1. Easy (2.22 stars, 145 notes)
2. Hard (4.63 stars, 275 notes)
3. Insane (4.95 stars, 328 notes)
4. Normal (4.08 stars, 199 notes)

Wolf wrote:

FIRST
LET'S RANK THIS

pimpG wrote:

lol

sb'ers, video/background helpers usually don't go to tags

you even have collabs on your mapset so that could be confusing

but thanks anyway

Wolf wrote:

Shouldn't be a problem having your name on the tags, unless you don't want him to put it.

pimpG wrote:

k

Wolf wrote:

pimpG wrote:

k

np

Also maybe add lyrics in description ? :OO

Gabe wrote:

Also maybe add lyrics in description ? :OO
or storyboard it ? :OO

CloudSplash16 wrote:

Hi there! Wolf asked me to mod this~ Hey cloud \o/

[Normal]
Wolf:
01:08:044 (1,2,3) - This figure looks kinda messy. The movement from (1) to (2) is not smooth and can be confusing. Try something like this: http://puu.sh/6gBZT.jpg Did that so it can have some variation on the gameplay but alright I guess, moved slider to improve flow.
01:55:663 (1) - Why 1.2x SV on this slider? It really comes out of nowhere, and is confusing the play. Nice catch, shouldn't be there.
02:04:711 (4) - Missed a clap Done.

[Hard]
Wolf:
00:28:044 (1) - Whistle on end. Done.

Good luck.

CloudSplash16 wrote:

Hi there! Wolf asked me to mod this~

[General]
I think offset should be 1384 (+6) Fixed
01:55:663 - There are two inheriting sections here... remove one. Fixed
You really didn't need to make all these inheriting sections to use the different hitsounds, especially since you don't have any custom hitsounds. If you didn't know, you can keep it all as Soft, and just change the sounds of a hit using the drop-down menus in the top left (above "Select"). For example, at 00:08:996 (1) - you can select the slider head and change the "Additions" to "Drum", then add the whistle. Not necessary to change now, but just something to keep in mind for future maps. Oooh... I didn't know that, thanks ^^
Set a preview point. Added
Make tags in Insane the same as other diffs. Fixed

[Easy]
OD1 seems excessively low. I think OD2 would fit better, since there is much more sliders than circles. Changed
Wolf:
00:24:235 - At this section, I don't really understand your hitsound pattern. Try for something with a consistent feel? I would suggest using whistles on beats 2 and 4 of every measure. (Example: http://puu.sh/6gAwU.png)

I implimented almost all of my whistles on voices. I did add more whistles and removed some

01:06:139 (5) - Maybe soft finish would be nice on head and repeat to emphasize this special rhythm
01:08:520 (2) - Feels very empty. I think you should use clap on head and end. These can be heard in the music.
02:01:854 (4) - ^
02:09:473 (5) - ^
VinylDash14:
00:39:473 (1,2) - Make a nicer blanket http://puu.sh/6gAVi.jpg Fixed
01:11:854 (3) - Try to make this flow nicer from (2) and into (1). Example: http://puu.sh/6gB7R.jpg (Rotate 15 degrees CW and move to x:132|y:154) Sure
01:17:092 (5) - maybe clap would be better here Sure
01:46:139 (2) - Whistle on end? I don't like it here IMO
01:47:092 (3) - ^ ^
02:20:901 (3) - Curve the second section the other way for better flow? http://puu.sh/6gCxc.jpg Fixed
02:20:901 (3) - I feel like end should have clap instead. Agreed
02:22:330 (4) - Try soft finish on head and repeat. I think it'll do nice emphasis of this rhythm. Ok
02:24:235 (1) - Clap on end. You can hear it in the music.
02:25:663 (3) - Clap on head.

For these last two, I don't like claps right here. I like the way when you can hear him sing peacefully w/out any claps. I could add them, but I won't.

[Normal]
HP3 is too easy. I think you should use HP4. Sure.
Same hitsound suggestions from Easy
Wolf:
01:08:044 (1,2,3) - This figure looks kinda messy. The movement from (1) to (2) is not smooth and can be confusing. Try something like this: http://puu.sh/6gBZT.jpg
01:55:663 (1) - Why 1.2x SV on this slider? It really comes out of nowhere, and is confusing the play. Yup, that was a nice catch, fixed that.
02:04:711 (4) - Missed a clap
VinylDash14:
01:15:425 (5) - Try a Normal Finish here? (for explosion) I never really thought of that. Added
01:15:663 (1) - Clap on end. No. Refer to the note after easy
02:13:282 (1) - Stack on head of 02:11:854 (3) - Alright
02:17:092 (3) - Clap Refer to note
02:17:568 (4) - clap on end ^

[Hard]
HP->5
OD->5
Same hitsound suggestions as Easy and Normal.

Sure

Wolf:
00:28:044 (1) - Whistle on end.
VinylDash14:
00:08:520 (1) - I think that either this slider should be removed, or you should disable countdown. Since the slider is placed on beat 4, it makes the countdown start on beat 4 of the previous measure, which is really awkward. Removed countdown
00:11:854 (3,4) - I think you could use higher DS (a jump) between these to match the feel of the music. Eehh... no thanks
00:13:520 (2,1) - Blanket these? It's fine where it is

[Insane]
This is a bit easy for an "Insane" diff (compared to most maps I've played).

I like insanes like this. I just don't want to overmap, which is what I'm afraid of.

I suggest OD7 and HP7

I bumped both up to 6.

00:08:520 (1,2) - I think that either these should be removed, or you should disable countdown. Since the notes are placed on beat 4, it makes the countdown start on beat 4 of the previous measure, which is really awkward. Disabled countdown
00:13:996 (3) - You could map out the triplet here. Nah
00:22:330 (6) - NC (New combo). Ok
00:29:473 (5,6) - Make a better blanket Fixed
00:29:949 (6) - NC Ok
00:49:711 (1) - ^ Found out what you meant I think, but no.
01:06:139 (5) - NC here or on (6) Eeehh... Maybe
01:19:711 (5) - NC Alright
01:27:092 (1) - Shorten this by a 1/4 tick. Blue tick doesn't follow the music here. Fixed
01:30:901 (5) - NC Nah. The combo after it was too short
01:50:187 (4) - ^ Okie
02:07:806 (5) - ^ ^
02:15:187 (5) - ^ Nah
02:22:330 (5) - ^ ^

Good luck.

Lapis Aoki wrote:

[Easy]
01:00:907 -Change shape. Hmm, kinda did it straight so it won't compromise the flow, so no changes.

Example

01:28:050 -^Yup, here looks better. Changed shape.
02:07:098 -^Done.

GL ~ ! Hope it get ranked soon~

Lapis Aoki wrote:

Hello there VinylDash~ c:
[General]
00:37:931 -Preview Point. Hmm... sure
[Easy]
00:08:526 -Note. Good idea.
00:39:479 -The hitsound should be soft.I highly agree, although, I won't change the normal finishes in the kiai
02:25:193 -Move. I think it's fine right here.
[Normal]
00:08:526 -Note. Good idea.
00:09:717 -Move.

Example

00:09:955 -^

Example

00:11:621 -^
00:11:860 -^

Eh... I like where the 1/2 notes are, and I only want to follow 1.00x spacing, or nearly around it.

GL ~ ! Hope it get ranked soon~

Pagno wrote:

hello!

~ Mod here ~

[General]
Take a look at AIMod, it appears that tags aren't the same among the difficulties Ooops, fixed.

[Insane]
OD7

00:21:860 (5) - Blanket this with the hitcircle
00:22:574 (2) - ^

Both somewhat fixed

00:38:764 (4,5) - personally I dislike it when kiai time starts on a slider's end, so maybe do something like


I like this here, so no change

00:42:812 (5) - here too, make a better blanket Fixed

00:46:383 (3,4) - like before, it feels like it's missing something on the white tick between those two notes, consider putting something on it - and also please don't make the slider end on the long white tick I only end it there because I was following the vocals for this part and the short other parts

01:15:669 (1) - normal-hitfinish on here too? No, I did the normal hitfinish for the explosion

01:19:002 (4) - make the New Combo start here Alright

01:48:050 (1) - normal-hitfinish I don't see a reason why.

02:09:002 (4) - blanket! But it is? O.o
[Hard]
02:12:812 (5) - *nazi mod* blanket this better with the previous slider's head Fixed

Nothing to say about this difficulty! It's very well made, flow is excellent and patterns are very nice!

[Normal]
Are you sure about Circle Size? I'd have put a lower value - I'm well aware however that it would mess up the whole map if you changed it

tickrate 1

[Easy]
tickrate 1

I will talk to wolf about the tickrates.

I apologise for not finding things to fix in easier difficulties, in my opinion they are fine as they are - just a few more mods and they will be rid of any problem!
Overall mapset is really nice! Only thing, be careful with blankets!
I'm looking forward to see this ranked! Good luck

Thanks for the mod, you two!

Lust wrote:

Well here is your request \o/
Nice song btw (I'm not the one for brony type stuff but this is pretty nice) Thanks. I actually like mlp songs better because they hold a steady beat IMO.

1. Please go through and snap all the unsnapped green lines throughout the difficulties, especially the kiai times. Some of them cause kiai times to not start at the same place throughout the set
2. The drum sounding hitsounds are kind of loud imo (well they are all really loud), find a way to reduce the volume of them or find different samples. Also I'd recommend of finding a quiter sliderslide, it'll definitely benefit the mapset.

Both of the general shall be fixed and considered.

[Easy]Nice and clean easy.

1. 00:08:526 (1,2) - (Nazi) Blanket is slightly off Fixed
2. 00:20:431 (1) - Move this down so it fits better and flows more nicely. Breaks the flow after that, so no.
   
   ---------------
3. 00:25:193 (2) - Have this perfectly blanket 00:23:764 (2) - 's hitburst Wolf's part
4. 00:27:574 (4,1) - (Nazi) Blanket is slightly off ^
5. 00:33:288 (2) - 319:38 so that its perfectly stacked under 00:29:955 (2) - 's slider end (and will fix the blanket) ^
6. 00:35:193 (4) - Move this one to 319:38 after doing the above^
   ---------------
7. 00:42:812 (4) - Put a slight curve on this slider so that it flows nicely in to 00:43:764 (1) - Done
8. 00:46:621 (3,1) - Blanket can be improved here Fixed
   ---------------
9. 00:57:098 (4,1,2) - Weird flow here. The repeat slider of the beginning angles in to another direction, while the circle goes upwards, then the slider following that is in another direction entirely. Try this pattern and hopefully it will help with the flow. I'd also probably rearrange this 00:56:145 (3) - slider so that it fits this pattern suggestion nicer. Wolf's part
10. 01:04:717 (4) - another weird flow going on, curve this slider in the other direction for it to improve ^
11. 01:08:050 (1,2) - (Nazi) Blanket is slightly off ^
    ---------------
12. 01:21:383 (1) - I'd stack this on top of 01:19:002 (2) - just for consistency with the previous patterns. Also for good measure be sure to adjust the following pattern too Somewhat re-did.
    ---------------
13. 01:26:145 (2,3) - Blanket is slightly off Wolf's part
14. 01:29:955 (3,4) - (Nazi) ^ ^
15. 01:36:145 (4,1) - ^ ^
    ---------------
16. 01:49:479 (2) - 76:192 so that it stacks perfectly with 01:47:098 (3) - . Be sure to adjust the spacing in the next object afterwards Fixed Actually, it's almost the same thing, and I don't like it where your suggestion is.
17. 02:26:264 (1) - I'd put the volume to 5% and soft sampleset for this spinner. No noise at the end to really warrant a loud hitsound there I agree.

[Normal]Good normal! Not really much to mod here

1. 00:42:336 (5) - This can better blanket 00:43:764 (1) - I think it's fine for now... looks blanketed perfectly
2. 00:50:907 (1,2) - ^ Fixed
3. 01:23:764 (3) - Move this circle down so that if follows 01:22:336 (2) - slider body. Its a good idea with repeats for the following objects to be in the direction of the slider body for better flow Pretty much breaks the flow here afterwards, but I'll talk it over w/ Wolf.
   ---------------
4. 01:38:526 (4) - Just make this a straight sliderWolf's part
   ---------------
5. 02:26:264 (1) - Same spinner suggestion as in easyI agree

[Hard]Not a bad hard, just a bit sloppy on the blankets is all. I suggest looking through it again to find any that are off I didn't point out. You can use the approach circles to help you out with this!

1. 00:09:002 (1) - Remove NC. You didn't do this is normal or easy, so why here? Did it to emphasize the beginning vocal
2. 00:13:764 (3,4) - Blanket is slightly off Fixed
3. 00:18:526 (1) - Probably a good idea to have a perfect blanket 00:19:241 (2) - Alright
4. 00:20:431 (1,2) - Blankets are off Fixed
   ---------------
5. 00:24:002 (5,1) - Blanket is slightly off Wolf's part Eehh... I could fix that.
6. 00:29:479 (5,6) - Blanket is off Wolf's part
7. 00:32:574 (2,4) - I'm sorry but this is unrankable. 00:32:574 (2) - 's hitburst covers 00:33:764 (4) - repeat. Find a new pattern please. ^
8. 00:37:812 (5,6) - Blanket is a bit off ^
   ---------------
9. 00:39:241 (8,1) - Blanket is off Fixed
   ---------------
10. 01:29:479 (2) - Move this slider over so that it follows 01:29:002 (1) - Wolf's part
11. 02:08:764 (4,5) - (Nazi) This blanket is slightly off ^
    ---------------
12. 02:26:264 (1) - Same spinner suggestion as before I agree

[Insane]

1. 00:12:098 (4,5) - Spacing is kind of large so its kind of hard to play for 1/4 distance It's fine.
2. 01:08:050 (1,2,3) - The anti-jumps aren't really suitable here. I would space them out I don't think its necessary to space them out.
3. 01:15:669 (1,2,3) - ^ ^
4. 02:24:241 (1,2,3,4) - Think of a more intuitive pattern here to end the map please D: Re-mapped last section.
5. 02:26:264 (1) - Same spinner suggestion I agree

Ahh I got a bit lazy at the end, but still clean mapset. Good luck!

Lust wrote:

[Easy]

1. 00:25:193 (2) - Have this perfectly blanket 00:23:764 (2) - 's hitburst Looks pretty good to me. No changes.
2. 00:27:574 (4,1) - (Nazi) Blanket is slightly off How the hell is this off. No changes.
3. 00:33:288 (2) - 319:38 so that its perfectly stacked under 00:29:955 (2) - 's slider end (and will fix the blanket) I'm pretty sure this isn't needed. No changes.
4. 00:35:193 (4) - Move this one to 319:38 after doing the above Haven't changed above, sorry.
5. 00:57:098 (4,1,2) - Weird flow here. The repeat slider of the beginning angles in to another direction, while the circle goes upwards, then the slider following that is in another direction entirely. Try this pattern and hopefully it will help with the flow. I'd also probably rearrange this 00:56:145 (3) - slider so that it fits this pattern suggestion nicer.Hmm, I agree that the flow here can be better, but it's not that bad imo. If someone else complains I'll change.
6. 01:04:717 (4) - another weird flow going on, curve this slider in the other direction for it to improve Nice, changed.
7. 01:08:050 (1,2) - (Nazi) Blanket is slightly off Sorry, this doesn't need to be changed.
8. 01:26:145 (2,3) - Blanket is slightly off ^
9. 01:29:955 (3,4) - (Nazi) ^ ^
10. 01:36:145 (4,1) - ^ ^

[Normal]

1. 01:38:526 (4) - Just make this a straight slider I disagree. The point for making this a curved slider is to improve the flow. No changes.

[Hard]

1. 00:24:002 (5,1) - Blanket is slightly off Looks good to me. No changes.
2. 00:29:479 (5,6) - Blanket is off I don't see how I can improve this. Sorry.
3. 00:32:574 (2,4) - I'm sorry but this is unrankable. 00:32:574 (2) - 's hitburst covers 00:33:764 (4) - repeat. Find a new pattern please. Vinyl pointed this out when we were mapping, so I guess it should really be changed . Done.
4. 00:37:812 (5,6) - Blanket is a bit off Nah :/
5. 01:29:479 (2) - Move this slider over so that it follows 01:29:002 (1) - Good catch. Moved slider.
6. 02:08:764 (4,5) - (Nazi) This blanket is slightly off Nah.

You could've added more screenshots on your mod since you pretty much just said about blankets, that way I could compare if my blankets were that off.
Regardless of that, thanks for modding!

.osz: http://puu.sh/6ZUT2.osz

Fluttershy03 wrote:

Easy

01:00:907 (4) - Maybe this could look more visually appealing? How so? Looks good for flow. No changes.

Overall, this map is really good This is only my 3rd mod so sorry if I didn't spot much.

Winek wrote:

[Easy]
00:25:193 (2,3) - Not sure to understand that snap difference, as it goes to x1.0 to x8.5? What do you mean? Spacing is consistent here. We're aiming for 0.84x to 0.86x, but mostly 0.85x.
01:03:764 (3) - I'm not sure about the flow here. What about making it curvier? Hmm, I agree, the flow was a bit weird here. Changed some stuff, thanks for pointing it out.

[Normal]
00:34:955 (5) - What about removing the reverse arrrow( simple 1/2 slider) , and making it start at 00:35:193. The actual is kind of weird, we don't really hear the music. Hmm, I disagree. I think it matches perfectly with the claps from the song. No changes.
02:09:717 (4) - This note feels weird somehow. It's certainly because it start on red tick.. Matches with previous patterns and the song itself (drum beats). No changes.

[Hard]
02:02:098 (6) - This note feels kind of weird. What about reducing it to 1/2 and add a circle after? I never really liked those 1/1 sliders starting on red ticks. Oh well, sorry about that xD. But I really think it fits with the song, so no changes.

Fluttershy03 wrote:

Hey there o/

Easy

01:00:907 (4) - Maybe this could look more visually appealing?

Normal

00:41:860 (4) - NC No.
00:53:764 (4) - Align this with the sliderend of 00:53:288 (3) - Changed the slider.
01:40:431 (1,2,3) - Improve flow and appearence here complete remap.

Hard

00:41:860 (4) - No NCNo.
00:53:288 (2) - NC^
01:47:574 (5) - NC ^
01:48:050 (1) - No NC ^

I don't like following vocals, even though vocals sound like they are in bg music.

Insane

01:09:717 (5) - NC Uhh.. alright.
01:10:193 (1) - No NC No, it just sounds... off.
01:28:288 (5,6) - Bad flow? Not really. I like it where it currently stands.
02:25:193 (3,4,5,6,7) - This star feels out of place with the rest of the map. Get rid of it or add more stars. Not changing, but might change the star to something else.


Overall, this map is really good This is only my 3rd mod so sorry if I didn't spot much.

Winek wrote:

Um Hello, Friendly mod here o3o

[Easy]

Feedbacks
I really love it, but what i dislike aree 1/2 sliders with reverse arrow placed like randomly. These should really focus on the music and vocals, like this one: 00:42:812 (4) or 02:12:336 (2) that are great.

These work great in bpm 140 or under in easies IMO

Suggestions

01:09:955 For this part, due to laarge sliders, They break clap combo alot. What about making them constant for that parts? I would really love to see claps at each 3/4. (3 White Ticks) Not sure what you mean... ATM I really love where the claps are.
01:40:431 (1) - You've made a pretty 2/1 slider, i really like it. But what about doing same on 01:42:336 (3,4) ? I think it would fits in better, really, whit a circle after it. Maybe.
01:52:812 (2) - I would prefer it as a simple 1/1 slider. Nah.
01:54:717 (4) - Here, same thing, it look kinda random, and i don't like hearing the note 3 times. ^
02:09:479 (5) - I don't understand, why didn't you put a clap? Emphasizing the vocals for the whisltes instead.
02:12:336 (2) - I LIKE this 1/2 reverse arrow. It really feels the (vocals).

[Normal]

Feedbacks
I like the difficulty, but why CS4? It's more fitted for Hard, or even Insane!? Anyway, it's your choice, but just playing this with Hard Rock get really hard. I kind of liked the difficulty, but i think you could mirror some note, to increase apperance. Like these 2: 00:31:860 (1,2) They could be more alike to make the map prettier, but that's our choice. CS4 works perfect on normals. Some CS5 and CS4 in my career.
00:53:288 (3) - Sincerely, I would prefer it as a simple circle. But go ahead of your choice. I guess.
01:08:764 (2) - Again, I'm not too sure about the whistle... Vocals.
01:13:764 (4) - The whistle here is weeird, especially on the reverse arrow, where it look total random.. Some vocal and background music here. Keeping it, but might remove it in the future.

[Hard]
Feedbacks
Not much to say. I appreciate the difficulty, again. I got some suggestion, if you will?
00:39:479 (1) - What about doing that! Btw the skin is ugly as hell, even hell is prettier. The egg is a reverse arrow. I prefer my slider better for a blanket.
00:42:812 (8) - I would really keep a constant sound for the whistle, i would add one on the downbeat, after the reverse arrow i guess
00:47:574 (2) - That's about the same suggestion as the first one. No because clap and I'm not a big fan of overriding hitsounds

[Insane]
Feedbacks
Pretty nice! (Even if i can't pass it!) What just bug me are the whistle, again. All the rest is completely fine.
00:40:431 (4,5,6) - Since here you overmapped added some 1/4 notes, why don't you do the same at 00:42:336 (3,4)? ( I think it's this one.) No.
00:45:193 (6) - Just my preference, but I would extend this to make a 1/1 slider, removing this one: 00:45:669 (1) . I don't really like this idea...
00:51:741 (2) - Sincerely, I don't really like that overmapped 1/4 note. It's not overmapped/It's not terrible, it's just difficulty because of 1.25x slider change to kiai.
00:55:193 (2,3,4) - There is a overmap 1/4 note here, why not do the same at00:57:336 (2) -? ^
01:10:431 (2) - Really me, I don't like it. What about a simple 1/2 slider? Nah.
01:51:145 (2,3,4) - This overmap 1/4 note feels kind of random. Removed

General Feedbacks
What I don't really enjoy are whistles. They are kind of placed "randomly", or eve if you followed something, they still look random. Though all of the beatmap is Really great! So good luck on ranking it, I'll give you a star.

CandyWind wrote:

LOVE THIS MAP
Get it ranked bro <3