We do need someone to set down the line, hopefully my reasonings were clear enough for Kwan or anyone that reads this thread for that matter.
THISztrot wrote:
Overall quality is a rankablity issue, it will continue to be a rankablity issue
FCL wrote:
- [diff_name]
- 00:01:586- volume of this slider sounds a bit loud imo, reducing to 30% looks better
- 00:02:586 (1,2) - hmmm, this high spacing between sliders with low sv at the beginning of the map plays kinda uncomfortable (at least for me exactly). At least 7x between sliders could works better I admit it's a bit extreme but I'll keep it anyway, it's fun and not hard at all.
- 00:04:186 (1,2) - something similar, but 8x here could works good. Anyway you should get more opinions about it I will.
- 00:10:586 (1,1,1) - since you had mapped these sliders to vocal, would be good you will make muting of the tails of these sliders, cuz they haven't some sounds
- 00:14:686 (7) - this combo feels a bit long, so I recommend you add nc here since spacing was changed
- 00:19:586 (6) - nc would be good too for better readability of stack
- 00:22:986 (7,1) - just you could improve this blanket
- 00:23:386 (1,3) - seems you made these 1/2 sliders intentionally, but anyway I think that mapping of 1/4 would work good cuz fit with song better. just replace these sliders to 1/4 repeats looks like great idea, just try. https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5235431 I don't really like those, not a fan of such patterns.
- 00:25:986 (5) - I'd add nc's for all these sliders cuz sections with 3 kicksliders looks different from previous patterns Yeah but it's consistent, NC would just be too spammy.
- 00:49:186 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - nc spam looks fine for me, but you could make the placement of notes more structured, now they looks kinda randomly and doesn't so understandable imo I tried make it something that supports back&forth movement, it seems good for me.
- 00:51:186 (1,2,3,1,2) - seems whistles fit good with these circles, cuz we have only vocal without music, just try again
- 01:15:986 (2,3,4) - ^same for heads of sliders
- pretty good stuff, and remapped diff seems better for me than before lul
Strategas wrote:
[name diff]
00:02:586 (1,2,4,1,2) - this spacing is really overdone here, this is so calm, it doesn't matter if there is a buildup sound, it just doesn't call for this spacing, you should try emphasizing differently here I'll keep that in mind.
00:05:586 (4) - then it's weird you put no pressure here when you focused so much on spacing the vocals uhhh
00:07:386 (4) - dunno if you just don't nc here cause it looks better, but it breaks consistency
00:08:786 (2) - might sounds dumb but, I'm assuming you nced 00:08:586 (1) - because of sv change but didn't nc 00:08:786 (2) - tbh I find no need to nc 00:08:586 (1) - in the first place if you don't follow your ncing logic,
00:09:586 - aaa this green line does nothing, I guess it won't hurt to remove it
00:19:586 (6) - nc for consistency
00:28:486 (2) - you can possibly polish this slider, I just find it ew atm, 00:29:786 (1) - is much better
00:35:386 (1) - ctrl g plays much better since you made it linear it's kick slider and has even amount of space between 00:34:986 (3,4,1) - on the clickable object, it will not feel comfy when dealing with same movement on different distance
00:39:786 (6) - I disagree with changing the shape here, if you keep it like 00:38:186 (3) - 00:38:986 (3) - it will be much cooler imo Feels forced for me
00:39:386 (4) - also nc
00:40:498 - slider end unsnapped
00:58:986 (2,3) - looks sloppy, I'm sure you can polish
01:03:186 (7) - nc?
01:11:186 (7) - nc instead of 01:11:586 (1) - ? seems more reasonable to me if you compare note intensity, also I dunno if it's good here to keep that slider on downbeat even if you follow that vocal, the instrument is also strong here
01:13:186 (8) - missing clap on sliderhead
01:12:786 (7) - I'd suggest nc here, remove nc at 01:13:986 (1) - and add nc 01:14:586 (3) - or 01:14:186 (2) - ,the slider end would be ideal place for nc but you have it on slider end which I don't agree either xd, then nc 01:14:986 (5) - because of sv change at 01:15:386 (9) - and just fits the music, then removing nc on 01:15:786 (1) - and adding on 01:15:986 (2) - would make more sense to the music atleast
01:16:988 - slider end unsnapped
ai mod pointing the stack leniency thing, dunno up to you to change it or not
oh and 00:16:786 (5,1) - 00:24:086 (1,2,3) - 00:17:486 (3,4,5,6) - not sure if you intended to keep the antiflow movements here, but they are only for challenge if anything since they don't really play that well, unless you're beyong this level
didn't expect to write much here, overall the aesthetics were the main thing for me, but that's subjective I guess. I liked the kiai tho xd
hope it helps somehow, good luck requalifying
Unnoted = Fixed / changed / whatever.Lasse wrote:
even though this was remapped I'd feel bad to get kd for modding the same thing twice lol
map: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/455756 just pick one of the two extras or something, it doesnt have enough mods to go for ranking yet anyways :v
general stuff was already checked well enough here in the past so I'll skip that
[ex ex]
00:05:586 (4) - having this spaced like 00:03:986 (4) - (or even more) would fit the vocal+pitch wy better than a stack
00:09:786 (3,1) - not stacking this would make 00:12:986 (5,1) - easier to get since right now it'S easy to expect the second one to also be a stacked 1/1 (at least is messed me up on my sightread and I'd consider my ar9.3 reading fine enough)
00:17:286 (2) - would work wel las a kickslider to cover the weaker sound on the white tick, probably sth like http://i.imgur.com/uKrdTOy.jpg
00:24:286 (3) - slider starting on blue tick doesnt work that well here cause cause what? .-, blame the song
00:29:786 (1,2) - i hate pointing out minor visual things, but http://i.imgur.com/02NX78U.jpgwould look so much nicer than the sligh overlap on the slidertail
00:40:386 (2) - is unsnapped, you probably wanted 0.9x sv here?
00:46:586 (2,3) - if you go with the "muted 1/4 sliders to emphasize vocals" thing then shoudnt those also be such sliders?
or maybe at least 00:45:786 (5,2) - cause they even have weak sounds on the blue ticks
01:03:186 (7) - missed nc? fits your 4/1 pattern in the chorus
01:16:786 (4) - unsnapped again, should use 2x sv or change the length slightly, but the first option fits the pattern better
01:17:786 (1) - could be spaced more to emphasize the finish, with how high the spacing before is it's unlikely to be misread as 1/2, sth like http://i.imgur.com/xOLAn9S.jpg
01:18:386 (4,6) - would work well with a bit higher sv cause they are pretty strong and high pitched
Left wrote:
M4M place holder use!
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/452412
00:17:786 (6) - NC? for consistency?
00:21:086 (1) - ^
00:22:786 (5) - NC
00:26:886 (2,3) - better blanket
00:40:186 (1,1) - I think it's really uncomfortable to use this DS while 00:37:786 (1,2) - -> 00:38:586 (1,2) - -> 00:39:386 (1,2) - -> increasing DS Yeah but those are 1/4 sliders that put more pressure in the current context.
00:41:786 (4) - NC
00:43:986 (3,4,5) - how about using same pattern with 00:43:586 (1,2) - . now I think it's not suitable for downbeat. It's fine because of the vocals.
00:56:386 (2,4) - blanket
00:52:186 (1) - How about using NC every 2 downbeat? it's kiai part.
01:06:786 (7) - NC
01:17:386 (1) - I think using more fast slider would be better..but it's your interpretation It is.
00:58:986 (2,3,4) - DS between 2,3 is too low, considering other same patterns and song's difficulty. And one more, it's too linear pattern (2->3->4) I felt a bit hard to hit 4. How about at least use different flow like here 01:11:986 (4,5,6) - ? It's not completely linear, I agree it's a bit tough to play, but it is planned in a way that allows you to quickly move to 3 without actually following 2, I think it's cool.
Good luck! I like this map.
made some changes of my own tooCellina wrote:
Diff... what was the diff's name xD
- 00:05:786 (1,2,3) - what about this?
- 00:32:386 (5,6,7) - why did you used 1/2 slider even you used 1/4 for other parts? i strongly recommend change into the 1/4. It doesn't work well at all, unfortunately.
- 00:44:186 (5) - NC?
- 00:52:486 - place a note here with stacking on 00:52:586 (2) - ? It's overmapped :< I'd love to do this but I decided to avoid overmapping as much as I can here.
nice beatmap, gl!
The problem with the map wasn't because it was difficult, It was the mapping. It was too all over the place.wonders wrote:
i strong recommend you keep the original one and find a new bat, THIS IS NOT TOO DIFFICULT, (40000+rank)even i can play it
That's the gimmick, otherwise it just feels 'weak' and boring :\Xayler wrote:
Isn't the CS now too high compared to Insane? It goes from 3,5 to 4,8 , where is normal 4? I think that 4,8 is too high, maybe 4,2 or something would be better to aim.
Also the 0,3x slider velocity, it's remembering me pensamento beatmap now, lol.
I also think that the previous one was better, maybe mix the new and previous one together? Or just maybe this mapset doesn't need an Extra, that would also be an option, well making insane a bit harder then.
Looking forward to this map evolution!
I would do a proper mod, but my experience isn't that high so idk.
u did this to yourselfpishifat wrote:
u did this to yourselfAvishay wrote:
Decent formatting in your mod post is viewed positively.
NORMAL
thE diFficUlty itSeLf is k but wAy tOo deNse foR tHe loWest diFf:(
lIke reAlly yOu nEed An eaSy, eVeN iF it woUlD mEan uNdeRmaPping a loT oF tHe reD tiCk snArEs aNd nOisE spAm StuFf
oH aNd soMe hItSouNds (wHiCh woUld bE on aLl diFfs i guESs):
01:18:620 (2) - miSsinG fiNish or soMEthing liKe 01:21:820 (2) -
01:04:220 (2) - sAMe soRta ThiNg lIkE 01:02:620 (2) -
00:49:020 (5) - fiNisH>clAp tbH muSiC
ADVANCED
00:22:020 (1,2,3) - sUpeR miNor buT dUnNo hoW intEntiOnal tHe swiTchiNg to 1.5x sPaCinG waS hEre sInCe evEryThiNg iS 1.4 in thE seCtiOn anD muSIc is SameEe
HARD
thE
INSANE
00:08:820 (5) - sHoulD pRobAblY gEt riD oF thAt LasT rEpeaT likE You diD wiTh tHe exTra. i tHinK yoU dId iT on tHe upPer diFf for lEnienCy whEn moViNg to tHe neXt NoTe, buT lenIenCy froM juSt ClicKinG is A tHinG toO (espEciaLly WhEn lOts of pEoPle tRy To siNglEtaP stuFf liKe tHis soMeHoW)
01:02:620 (4,1) - pLeAse yoUr cuRreNt plAceMent Is makIng iT seEm liKe strEam sTarTs At 01:02:920 (1) - wHich iT Um doESnt
seParAtiNg 4 And 1 spaCing wIsE adDs to The wHat Too
aNd bLue TicK nEw cOmBoinG wiThOut inDiCatIve sPacIng is LikE noT idEaL SinCe coMboINg asSisTS reAdiNg bY alWAys hAvIng tHem StaRt oN wHitE/redzZzzZZZz tHiS wAs oN tEe Bn tEst YOu alrEadY KnOw iT
ooOOo aND tHe SamE thIng hapPeNs on eXtrA pLs
EXTRA!!!!
00:01:820 (1,1) - sV indICaTinG tHe bUilD uP woUlD Be coOl
00:40:420 (3) - sOmeThiNg tO MaKe pEoplE knOw thIs iS aCtuAlLy haLviNg in sPEed wOulD bE o K
00:19:420 (5,1) - 00:21:020 (4,1) - aSsuMinG yOu ReaD tHe raNt oN inSanE u kNow wHaT i WanT to SAy. sWaPpinG nCs wOulD mAke TheSe Not GroSs
01:15:220 (1,2,3,4,1) - UM wouLd haVe moRe oF a bUilD up eFfeCt iF yOu aCtualLy sTartEd wIth NoT-huGe sPaCIng. bEginNing wItH yoUr pReViouS usUaL 1/4 sPacInG 01:14:420 (7,8,1) - thEn goiNg Up frOm thEre Is liKe "wOah It'S geTtiNg faSTeR"" RatHer thAn "woAh iT's FasT" yeS
01:18:620 (3) - sHouLd ReaLly hAve SomE sOrT oF emPhaSis To hEre:(
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/414289 i have to apply handsome's mod and do some timing thing but after that $$$$$$$
WAT R U DOINBearizm wrote:
u did this to yourself
c3VyZSwgcmFuayBteSBtYXAgZmlyc3Q=pishifat wrote:
hi, mod req
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/406273
thanks in advance !
hi, old diff is back, after not looking for several months I want it to stay :d thanksMAH BASS CANNON wrote:
pishifat QAT, AXION ranked...time to bring this gem back from the dust? with old diff maybe? for what it's worth no one iv'e spoken to about this map thinks the old diff is "unreadable", it's the exact same as any other alternating map.
Avishay wrote:
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on יום שישי 28 אוקטובר 2016 at 13:26:43
Artist: (K)NoW_NAME
Title: Knew day
Source: 灰と幻想のグリムガル
Tags: hai to gensou no grimgar op opening tv size
BPM: 150
Filesize: 17737kb
Play Time: 01:22
Difficulties Available:Download: (K)NoW_NAME - Knew day
- Advanced (2.97 stars, 201 notes)
- DiFf_(k)NAME (5.32 stars, 364 notes)
- Easy (1.33 stars, 84 notes)
- Hard (3.58 stars, 281 notes)
- Insane (4.48 stars, 357 notes)
- Normal (1.98 stars, 153 notes)
Download: (K)NoW_NAME - Knew day (no video)
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------yeee lets undermap and insert big jumpss
old (new) extra - https://puu.sh/rYnjT/981a06328c.osu