I see Cookiezi is so good he got nominated two times \:D/Mustaash wrote:
me
no seriously, no particular order:
Cookiezi
White Wolf
5321_Kinoko
Rucker
Flute
SiLviA
SapphireGhost
Renard
KeigoClear
nobody mentionned me::(:(:(:(:(:(;:(:(:(:(:(:(:(
icwudtdlovan wrote:
I see Cookiezi is so good he got nominated two times \:D/Mustaash wrote:
me
no seriously, no particular order:
Cookiezi
White Wolf
5321_Kinoko
Rucker
Flute
SiLviA
SapphireGhost
Renard
KeigoClear
nobody mentionned me
i see Cookiezi has a new synonymdlovan wrote:
I see Cookiezi is so good he got nominated two times \:D/Mustaash wrote:
me
no seriously, no particular order:
Cookiezi
White Wolf
5321_Kinoko
Rucker
Flute
SiLviA
SapphireGhost
Renard
KeigoClear
nobody mentionned me
...Gotori wrote:
White Wolf
ShaggoN
AmaiHachimitsu
Niko-
SiLviA
CXu
Mesita
Rucker
fartownik
TTTL
No votes are retarded so long as they're serious. No matter how silly they sound from your own subjective point of view.Wishy22 wrote:
Yeah, ignore retarded votes, some stuff is clear and the top 4/5 can't really be topic of debate, the best 4/5 players are obvious and all you may do is change the other of the 2~5 ones.
No, really.kriers wrote:
No votes are retarded so long as they're serious. No matter how silly they sound from your own subjective point of view.Wishy22 wrote:
Yeah, ignore retarded votes, some stuff is clear and the top 4/5 can't really be topic of debate, the best 4/5 players are obvious and all you may do is change the other of the 2~5 ones.
This.Blue Dragon wrote:
Cookiezi
White Wolf
SilviA
Rucker
No, really.Gaba wrote:
No, really.
Putting this player: http://osu.ppy.sh/u/amaihachimitsu or any other common player in front of clearly top players is indeed retarded, that guy was simply voting for his country friends.
Wishy isn't being subjective, everyone knows who are top 5 even if you play the game for 1 month, what amazes me is old players that knows very well who they are and still vote like retards for their friends.
No matters, I am asking few things to users that vote; be objective is one of these, I am not saying "you must vote those players", But it's like someone voting Cyclone or Saturos as 2011 best player, this make no sense, at least I am asking to vote active players..kriers wrote:
No, really.
So long as players are given the right to vote for their players, no matter how retarded it must seem to you, it still is their right to do so. What's the point in voting if anything that wishy or you don't like will make it void?
Because there doesn't seem to be a good way to measure skill except for opinions, voting is inevitable.Salvage wrote:
It's not a bout that kriers, we're not trying to show we apply democracy here and that we're not some badass guys who want to manipulate the users votes, that doesn't even matter here .. we are voting to make an interesting top 20 video of osu players, top 1-5 it's clearly that way and it can't change, not because we're some anti democratic fascists or anything like that, but because the idea is the video to look as it should look, and i think u can't deny the 1-5 places are those.
Blue Dragon wrote:
1. Gaba
2. fabriciorby
3. myself
4. Caco
5. Asterio
6. Coy
7. Utena
8. Bianco
9. antsu
10. White Wolf
No, seriously?
now for full voting
1. Cookiezi
2. White Wolf
3. SilviA
4. Reisen
5. Rucker
6. Remilia-Scarlet
7. Flute
8. Niko-
9. KeigoClear
10. M A I D
kriers wrote:
I can't deny the 1-5 places, but if someone does, I can't deny their opinion either
With enough serious votes, ridiculous propositions won't make it among top10, anyway.Salvage wrote:
It can be analyzed and dropped in case of ridiculousness.
Salvage wrote:
We should seriously ignore those kind of votes.
Many players really think Shaggon is a top player nowadays, we all know he is really far away from being even into the top 20. It may be subjective but some people REALLY think some players are top players when they are, in reality, not even comparable.kriers wrote:
No votes are retarded so long as they're serious. No matter how silly they sound from your own subjective point of view.Wishy22 wrote:
Yeah, ignore retarded votes, some stuff is clear and the top 4/5 can't really be topic of debate, the best 4/5 players are obvious and all you may do is change the other of the 2~5 ones.
Then name this as "Most popular players" please. Only votes from people who show some kind of knowledge should be accepted, votes from some random guy who comes and shows he has no clue about who are the best players should be ignored. Democracy's weakness comes from the people voting since they may know nothing about what they are voting, the mere fact of doing this an "everyone can vote" thing is stupid, but at least just go and ignore some people for the sake of making a good top, don't let it be like last year's.kriers wrote:
Because there doesn't seem to be a good way to measure skill except for opinions, voting is inevitable.Salvage wrote:
It's not a bout that kriers, we're not trying to show we apply democracy here and that we're not some badass guys who want to manipulate the users votes, that doesn't even matter here .. we are voting to make an interesting top 20 video of osu players, top 1-5 it's clearly that way and it can't change, not because we're some anti democratic fascists or anything like that, but because the idea is the video to look as it should look, and i think u can't deny the 1-5 places are those.
With voting, you get all the negatives effects of it as well and some places might get swapped.
It's impossible to make the list look entirely right for everyone.
I can't deny the 1-5 places, but if someone does, I can't deny their opinion either
Stop with this, I am getting sick of you. I\we didn't decide to ignore any vote, I was just saying as someone (rightly wrote), do you think will be right see a player that did not play in the last year into the top 20? C'mon we all know that ShaggoN is a pro, okay, but he did not play the last year; well I am not going to ignore any vote, the discussion ends here, let people vote, learn to read and stop discussing.CXu wrote:
So if I voted Rucker as #1 in 2011, WW as #2, Silvia as #3 and Cookiezi as #4, you would just "lolfuckyou" and disregard my voting just because "hey it's obvious Cookiezi is #1 huehue"?
That's silly.
Don't pick on CXu, because he does have a point here. And yeah, let's stop discussing any further. At the same time, you should stop disrespecting votes from here on. Shaggon did play in 2011, so he can be counted in, wether you like it or not.lesslunatic wrote:
Stop with this, I am getting sick of you. I\we didn't decide to ignore any vote, I was just saying as someone (rightly wrote), do you think will be right see a player that did not play in the last year into the top 20? C'mon we all know that ShaggoN is a pro, okay, but he did not play the last year; well I am not going to ignore any vote, the discussion ends here, let people vote, learn to read and stop discussing.CXu wrote:
So if I voted Rucker as #1 in 2011, WW as #2, Silvia as #3 and Cookiezi as #4, you would just "lolfuckyou" and disregard my voting just because "hey it's obvious Cookiezi is #1 huehue"?
That's silly.
did I ? D:kriers wrote:
you should stop disrespecting votes from here on.
Any vote for Shaggon should count.lesslunatic wrote:
did I ? D:kriers wrote:
you should stop disrespecting votes from here on.
kriers wrote:
Any vote for Shaggon should count.
pointless discussion. lol; keep the subject of the topic, let's vote!lesslunatic wrote:
I didn't decide to ignore any vote
