forum

A question for OT

posted
Total Posts
9
Topic Starter
abraker
You are grading a student and you have a choice between giving a student an 'A' or a 'B'. However, there is a small chance that the student may commit suicide if you give a 'B'.

You mark the answers and the student deserves a 'B'. What grade do you give?
jaaakb
B, maybe a if it was likely to help them get over depression or whatever. I've no idea what helps people who want to kill themselves. If/when they find out their small good things are lies it might be worse.

I think i'm twisting the premise of question for being honest to be more morally acceptable.
Penguin
I don't believe this is a good hypothetical question. A person doesn't commit suicide because of a grade they score on a test. They would commit suicide because of the already existing mental condition that they have been and are currently experiencing.

Plus, if I knew that they were suicidal to begin with, wouldn't it be more effective long term if I try to actually help the person, instead of giving them an A thinking it will magically make them not suicidal anymore?
lol
if they tell you they are going to commit suicide you forget the test and get them help

i think
Comfy Slippers
Depends on if this said student is adamant or amenable to changes. This specific case is a poor touch on idealist vs pragmatist approach as it's relatively vague and somewhat irrational.
Naimae
if they've put a lot of effort in the class, then an A, or a B+ if that exists. but that would apply to all students, i think - getting a bit of a higher grade just because they put a lot of work in.

but if we're talking about someone who's depressed, then chances are that it doesn't come off like that since they'll be too lazy to do anything. maybe they won't even come to class. if we're in university, i can't really do anything i think since it's probably not as noticeable since i have so many other students and skipping classes is more normal.

if we're in high school, then i can contact his parents and ask what's up. if not i can ask them to see the school counselor or something. if something is seriously wrong, then i'll be easier on them, but i'm not going to do something before i know about what's going on. not that they have to be awfully specific, i'd just want to know if something is actually wrong or not. if i gave him a better grade at the first sign of depression, then others might start faking it just to get a bit of a better grade.
ColdTooth

lol wrote:

if they tell you they are going to commit suicide you forget the test and get them help

i think
Honestly, this, if I knew a student needed help, it's best to get help. Forget the test that they took.
johnmedina999
The grade he deserves is the grade he deserves. Giving the student a B is the only fair option.
Achromalia

lol wrote:

if they tell you they are going to commit suicide you forget the test and get them help

i think
this ^

I'd still give them a B though. Bumping grades for my benefit just because I'm almost failing wont do shit to me personally. The only thing it'll affect is my parents, which in turn yell at me, which would probably affect me. It's more of an indirect slitting of the neck, but still a decapitation nonetheless. I just wanted to help make this more accurate if I could.

Still, I'd help them out. If I notice something going on with them, I'd like to encourage them, and let them know that their grades say nothing about what I think of them as a fellow human being.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply