed playing and modding it!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Good luck!

Dai wrote:

-Bakari- wrote:

thanks -Bakari-, aku cinta kamu

Dai wrote:

that's because I'm using 1/1, so there aren't any note on red tick

1. Red - Unrankable issue, you must fixed
2. Purple - Highly recommended, consider to use it
3. Black - Suggestion, feel free to fixed or not
4. Gray - Presonal preference

1. Fine

1. Quite okay

1. Fine

1. 00:22:548 (2) - Here can be blanket better with 00:19:890 (1) - , move the repeat point to x:244 y:300
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:24:446 (1) - You can try this, it looks better
   SPOILER

   
   If you need code
   Click This!

   352,112,24446,6,0,B|324:204|220:188|220:188|88:176|32:248,2,360,4|0|0,0:3|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

3. 00:40:776 (4) - well, still nazi here, make a better blanket like this
   SPOILER

   
   Code
   Click This!

   264,196,40776,2,0,B|208:232|152:216|120:188|120:188|148:272,2,240

1. Nothing to say, here we go

1. 00:23:117 (4,1,2) - This is an example. We can see, 00:24:446 - and 00:24:826 - have same tunes, but 00:25:206 - is higher than them, that means, if you want to use finishes, it is better to add it on 00:25:206 - , not 00:24:826 - . The following parts like 00:25:586 (2,3) - and so on, they are the same, add finishes on slider end, not repeat points. But patterns like 00:31:282 (3,4) - are different, 00:31:662 - and 00:32:231 - have higher tunes instead, so they should be finishes

1. 00:23:117 (4) - Quite creative!
2. 00:30:143 (1,2) - Distance here is wrong, please make it around 1.00x because it is a Normal diff

1. Okay.. But too many repeat sliders make this diff lack of hit

1. 00:23:117 (4,1,2) - The same as I said in Normal

1. Really a good symmetric diff

1. Nice

1. 00:23:117 (4,1,2) - The same as I said in Normal

1. 00:20:269 (2) - I think you can try Ctrl+G H J this to make a better flow, also in 00:21:029 (4,6) -
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:34:984 (8) - move to x:208 y:180, it looks and plays better
3. 00:35:839 (4) - Ctrl+H this then move to x:428 y:232 for a better flow. Btw, is your spacing wrong here? Before this there is around 1.20x spacing but after this there is around 1.10x even 1.00x... well, this is a tiny problem.
   SPOILER

   

1. You must remove these files "soft-sliderwhistle, soft-hitclap-1lama" As you know, you didn't use these files.

• 
  I feel this SV Rate (1.2) is a bit fast for this difficulty. I recommend you to use about SV 1.0

1. 00:10:776 (1,2,1) - Please make the queal spacing here. It would look better.
2. 00:22:548 (2) - add a clap to the tail of the slider same as here 00:22:548 -
3. 00:36:978 (4) - I'm worry about off-screen at this note. So you should consider moving these up for safety.
   It's better to use more hitsounds ~

1. 00:09:257 (3) - Same as Easy diff 00:36:978 (4) -
2. 00:41:345 (4) - Remove a whistle to the head of the slider since it follows nothing.
3. 00:50:459 (4) - ^
   Please check spacing again, you should consider using x1.0 at all parts.

1. 00:51:788 (1) - hmm... Please check this rule ~ You have to change another slider.
   
2. 00:52:928 (2) - ^ Same.
   I think if you make more jump parts, it's more exciting ~

1. Overall Difficulty and HP Drain Rate -1. It's really hard for this difficulty.
2. 00:19:606 - i feel kind of empty here, it is better to use 1/4 rhythm for playing also you followed this sound at previous 7 hits 00:18:940 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - . So you should consider adding a note here.
3. 00:19:795 - ^ Same.
4. 00:24:446 (1,2,3) - How about making the equal spacing here ?
   Again, more jump parts pls! I feel it is a bit boring = =