^ post directed to Irre
forum
Mafia in Hoenn Region - Game Over
posted
Total Posts
1,151
I already explained a lot why I think Frostings is scum.Drezi wrote:
I agree that the reasoning for the Jess townread is nonsense, but I'd like to hear more about the quoted part.fartownik wrote:
I just said that because it really was easy to read your scumplay right from the beginning of the game.
It's two reasons to be exact.
As stated already: >IF< Frostings is going to flip town, that would be a third reason. And an obviously more impactful one, but I can't confirm it yet, hence why I'm not voting you yet.
You don't need to get offended at all, right? (scumcred) I'm just not believing everyone who makes "ez game plz vote 4 frostings" assumptions.
As stated already: >IF< Frostings is going to flip town, that would be a third reason. And an obviously more impactful one, but I can't confirm it yet, hence why I'm not voting you yet.
You don't need to get offended at all, right? (scumcred) I'm just not believing everyone who makes "ez game plz vote 4 frostings" assumptions.
Nope, there's pretty much nothing addressing his play from before your vote on him, apart from "that was easy", and you just said that it was easy to read his scumplay right from the beginning.
The read is real. There is no new player that joins his first/second game, gets placed in scumfaction and plays "nonsensical scum" on day 1. I was at L-4 as the game just started, and so I gave my honest reads to let you all know that I am actually paying attention to this game, not just making trash posts for no reason. I don't know why you keep bringing up Irre and the last game either, when this is a new game and different things happen. Not sure if you think I'm scum acting naive, but, believe it or not, I'm one of the people actually making analysis here, unlike half the others.fartownik wrote:
More scumpoints to you, you're digging yourself a grave. Actually there is a way a new-scum would publicly townread you and that is a nonsensical scum, which may be the case here. You didn't learn from past game with Irre, did you? I think you did, you're just pretending that you didn't because you are scum and you can't actually judge whether Jess's read on you has any legit base so you grab onto anything that was given to you so you have a "read" (townread specifically) on at least 1 player.
Your posts are filled with hypocrisy: "More scumpoints to you, you're digging a grave" because I make a "weak" read on one person? Take a look at yourself and what you're doing to me right now. You make a scumread on me (off of what?) and now you're trying to backup your arguments with absolutely no evidence
I think this is another reaction test. If you're scum and actually pushing me this far, you're being stupid; if you're town and you're actually pushing me this far, you're being stupid.fartownik wrote:
Also if you don't see any town-merit in my posts and only see them as an attack on your person, well, that is another scumtell to me.
Magic Bomb, why don't you tell us YOUR thoughts?- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Drezi, just wondering, what are your thoughts on Frostings right now?
MBomb
I guess it's best to wait some other people to state their opinions.
Sorry I'm late.
Unvote
---------------------------
Okay, also:
I like Magic Bomb's attitude specially if it is they first game, but I do hope all their questioning comes with their own conclusions later, secretive play just hurts Town and brings suspicion.
@Irre: why is Drezi null-town? Just because he voted Jess early game for that silly read? I hardly find that enough content to assume that. MB (magic bomb) being null-scum for the excess of questions I suppose?
Not much to say about Tess, just random stuff but I do agree that frosting's moves are not really.. good.
Unvote
This post made me facepalm. I know RVS is over but I wanted to point it.Frostings wrote:
Alright time to go ham on Day 1 RVS readstrying to stop day activity even while he's asleep? Indicative of scumfartownik wrote:
Going to sleep, I better not wake up to 15 pages of posts tomorrow morning (warning).fartownik + Drezi scumteam confirmedDrezi wrote:
I was just about to post that, im off too but 7/12 of us are from my timezone, so it should be a bit more balanced this time around finally : pscumpainting me already, probably scumTess wrote:
I spy with my little eye
A scummy smelling frosty pie
Irre: Nothing worth noting so far, but we all know crabs have a hard exterior. He's scum who's hiding behind his shell acting town. Probably scum
Jess: random FoS on SNB with no explanation? wtf? obvscum
rEdo: literally posted nothing this game. typical lurker tsk tsk. town.
Sniverre: This guy is totally lying about being new at this game, He's going to make a bunch of scumslips and then just use his "i'm new" as an excuse. FoS on this guytypical goodie, trying to get towncred by being helpful. scum post right thereZexion wrote:
Take your time and read more of the wiki. It gives a great insight of the mafia game and how to play it and stuff. I learned a lot from there!town <3 (but I'm still suspicious, probably scum)- Magic Bomb - <- (how does anyone write this username without going crazy, it took me like ten tries to get it right) wrote:
oh wait plz no wagon
Unvote
Amianki: RIP CalignoBot, Amianki probably NKd him. totally scum
SNB: do I even need to explain
alright I'm a king
Why would you take that post seriously?Tess wrote:
Are you being serious
From experience I can tell that Amianki's early "reads" are not to be trusted at all. Most of the time he just does a 180° on it later.Amianki wrote:
Ok yeah, Frostings is town.
Random question after being scumread. Avoiding the topic?Frostings wrote:
I was just waiting for everyone to arrive
now that we're all confirmed, we can really get started
couple new faces here
Jess and Magic Bomb, what are your mafia experiences?
Agreeing on this one. Farto's content appears helpful, I do not buy Frosting being scum just because he looked for townreads right away, might be him just joking around (as RVS was seemilgly hard to finish), tho that avoiding the topic early game makes me wary...Static Noise Bird wrote:
I have no idea about farto yet tbh, they're posting seemingly in-depth content but it's way too early to judge whether they're going to be helpful or non-content miniwalls or whatever. Their last vote was pretty funny. If it was not a reaction test, then I'd be less amused and more suspicious though.
---------------------------
Okay, also:
I like Magic Bomb's attitude specially if it is they first game, but I do hope all their questioning comes with their own conclusions later, secretive play just hurts Town and brings suspicion.
@Irre: why is Drezi null-town? Just because he voted Jess early game for that silly read? I hardly find that enough content to assume that. MB (magic bomb) being null-scum for the excess of questions I suppose?
Not much to say about Tess, just random stuff but I do agree that frosting's moves are not really.. good.
MBomb
MBomb
He got my towncred for pointing out good quotes, also seems to pay attention.Zexion wrote:
@Irre: why is Drezi null-town? Just because he voted Jess early game for that silly read? I hardly find that enough content to assume that. MB (magic bomb) being null-scum for the excess of questions I suppose?
And not for the early-game vote. ^
Okay, I'm here.
I'm fine with the Frostings wagon, but I don't really think he's scum. Yet.
@Frostings, Jess: Who's scum?
This guy is town.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
oh wait plz no wagon
Unvote
Tad, or even more than that, too early, but this seemed as a try to generate discussion. That's town to me.Frostings wrote:
Alright time to go ham on Day 1 RVS reads
- - stuff here - -
Aaand then this is not.Frostings wrote:
oh ok I see it now, it's in the italics in the first post
3 scum guys, let's find them
Why are you so cautious this early?Frostings wrote:
fluff posting while criticising my fluff posts. null so farDrezi wrote:
@Frostings: Do you have any real early read on Tess?
why are you asking me?
Why? After two posts, which were the confirmation post and a RV to Jess?fartownik wrote:
I like Drezi.
xdfartownik wrote:
Also sems like we will have more Irre-like players this game than ever before.
I'm fine with the Frostings wagon, but I don't really think he's scum. Yet.
@Frostings, Jess: Who's scum?
Am I the only one who thinks it's a bit too early to jump so strictly on Frostings?
Why exactly did you pick this post instead of the various better ones?rEdo wrote:
This guy is town.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
oh wait plz no wagon
Unvote
Seemed like a random question, didn't realize Tess was scumreading me (apparently)rEdo wrote:
Why are you so cautious this early?
Also not being cautious, simply trying to generate more discussion
No one stands out in particular so far, doubt fartow would draw attention to himself that early if he were scumrEdo wrote:
@Frostings, Jess: Who's scum?
as far as town reads go, I'm getting good vibes from mb, though doing so excessively will arouse my suspicion
^some truth to my trollpost, though I'm gonna try not being so paranoid this game, since my reads were completely wrong the last game we playedFrostings wrote:
typical goodie, trying to get towncred by being helpful. scum post right there
Topic Starter
"Let's split for now. That way, we can find the mafia easily."
"Okay, I'll go to Mauville City for now."
"Hmm... Pretty sure there's a Game Corner here somewhere."
"Here it is! Wait, what? It's closed? Nooooooo."
"Okay, I'll go to Mauville City for now."
"Hmm... Pretty sure there's a Game Corner here somewhere."
"Here it is! Wait, what? It's closed? Nooooooo."
Votecount 1.4
fartownik -
Drezi -
Tess (2) - Static Noise Bird, - Magic Bomb -
Irreversible -
-[Jess]- (1) - Drezi
rEdo -
Sniverre235 (1) - Frostings
Zexion -
- Magic Bomb - -
Frostings (3) - Tess, Sniverre235, fartownik
Amianki -
Static Noise Bird -
Not Voting: Irreversible, rEdo, Amianki, -[Jess]-, Zexion
With 12 players alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.
Deadline will be on July 25 8:30PM GMT -5. This is 9 days from now.
Let me know if I made any mistakes.
fartownik -
Drezi -
Tess (2) - Static Noise Bird, - Magic Bomb -
Irreversible -
-[Jess]- (1) - Drezi
rEdo -
Sniverre235 (1) - Frostings
Zexion -
- Magic Bomb - -
Frostings (3) - Tess, Sniverre235, fartownik
Amianki -
Static Noise Bird -
Not Voting: Irreversible, rEdo, Amianki, -[Jess]-, Zexion
With 12 players alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.
Deadline will be on July 25 8:30PM GMT -5. This is 9 days from now.
Let me know if I made any mistakes.
Oh shit lmao.
Unvote
Unvote
This is not something you should say if you're town and trying to figure out his alignment.Frostings wrote:
I think this is another reaction test. If you're scum and actually pushing me this far, you're being stupid; if you're town and you're actually pushing me this far, you're being stupid.
I come back to 5 new pages of accusations in all directions.
I caught up by now, I'm sticking with my vote on Frostings.
As for any reads, I think Irre and Zexion are likely to be town, but not much can be confirmed about anyone so far.
I have a small list of three scum suspects, however, if they are scum, then the rest of town is fucked. I think everyone should step up their game and start paying close attention to what's going on.
In the meantime, could everyone tell me about their mafia experience? This is my second game.
That was really just taunting.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Mainly because of Tess's scumread on Frostings
Pulling an Irre is now a thing.fartownik wrote:
Also sems like we will have more Irre-like players this game than ever before.
By that I meant "are you seriously doing this?" rather than asking if he was joking. It was obvious that he was joking, which is why I didn't want to take the game too seriously at first.Zexion wrote:
Why would you take that post seriously?Tess wrote:
Are you being serious
I caught up by now, I'm sticking with my vote on Frostings.
As for any reads, I think Irre and Zexion are likely to be town, but not much can be confirmed about anyone so far.
I have a small list of three scum suspects, however, if they are scum, then the rest of town is fucked. I think everyone should step up their game and start paying close attention to what's going on.
In the meantime, could everyone tell me about their mafia experience? This is my second game.
I think I said this is a good wagon, but keeping in mind that Frostings himself might not really be scum.Static Noise Bird wrote:
Am I the only one who thinks it's a bit too early to jump so strictly on Frostings?
Ah, I just quoted the post that gave me this impression the most. His general doing seems good, of course. He's asking questions, asking people to give his reads. He's doing the analysis. What worries me, though, is that he seems afraid to state his opinion about stuff directly to people (or at least I'm getting that impression), but that's the first game he's playing, so I'll accept that for now. I mean, he's not as aggressive towards some people as he might be, but I think he needs to do a research himself before calling out scums.Static Noise Bird wrote:
Why exactly did you pick this post instead of the various better ones?rEdo wrote:
This guy is town.
@Tess: LOL is this really your second game? I've played like 10 on this forum and ~50 IRC-based games.
Are they Frostings-related?Tess wrote:
I have a small list of three scum suspects, however, if they are scum, then the rest of town is fucked. I think everyone should step up their game and start paying close attention to what's going on.
It's really my second game. Also, they're not Frostings related, they're people who seem to be working together, whereas Frostings is just machinegunning scumreads wherever he can, just like in the last game, where he was town. But I'm keeping my vote on him for reasons.
MBomb
You did make a mistake, I'm on Tess and Not Voting, I should only be on Tess.Navizel wrote:
"Let's split for now. That way, we can find the mafia easily."
"Okay, I'll go to Mauville City for now."
"Hmm... Pretty sure there's a Game Corner here somewhere."
"Here it is! Wait, what? It's closed? Nooooooo."Votecount 1.4
fartownik -
Drezi -
Tess (2) - Static Noise Bird, - Magic Bomb -
Irreversible -
-[Jess]- (1) - Drezi
rEdo -
Sniverre235 (1) - Frostings
Zexion -
- Magic Bomb - -
Frostings (3) - Tess, Sniverre235, fartownik
Amianki -
Static Noise Bird -
Not Voting: Irreversible, rEdo, Amianki, -[Jess]-, - Magic Bomb -, Zexion
With 12 players alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.
Deadline will be on July 25 8:30PM GMT -5. This is 10 days from now.
Let me know if I made any mistakes.
@Navizel: You should definitely bold out the left-most names in each lane. That's called pleasure for eyes. Removing names with no votes on them seems like a good idea, too.
you know what
I'm gonna insta-scumread everyone who has a little girl in their avatar
THIS IS A PLAN
I'm gonna insta-scumread everyone who has a little girl in their avatar
THIS IS A PLAN
MBomb
Topic Starter
Votecount 1.4 should be good now.
MBomb
They don't need to pretend to play nonsensical scum to be nonsensical. They simply have no idea what they're doing thus they can do anything. I don't like your read at all. The fact that you make analysis doesn't make you Town. There's most likely scum in the lurking, but that's not the rule. Also really? Mafia is all about assumptions, much less evidence. You can't really have 'evidence' on anyone in this game if you really want to go there, you can only assume to a certain point and base your actions on those assumptions. So far I assume you're a good candidate for being scum, that's all. I've made my points in previous posts, they may be trivial to you, but they're more or less scumtells to me.Frostings wrote:
The read is real. There is no new player that joins his first/second game, gets placed in scumfaction and plays "nonsensical scum" on day 1. I was at L-4 as the game just started, and so I gave my honest reads to let you all know that I am actually paying attention to this game, not just making trash posts for no reason. I don't know why you keep bringing up Irre and the last game either, when this is a new game and different things happen. Not sure if you think I'm scum acting naive, but, believe it or not, I'm one of the people actually making analysis here, unlike half the others.
Your posts are filled with hypocrisy: "More scumpoints to you, you're digging a grave" because I make a "weak" read on one person? Take a look at yourself and what you're doing to me right now. You make a scumread on me (off of what?) and now you're trying to backup your arguments with absolutely no evidence
I think this is another reaction test. If you're scum and actually pushing me this far, you're being stupid; if you're town and you're actually pushing me this far, you're being stupid.[/quote]fartownik wrote:
Also if you don't see any town-merit in my posts and only see them as an attack on your person, well, that is another scumtell to me.
Well, I wrote that because I thought you're scumreading me for scumreading you (OMGUS'ing).
Could you elaborate?Tess wrote:
I have a small list of three scum suspects, however, if they are scum, then the rest of town is fucked. I think everyone should step up their game and start paying close attention to what's going on.
I played some games.. I'm not saying anything else without my lawyer.Tess wrote:
In the meantime, could everyone tell me about their mafia experience? This is my second game.
When I've read this, I thought it must be obvious that it is Frostings related, however:rEdo wrote:
Are they Frostings-related?
This makes literally no sense for me right now. Why would you vote someone you don't think is scum? You apparently already have a scum-trio, so you don't need to reaction test as well.Tess wrote:
Also, they're not Frostings related, they're people who seem to be working together, whereas Frostings is just machinegunning scumreads wherever he can, just like in the last game, where he was town. But I'm keeping my vote on him for reasons.
FoS: Tess
It happens sometimes, sometimes activity is really low.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Oh also I'm surprised by the small amount of posts whilst I was gone, it was 3 hours and there was only like 7 posts...
I very much hope to hear from Amianki, Sniverre and Jess tomorrow when I wake up