btw these tuning parts are dumb
Yup, I agree. This game hasn't really been fun for me either. I know your alignment now but it doesn't feel like a win at all. And having flavor abilities is kinda meh imo. So yeah, I've said what I've wanted to say, my game plan I posted above will probably end the game and from now on I won't be doing closed setup games like these again because they'll probably just end up like this.Shiirn wrote:
Reading over things.....
I'm done. This setup is clearly untested and balanced improperly as it is overwhelmingly in favor of town assuming people claim truthfully. This is a role madness game except with a smidgen of balance thrown in via making abilities X-shot, which isn't actually balancing shit because two actions per person is way more than enough. How do I know this? Because it's obvious when you read between the lines what with the many varied hints and tellclaims and further hints that everyone's skills are X-shot.
Not only this, but the party-name flavor system is also overwhelmingly pro-town. It's another layer of claiming that punishes any sort of strategy scum can try to run. It's another layer of lies that maf has to tell.
I can safely say that if every player had truthfully roleclaimed (except for scum, obviously) and party-name claimed day 1 that there would be absolutely zero chance of mafia winning.
Which has made this entire thing a god damn waste of time. There's zero fun in being on either side of a conflict that is practically predetermined.
Vote: Tess
Simply because due to Xiz the Village Idiot getting 'random' game-ending tells. Fuck you, Frostings, that's not fair. Regardless of whether I'm scum or Tess is scum, I want you, personally, to know that I am severely disappointed in how this setup was balanced. If it even was.
I just realized this is impossible since the mafia team kinda outted themselves lol.Xiz wrote:
What if my dreams/checks are fake and I don't know it (like insane cop)
I already logically explained to you but it's beyond you I suppose.beeboy123 wrote:
Why am I dying before automedic again?
Like logically someone explain to me why I would counter claim his doctor claim if I wasn't actually a doctor...
I feel like some bs is going to happen and you will assume there is 2 doctors.
We're kinda going by your claims, so please don't increase my paranoia even moreXiz wrote:
What if my dreams/checks are fake and I don't know it (like insane cop)
Because as everyone agrees, this is too town sided
beeboy123 wrote:
Just because you explained it doesn't make it the right decision.
Sorry beeboy but even from a town perspective your posts are making no sense. If we go by that logic then nothing we say ever in mafia would work, we can't obviously know which role a person has until we lynch him, but we have to assume and explain things that would lead to some clues about that role. The best explanation wins, otherwise there's no way to move the game forward.beeboy123 wrote:
I am town aligned though so it can't possibly be the right decision silly
If you are town aligned then you are a bad player as I have stated before.beeboy123 wrote:
I am town aligned though so it can't possibly be the right decision silly