Suzully wrote:

According to current draft of the rules,

[*]Hitsounds from hitcircles and sliders must be audible. These provide feedback for the player, and having them silent in a rhythm game doesn't make much sense. If you don't like the default sounds, then find replacements rather than silencing notes. You can use hitsounds from the Custom Hitsound Library or easily find others online. Lowering the volume of a few notes to provide a dampened effect is usually fine, but complete silence is always unacceptable. The end of a spinner (or even the entire spinner) the sliding sound of a slider, and the end of a slider can be silent, but only do it if it makes sense. Finally, you cannot silence both slider ticks and slider slides together.

It's not complete silence.
Also it provides a dampened effect? No, it's the last note, and it's a part of end of slider.
I think it's fine

EDIT:Wow Raging Bull ninja'd o.o

DoKoLP wrote:

• [Kit's Normal]

1. 00:40:926 (3) - Clap on sliderreverse
2. 00:43:563 (2) - ^
3. 00:54:113 (2) - Clap on sliderend
4. 01:56:091 (2) - ^
5. 02:54:442 (1) -
6. 03:24:772 (2) - Clap
7. 03:31:695 (3) - Clap on sliderend
8. 03:45:212 (5) - Clap
   
   Sometimes you did make 3 claps in a row and sometimes you didn't make it, so the rhythm (claps) goes kinda unevenly.
   
   [Suzully's Hard]
9. 03:03:179 (4) - Silderend is silenced > unrankable (Yes, volume 10% is unrankable, if it's not while spinning)
   
   
   [Insane]
10. 00:49:992 (1) - Remove new combo and replace it here (00:49:827 (6)) or here (00:50:157 (2))
11. 03:03:179 (3) - Sliderend is silenced > unrankable (same as above [Suzully's Hard])
    
    
    [TL's Taiko]
    [General]
12. Lead-In-Time?! Why? Remove it D: It's needless.oops,easy miss;; Fixed
    
    I don't know much about Taiko, so i can't mod this diff^^'

Those silent sliderends and needless Lead-In-Time have to be changed, imo.
Other things are only suggestions.

Colin Hou wrote:

no problem

Garven wrote:

[General]
MP3 quality sounds really bad. Can you try and find a better one?
Actually, I made a new one for you and sent it via chat, so get things re-timed. :3 mp3 changed!thanks Garven

[All osu difficulties]
01:00:706 - Extend the start of break to here fixed~

02:15:871 - ^fixed~


[Kit]
Tick rate 2 fits better~fixed~

Garven wrote:

[Suzu]
00:15:212 (1,2) - Spacing. It might be better if you did something like this: Good formation! Fixed!

SPOILER

00:26:915 (2) - Move one grid up so that the circles aren't overlapping in the slider. Fixed.
00:45:377 (2,3) - That spacing intentional? Kinda deceiving... Changed pattern~

aabc271 wrote:

Hi ~
Here is my Taiko mod ~
Mod request by Garven

Blue~ Critical issues, you must fix this
Purple~ I think you should fix this
Pink~ Suggestions only

[TL's Taiko]

I strongly suggest you using SV 1.4 instead of 1.2
See the following screenshot
SV 1.2
SV 1.4
1.2 is too clustered and it doesn't look good~

HP -1 ? Drain rate seems a bit harsh~

00:51:561 - ( 70 ~ 86 ) The long stream doesn't fit the previous part of the diff because it suddenly increases the difficulty and ruins the flow of the song. You should break down the long stream into shorter 1/4s or 1/2s. Same situation for 01:45:297, 03:45:792

01:06:973 - ( 60 ~ 66 ) It's quite strange to have a stream that both starts and ends at blue line. Same situation for 01:12:248

01:24:116 - ( 169 ~ 174 ) Starting the stream at blue line doesn't really fit well. Delete 169 will be better. Same situation for 01:33:347


May need to balance the difference on easy and hard parts

I'll have a recheck after fixing this ._.

But anyway, I like the song

aabc271 wrote:

Hi~
Here's my recheck for the Taiko diff ~

Blue~ Critical issues, you must fix this
Purple~ I think you should fix this
Pink~ Suggestions only

[TL's Taiko]

Firstly, the diff looks much better now ^^
esp 00:16:121 ~ 00:51:231 & 00:58:319 ~ 01:33:099. They look quite good to me ~

But there are still some things that I recommend to fix
After updating the map, I'm sure that the Taiko diff is ready to go :3

00:52:220 - ( 76 ~ 84 ) You may consider shortening this. Not a big issue ~

01:33:347 - ( 225 ~ 242 ) Most 1/4s start at the blue line, which doesn't fit the music very well ( as seen here ).

02:41:918 - ( 70 ) Delete this note ? A single stream that starts with blue line looks odd ~

03:45:792 - ( 164 ~ 193 ) This part could be widening the diff spread. You may consider simplifying it a bit, esp for 2nd stream which has more complicated patterns ~

Suggested patterns

Suggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~

00:16:451 - ( 3 ~ 9 ) o o ooo o o ?

00:58:649 - ( 3 ~ 8 ) o o o o ?

01:51:973 - ( 99 ) Red note ?

02:00:957 - ( 150 ) Blue note ?

02:32:440 - ( 15 ~ 16 ) Both blue notes ?

02:40:187 - ( 60 ) Blue note ?

02:42:989 - ( 77 ) ^

Nice to see improvements in the map ~

Suggestions : Try to be more consistent with your patterns next time. The notes arrangement still looks quite random to me
The hitsounds are quite good though

Anyway, good luck on your rank

Colin Hou wrote:

Taiko is not updated.

aabc271 wrote:

Suggested patterns

Suggestions only. Change them only if you want to ~

00:16:451 - ( 3 ~ 9 ) o o ooo o o ?Fixed

00:58:649 - ( 3 ~ 8 ) o o o o o o ?Fixed

01:51:973 - ( 99 ) Red note ?
Fixed


02:00:957 - ( 150 ) Blue note ?
Fixed

02:32:440 - ( 15 ~ 16 ) Both blue notes ?
Fixed

02:40:187 - ( 60 ) Blue note ?
Fixed

02:42:989 - ( 77 ) ^
Fixed

vytalibus wrote:

[Insane] is my real problem. Random jumps every second is NOT a reasonable way to justify a difficult... difficulty. The jumps are way too sudden, and appear at times when the song does not even hint to it. This isn't a question of difficulty itself, but more of a question of appropriation.

There are lots of other ways to make an Insane. I suggest you stop limiting yourself to jumps and find them.

cRyo[iceeicee] wrote:

02:39:846 (1) -
missing hitsound ? oops,easy miss>< Fixed!(Insane)

Garven wrote:

Ack, something I Just noticed:

[Suzu Hard]
00:42:979 (2,3) - This spacing is a little dodgy, especially after the jump at 00:42:154 (4,1) -

SPOILER

Suzully wrote:

Garven wrote:

Ack, something I Just noticed:

[Suzu Hard]
00:42:979 (2,3) - This spacing is a little dodgy, especially after the jump at 00:42:154 (4,1) -

Changed pattern~

SPOILER

1. Timing:
   1. 1st Offset: Seems okay, but +2~4 ms would be perfect.
   2. 2nd Offset: This one feels off, it needs +6ms.
      (Both confirmed with Blissfulyoshi, thanks Blissy!)

1. 01:31:110 (1,2,3,4,5) - This spacing needs to be either increased or decreased, right now these objects look like "fake" 1/2 beats. (Because the spacing is the same to the objects that are 1/2 apart)
2. 01:33:748 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^
3. There are a few other similar mistakes but these are the ones that seem to cause problems.