Sakura Hana wrote:

[Skin]
Fun fact, you need to make that spinner circle less transparent (more opaque) because it's barely visible Increased to 75% opacity, should be a lot more noticeable now
http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/131364 Hey it's a pink note!
http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/131366 Hey it's a pink approach circle! there must be a note behind the hitb-- OH F ITS A SPINNE- damn missed ;_;

[General]
Two of your diffs are missing the 2nd offset red line, more specifically your guest ones
Actually i dont think you need the 2nd red line due to v
I dont think this is a 3/4 timing signature song. k, removed
Combo color 3 and 4 are very similar i recommend you swap your colors around by editing the .osu file. Switched combo color 2 and 3
Kiai should start here: 01:04:797 - Since the previous kiai section is the build up to the chorus, so it makes no sense to start kiai earlier (hoLysoup got it right \o/) Changed for my diffs and hinacle

[Insane]
01:01:197 (1,2,1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - I seriously disagree with this, is it even following the song? o.o in either case it's a bit too much. The song + video suddenly get faster here and i wanted to represent that with the stream and also to lead in to the kiai time. It's not really following the vocal properly so, changed so that it does.
You spam claps for a large portion of the map, i recommend you go with claps on 2 and 4 instead. Reduced clap for 01:23:997 - 01:40:497. Don't think i used clap anywhere else except for the part at the beginning.
01:50:397 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,1) - I disagree with this too sorry ._. for the same reasons as the other one. Meh, i give up mapping this part. Replaced with spinner.

[Easy]
Ehh, dont use slider speed changes on the easiest diff, that's about it. Fixed, but use 0.8x distant snapping rather than 1.0x snapping instead. 1.0x snapping spaced out the sliders a bit too much.

Also i dont know why but that video is lagging a lot (even tho i got a strong computer) i recommend you re-encode it or something, Good Luck!~ Will try reencoding, but i don't know why it is lagging in the first place through. I used x264 to encode the video.

Astom wrote:

o/
Uhm some suggestions

[General]
-Start kiai in 01:04:797 like holy's diff Fixed in Sakura Hana's mod.

[Insane]
-00:04:797 (2) - finish at start instead of whistle. (with reduction of volume) k, 40% volume
-00:07:197 (1) - finish (with reduction of volume) ^
-00:09:522 (1) - -^ ^
-00:35:397 (1,2,3,4) - finish instead of clap in (3) and delete (4) ? (also fix their position) Done, changed 3 to slider
-00:44:997 (1,2,3,4) - -^ ^
-00:40:497 (5) - finish at end Done
-00:50:397 (1) - finish instead of whistle at start Done
-01:04:797 (1) - finish at start Done
-01:14:397 (1) - -^ ^
-01:28:797 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - I don't think than that circles and claps suit music at all, I think than something like hinacle's diff suits better. Imo, it fit well with how she is singing and since this is an Insane, i want to follow how she is singing as accurately as possible.
-01:38:697 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - -^ ^
-01:38:397 (7) - finish instead of clap clap feel better with current pattern

KayeSara wrote:

As your mod4mod on my queue~
Time for modding~All of them just a suggestion.
[General]
Nothing


[Easy]

1. All of my spinner suggestion is what the mat think, even I do nt think so. That's bloody ignorable issue.
2. 00:28:797 (1) - spin is too hard for easy that appear fastly. Remove it from 00:28:947 to 00:31:197. This should be fine, auto can get 12k point and i can clear this even if i spin at 150-200 spins per minute.
3. 00:59:997 (3) - Remove it, it does't fit the rhythm just in my opinion. Add a reverse slider, from 00:59:997 to 01:00:597 (01:00:297 should be the reverse time Done, adjusted spinner
4. 01:00:897 - Add a note Made spinner start here instead
5. 01:01:197 (1) - As I said before, too fast, then make it from 01:01:347 to 01:02:997 ^, already made spinner longer
6. 01:21:897 (1) - ^ Since all spinner suggestion is because of what mat thinks... I will just say, mat already checked this and no complaints about the spinner.
7. 01:40:797 (1) - ^ ^
8. 01:45:597 (1) - ^ ^
   That's all~

[Insane]

1. 00:50:397 (1) - if make slider velocity 0.5X maybe better? (Same as 00:51:597 (1) and 00:52:797 (1) ) 0.5x is too much, 0.75x works better
2. 01:09:147 (1,2) - Making a slider instead of it or you can overlap those notes...just feel beeter becasuse too much 1/6 beat snap divisor is hard to catch the rhythm. This is an Insane, i want to follow the vocal as closely as possible and i like it this way.
3. 01:09:747 (1,2) - ^ ^
4. 01:40:797 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - A little slow... add note in the middle of them? Death stream doesn't really fit this part, i just want to follow the piano here.
   Again, all of it are just suggestion, just keep your own mind

Good Luck~

pieguy1372 wrote:

Easy:

00:09:597 (1,2) - Should be 1/3 later...also, remove the whistle from the body of (1)? This is snapped to 1/4 and is on the blue tick. Should be correct. K, removed whistle.
00:26:297 (4) - New combo? One combo for this part is fine i think

Insane:

00:09:522 (1,2,3) - These should be 1/3 later Snapped to 1/4 on blue tick. Should be correct.
00:31:697 (1) - Should be 1/6 later Already tested this at 0.25x playback, the place it is at right now is correct.
00:32:547 (5) - ^ ^ 0.25x playback, the place it is at right now seems correct.
00:38:997 (6) - Should end 1/6 later Don't see a problem with it ending at 1/3 snap
00:41:247 (1) - Should be 1/6 later Should be fine
00:41:597 (3) - Should end 1/6 earlier I feel slider is too short is it end 1/6 earlier
00:42:147 (5) - Should be 1/6 later Seems right to me
00:42:297 (6) - Should end 1/6 later Same as 01:41:597
00:49:097 (7) - Perhaps end this 1/3 later? Want to keep 1 tick between the notes at 1/3 snap
01:01:797 (3,4) - Space these farther out? I keep thinking these are 1/2s K. 0.9x spacing (1.0x feels too much)
01:10:697 (3) - End it 1/3 earlier? Follows vocal better like this
01:11:547 (2) - Move it 1/6 later Seems fine
01:13:147 (3) - End it 1/3 later? ^
01:17:897 (4) - End it 1/3 earlier? Follows vocal better
01:19:097 (3) - End it 1/6 earlier ^
01:19:697 (3) - ^ ^
01:20:297 (3) - ^ Doesn't really follow vocal properly, but will be weird to make this one longer than the rest
01:26:397 (4) - New combo? (If you do, please remove the NC from 01:27:297 (1) and add one on 01:27:597 (2)) This part is following a combo pattern, so no change.
No change in beat position and slider length since i think they are all fine

Nice map~

loveFantasy wrote:

hi~

[General]

1. about the break, i suggest you start it at 00:11:997 in all diff (don't adjust anything in Insane), and don't manually change it's ending time (it plays ok though.) Seems like only Easy has a manually changed ending time, fixed. Changed when Hinacle's break time begins so that it's the same as other diffs.

[Easy]

1. 00:09:522 (1) - remove whistle on slider body, it's too noisy Done
2. 00:26:297 (4) - this worth a new combo Hm, since someone before has also suggested this, i will change it.
3. 01:00:897 (1) - start it at 01:01:197 A bit worry about spinner length, but i guess it's fine.
4. 01:23:097 (T) - don't end a KIAI section during a spinner Changed to be the same as hoLysoup's Normal

[Insane]

1. 01:02:197 (1) - sync bad with music, i suggest just use circle and slider to map the vocal K, I think it's fine she sings just "Ne~" for this part.
2. 01:10:697 (3) - some will say end it at 01:11:197, but i really think end this at 01:11:247 provide better flow..because this is a long slider and the later combo are in 1/2 This was intentionally done so that you have time to hit (1) in the next combo. For some reason i kept hitting (1) too late when the slider is put here or get a 100 on slider.

kevin840310 wrote:

As your request on my queue
General Speaking:
nothing

Insane:
remove the slider in 1:56:397 It's fine, i want to follow the drums at the end.

Easy:
I have seen it. No problem I found.

JoJo wrote:

Hi hi ~ My mod here
Take from KPY and JoJo's queue ~ ><

Red-You must fix it.
Blue-You'd better to fix it.
Black-Suggestion only.

[General]

• ●'spinner-background.png' should be 1023*692 and currently is 1024*692 ~ >< Fixed
  ●Well..The comboburst images you're using is not cut perfectly in the right.
  I suggest you to remake them @.@ (comboburst-3.png is Okay) I can prob fix comboburst-0 (erase the stick a bit), but the rest idk. I'll let holysoup look at it.
  ●Please unify the Stack Leniency in all diffs ~! From my understanding, it doesn't need to be consistent as, while Hard/Insane may need higher stack leniency (so that stack look better in game). Easy and Normal doesn't. Will change my Easy if holysoup change through.

[Insane]

• 00:32:297 (4) - Could be stack better. Should be fixed now
  01:50:397 (1) - Unify the end point of this like other diffs do. End it at 01:54:672 ~ Done

[Easy]

• 01:43:097 (1) - Too close to the spinner imo. I think it's fine there is two~ white tick or so before this note and again, you can always stop spinning earlier (one of the first thing i learn when i start playing osu).

Well.. @.@ Don't like nazi so that's all ><
Nice map ~ Star'd ~

wmfchris wrote:

[Insane]
Maybe whistle is too frequently used? There's some section that Chata sang in a lower melody, then putting a whistle which is a high tone excessively sounds weird. Ah you're right, for some reason i had a strange idea of putting whistle every time she sings. Reduced for the part after the break, the rest seems fine i think. Tell me if not..
00:04:797 (2) - There's a vocal 1/6 eariler who is lourder than the echo at 00:04:797, so I think you may start slider 1/6 eariler. This is an insane and maybe you should fix this :3 I find it weird to do this mainly because i want to keep consistency with previous section. You're right that it is 1/6 earlier through (or 1/8 since we're snapping in 1/4 here).
00:11:097 (x) - maybe start this right after (3), or on the vocal "four!" that maybe too short x_x Guess i'll change to the blue tick right after (3).
00:24:797 (2) - whistle? Done
00:28:397 (2) - ^ ^
- I'm not sure about that, but some note+slider 4-plets sounds odd to me orz Feel fine to me, but up for suggestions.
00:43:997 (4) - remove whistle Done
01:49:197 (7) - use a slow slider (remember to NC) and mute the ending? This part doesn't seem like it slow down. It just suddenly end and the gap is to represent that. So no. Don't think it need to be mute as this part is quite loud.
01:54:597 (s) - end the spinner at similar time of other diffs Fixed in earlier mod
01:56:397 (1) - remove so that it ends like other diffs, this sounds well already when one finishes the map. Want to keep this, will remove if someone has a very good reason for me to do so. This part is nagging me to map it in Insane .

you may need more efforts on arranging notes, but it seems technically well : D

[Easy]
ok.

starrrrrrrrr D:

Index-San wrote:

hello...

general:
easy kiai time ends at 1:23:997
holysoup kiai ends at 1:23:997
hinacle and insane ends at 1:23:097

maybe make them ends same for all diff? I think it's fine, Easy & Normal have a spinner for this part while Hard & Insane map this part out. But if this is unrankable i will change.

easy:
01:20:997 (4) - make the slider start at 01:20:697 end at 01:21:597 I want to put the slider on the strong beat and i think here is where the strong beat is. 01:20:697 feel like a weak note to me due to volume.

insane:
01:20:697 (1) - i thought i missed this note when i play this map because of the volume xD Opps forgot to put another timing section here. Fixed (90% voluime)

star because it has unique 1/3 and 1/6's xD lol

backstep wrote:

Here this is my mod :3

[Easy]
00:07:197 (1) remove whistle. Done
00:23:997 (3) 1 grid left ? (lv4 grid) ^
00:36:597 (1) 1 grid right and 1 grid up ? (lv4 grid) ^
00:38:997 (3) 1 grid left ? (lv4 grid) ^
00:39:597 (4) 1 grid right and 1 grid up ? (lv4 grid) ^
00:46:797 (1) 2 grid up ? (lv4 grid) ^
00:52:797 (3-4) 2 grid up ? (lv4 grid) ^
00:59:997 (3) 1 grid right (lv4 grid) ^
01:07:197 (4) 1 grid down ? (lv4 grid) ^
01:16:797 (5) 1 grid right (lv4 grid) ^
01:25:797 (3) 1 grid up ? (lv4 grid) ^
01:35:397 (3) 1 grid down ? (lv4 grid) ^

[Insane]
01:48:197 (2) x=104, y=144 Done
01:48:397 (3) x=40, y=232 ^
01:48:597 (4) x=104, y=320 ^
01:49:197 (7) 1 grid up ? (lv3 grid) ^
Quite helpful suggestion for Insane ^^

Good Luck!

Kiddo-Kun wrote:

[Insane]
00:10:872 (1) - This spinner starts too early. Actually, I recommend removing this spinner and adding in something else. I want to keep this, and the only other thing i can add other than a spinner is a circle. So i think it's fine like this. Also from my understanding, spinner can start at any tick as long as it's after the note, but changed to 1/4 snapping for this part.
01:56:397 (1) - Perhaps remove the repeat. Sounds much better this way. I think ii's fine.

That's all I have to say.

ikari_kyon wrote:

chata <3
first mod from kei&kyon's queue
3rd mod that I made >_<

Insane

00:07:047 (x) - Add a note? No, because i want the slider to be the last note of the combo, also want to leave a space for a sort of jump.
00:13:197 (B) - I think break should star here I think it's fine, don't think i will change the break time anymore unless there is something unrankable about it.
00:32:297 (4) - delete this note and extend previous slider to here? i think this is too easy for Insane and doesn't follow vocal as well
00:32:997 (7) - ^ ^
00:36:897 (4) - delete and replace (3) with a slider that end on 00:36:997 ? Having a gap there play better. I think (3,4) is fine as it is.
00:39:297 (7) - delete and exteend previous slider to here? I use slider when ever she hold a note. Since she sing a note here i put a circle.
00:41:397 (2) - move a tick previous I'm sure it is correct like this (test in 0.25x playback)
00:41:897 (4) - delete and exteend previous slider to here? She sing a note here so i represent it with a circle
01:02:172 (x) - add a slider like (2) or 2 notes like (3,4), then move the spinner to 01:02:447 and finish spinner on 01:03:447 or delete the spinner >_< I want a spinner here to show that the music suddenly get faster. Also, the spinner is a good way to end a section since i can map the next part anyway i want. Didn't change (3,4) to slider as again, she sings note there and not hold it.
01:05:997 (3) - add finish No
01:07:197 (1) - ^ Don't think it fits
01:08:297 (6) - ^ ^
01:09:297 (2) - stack with (1) ? It play well like this
01:09:897 (2) - ^ ^
01:10:697 (3) - add finish? Feel like a finish spam.
01:13:147 (3) - move a tick previous and exteend to original finish? Ty, 1 tick backward in 1/6. Feel a lot better now.
01:15:597 (3) - add finish No
01:16:797 (1) - add finish Don't want to spam too much finish
01:19:097 (3) - replace with a circle? Don't see a problem with this being a slider
01:19:697 (3) - ^ ^
01:21:097 (3) - delete Done, minor remap so that it's feel better
01:21:997 (1) - remove new combo and put new combo on the next circle? I put new combo here because she start singing here
01:26:297 (x) - add a note No to all, i think the note is already correct as it is.
01:27:497 (x) - ^
01:27:797 (x) - ^
01:28:097 (x) - ^
01:28:797 (1) - move to 01:28:697 Keeping it the same since all note were on white ticks
01:28:997 (x) - add a note No
01:29:397 (4) - move to 01:29:297 looks fine
01:29:597 (x) - add a note ^
01:29:997 (6) - delete Hm want to keep it so that it's interesting
01:30:797 (9) - delete ^ boring for them all to be 1 tick circle
01:35:897 (x) - add a note no
01:45:597 (1,2,3~ the rest) - use a high spacing Spacing is fine imo.

Easy

00:13:197 (B) - I think break should star here Keeping consistency with other diffs (the break all start at 00:12:597) .
00:57:297 (3) - add clap? There is already clap on the next slider
00:57:597 (1) - remove all claps from here? I think it's fine, hitsound feel empty without claps here.
00:59:097 (2) - add clap? No change since i didn't remove clap from previous suggestion
01:00:897 (4) - add note? I left this gap here so beginner know a spinner is coming
01:01:197 (S) - remove finish Done
01:07:797 (4) - remove clap Done
01:11:397 (1) - remove finish Done, replaced with whistle
01:14:097 (2) - remove clap Done
01:17:397 (5) - ^ ^
01:45:597 (S~) - 2 consecutive and looooong spinners Don't really think anything else fit, since it'll probably be too hard for beginners to play. And it last about 8 seconds, i agree this is long, but no one is forcing you to spin the whole 8 seconds.


That is all >_< Im newbie at modding, but I hope to be helpful Not bad for your 3rd mod, some helpful suggestion ^^

Muya wrote:

- Easy:
00:09:597 - Please vocal's "one two three four"　do not matching. timing is bad orz Timing is correct, please check in editor at 0.25x playback
00:12:597 - why break time start here? I think unnecessary Doesn't really make a different game play wise
00:56:997 (3) - add clap to 2nd note? Doesn't fit

- Insane:
00:09:597 - Please vocal's "one two three four"　do not matching. timing is bad orz Same as Easy, timing is correct
00:12:597 - why break time start here? I think unnecessary Same as easy, doesn't make a difference
01:49:197 (7) - change to circle? Slider work better


so many spinner maps orz
I want to reduce Spinner are fun

Mok wrote:

Heya

[Holysoup]
BSD: 1/6. It's 1/4 at the beginning, the rest is 1/3 or 1/6 through.

Pretty okay :3

Megurine Luka wrote:

Hi. Mod as requested
Sorry for being late.

[General]
Make spinner-background.png into black and white I don't think so, the default spinner isn't black and white and when i see a spinner, i know i have to spin.
It will confuse players when they spin.

[Easy]

AR-1~2 -1 ar
OD-1 -1 od

[Hard]&[Insane]

Nothing I can suggest

Very good map. Even though timing section really confuse me a lot. Can you tell me what you find confusing about the timing section?
If you do not make any change, plz do not give me KD.
Good job and Good luck Ty