A certain beatmap will need to have at least 25 stars (Blue), one MAT star (Pink, proto-bubble), and 2 BAT stars (Yellow, bubble), making a total of at least 28 stars.

Mashley wrote:

How would this fix anything?

Selee wrote:

A certain beatmap will need to have at least 25 stars (Blue), one MAT star (Pink, proto-bubble), and 2 BAT stars (Yellow, bubble), making a total of at least 28 stars.

I think this would make it much slower...

Or you mean more BAT/MAT?

adron zhero wrote:

To experienced players is easy to get beatmaps ranked, they know how everything works. But for new/inexperienced players, isn't.

The first submition will cost no kudos, although he'll need to aquire 4 kudos to have his first beatmap ranked

E-Hooker wrote:

The first thing that made me go what the hell: What if a new mapper submits a beatmap, and with the community being somewhat elitist and in general most new mappers become neglected, nobody cares about the map, the mapper loses motivation, an the map gets graved. The next time they want to try again, it's going to cost them 4 kudos they don't have.

How does that fix anything?

The rest went downhill from there.

NatsumeRin wrote:

first you need to prevent the abuse of stars, and it's impossible.

kud for stars only? it may works but also slower than current system i guess.

adron zhero wrote:

NatsumeRin wrote:

first you need to prevent the abuse of stars, and it's impossible.

kud for stars only? it may works but also slower than current system i guess.

But it is alredy abused, maybe this way ppl think first before post something (maybe >.>).

NatsumeRin wrote:

first you need to prevent the abuse of stars, and it's impossible.

adron zhero wrote:

If it is impossible to prevent, create another system?

Anyway, the point of this system is make everyone to contribuite to the comunity. Maybe this way, people understand how the star system works, and stop abusing it.

adron zhero wrote:

Ranking:
BATs and MATs will have the same duties but a bit diferent.

A certain beatmap will need to have at least 25 stars (Blue), one MAT star (Pink, proto-bubble), and 2 BAT stars (Yellow, bubble), making a total of at least 28 stars.

adron zhero wrote:

Kudo System:
The kudo system have lost it purpose and is un-effective. Players distribute kudo stars just because they are friends, or because they like the song.

Instead of using kudos to give "reputation" to a beatmap, they will be used to give a player the possibility to submit a beatmap. When a player submit a beatmap, 4 kudos will be deducted from him.
The first submition will cost no kudos, although he'll need to aquire 4 kudos to have his first beatmap ranked.
Uploads will cost no kudos.

adron zhero wrote:

The current ranking system is quite slow because there is more mapers then moders. So with this new ranking system we will speed everything a bit and improve some aspects of it.

E-Hooker wrote:

The first thing that made me go what the hell: What if a new mapper submits a beatmap, and with the community being somewhat elitist and in general most new mappers become neglected, nobody cares about the map, the mapper loses motivation, an the map gets graved. The next time they want to try again, it's going to cost them 4 kudos they don't have.

How does that fix anything?

The rest went downhill from there.

Gomo Psivarh wrote:

I support the idea that new maps cost kudos.

Gomo Psivarh wrote:

And I think we should punish those mappers who have a tons of grave maps.

If your grave maps are more than your ranked maps, you have to spend extra kudos on submitting new maps.

strager wrote:

Gomo Psivarh wrote:

And I think we should punish those mappers who have a tons of grave maps.

If your grave maps are more than your ranked maps, you have to spend extra kudos on submitting new maps.

Why's that? I can't see any reason why maps in the graveyard are bad other than the fact that they often occupy server space unnecessarily.

Gomo Psivarh wrote:

Everybody will be pissed off if he or she spent a lot of time to mod a map but the map graved eventually.

dkun wrote:

This is the purpose of #modhelp and #modreqs. I don't see you in it, so you're not exploring your opportunities for mods. People know how the star system works, it's quite simple if you think about it.

dkun wrote:

And for the maps that are actually good and don't require mods? This is contradictory to what you "think" the star system is about. Stars are given for a "quality" map. Sure, people just star this left and right, but this is unfair.

dkun wrote:

The kudos system hasn't lost its purpose. There are moderators revoking unfair kudosu to players. This is a general problem, and is being dealt with accordingly.

dkun wrote:

There's modders available, you're just looking in the wrong places. Again, this is why #modreqs and mod queues exist. The new MAT "bubble" system is speeding up the ranking of maps as well. The ideas you have posted here will not improve the speed.

Derekku wrote:

A new ranking system is already in the works.

Derekku wrote:

removing star privileges from non-modders

Blue Dragon wrote:

Derekku wrote:

removing star privileges from non-modders

How can someone be considered a "modder" on this system? Like, a certain amount of kudosu gained or what?

adron zhero wrote:

So where is it? I want to discus it, see how it works. Just say "they are working on it" is pretty vague and disappointing don't you think?

adron zhero wrote:

This way, players will need to help each other, making the ranking process more confortable and easier to inexperienced players.

Zekira wrote:

adron zhero wrote:

So where is it? I want to discus it, see how it works. Just say "they are working on it" is pretty vague and disappointing don't you think?

It's somewhere out of your reach anyway.

Gomo Psivarh wrote:

A player's first beatmap will never be moved to graveyard.

adron zhero wrote:

well, an avarage of 4 months to get a beatmap ranked is soooo fast.

NotShinta wrote:

Gomo Psivarh wrote:

A player's first beatmap will never be moved to graveyard.

What.

adron zhero wrote:

And who said anythng about getting maps ranked faster?

Gomo Psivarh wrote:

A player's first beatmap will never be moved to graveyard.

strager wrote:

adron zhero wrote:

And who said anythng about getting maps ranked faster?

You did.

The current ranking system is quite slow because there is more mapers then moders.

adron zhero wrote:

And who said anythng about getting maps ranked faster?

strager wrote:

You did.

adron zhero wrote:

... This way, they can rank maps faster.

adron zhero wrote:

What is better: 5 well made maps ranked per day or 20 bad maps ranked per day?

adron zhero wrote:

And who said anythng about getting maps ranked faster? What i am saying is, QUALITY FIRST, THEN RANKED!

adron zhero wrote:

Getting maps ranked faster is a consequence, it's not the main concern of this system. It maybe will improve the speed, but mainly, it will produce better beatmaps.

MetalMario201 wrote:

Moved to Feature Requests (where it belongs) so Derekku can deny it