forum

#indonesian [added]

posted
Total Posts
46
This is a feature request. Feature requests can be voted up by supporters.
Current Priority: +18
Topic Starter
mekadon_old
Well #malay is mostly used by people from Indonesia (No offense, just in case), so #indonesian seems more ideal since without them, what would #malay be. inb4 rename it or whatsoever.

Help me make description aaaa
mycyber
support this ^^
-SiN-
"Malay" is standard forms of Malaysian and Indonesian, why there is only some malaysian player join this channel?
the idea itself wasn't bad but i prefer we could chat together, share something, getting crazy together in channel as malaysian and indonesian

come on malaysian player, don't be afraid to us xD
this channel is open for you guys.
Topic Starter
mekadon_old

-SiN- wrote:

"Malay" is standard forms of Malaysian and Indonesian, why there is only some malaysian player join this channel?
the idea itself wasn't bad but i prefer we could chat together, share something, getting crazy together in channel as malaysian and indonesian

come on malaysian player, don't be afraid to us xD
this channel is open for you guys.
I rather say this by activity basis. Oh bleh, I don't think this is going anywhere D:
-SiN-
just... wait for a while :3
Hakeru
so..umm..

is #malay renamed into #indo or .. ?

:s
Topic Starter
mekadon_old

Hakeru Prismriver wrote:

so..umm..

is #malay renamed into #indo or .. ?

:s
either that or having both
Niva
Well, just in case I posted a random log from #malay (#malay-20110129-095644.txt):

SPOILER
09:43  *Nivalis is listening to (r300k & Mhz (Curium) - G.O.A)[http://osu.ppy.sh/s/18131]
09:43 <Nivalis> : tinggal cari 2 orang lagi tuh
09:44 <dNextGen> : udah FC
09:44 <dNextGen> : cuman gw ga bisa maen hidden
09:46 <Hakeru_Prismriver> : kita janjian aja
09:46 <Hakeru_Prismriver> : ngerebut rank di lagu apa
09:46 <Hakeru_Prismriver> : rame2 lol
09:46 <dNextGen> : eh yg diff hard deh
09:46 <dNextGen> : gw maenin sini ID lo ama awell
09:47 <dNextGen> : gw hapal lol
09:47 <Hakeru_Prismriver> : lagu apa
09:47 <Hakeru_Prismriver> : enak ya dah apal ._.
09:47 *dNextGen is listening to (r300k & Mhz (Curium) - G.O.A)[http://osu.ppy.sh/s/18131]
09:47 <Hakeru_Prismriver> : btr gw ngejar ini dlu
09:47 *Hakeru_Prismriver is listening to (DJ YOSHITAKA - ALBIDA)[http://osu.ppy.sh/s/19561]
09:47 <dNextGen> : tunggu awell aja ntar
09:47 <Hakeru_Prismriver> : pngn sekali2 di tuduh cheater
09:47 <dNextGen> : jgn
09:48 <dNextGen> : tapi ntaran aja ya gw mw nonton Gosick
09:48 <dNextGen> : lalalalalala
09:48 <Hakeru_Prismriver> : yee
09:48 <Hakeru_Prismriver> : wakwkaw
09:48 <Hakeru_Prismriver> : oh iya gw blm nonton gosick ._.
09:49 <Hakeru_Prismriver> : uh ketinggalan
09:49 <vesperinamu> : halo
09:50 <Hakeru_Prismriver> : hai
09:50 <Nivalis> : hi xD
09:51 <vesperinamu> : masih nubi :o
09:54 <Nivalis> : @_@

Based on the log above, we can see if the #malay channel is mostly inhabited by Indonesian players using Indonesian language xD
I think renaming to #indonesian (or even having both #malay and #indonesian) would be nice.
Support~

(No offense to another player from Indonesia/Malaysia though. If somebody requested to delete the log I'll edit post)
Jarby

Nivalis wrote:

(or even having both #malay and #indonesian)
Uh...

The differences between Malaysian (Bahasa Malaysia) or Malay (Bahasa Melayu) and Indonesian (Bahasa Indonesia) are slightly greater than those between British English and American English. They are roughly mutually intelligible, but with differences in spelling, pronunciation and vocabulary.
Assuming this is a valid statement, there's no real point in seperating them, is there? I guess this is basically what -SiN- was saying. Is there some sort of name that would suggest accommodation for both groups? That seems like the best option at this stage.
-SiN-
The differences between Malaysian (Bahasa Malaysia) or Malay (Bahasa Melayu) and Indonesian (Bahasa Indonesia) are slightly greater than those between British English and American English. They are roughly mutually intelligible, but with differences in spelling, pronunciation and vocabulary.
Assuming this is a valid statement, there's no real point in seperating them, is there? I guess this is basically what -SiN- was saying. Is there some sort of name that would suggest accommodation for both groups? That seems like the best option at this stage.
Correct!
there is no point to separate them, renaming the channel is ok
but i want to ask right now.. is the Malaysia players need a channel?
Dai
since there's only 3 voters, I think nobody noticed this thread
RhaiizoN
Maybe i can support this..(changed it #malay to#indo or added #indo channel) 8-)
since not many Malaysia's Player are playing osu! there are more like 20people online when weekends.. their people are talkless :| so we don't need a #malay chat, though.. mostly malaysia player always active in english on foreign game/chat

Hey how to vote? do we need a $_$ for that?
Decipher

RhaiizoN wrote:

Maybe i can support this..(changed it #malay to#indo or added #indo channel) 8-)
since not many Malaysia's Player are playing osu! there are more like 20people online when weeken ds.. their people are talkless :| so we don't need a #malay chat, though.. mostly malaysia player always active in english on foreign game/chat

Hey how to vote? do we need a $_$ for that?
I think RhaiizoN-san is right, Malaysian players is talkless... (No offense)
Maybe renaming the channel is better, but adding #indonesian channel also not a problem.

Hey RhaiizoN-san, you just need to click "Promote this request" (see at top of thread) to vote :)
Maliciousness_old
i think it's not about who use that channel... or about differencess in language, etc..etc....
it's better that we got both #Indonesia and #Malay channel
since new players...
either player from Malaysia or Indonesia must be looking for their own country channel
(i accidentally found out that Indonesian players usually chat in #Malay channel...even i don't know that Indonesian players have their channel until now)
: (
Sun and Lunar

-SiN- wrote:

Correct!
there is no point to separate them, renaming the channel is ok
but i want to ask right now.. is the Malaysia players need a channel?
try renaming it and wait for malaysian's complains, if there were none, it's a deal
Hakeru

Sun and Lunar wrote:

-SiN- wrote:

Correct!
there is no point to separate them, renaming the channel is ok
but i want to ask right now.. is the Malaysia players need a channel?
try renaming it and wait for malaysian's complains, if there were none, it's a deal
LOL

+1
-SiN-
had to agree but no admin here :lol:
Sun and Lunar

-SiN- wrote:

had to agree but no admin here :lol:
well, it's the time for our indonesian active player to take admins here

since we can do nothing now, it can't be helped ┐( ̄ー ̄)┌
Hakeru
*promote this*
HeatKai
Nah , I think its fine like this.
there is Not many active malaysian player.
but I think , you should renaming it to #indonesian
or somethingl like that.
Well , I agree with -sin-
so bla bla bla.
Equivalent_old
Malaysian players didn't even reach 100, what the points making one
xsrsbsns

Equivalent wrote:

Malaysian players didn't even reach 100, what the points making one
actually malaysia has 7k players (inb4 multi accounts) but close to none uses #malay so w/e

also the current #malay isn't #malaysian
like SiN explained the term 'malay' supposedly includes both malay(sian) and indonesian languages, so players from both countries are welcomed
^ that was the point of making a #malay, just like how #chinese isn't #china or w/e

however, due to the misleading (?) nature of the term here, and since indonesian players who use #malay greatly outnumber malaysian ones (actually there are virtually no malaysians there), i agree with renaming it into #indonesian

of course, after you do it, i will still lurk #indonesian \:D/
Gon
what does the "active users" list in the country rankings even mean rofl. highly doubt there's 7000 active malaysians logging into osu on a daily basis

support since malaysians obviously don't use the channels that are provided to them (this includes me. hurr).
dNextGen
bump
Dai
bump
dNextGen
no one cares bout this thread cuz we're no popular lols
GladiOol

dNextGen wrote:

no one cares bout this thread cuz we're no popular lols
I still love you though <3
dNextGen
i love you too gladi

/no homo
Dai
how is it going?
Frizz
If there was #indonesian channel, all the Indonesians would move out from #malay to #indonesian, leaving #malay to be deserted, as most of the people in #malay are Indonesians.

Totally what I think about it for a long time.

tl;dr - let's just keep it this way or rename the channel.
Dai

Frizz925 wrote:

tl;dr - let's just keep it this way or rename the channel.
:roll:
Rey Fullbuster
want to support it but i don't have any star right now :(
awell
promote this
inb4 just rename it to #indonesian or #indo i think
no need for a new channel
Naikaze

r3yn41d0 wrote:

want to support it but i don't have any star right now :(
Rei Hakurei

Gatyaa wrote:

r3yn41d0 wrote:

want to support it but i don't have any star right now :(
Topic Starter
mekadon_old
#indo sounds more decent

afaik less than 10 malaysians I know lurk in #malay so uh...

Someone just tell this to derek or something.
xsrsbsns
they've already put indo instead of malay or w/e in languages subforum anyway

makes me wonder why it isn't the same for chatrooms
Kurokami
Support but I don't have star now. We want a #hungarian also, but they just ignore the idea. ._.
paitehoens
vote :D
Topic Starter
mekadon_old
bump because people are asking this on #malay already
Yasora

paitehoens wrote:

vote :D
-Athena-
Y u make my stalking job harder D:, following an extra channel will be troublesome :3, it's fine as it is right now no support sorry.
RusticKey
I support.
How do I vote @.@

Edit : Well, I mean I support the idea on renaming the channel.
DerekMcD
Now we heard the Indonesian subforum was moved above.

Let's all pray for this channel quickly and bubbled very soon.
Derekku
As stated before, more language channels can't be added at the moment. However, when they can, we'll definitely split #malay into both #malaysian and #indonesian.
Bass
Should be moved since completed.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply