toara_fict wrote:

Hi. from #modreqs

[CC's Taiko Oni]

1. For Rank だとHitsoundはN固定がいいかと思います (アンランク要素なのか推奨程度なのかは今知らないので他の人にも言われたらでいいので一応頭に入れておく程度に受け止めてください )　なるほど、わかりました。
   
2. Delete Widescreen Support. ( Song setup から Designを開いてMisc. Togglesの1番上のチェック入ってるやつですー )　無効にしました。
   
   
   
3. 01:37:962 (45,46) - change kk ? ( VocalもBacksoundのキーボード系の音？も高音であるのでkにしてもいいかなあと思います )　ddkkdにしてみました。
   
   
4. 01:42:357 (76) - delete ?　( おとないのでけしちゃってもいいかなあ...と )　消しました。この方がいいですね。
   
   
   初心者なのかな？と思えない譜面でした！　ただBメロ部分00:52:198 (1) - ~ 01:16:656 (1) - が少しノーツ詰まりすぎてる感じがしたのでもうちょっと易しめにしたほうがいいかも！　少しノーツを減らしてみました。
   
   - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

6th wrote:

[Normal]

SPOILER

Spacing isn't consistent enough
SV changes are too high
There are many overlaps unpleasant to read that could be avoided

Needs rework imo - Not a really helpful mod here to be honest.

[Hard]

SPOILER

Again, many overlaps can be avoided
00:21:243 (2) - Spacing - I don't understand what's wrong.
00:22:771 (5) - ^ - I see what was wrong here. Good eye.
00:23:918 (2) - ^ - I don't understand again.
00:29:077 (3) - ^ - Saw what was wrong here.
00:49:141 (2,3,4) - ^ - Stacked (3) and (4).
00:55:638 (2,3,4) - ^ - Stacked (2) with (1), replaced (3) with a slider. Not really happy with this change, so I might revert.

00:37:294 (4,5) - Why not stacking them ? - Fixed.
00:50:096 (5,6) - ^ - Fixed.

00:41:498 (7) - Totally unpredictable - Tried fixing.
Well, I think continuing is useless cuz you would feel like if I was repeating the same thing... just check spacing that can be confusing as those strange squares and maybe flow in some parts like 00:27:931 (1,2,3) - or overlaps like here 00:43:408 (4,5) - 01:34:045 (1,2,3) -
Also, I recommand using this : 00:52:198 - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4624224 - That will make it all the more confusing to read. Declined.

[VICTORY]

SPOILER

SV looks a bit high at the beginning - Lowered.
00:15:319 (6) - This is exagerated - What?
00:19:331 (3) - CTRL+G and make it closer from (2) - Done.
00:21:911 - Missed something here ? - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4626985 This is a slider lol
00:23:917 (3) - Spacing - What?
00:25:637 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,1) - It is full of overlaps - I tried fixing.
00:41:115 (4,5) - Unpredictable - Moved.
00:55:446 (1,2) - ^ - Changed.
01:22:962 (9) - Exagerated spacing - I tried fixing.
01:24:873 (1) - ^ starting a stream after a jump like this one is a bad idea - Lowered distance.
01:25:828 (1) - ^ - Lowered distance.

Good luck ! (:

Silverdesu wrote:

i guess it's about time I actually mod shit

Key

Probably unrankable
Possibly needs changing
Opinion
Something commendable

Normal

SPOILER

decrease slider velocity
i actually recommend a remap, it's so jagged
half of this map doesn't conform to distance snapping

hell, fix all issues in aimod first, then i'll remod
don't go overkill with the beziers, this isn't 2012
00:25:828 - useless break time
00:32:325 (4) - no
00:37:293 (2,3,4,5) - feels weird to play, period
00:42:644 (1,3) - this just looks really bad when it's overlapping like that
00:50:669 (1) - similar to mcwc2307's easy, watch the recovery time
00:56:784 (3) - extend this for another two repeats?
01:17:803 (1) - spinner ending doesn't match up to anything in the song
01:19:714 - the sv increase makes the sv issue even worse; this looks more like a hard than an easy
01:19:714 - for this section overall you picked a really bad rhythm
01:31:179 (1) - okay you were actually heading in the right direction for like half a second
01:38:058 (2) - if the shit i said before didn't make this unrankable, this slider sure as hell will

Removed this entire difficulty. Not going to remap. Discussed with mcwc2307 to change his diff into a Normal. Should be coming soon-ish?

Hard

SPOILER

00:13:790 - okay already this is looking better than the normal diff - I haven't updated this entire difficulty in MONTHS.
00:13:831 - timing point doesn't snap to anything (same goes with a lot of other ones) - Fixed.
00:21:625 (3,4) - inconsistent spacing with your notes (pointed out by 6th) - Tried?
00:23:918 (2) - also inconsistent, but it's better because it's not some bull jump (pointed out by 6th) - And yet no one still gives me any clue on how to fix.
00:26:211 (6,7) - shorten jump just a tiny bit - Done (I think?)
00:30:415 (1,2,3,4,5) - try to avoid shit like this mainly because it looks bad and really sloppy - Yeah, noted.
00:32:135 (7,8,9,10,11,12) - why not just match up with the song for once - Well, I tried something.
00:35:574 (5,6) - don't stack this: hard difficulty actually allows some reasonable jumps - Yeah, okay.
00:36:529 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - highly recommended: rework entire sequence - Done.
00:40:160 (2,3) - decent jump imo
00:39:969 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - actually really displeasing to look at because it's all bunched in the middle - Well, I tried spreading this out though still looks kinda bad lmao
00:42:644 (1,2,3,4) - stacking is a gateway drug - Unstacked.
00:46:083 (1,2,3) - oh shit i didn't see this coming but do shorten the jumps a little bit - Done.
00:47:803 (4) - this jump is too far - Shortened.
00:50:669 (7) - feels late in the song - Fixed.
00:52:580 (2,3,4) - outlaw stacking now - okay dad
00:53:536 (5,1) - riiiight... shorten jump - Done.
00:54:109 (2,3,4) - stack me once, shame on you - : )
00:58:695 (2,3,4) - stack me twice, shame on me - : D
01:00:224 (2,3,4) - stack me thrice and i start making dank memes - pls no
01:02:326 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - this spacing just looks wrong - Redone, but it's probably shit still lmao
01:05:765 (5,1) - jumpville 2: bullshit escape - okay mom i fixed it
01:06:338 (2,3,4) - oh come on i thought the stacks were over - nope
01:07:294 (5,1) - shorten jump a tiny bit - Done.
01:17:038 (2,1) - ^ - ^
01:21:052 (5,1) - looks bad w/ overlapping - Moved.
01:24:872 (1,2) - shorten jump - Done.
01:29:077 (4,1) - here's an example of a decent jump in your map
01:31:561 (4) - overlapping unnecessary - Moved.
01:31:752 - fill in this gap with something - Done.
01:33:472 (8,1) - shorten jump a tiny bit - Done.
01:34:810 (2) - don't stack, it's hard to see - Unstacked.
01:35:001 (3) - no. - okay sorry
01:37:294 (1,2,3) - sounds late - Fixed, I think.
01:38:058 (3) - random sv change not cool - : )
01:38:058 (3) - slider sounds like it ends too early - Fixed.
01:40:542 (1,2,3,4,1) - i'm not sure if it's just me but the rhythm leading into the spinner makes no sense - Fixed, I think.
01:40:542 (1,2,3,4) - at the same time these are the best jumps in your map
01:45:701 (2) - sounds too slow - Fixed.

VICTORY
Mapped for difficulty, modded for pain

SPOILER

i love how this went from a 5.1(?) map to a 4.6 - It used to be 5.44, actually. lmao
despite that, this map has actually seen significant improvement over the last several mods
00:14:937 (5,6) - one keystone issue with this map is the really exaggerated, haphazard jumping (pointed out by 6th) - So THAT'S what he meant.
00:22:580 (3,4) - don't hide notes like this in this kind of map - Yeah okay.
00:22:962 (4,1) - this jump (pointed out by 6th) - Fixed.
00:23:153 (1,2,3,4) - come up with a new pattern for these - Eh, I tried.
00:40:733 (3) - weird rhythm on this slider - Vocals, yo.
00:45:701 (1,2,3) - space these bastards out, this is an insane diff right? - Uh, okay.
00:47:421 (1,2,3) - ^ - ^
00:48:758 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ - Sigh...
00:50:478 (1) - you could probably change this - Into what? It was a spinner before and that was too sudden.
00:52:962 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - that 5 is so separated from the rest of the stream - That was a legit fuck-up that I didn't notice lmao
00:52:962 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - as a note in general, make your streams more fluid instead of a thick, stationary stack. it helps with making it play and flow better while at the same time increasing difficulty without bullshit jumps. - I'll look into it when I won't be exceedingly lazy, as I am now.
00:54:491 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - ^ - For now, corrected just these 2 streams. Will do more later.
00:55:064 (10) - this 10 technically belongs on the stream ^ so don't push it so far away - Another fuck-up that I made my accident, rip.
01:01:370 (10) - random sv change for two ticks, not cool bro - : )
01:02:134 - your slider velocity here makes me want to kill a bitch - dude nice (lowered)
01:07:293 (9,1) - jump - oops
01:19:714 - REDO THIS ENTIRE KIAI. you have a good rhythm but the streams are nothing more than stacks and it looks pretty lousy - NO I WON'T REDO THIS KIAI BECAUSE IT'LL TAKE FOREVER. Also, like I said above, I will look into stream spacing later. Not now.
01:19:714 - but you keep bunching around the center instead of explore a little - Uh...what?
01:19:714 - and this sv is like me giving up and drowning in a river - okay sorry
01:19:905 (3,4) - plus the jumps are still a tiny bit fishy - rippi in pippi (fixed)
01:20:669 (7,1,2) - i legit can't tell if these are rankable anymore - lmao sorry
01:30:414 - missed stream opportunity - Uh???
01:37:102 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - this stream makes sense but at the same time it doesn't (spinnerstarts don't make noise so it sounds incomplete) - ...what?
01:42:452 (7) - NO BAD TOO FAST - OKAY, I SLOWED IT DOWN, FUCK.
01:46:083 (3,4) - k - nice

in other news:

just maybe i might do this as a gd but at this rate i don't expect it to be - pls no

gonna go die on bed now bye

Silverdesu wrote:

MORE MODDING FROM SILVER
R.I.P. Normal Edition

Key

Probably unrankable
Possibly needs changing
Opinion
Something commendable

---------------
Hard

SPOILER

00:24:682 (3) - put this slider to the right of the previous one
00:24:682 (3,4) - too far?
00:28:504 (2) - this slider looks bad
00:30:415 (1,2,3,4,5) - actually doesn't look half bad, gj m8erino
00:32:134 (6,7) - #modhelp says this jump is unfair
00:39:969 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - all of these should be a bit closer to eachother
00:42:644 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - now that i think about it the spacing here makes it look like this is a stream
00:50:478 (6) - sv change might actually be complaint-worthy but i can't tell

p l e a s e d o n o t g i v e k u d o s u

mcwc2307 wrote:

aww thats sad that you arent working on this anymore...

Lewdcream wrote:

cool map dude.

Nimagan wrote:

hyper hype

General
ar is a bit low.
in most songs the important sounds usually falls on white ticks. if you place a slider head on a red tick and end it on a white, there should be a distinct sound to support it.
careful with overlaps, while not detrimental to the map, it is kinda ugly.
to many slider shapes, keep them a bit consistent per section

map-sett
00:02:516 (2,3) - are a bit to close making a ugly overlapp - Fixed I think?
00:03:280 (3,4,5,6) - would look better as a perfect square - Fixed I think?
00:04:809 (1,2,3,4) - would look better as a symmetrical pattern (1 and 4 flipped symmetrical, 2 and 3 flipped symmetrical) - Fixed I think?
00:07:866 (1,2,3,4) - might look better with consistent spacing - Fixed I think?
00:13:981 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 1 and 3 are a bit close imo, whole section does not really flow well with 5 sticking out - I tried something here I guess.
00:19:523 - maybe have this sound clickable - I'll think about this for later.
00:20:860 (3) - overlaps 3 other objects - Uh...?
00:21:624 (5) - this should be nc - Fixed.
00:21:624 (5,1,2,3,4) - whole section feels off on emphasis, feel like they should be on whit ticks not red. - Fixed
00:23:153 (1,3) - overlapp - Fixed
00:25:064 (2,3) - ctrl + g as 00:25:446 - is to important to be left to slider tail - Done.
00:29:459 (2,4) - overlapp - Fixed
00:30:796 (2,3) - not properly blanketed, use approach-circle - ???
00:36:911 - emphasis this white tick. ctrl + g and maybe put in a full beat stopp (aka 00:37:102 (1) - delete this) - I'm not sure what you meant but I tried something.
00:42:261 (4,5,1) - bad blanket, try to keep visual spacing consistent here - I tried
01:06:720 (4) - should be on the red tick as this is where the triple starts, might want to do that with circles so you don't loose 01:07:102 - - Fixed.
01:09:013 (7) - as far as i know, 2x reverse on half beat slider is pretty bad, (to hard to read the 2nd reverse arrow, can be fine here because there is such a big gap from this to the next object but i would stil spilt it up in to 2 different objects - Done.

Unknowklone wrote:

Hello there

Hyperdimension

► 00:21:624 (1) - Imo you should put a note there and 00:21:816 (2) - and put a 1/4 slider with reverse here 00: 21: 816 (2) - because the guitar sound is very strong in this part of the song unlike the others sounds
► 00:33:281 - imo I think you should change that slider by 2 notes one on the red tick 00: 33: 281 - and another on the white tick 00: 33: 472 - because the blue tick has no sound, so you make a cleaner sound
► 00:53:917 (2,3) - This unnatural flow is uncomfortable for Hard players imo, try to overlap with these 00: 54: 300 (3) - 00: 53: 726 (1) -