Yes but now that is has ended, when you look at the standings, mafia are in the positive and town are in the negative. They've lost 5 to our 1. We win.
forum
Mafia Under the Sea (Game Over)
posted
Total Posts
397
Topic Starter
I don't think you understand. To win, the mafia has to control the majority of the town while no other roles with the ability to kill are alive. This requires at least having as many mafia members as town members alive at some point in time. You have not achieved this, nor would you have if NoHitter had been lynched.
No, you don't understand. To win, the town has to eliminate all mafia before they are eliminated themselves. The town has not done their end, either. However, there is a side 'in the lead', and that's mafia. The only part you could argue is that an aux could have killed one of us overnight, and so I propose that we settle this by having whoever would have killed someone tonight take a stab at the last mafia member. If they guess right, town wins. If not, we win.
Topic Starter
I am changing the activity policy. Slots will, after I have found a replacement for Malachite, be modkilled rather than replaced.
Edit: having carefully considered the lynch issue and the replacement issue, I have come to a decision. NoHitter has also been lynched since he was the rightful target of the lynch mob. Malachite has been modkilled for consistent inactivity.
NoHitter was a Lanternfish (Post-restriced Tracker, town)
Malachite was a Mackerel (town)
If anyone has any questions about what exactly a Tracker is, or the same for any other role that flips, they can pm me and I will give a general outline. Deadline for Night is September 18th. Thank you and have a nice night.
Edit: having carefully considered the lynch issue and the replacement issue, I have come to a decision. NoHitter has also been lynched since he was the rightful target of the lynch mob. Malachite has been modkilled for consistent inactivity.
NoHitter was a Lanternfish (Post-restriced Tracker, town)
Malachite was a Mackerel (town)
If anyone has any questions about what exactly a Tracker is, or the same for any other role that flips, they can pm me and I will give a general outline. Deadline for Night is September 18th. Thank you and have a nice night.
Topic Starter
The night is over, the dawn has come! And what an incredibly red dawn it is as the fish wake to the bodies of not one, nor even two, but THREE fish floating in the water. rust45, 0_o, and strager all lie dead before your eyes, staring vacantly into the depths of the ocean. On closer inspection, the fish notice that strager's mouth contains an unusually large number of sharp pointed teeth, in fact very very similar to the ones possessed by matthewtck and Two. Quite reasonably, they conclude that he was also a Piranha.
0_o, on the other had, has a sad little red body with the few white stripes on it dyed red by blood. Alas for the poor little Clownfish, now dead.
rust45's body, the fish also find to be unusually...large. Like, really large. As in, bigger than an entire school of fish would normally be large. Noting the baleen in his mouth and the great horn, tinged with blood that does not belong to him, the fish conclude that rust45 was a Narwhal.
strager, Piranha (mafia)
0_o, Clownfish (town) and
rust45, Narwhal (Night Vigilante, town)
are now dead and out of the game. With 4 alive, it takes 3 votes to lynch! Be careful, there is still a killer amongst you!
0_o, on the other had, has a sad little red body with the few white stripes on it dyed red by blood. Alas for the poor little Clownfish, now dead.
rust45's body, the fish also find to be unusually...large. Like, really large. As in, bigger than an entire school of fish would normally be large. Noting the baleen in his mouth and the great horn, tinged with blood that does not belong to him, the fish conclude that rust45 was a Narwhal.
strager, Piranha (mafia)
0_o, Clownfish (town) and
rust45, Narwhal (Night Vigilante, town)
are now dead and out of the game. With 4 alive, it takes 3 votes to lynch! Be careful, there is still a killer amongst you!
Well I guess this is as good of a time as any to claim cop and tell you DC is guilty.
DC's guilty what.
Topic Starter
Sending out prods to pieguy and DiamondCrash
Nice try Wojjan, but that little gambit isn't gonna work. Unless you're some kind of Insane Cop, which I somehow doubt. Pray tell who else you investigated and why.
If no one else claims Cop we can assume Wojjan is one because I'd figure there is one, and one hasn't died yet. Anyway, just in case I would like to know who Wojjan checked if he really is Cop.
Good god pieguy! why out of all the avatars you choose you choose that one as your first avatar !_!
Anyways... just saying since Wojjan almost never has a civilian role, he/she must have cop. I'm not a cop btw.
Anyways... just saying since Wojjan almost never has a civilian role, he/she must have cop. I'm not a cop btw.
No I'm not actually cop I was just testing for reactions.
Vote: DC
Vote: DC
How odd, could Wojjan actually be civilian? Only time will tell. I'll hold my vote for another IRL day.
No I'm not a civvie, my role is an anemone. Whoever targets me at night gets automatic protection.
Ha, that says a lot, forget what I said earlier.
Vote: DC
Vote: DC
Why are you voting for me again
Topic Starter
This Thread is Almost Dead Votecount!
pieguy1372 (0)
DiamondCrash (2) - Wojjan, DeathxShinigami
DeathxShingami (0)
Wojjan (0)
Not Voting (2) - pieguy1372, DiamondCrash
With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch!
DiamondCrash is at l-1!
pieguy1372 (0)
DiamondCrash (2) - Wojjan, DeathxShinigami
DeathxShingami (0)
Wojjan (0)
Not Voting (2) - pieguy1372, DiamondCrash
With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch!
DiamondCrash is at l-1!
Whoa, did we figure something out? o_O
Also, I personally find it suspicious that you said DC was Mafia when the killer who's left is almost certainly a Serial Killer. o_o
Also, I personally find it suspicious that you said DC was Mafia when the killer who's left is almost certainly a Serial Killer. o_o
Anyways~ if you're sure about yourself wojjan then vote again for DC.
And we wait even more so we can move on...
Topic Starter
Prods have been sent out to DiamondCrash and pieguy1372. If either requires prodding again, they will be modkilled.
So I'm town. Discuss.
with a face like this I have to be
Aaaaaa
Let's just get this over with. Vote: DiamondCrash
Let's just get this over with. Vote: DiamondCrash
Jeez guys. Have you even communicated outside of the thread?
Just end the game now, please.
Just end the game now, please.
well no one ever says anything unless they're being voted.
It's 4-way mylo without cops, we can't win this.
It's 4-way mylo without cops, we can't win this.
Topic Starter
Game Over Votecount!
pieguy1372 (0)
DiamondCrash (2) - Wojjan, DeathxShinigami, pieguy1372
DeathxShingami (0)
Wojjan (0)
Not Voting (1) - DiamondCrash
With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch!
DiamondCrash, Trout (town) has been lynched!
Wojjan, Anemone (Reflex Doctor, town) and pieguy1372, yellowtail (town) have been killed in endgame!
DeathxShinigami, Shark (Serial Killer) has won!
pieguy1372 (0)
DiamondCrash (2) - Wojjan, DeathxShinigami, pieguy1372
DeathxShingami (0)
Wojjan (0)
Not Voting (1) - DiamondCrash
With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch!
DiamondCrash, Trout (town) has been lynched!
Wojjan, Anemone (Reflex Doctor, town) and pieguy1372, yellowtail (town) have been killed in endgame!
DeathxShinigami, Shark (Serial Killer) has won!
wow dxs youd figure you'd at least kill me because lolololol mafia bond
Sorry darling but this time I wanted the spotlight 
so who killed me and what's a reflex doctor?
Topic Starter
Reflex Doctor automatically protects anyone who targets them, be it with a kill, splash, or any other action in between.
Lol.
I knew DC wasn't the killer, I just wanted the game over with. D:
EDIT: I just realized the game shouldn't have ended here. If there was a Doctor remaining, there was a chance of no one dying (if I target the Doctor and the killer targets me), where it would be 2 town:1 killer and we'd have another chance of winning. (Unless I'm mistaken)
I knew DC wasn't the killer, I just wanted the game over with. D:
EDIT: I just realized the game shouldn't have ended here. If there was a Doctor remaining, there was a chance of no one dying (if I target the Doctor and the killer targets me), where it would be 2 town:1 killer and we'd have another chance of winning. (Unless I'm mistaken)
I knew DxS was the SK btw. You didn't respond to my PM 
I was really stupid in this game. I trusted strager with my role, and I killed faceman.
SFG: Night actions and role PMs?
\:D/rust45 wrote:
I was really stupid in this game. I trusted strager with my role, and I killed faceman.
rust45 wrote:
I was really stupid in this game. I trusted strager with my role
I was after making the game fun (for me), not systematically winning the game.Two wrote:
rust45 wrote:
strager was really stupid in this game.
Topic Starter
Night actions
N1
- NoHitter tracks 0_o
- 0_o splashes matthewtck
- Nakata Yuji splashes strager
- Two kills Nakata Yuji
- Pieguy refrains from actioning
- Strager splashes Mashley, which doesn’t work because Mashley is dead. Instead, splashes DiamondCrash
- Rust45 refrains from actioning
- Matthewtck, DiamondCrash, Lybydose, and Meronmyon fail to submit actions
o Matthewtck randomly splashes matthewtck
o DiamondCrash randomly splashes pieguy
o Lybydose randomly splashes pieguy
o Meronmyon randomly kills matthewtck
N2
- 0_o splashes DeathxShingami
- DeathxShinigami kills strager
- Strager kills rust45
- Pieguy1372 refrains from actioning
- Rust45 kills 0_o
- DiamondCrash fails to submit an action (DiamondCrash randomly splashes rust45)
N1
- NoHitter tracks 0_o
- 0_o splashes matthewtck
- Nakata Yuji splashes strager
- Two kills Nakata Yuji
- Pieguy refrains from actioning
- Strager splashes Mashley, which doesn’t work because Mashley is dead. Instead, splashes DiamondCrash
- Rust45 refrains from actioning
- Matthewtck, DiamondCrash, Lybydose, and Meronmyon fail to submit actions
o Matthewtck randomly splashes matthewtck
o DiamondCrash randomly splashes pieguy
o Lybydose randomly splashes pieguy
o Meronmyon randomly kills matthewtck
N2
- 0_o splashes DeathxShingami
- DeathxShinigami kills strager
- Strager kills rust45
- Pieguy1372 refrains from actioning
- Rust45 kills 0_o
- DiamondCrash fails to submit an action (DiamondCrash randomly splashes rust45)
...SFG wrote:
Strager
o Meronmyon randomly kills matthewtcknext time don't make it obvious that he died before the night even started
And rust, don't make it obvious you're aux Day 1.
Topic Starter
Two, darling, I rolled the die to determine who meronmyon killed, as well as all other night actions that were not submitted, at the end of Night 1, not before Day 1 ended.Two wrote:
o Meronmyon randomly kills matthewtcknext time don't make it obvious that he died before the night even started
strager wrote:
And rust, don't make it obvious you're aux Day 1.
rust45 wrote:
I was really stupid in this game