Nakagawa-Kanon wrote:

modreqs

[Easy]
00:25:413 (4) - I think this is hard for easy user You do have a point, and i was afraid of that when i mapped that, but it does follow the song, and i didnt completely stack it below, if you had a suggestion it would be nice
00:52:842 (4) - same Same as above
00:54:770 (4,5) - same New players should be able to see both approach circles fine imo
01:11:699 (2,3,4) - same ;; Last kiai times are the climax of the map, hence they are slightly harder.
01:20:270 (4) - ;; Guess what same as the first 2
-Pointless to reply to last 2 since they are copy/paste anyways-

[Hard]
00:44:270 (1,2,3,4) - a... when I played, I missed this pettern B-but you can see the circles the momment you're going down the slider ;_;
01:05:484 (7) - add new combo Please red my previous comments about adding combos mid pattern
01:24:342 (1) - it's so surprising. Guess i do have to remove it huh orz oh well will think of something to do about this later. Edit: Changed 1.5x slider!

Charles445 wrote:

[RB's Normal]
[list]
[*]Where is all the Kiai? It should have the same Kiai as the other difficulties. I didn't want a lot of kiais in mine :s
[*]01:38:270 - Map this break, this is the only difficulty that doesn't have notes here. Well I didn't plan on mapping here since it was after a spinner so I thought a break would be nice.
[*]01:55:092 (1) - It might be a good idea to have this spinner start at 01:55:199. Gives the player time to get ready to spin. I think this one is okay since the slider ends when spinner starts, although I could push the spinner back a bit if more people says so.

Love the ending! o/ Thanks! All suggestions were considered though.

Nakagawa-Kanon wrote:

[RB]
00:26:913 (3) - 1gird down 1grid left, and add clap second reverse. Err..Sure. Added hitsound too.
01:23:484 (3) - 1grid left Moved
01:34:627 (1) - 1grid right Moved

1. Remove countdown in all diffs as it doesn't have time to be displayed.

1. I find this to be quite difficult for an Easy, given the rhythms used (especially 3/4) and the difficulty settings. But that's more of a personal opinion. I only have one complaint about the diff though:
2. 01:10:627 (1,2,3,4,1) - This and 01:24:341 (1,2,3,4,1) - this: I think it's too hard for the diff. It's the only time you have used so many 1/2s in a row, and they are all circles,
   And a few suggestions:
3. 00:15:770 (1) - Add a finish on this slider's beginning ? It will make the hitsounds symmetrical (seeing 00:17:484 (3) - has a finish on its beginning too) and I think it fits the song. Same goes for 00:43:199 (1) - and 01:10:627 (1) - 01:24:341 (1) -
4. The comboing in the last kiai is different from the comboing in the rest of the diff. =(

• The only complaint I have about this diff are the kick sliders, which I commented on IRC.

• Same hitsound suggestion as for the Easy. Aside from that, nothing to point out.

• Seems fine.

• Okay, a 1/6 stream in the beginning, why not, it does fit. But this kat placement in that stream does not fit at all. - ,-

Hard:

In my Oppinion more crashes fit to this song like adding one at 01:16:199 (4) Crashes? care to explain?

Odaril wrote:

Wheeee I'm modding a Sakura Hana map !

Please reply to this mod saying what you didn't fix (and what you did) and why.

General

1. Remove countdown in all diffs as it doesn't have time to be displayed.

Sure thing

Easy

1. I find this to be quite difficult for an Easy, given the rhythms used (especially 3/4) and the difficulty settings. But that's more of a personal opinion. I only have one complaint about the diff though:
2. 01:10:627 (1,2,3,4,1) - This and 01:24:341 (1,2,3,4,1) - this: I think it's too hard for the diff. It's the only time you have used so many 1/2s in a row, and they are all circles, Well i know just saying "my style" would irritate you so im going to explain, after playing TnT games where kiai/gogo time is used normally i've felt like it gives it some sort of climax, also kiai is supposed to be the strongest part of both the song and the map so i decided on all or most of my maps since then to make the final kiai slightly harder in a way, you would probably notice that easily in most of my maps, plus new players shouldnt have trouble hitting a 3 note 1/2 stream (the stream isnt completely circles) imo.
   And a few suggestions:
3. 00:15:770 (1) - Add a finish on this slider's beginning ? tbh i dont think why it didnt have a finish at the beginning, added. It will make the hitsounds symmetrical (seeing 00:17:484 (3) - has a finish on its beginning too) and I think it fits the song. Same goes for 00:43:199 (1) - and 01:10:627 (1) - 01:24:341 (1) - Added finish to all 3 of those as well, thanks!
4. The comboing in the last kiai is different from the comboing in the rest of the diff. =(

Hard

• Same hitsound suggestion as for the Easy. Aside from that, nothing to point out.

Did that, aditionally added some other finishes to match up with some on [Easy] (inb4 too many Finishes)

bmin11 wrote:

[Hard]
00:14:484 (1,2,3) - I couldn't hear any pace change for the song. I discourge anti-jumps unless there is a slow down of the song as the technique itself isn't really attractive.
00:41:913 (1,2,3) - ^ But i like how anti-jumps feel in these spots :<
00:44:270 (1,2,3,4) - Hopefully you can rank this before the new ranking criteria submitts. I guess? XD they can be seen fine even on Hidden because of lighting.png tho
01:05:484 (7) - New Combo But that's in the middle of a pattern D: doesnt make sense to me to put a new combo there
01:15:342 (2,4) - (Nazi) one grid to left so it forms a symmetry. Ignorable obviously Oh! thanks for pointing that out
01:36:556 (6) - New Combo? I guess, will change for now

[Easy]
00:03:770 (1,2,1) - Not so encourged for [Easy]. Kind of a complex beat as player have to concentrate on the reverse arrow, relief from slider and press it right away. My friends often find it challenging. Hmm will see what other people think about it
00:11:484 (3,1) - Same, but easier. ^
00:38:056 (1,2,1) - ^^ ^
01:11:699 (2,3,4,1) - I don't encourge a group of 1/2 notes for [Easy]. Lets leave the fun of 1/2 for [Normal]s Kiai is kind of climax for me so i often increase the difficulty a bit on the last kiai.
01:25:413 (2,3,4,1) - ^ ^
01:39:770 (1,2,1) - ^^^ ^^^

That's all for me. Nice even difficulty set

Sakura Hana wrote:

01:05:484 (7) - New Combo But that's in the middle of a pattern D: doesnt make sense to me to put a new combo there

SapphireGhost wrote:

Hi hi, this marks my first official mod as a MAT! Lucky you! \o/

[General]
- First of all, the BG isn't 4:3, and that makes me sad. I made a 1024 x 768 version you could use, though. The centering is a bit different (I tried to center it, but the stupid glowy thing at the bottom kept getting messed up) but at least you have the right dimensions. Sure, will change it after i finish with the mod

:)

[attachment=0:3e7fc]BG.jpg[/attachment:3e7fc]

- Are you sure "MMORPG" is a necessary tag? It's alright, but I don't think people will search for it. Well it's not like an extra tag will hurt anyone, specially such an uncommon one

[Hard]
- About the end-of-break drags in this difficulty and in [Easy], perhaps it would be better to drag them to the nearest big white tick instead of the current tick. Maybe ask the guest mappers if they'd like to do the same. Fixed!
00:25:842 (1,2,3,4,5) - Patterns like this look lovelier if you can avoid overlap. Changed a bit
00:43:199 (1,1,2,3,4) - I can't help but feel that this section is a little messier than it needs to be. The slider is covering some Some what? o.o but i like this pattern :< i think it's kinda cool to see the approach circles appear behind you when you're running down the slider
00:53:270 (1,2,3,4,5) - Same thing as before. Fixed as well
00:55:413 (1) - I couldn't hear the end of this spinner, or that might just be temporary deafness. I think a normal finish would work well here, as a suggestion. Oh wow, thanks for pointing that out, indeed that was not intentional
01:05:270 (6,7,8,9,10,11) - I think I said this before, but this pattern really would look better without the small overlaps. It's okay to go off distance spacing for a little when the change is that small. 1/2 grid fix go! o/
01:20:699 (1,2,3,4) - Here's another place with small overlaps that could look better non-overlapping. blissfulyoshi doesn't like small overlaps, so think of him. In this case i gotta reject it, because the whole point is all slider ends being aligned.
01:42:556 (6,7,8) - I don't particularly like how this pattern doubles back on itself, it feels a bit less natural than the other patterns. Perhaps you could sort of rearrange the whole combo into a different shape, still with symmetry, but that doesn't cross over itself. Well I can't think of anything that wouldnt mess up the star shape start, you got any ideas?
01:46:413 (8,9) - Small overlap here. Fixed
01:48:770 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Seeing how this bit is building up to the ending of the song with the decrescendo and whatnot, perhaps it would be better to add a more creative pattern than just these 1/1s. I thought the jumps were good enough, besides i dont want to make it too Inanish :<

[Easy]
- It might be a good idea to lower HP Drain/Approach Rate/Overall Difficulty by 1, it's a touch too high at the moment. IO lowered HP and OD, but AR feels better to me that way, mostly because it shows the speed at which you'll move during sliders.
- [Easy] difficulties where the spacing is this low sort of bother me because it's not as fun in my opinion, and harder to map 1/2s without either overlapping or breaking the Distance Snap. I don't find the super low spacing very fun, either. Perhaps you could be more Larto-like in future Easies. I'll take that in mind, thanks for the advice
00:36:342 (1,2,3,4,1) - I believe this pattern would be better if the notes didn't overlap and also if the (3,4,1) spacing was more consistent than it currently is. Fixed
01:07:199 (1) - You were using lots of curved sliders, so the linear slider felt rather out of place here. It'd be nice if you could make a smooth curve out of it. You're right, i was going for something different at the time, but ended up not being able to use it in the end and forgot to make this slider a curve, thanks! Fixed
01:10:627 (1,2,3,4,1) - The many 1/2s in a row here might be asking a bit much for an Easy player, I'd love it if this pattern were simplified. They are the climax part of the song/map
01:24:341 (1,2,3,4,1) - Same thing as above. ^
01:48:770 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I'd love it if this pattern was rotationally symmetrical somehow. Is it better now?

That's it. The objective rankability stuff here all seems to check out, so when you've checked all the things I've pointed out please send me a Forum PM and I'll re-check this as soon as possible. For now you can have the star icon, good luck with ranking!

OzzyOzrock wrote:

doiukotonano

Zelos wrote:

Easy:
00:17:484 (3,1) - maybe maybe stack the ending of slider 3 and beginning of slider 1 directly on top since they are pretty close already? X You should have seen how kris crosses are usually mapped by now :<
01:10:627 (1,2,3,4,1) - this is just purely my opinion right here but I think this might be a bit much for easy players. X Read what i've replied probably 100 times in this thread to other modders, but here it goes again, it's the climax of the map, it's supposed to be harder than the rest
01:24:341 (1,2,3,4,1) - the exact same situation as above. ^


Hard:
00:25:842 (1,2,3,4,5) - your staircase pattern here is inconsistent. this is easily fixable by moving 3,4,5 to the left 1 grid point. X Uhh problem is that if i move them more to the right, they overlap again, considering this is distance snapped
00:25:842 (1,2) - im not a big fan of note3 (its the only one that is hidden by the path itself) incoming directly behind slider 1. i suppose its not unrankable to have hidden notes like that but maybe change it? X By the time the slider has started to appear the hitburst is already gone, check in testplay and you'll see
01:22:413 (1,2,3,4) - this square slider jump is so un-equal. i really suggest you make slider pairs 1,3 and 2,4 equidistant from the center. it would look a lot better if you did. X Huh? i see they are all by the same ammount of grids from the center?

Like I said, only suggestions. (sapphireghost will probably eat me wont he ;_;)

Star!

Zelos wrote:

RB's Normal:
(only a suggestion) 00:05:056 (4,2) - perhaps make note 4 and slider end 2 stack? it would look a tiny bit neater? I suppose you could do this by moving (1,2,3,4) to the right 1 grid point if you wanted to.

kanpakyin wrote:

Congrats Sakura!

oh...the beginning of the Taiko diff is X_X

Natteke wrote:

And you were among the people who supports the "Hitcircles must never be hidden under slidertracks"???
I don't get this D:

OzzyOzrock wrote:

1/4 for 1/6, sounds good yeah ok logical

OnosakiHito wrote:

You still don't know some things about Taiko mapping.