Sorry to break the HYPE party, the naming of Normal is questionable.
Just 'Normal' please
Just 'Normal' please
forum
scop - Yubikiri [Osu|Taiko]
posted
Total Posts
69
Topic Starter
Skylish wrote:
Sorry to break the HYPE party, the naming of Normal is questionable.
Just 'Normal' please
"Ayyffy's" serves to provide information as to the two people to worked on the difficulty by combining I and Ayyri's names together.
The term "Fated" is used as a song-thematic replacement for "Collab".
"Collab" refers to two people working together. "Fated" is two people meant to be together. Considering the contents of the song regarding promises and what feels like fate, I found it fitting as a replacement.
Especially since the song is between two ladies and the collab between two ladies.
The difficulty name itself, "Normal", is untouched, and clearly indicates difficulty level among the spread.
For a song as elegant as this one, the regular word "collab" just seems garish and unfitting.
If the difficulty name was just "Ayyffy's Fated", I would understand this concern, but this is not the case.
Those that I talked to about this previously and explained it to said it should be fine >.<
edit: my previous in-thread explanation too, for reference:
Noffy wrote:
1.) it's not a custom name. it does not take place of the difficulty name "normal". 2.) it is a thematic replacement of where the word "collab" would typically go. When two people are "fated" they are "joined together" by something that was inevitable, when two people collab they are "joined together" by making the map... and this collab was inevitable, so...~
Fyi in case you are not very clear with naming system:
Either one case below should exist:
+ Collab Normal
+ Mapper1+2's Normal
===========
> Any thing after 's is considered as 'difficulty name'. In the current case, 'Fated Normal' is treated as an isolated difficulty.
> Fated =/= Collab, it is not a usual naming habit and imo 'fated' means 'destinate'. If you use a combined mapper's name already in front of difficulty name, there is no need to put 'collab' keywords any more.
===========
I don't mind 'Fated Ayyffy's Normal' , but not 'Ayyffy's Fated Normal' . They have 2 different meanings.
Either one case below should exist:
+ Collab Normal
+ Mapper1+2's Normal
===========
> Any thing after 's is considered as 'difficulty name'. In the current case, 'Fated Normal' is treated as an isolated difficulty.
> Fated =/= Collab, it is not a usual naming habit and imo 'fated' means 'destinate'. If you use a combined mapper's name already in front of difficulty name, there is no need to put 'collab' keywords any more.
===========
I don't mind 'Fated Ayyffy's Normal' , but not 'Ayyffy's Fated Normal' . They have 2 different meanings.
Topic Starter
Skylish wrote:
Fyi in case you are not very clear with naming system: I'm very clear:The difficulty indicated "normal" is unchanged. There is nothing against adding a descriptive adjective.Ranking Criteria wrote:
A difficulty's name must indicate its level of difficulty, with the exception of the hardest level of difficulty in a set. The mapset's hardest difficulty may use an appropriate custom difficulty name, unrelated to a username. Mapsets may also use a complete set of custom difficulty names that clearly indicate their level of difficulty to the player. Marathon maps with a single difficulty may use free naming.
Either one case below should exist:
+ Collab Normal
+ Mapper1+2's Normal
+ Mapper1+2's Collab Difficultynamehere does exist although rarer.
===========
> Any thing after 's is considered as 'difficulty name'. In the current case, 'Fated Normal' is treated as an isolated difficulty. And it properly indicates its level of difficulty. The actual difficulty indicator is unchanged.
> Fated =/= Collab, it is not a usual naming habit and imo 'fated' means 'destinate'. If you use a combined mapper's name already in front of difficulty name, there is no need to put 'collab' keywords any more. Yes it's not usual, it's just for this song. It wouldn't work for other songs. Not having any "collab" keyword risks the difficulty name being misread as "Ayyri's Normal" or Ayyffy being mistaken for a third mapper.
===========
I don't mind 'Fated Ayyffy's Normal' , but not 'Ayyffy's Fated Normal' . They have 2 different meanings. Fated Ayyffy's Normal no longer makes grammatical sense. Besides breaking grammar, I do not see other difference between these two.
I'd have to disagree, the difficulty name not only clearly indicates its level of difficulty, but also has clear relation to the map. There's no need to change this difficulty name.Skylish wrote:
Fyi in case you are not very clear with naming system:
Either one case below should exist:
+ Collab Normal
+ Mapper1+2's Normal
===========
> Any thing after 's is considered as 'difficulty name'. In the current case, 'Fated Normal' is treated as an isolated difficulty.
> Fated =/= Collab, it is not a usual naming habit and imo 'fated' means 'destinate'. If you use a combined mapper's name already in front of difficulty name, there is no need to put 'collab' keywords any more.
===========
I don't mind 'Fated Ayyffy's Normal' , but not 'Ayyffy's Fated Normal' . They have 2 different meanings.
i think i need a site showing your current source because all i could find is "初音ミク -Project DIVA- F 2nd", with a space between F and 2
i also don't think the difficulty name has any issues with the ranking criteria, though not sure why you would put an adjective there, it's just a normal difficulty
i also don't think the difficulty name has any issues with the ranking criteria, though not sure why you would put an adjective there, it's just a normal difficulty
Topic Starter
It was based off of the logo
look at that F and 2nd
all up against eachother
getting really nice and comfy
absolutely definitely no space inbetween the two...
...
time to pm you
look at that F and 2nd
all up against eachother
getting really nice and comfy
absolutely definitely no space inbetween the two...
...
time to pm you
disqualify to fix source
Topic Starter
Fixed
back!
Topic Starter
Thank you! (ﾉ◕ヮ◕)ﾉ*:･ﾟ✧IamKwaN wrote:
back!
CONGRATZ!!!
Topic Starter
now that i'm free from anxiety over whether the difficulty name is acceptable or not..
(best song quote)
I think you mean AAA AAA AAA AAA A!Renumi wrote:
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! aaaaaaaaaaaaaa
(best song quote)
hi frogWeber wrote:
cute noffy
thank you greatly !!Akitoshi wrote:
oh hey gratz!
thank you greatly x 2 (nice icon btw)KittyAdventure wrote:
Akitoshi wrote:
oh hey gratz!
THANXXX!!!!!!Pachiru wrote:
CONGRATZ!!!
Congratulations Noffy!! (((o(*ﾟ▽ﾟ*)o)))♡
Topic Starter
d=(´▽｀)=b thanks jack!!jack1817 wrote:
Congratulations Noffy!! (((o(*ﾟ▽ﾟ*)o)))♡
I would like to point out that base slider velocity is bugged in both Taiko difficulties. Please contact me for disqualification so you can fix them via notepad to 1.40 sharp.
Topic Starter
this is the penance i get for trying to rank a set in only three monthsNardoxyribonucleic wrote:
I would like to point out that base slider velocity is bugged in both Taiko difficulties. Please contact me for disqualification so you can fix them via notepad to 1.40 sharp.
fixed
Disqualified as requested to fix the bugged base SV.
Topic Starter
Nardoxyribonucleic wrote:
Disqualified as requested to fix the bugged base SV.
Updootedled
Back as no gameplay elements are affected upon the change.
Topic Starter
Thank you !! ^^Nardoxyribonucleic wrote:
Back as no gameplay elements are affected upon the change.
(third time's the charm right)
(I PRAY)
delete pepsi gj ayyri
(also im probably wrong, but dont hybrid sets need a bubble from each mode?)
(also im probably wrong, but dont hybrid sets need a bubble from each mode?)
Topic Starter
this is a cocacola only householdstrickluke wrote:
delete pepsi gj ayyri
(also im probably wrong, but dont hybrid sets need a bubble from each mode?)
and
no they don't, there's been proposal to change it but as of now only two bns are needed for any map.
.. i think
idk what happens to hybrids with 3 or 4 modes
i suppose it doesn't matter that much since a standard bn already qualified it