MineC24 wrote:

M4M~

you make less than star rating 3.0 diff I'll think about it.

Basic

AR - 1 done

00:24:993 (1) - slider's end -> stack by 00:23:098 (2) (have thraw) done
01:14:256 (1,2) - same as 01:16:783 (1) no, then would be a bit boring (see next patterns)
01:33:835 (3) - same as 01:33:204 (2) (and rotate 180) done

Advanced

OD + 1 done

00:13:783 (2,3) - Distance set 1.1x done
00:47:414 (5) - Close up by 00:47:177 (4) no
00:52:467 (4,5) - Ctrl + G no, it can prevent flow
01:00:362 (1) - looks bad... changed pattern
01:02:888 (3) - NC done

Extreme

00:40:704 - add note no
01:02:888 (5) - NC done

GL Thanks for Your mod!

MineC24 wrote:

M4M~

TK'S Muzu

00:06:045 (21) - add finish
00:13:308 (49) - d
00:18:361 (65) - ^
00:45:046 (177) - ^
01:15:203 (274) - ^
01:20:256 (290) - ^

TK'S Oni

looks nice

GL

Lena wrote:

Hi.

Extreme
00:17:414 (1) - It's too Long jump. Like this? now it's better imo

SPOILER

00:26:730 (2,3,4,5) - ^ reduced spacing a bit
01:08:414 (4) - NC done
01:13:625 (4) - ^ done

Advanced
00:26:572 (5) - distance same.. so NC (Readable) done
01:10:940 (2) - Every slider must have a clear and visible path to follow from start to end. done

Easy
00:21:204 (3) - Like this done

SPOILER

01:12:993 (1) - ^ nope

SPOILER

nice map.. Sorry my poor mod
good luck!

Kanye West wrote:

fun map

1. 00:17:414 (1) - This is a quite big jump, it's a calm part and you could reduce the spacing.
2. 00:45:677 (3) - Why that red tick? Delete it and make the slider totally linear.
3. 01:03:362 (2) - Avoid the overlap by moving it 1 grid up

1. 00:12:835 (2) - I don't really like this shape just for making blankets cooler, avoid one blanket out of these two and choose a better shape.
2. 00:15:204 - Add a note here, you can clearly hear a sound.
3. 00:21:414 (2) - New combo should be here.
4. 00:26:256 (4,1) - Spacing is muuuch confusing here, and such ar doesn't help too.
5. 00:46:940 (3) - Stack (3) on 00:45:204 (1) - 's head for a better flow
6. 01:19:783 (2) - Ugly shape x_x

1. 00:19:309 (3) - This is kinda confusing, new player will click tail instead of head, try to rearrange that.

• 
  Nothing to say..

Leader wrote:

Hello, M4M

[Extreme]

1. 00:17:414 (1) - This is a quite big jump, it's a calm part and you could reduce the spacing. changed a little, this is circle-slider jump so it's comparatively easier. If there will be circle-circle jump, I would to reduce spacing.
2. 00:45:677 (3) - Why that red tick? Delete it and make the slider totally linear. done
3. 01:03:362 (2) - Avoid the overlap by moving it 1 grid up done

[Advanced]

1. 00:12:835 (2) - I don't really like this shape just for making blankets cooler, avoid one blanket out of these two and choose a better shape. changed pattern a bit, now it should better play
2. 00:15:204 - Add a note here, you can clearly hear a sound. done
3. 00:21:414 (2) - New combo should be here. now it's ok imo, it would look like NC spam
4. 00:26:256 (4,1) - Spacing is muuuch confusing here, and such ar doesn't help too. right, changed (1)'s position to stack with previous note, I hope that slowdown like this will be more readable; also changed AR to 8 to make other spacings less confusing.
5. 00:46:940 (3) - Stack (3) on 00:45:204 (1) - 's head for a better flow done
6. 01:19:783 (2) - Ugly shape x_x changed ;w; i don't know why, but like these

[Standard]

1. 00:19:309 (3) - This is kinda confusing, new player will click tail instead of head, try to rearrange that. done

[Basic]

• 
  Nothing to say..

Fun map, if I were you I'd map the part after kiai, but your choice, good luck! Hmm... nah, I don't want to make additional mess in beatmap Thanks!

• [Basic]
  HP Drain +1
  AR -1

1. 00:02:256 (2,2) - Bad overlap, you can replace 00:00:993 (1,2) - a bit
2. 00:11:098 (1) - This spinner is too short for beginners, they may not react in time and fail the combo. Maybe delete 00:09:835 (2) - and start the spinner here 00:09:835 - ?
3. 00:16:308 (2) - Delete this circle?
4. 00:28:782 (2,2) - Bad overlap
5. 00:46:466 (3) - Maybe smth like this to get a better flow?
   img

   
6. 00:50:256 - Maybe start the spinner here and end at the 00:52:150 - ?
7. 01:06:993 (1) - Maybe remove reverse and start at 01:07:308 (1) - ?
8. 01:18:361 (1) - Delete this circle?
9. 01:24:361 (6) - NC here, 01:23:414 (1) - remove NC
10. 01:40:466 (3) - Add reverse here and start spinner from 01:42:045 - to 01:43:940 -

• [Standard]
  HP Drain +2 or 3
  OD +1

1. 00:18:361 (3) - Too near from th HP bar
2. 00:24:993 (1,3) - Bad overlap
3. 00:33:835 (1) - Remove NC
4. 00:37:624 (5) - NC
5. 00:46:466 (1) - Remove NC
6. 00:54:045 (1) - ^
7. 01:06:835 (4) - Remove this circle
8. 01:15:519 (1) - Remove NC
9. 01:18:045 (1) - ^
10. 01:21:203 (1) - ^
11. 01:28:150 (1) - ^
12. 01:30:677 (1) - ^
13. 01:53:414 (1) - ^

• [Advanced]
  AR -3

1. 00:43:308 (3) - Ctrl+G

• [Hyper]
  HP Drain +1
  AR -2 or 3

1. 00:36:203 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Maybe you can make more spacing between them?

• [Extreme]
  HP Drain +1
  AR -2

AlexaBM wrote:

hi~ M4M from your queue

• [Basic]
  HP Drain +1 done
  AR -1 done

1. 00:02:256 (2,2) - Bad overlap, you can replace 00:00:993 (1,2) - a bit done
2. 00:11:098 (1) - This spinner is too short for beginners, they may not react in time and fail the combo. Maybe delete 00:09:835 (2) - and start the spinner here 00:09:835 - ? extend spinner (added reverse to previous slider)
3. 00:16:308 (2) - Delete this circle? i don't see any problem with this circle, but when other modders will have this problem, i'll try to remove it.
4. 00:28:782 (2,2) - Bad overlap done
5. 00:46:466 (3) - Maybe smth like this to get a better flow? done, but made slider more vertical
   img

   
6. 00:50:256 - Maybe start the spinner here and end at the 00:52:150 - ? done
7. 01:06:993 (1) - Maybe remove reverse and start at 01:07:308 (1) - ? done
8. 01:18:361 (1) - Delete this circle? not really... looks fine.
9. 01:24:361 (6) - NC here, 01:23:414 (1) - remove NC done
10. 01:40:466 (3) - Add reverse here and start spinner from 01:42:045 - to 01:43:940 - ok

• [Standard]
  HP Drain +2 or 3 it's fine imo
  OD +1 ^

1. 00:18:361 (3) - Too near from th HP bar now should be better
2. 00:24:993 (1,3) - Bad overlap done with changed shape
3. 00:33:835 (1) - Remove NC
4. 00:37:624 (5) - NC
5. 00:46:466 (1) - Remove NC
6. 00:54:045 (1) - ^
7. 01:06:835 (4) - Remove this circle done
8. 01:15:519 (1) - Remove NC
9. 01:18:045 (1) - ^
10. 01:21:203 (1) - ^
11. 01:28:150 (1) - ^
12. 01:30:677 (1) - ^
13. 01:53:414 (1) - ^ fixed most of NCs.

• [Advanced]
  AR -3 nonono, it would be too small, i consider changing AR to 7.

1. 00:43:308 (3) - Ctrl+G sure

• [Hyper]
  HP Drain +1 done
  AR -2 or 3 (see Advanced diff)

1. 00:36:203 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Maybe you can make more spacing between them? dunno, I'll wait for next suggestions.

• [Extreme]
  HP Drain +1 I don't know... don't like HP>=7, maybe I'll change it.
  AR -2 (see Advanced/Hyper diff)

That's all I can find, GL~

not94 wrote:

hey there^^ hi~
Im a new modder so don't be mad if I can't write so much about your map

Beginner:
00:22:427 - what does this timing point do here? dunno, just didn't removed unused timing points from Extreme diff done
00:22:466 - thats too loud turn down the volume a bit I think it's ok, I don't like loud hitsounds, but music at this point is really loud.
01:24:361 - ^ ^

standard
same as Beginner
00:22:466 - 00:32:571 - I think you should change the hitsounds from every 1/1 snap into every second 1/1 snap there's no reason to changing it, claps sounds fine imo
01:38:887 - suggestion: done, but a little different way (to prevent spacing problems)


advanced
same as beginner
except that i couldn't find anything bad

Extreme:
Still the same as beginner
and again! I didn't find anything bad

Hyper:
same reasons in beginner again.
(why did you needed that timing point thou)
really good diff again^^

VinylDash14 wrote:

Mod.

[Basic]

00:45:835 (2) - Can be confusing done

01:11:414 (2,3,4) - IMO this can be done a little better, structure of it just looks bleh IMO hmm... changed, now should be ok


[Standard]

Overall, the SV could be a tiiiiiny bit faster, but that's just me.

00:23:729 (1,2,3,4) - Hmm, you could add a neat pattern instead of just a straight line ok, moved circles a little.

01:05:098 (2) - NC done


[Advanced]

01:23:729 (3) - Don't put this ontop of the reverse arrow of 01:24:361 (1) - It's just so confusing sure, changed shape


[Hyper]

00:23:729 (1) - Remove NC no, these combos have similar length so why should i change it?

01:16:387 (4,5) - Move this to the left. And somewhat more easier it plays ok


[Extreme]

Nothing found

Can't mod taiko.

• [General]

1. Color Combo 4 and 3 is too dark imo. You can't see it clearly with that dark bg. Change it.
   
   [Basic]
   
2. Decrease tick rate to 1, Tick Rate 2 will easily kill beginners, especially those who can't follow sliders very well.
3. 00:08:571 (1) - Good flow tends to make player easier to understand where the next object will be. It'll be nice if you changed this to this slider :
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 00:10:466 (1) - The spinner placement is not that good. The clap voice in the song is not followed by any objects, which is kind of a bummer, maybe change it to this ?
   
5. 00:12:361 - 00:22:150 - this pattern is too confusing imo, maybe you can create something more simple than this or simply, just put a break section on it. Same thing happens on 01:14:256, as well.
6. 00:22:466 (1) and 00:27:519 (1) - both of this slider have clap on it's tail, this could be good if you make it repetitive and same with the song. But due to the pattern, this is hard to do. Don't use claps on this section
7. 00:42:045 (2) - this is confusing, most of beginner player is not used to this kind of slider, change it to a single circle
8. 00:47:729 (1) - extend the tail to 00:48:677 and put it near (2). you alreay done this kind of pattern before, so I think this is ok.
9. 01:00:361 (1,2) - Why don't you make it like 00:52:782 (1)? It's easier. You have to change the other pattern as well, though. Make it like this if you want to :
   
   SPOILER

   
   
10. 01:05:414 (1) - hitsound problem here. set the hitsound like 01:02:887 (1)
11. 01:07:940 (2,3,4)- Again, this is too confusing for beginners, change it to a slider.
12. 01:10:466 (1) - ^
    
    [Standard]
    
13. 00:09:203 (4,5,6) - This is too boring, especially for a Normal map. Add more objects.
    
14. 00:12:835 (1) - There's a big empty space next after this object, I suggest to repeat this slider.
15. 00:18:361 (3) - change this into a slider, put the tail on 00:18:993, same reason as above.
16. 01:05:414 (2) - hitsound problem here. set the hitsound like 01:02:887 (1)
17. 01:06:993 (3) - there's no sound on 01:06:993 that can be applied with any object. move the slider to 01:07:308 and don't repeat it.
18. 01:43:308 (1) - instead of drum-finish, use normal-finish as hitsound, feels much better imo.
    
    [Advanced]
    
19. there's a lot of object distances inconsistency here, change it.
20. 00:09:519 (3,4) - Don't stack, confusing
21. 01:05:414 (2) - same problem as other diff
    
    [Hyper & Extreme]
    
22. is the only difference on both of this map is AR? I think this is as hard as Extreme, and no, you don't need two super-difficult maps. It's ok if you want to keep it though, but the spreading looks bad.

nanda2009 wrote:

hi.

• [General]

1. Color Combo 4 and 3 is too dark imo. You can't see it clearly with that dark bg. Change it. changed a bit
   
   [Basic]
   
2. Decrease tick rate to 1, Tick Rate 2 will easily kill beginners, especially those who can't follow sliders very well.
3. 00:08:571 (1) - Good flow tends to make player easier to understand where the next object will be. It'll be nice if you changed this to this slider : looks nice, changed
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 00:10:466 (1) - The spinner placement is not that good. The clap voice in the song is not followed by any objects, which is kind of a bummer, maybe change it to this ? ok, remapped with next section
   
5. 00:12:361 - 00:22:150 - this pattern is too confusing imo, maybe you can create something more simple than this or simply, just put a break section on it. Same thing happens on 01:14:256, as well. You're right, these patterns look really "hard" for new players and it doesn't fit to low AR. Patterns simplified.
6. 00:22:466 (1) and 00:27:519 (1) - both of this slider have clap on it's tail, this could be good if you make it repetitive and same with the song. But due to the pattern, this is hard to do. Don't use claps on this section claps sounds better imo
7. 00:42:045 (2) - this is confusing, most of beginner player is not used to this kind of slider, change it to a single circle done
8. 00:47:729 (1) - extend the tail to 00:48:677 and put it near (2). you alreay done this kind of pattern before, so I think this is ok.dunno...
9. 01:00:361 (1,2) - Why don't you make it like 00:52:782 (1)? It's easier. You have to change the other pattern as well, though. Make it like this if you want to : I think it's ok,just tried to make this diff less repetitive. When next modders will have suggestions about this, I'll change it.
   
   SPOILER

   
   
10. 01:05:414 (1) - hitsound problem here. set the hitsound like 01:02:887 (1) done
11. 01:07:940 (2,3,4)- Again, this is too confusing for beginners, change it to a slider.i don't know ;p
12. 01:10:466 (1) - ^ no, there it's ok.
    
    [Standard]
    
13. 00:09:203 (4,5,6) - This is too boring, especially for a Normal map. Add more objects. I'll think about it, actually don't know about this pattern.
    
14. 00:12:835 (1) - There's a big empty space next after this object, I suggest to repeat this slider. sounds good
15. 00:18:361 (3) - change this into a slider, put the tail on 00:18:993, same reason as above. rather no, maybe it would be repetitive with previous suggestions.
16. 01:05:414 (2) - hitsound problem here. set the hitsound like 01:02:887 (1) done
17. 01:06:993 (3) - there's no sound on 01:06:993 that can be applied with any object. move the slider to 01:07:308 and don't repeat it. nice idea!
18. 01:43:308 (1) - instead of drum-finish, use normal-finish as hitsound, feels much better imo. done
    
    [Advanced]
    
19. there's a lot of object distances inconsistency here, change it.
20. 00:09:519 (3,4) - Don't stack, confusing done
21. 01:05:414 (2) - same problem as other diff done
    
    [Hyper & Extreme]
    
22. is the only difference on both of this map is AR? I think this is as hard as Extreme, and no, you don't need two super-difficult maps. It's ok if you want to keep it though, but the spreading looks bad. I see the difference between Hyper and Extreme diff. Extreme has longer and more spaced streams with hard jumps, hyper is just lite version of hardest diff. I was able to FC Hyper with HDHR while I have never FC'd harder diff. Originally, I didn't plan diff like Hyper, but the difficulty gap between Advanced / Extreme was too big. Also, keep in mind that Advanced before modding had AR8 and Hyper AR9. Hope You understand it~

Anyway, a really great mapset. I enjoyed playing it. GL.

For a 4 and a half star, this is pretty difficult. Who cares about star rating ?!~ ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

iNickel wrote:

[Generalnie]
Masz bardzo dobry design, ale radze ci poszukać hitsound moda, bo to jest twoja słabość :/ Hm, szczerze mówiąc, myślałem że hitsoundy które są w tej mapie są najlepsze jakie kiedykolwiek zrobiłem, raczej jedyne problemy jakie napotkali inni były z łatwymi poziomami pewnie dlatego, że hitsoundy manualnie dodałem tylko do Extreme, a do reszty skopiowałem ;w;

[Basic]

- Radze ci jeszcze raz sprawdzić flow, bo coś się nie wygodnie gra.
- Chyba ten diff jest zrobiony w twoim starym stylu mappingu, bo standard jest o wiele lepszy. (Moja opinia) Też tak mi się wydaje, po prostu nie jestem/byłem dobry w mapieniu łatwych poziomów :p Coś tam pozmieniałem, może będzie lepiej

[Standard]

Supcio! Perfekcyjny design i flow! wowwwww

[Advanced]

-Fajna mapa ale Flow niefajny Hmm, konkrety? Myślę, że to głównie przez to, że pierwotnie diff miał AR8 i po zmianie niektóre patterny wydają się słabiej czytelne.
Bardzo ciężko grać tę mapę przez to. Radze ci wszystko sprawdzić!

[Extreme]

Stack Leniency: 3 lub 2 A coś szczególnego to zmieni? :p

[Hyper]

HD - 5 ok
OD - 5 Myślę, że OD6 jest ok, głównie ze względu na rozkład OD na poziomach. 5 byłby za mało jak na poziom o trudności w okolicach Insane.
Stack Leniency: 3 lub 2 Patrz Extreme

To tyle. Nie znalazłem żadnych błędów ale dałem ci cenne rady. Jak nie chcesz to nie musisz dać Kudosu! Są sugestie jest kudosu!~ Dzięki ( ﾉ^ω^)ﾉﾟ

Powodzenia!

1. background image should be 1024x768 or 1366x768 at max.
   you could cut off the sides to avoid resizing. o:
2. I'd prefer lighter combo colours. you could use similar shades but just light ones, it'd still fit the background.

1. hmmh, you'd have to move all objects then, but maybe increase DS? to 1.2, I'd say.
   that way you avoid overlaps like 00:00:993 (1,2) and 00:06:045 (1,2) and a few more
   imo they decrease readability, which is important in easier diffs. .o.
2. 00:14:256 (2) - to have nicer movement here place 2 further down than 00:12:835 (1)'s end ( eg 284|324 )
   and bend 00:14:887 (1) in the other direction?
3. 00:18:361 (3) - Ctrl + G?
4. 00:26:887 (4) - place at 192|216 for better symmetry with 00:23:729 (2,1,2,3)?
   it looks so random otherwise. :c
   00:31:940 (4) - similar thing, place at 228|144?
5. 00:37:624 (1) - rotate by 45° (selection centre)?

1. AIMod points out some spacing mistakes, but since it's sooo buggy I won't check that
   (and leave the work to you.. :b you can check them if you want to.. xD)
2. why is the slider tick rate 2 here and 1 in the Basic diff? .o. I didn't look at the others yet, so Idk which is "correct"..
   but you should stick to one slider tick rate I think. o,o
3. 00:08:571 (1,2,3,4) - think of a pettern for them? they look randomly placed atm.
   imo it'd look better if you place them in a polygon pattern or something like that
4. 01:38:887 (4) - rotate by -45°?

Squirrel wrote:

Hellow, mod from queue ~ :3
It might not be helpful at all, though.. Idk. just some suggestions ~ x3

[General]

1. background image should be 1024x768 or 1366x768 at max.
   you could cut off the sides to avoid resizing. o: / I think current size is fine, Ranking Criteria doesn't say that BG must be 16:9 or 4:3.
2. I'd prefer lighter combo colours. you could use similar shades but just light ones, it'd still fit the background. / Now should be light enough Before modding these colors were almost black O_o

[Basic]

1. hmmh, you'd have to move all objects then, but maybe increase DS? to 1.2, I'd say.
   that way you avoid overlaps like 00:00:993 (1,2) and 00:06:045 (1,2) and a few more
   imo they decrease readability, which is important in easier diffs. .o. / Yeah, I have similar thoughts about it and now I'll remove overlaps (increased spacing as You suggested so some patterns was remapped, I used some of Your next suggestions)
2. 00:14:256 (2) - to have nicer movement here place 2 further down than 00:12:835 (1)'s end ( eg 284|324 )
   and bend 00:14:887 (1) in the other direction?
3. 00:18:361 (3) - Ctrl + G?
4. 00:26:887 (4) - place at 192|216 for better symmetry with 00:23:729 (2,1,2,3)?
   it looks so random otherwise. :c
   00:31:940 (4) - similar thing, place at 228|144?
5. 00:37:624 (1) - rotate by 45° (selection centre)?

[Standard]

1. AIMod points out some spacing mistakes, but since it's sooo buggy I won't check that
   (and leave the work to you.. :b you can check them if you want to.. xD) / ;w; most of "spacing errors" are small, single spacing changes like 0.85 which isn't bad rather :p
2. why is the slider tick rate 2 here and 1 in the Basic diff? .o. I didn't look at the others yet, so Idk which is "correct"..
   but you should stick to one slider tick rate I think. o,o / k
3. 00:08:571 (1,2,3,4) - think of a pettern for them? they look randomly placed atm.
   imo it'd look better if you place them in a polygon pattern or something like that / yeah, changed to square
4. 01:38:887 (4) - rotate by -45°? / why not?

and there is nothing I can say about Advanced, Hyper and Extreme.. I liked those diffs, nothing wrong with them. <3 / yeah :3

soo, good luck with this! (=
*squee*

DenoisoGoiso wrote:

awwwwwwwwwwwww
since 3 people mod taiko, i will mod this \:D/
From my #modreqs queue \:D/

[♪⁽⁽٩( ᐖ )۶⁾⁾ ₍₍٩( ᐛ )۶₎₎♪'s Muzu]

1. Any feedback/greetings and General
   
   
   • ♪⁽⁽٩( ᐖ )۶⁾⁾ ₍₍٩( ᐛ )۶₎₎♪' ~Good~ ♪⁽⁽٩( ᐖ )۶⁾⁾ ₍₍٩( ᐛ )۶₎₎♪'

1. Kats Suggestion
   
   
   • 00:29:571 (109) - Delete kat? unnecessary kat for pitch, yea, this is really unnecessary. so consider delete it~ - ugh. i dont think so. this part has stronk main-melody and cymbals.
     01:22:308 (296) - Add kat i don't have a brain lol - fixed.

1. Delete/Add Suggestion
   
   
   • ahh so clean

1. Other Suggestion
   
   
   • 00:04:571 (14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21) - This pattern pitch is so akward :O maybe swap (15,16)? Description? awww i don't have a more brains :OOOOO - kept.

nah
i don't have a more brain for mod oni :OOOOO
So, good luck~

MasterKirin wrote:

Mod from my queue

[Basic]
00:02:256 (2) CTRL+SHIFT+R and rotate it by -4 / done (better blanket)
01:15:203 (3) ^ / there's ok here, i don't want to increase spacing without important reasons
01:53:414 (3) CTRL+SHIFT+R and rotate it by 2 / done

[Standard]
00:57:835 (1) CTRL+SHIFT+R and rotate it by 2 / ok

[Advanced]
01:29:887 (3) Make it symmetrical like this http://puu.sh/6Si6b.jpg / you mean parallel?

[Hyper]
Nothing to say here

[Extreme]
Nothing to say here too.

Sorry for the poor mod and good luck!